Split Thread Atheism and lack of belief in the afterlife

.... At best you can say that you have no reason to consider these gods in any context.
I have no reason to consider any gods.



When you 'fix' anyone's quote you need to indicate what you changed. It's impolite not to. Thanks.

Strike through what you delete [strike ] [/strike ]

And put what you add in brackets: []
 
Last edited:
... There is no reason to add a "as far as we know" or any other qualifier. ...
This is an important concept.

The same goes for not needing to claim we haven't ruled the existence of gods out unless one believes one also needs to add, "we haven't ruled out invisible pink dragons in my garage," as one example.

Claiming lack of randomness indicates an intelligent designer is just as ludicrous. Lack of randomness could indicate a chemical reaction, or the effect of gravity, or the effect of quantum particles involved in the electromagnetic field...etc.

Nothing about lack of randomness suggests an intelligent intervention.
 
Hmm... 37 pages...


And has anyone managed to explain that the mechanisms of 'natural selection' and 'sexual selection' do not meet any definition of random?

No but I can think of an example. We don't really find our one 'soul mate' when we meet our lifetime partner. There is some randomness as to who we meet when those chemical pheromones are doing their thing. Place, time, who, chance of interacting ... Isn't there some randomness to that?

It could be non-random if we pair up with someone in our circle. But it doesn't have to be.

I met my last partner, the one I have a son with, when I was looking through tapes at a used record store. And before that we had once crossed paths in a restaurant when he was with his band setting up equipment. I asked him the name of the group, that was it. We'd have never gotten together had we not started talking in the record store.

It might be rationalized in a number of ways how that wasn't random. Or one might see it as random. I think there is an element of randomness with a lot of non-randomness as well.
 
This is an important concept.

The same goes for not needing to claim we haven't ruled the existence of gods out unless one believes one also needs to add, "we haven't ruled out invisible pink dragons in my garage," as one example.

Claiming lack of randomness indicates an intelligent designer is just as ludicrous. Lack of randomness could indicate a chemical reaction, or the effect of gravity, or the effect of quantum particles involved in the electromagnetic field...etc.

Nothing about lack of randomness suggests an intelligent intervention.


Exactly... and this is yet another example of the risible irony of apologetics for gods... even when one grants them their clear errors just for argument's sake... they still fail in demonstrating the gods they want so desperately to clench onto.
 
No but I can think of an example. We don't really find our one 'soul mate' when we meet our lifetime partner. There is some randomness as to who we meet when those chemical pheromones are doing their thing. Place, time, who, chance of interacting ... Isn't there some randomness to that?

It could be non-random if we pair up with someone in our circle. But it doesn't have to be.

I met my last partner, the one I have a son with, when I was looking through tapes at a used record store. And before that we had once crossed paths in a restaurant when he was with his band setting up equipment. I asked him the name of the group, that was it. We'd have never gotten together had we not started talking in the record store.

It might be rationalized in a number of ways how that wasn't random. Or one might see it as random. I think there is an element of randomness with a lot of non-randomness as well.


Think of a young American man who was drafted to go fight in Korea or in Vietnam a whole other continent... while stationed there he met a girl and and now has a child.

Think of an Emperor and his handlers in Japan who decided to wage a war on another continent which made the USA join a war in yet another continent... which resulted in a boy from the USA having to go fight a war he knew nothing about in a continent he would have never set foot in and met a nice Italian girl in Cecily the daughter of a Cosa Nostra family and he marries her and takes her back and her father and mother and brothers and sister to his continent and they start a new "family" there.

Think of a young man stealing a kiss from his sweetheart in Iraq and dreaming of soon starting his family when a drone overhead misses its target and extirpates any hopes of him ever starting a family.

Think of a brigand in Somalia armed to the teeth because of arms manufacturers in Germany wanted more money... and he uses his Israeli and German made weapons sold to him by an Australian arms peddler to go pillage and rape in an African village and this girl gets pregnant.
 
Last edited:
Hmm... 37 pages...

Did anyone manage to find any atheists that believe in an afterlife yet?

And has anyone managed to explain that the mechanisms of 'natural selection' and 'sexual selection' do not meet any definition of random?

No but I can think of an example. We don't really find our one 'soul mate' when we meet our lifetime partner. There is some randomness as to who we meet when those chemical pheromones are doing their thing. Place, time, who, chance of interacting ... Isn't there some randomness to that?

It could be non-random if we pair up with someone in our circle. But it doesn't have to be.

I met my last partner, the one I have a son with, when I was looking through tapes at a used record store. And before that we had once crossed paths in a restaurant when he was with his band setting up equipment. I asked him the name of the group, that was it. We'd have never gotten together had we not started talking in the record store.

It might be rationalized in a number of ways how that wasn't random. Or one might see it as random. I think there is an element of randomness with a lot of non-randomness as well.

'Natural selection' and 'sexual selection' are not the only two factors in evolution. There are random factors such as incomplete or improper copies of our alleles.

One of the best science communicators on YouTube is Forrest Valkai. I highly recommend his short 4 part series on Evolution


Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/1GMBXc4ocss


Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/cBmC1AJ9PSM


Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/1WoGXmh25Zc


Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/_Axyrz8U_a4
 
'Natural selection' and 'sexual selection' are not the only two factors in evolution. There are random factors such as incomplete or improper copies of our alleles.

One of the best science communicators on YouTube is Forrest Valkai. I highly recommend his short 4 part series on Evolution

Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/1GMBXc4ocss
Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/cBmC1AJ9PSM
Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/1WoGXmh25Zc
Or watch it on Youtube https://youtu.be/_Axyrz8U_a4


Forrest Valkai said:
They Literally evolved to not be alive anymore


Hahaha... EXCELLENT.... thanks for those links... I was about to watch the new Citadel episode... now I have something much better.

:thumbsup:
 
But constrained-random is still random... just constrained... just like a draw of a card is not going to give a tomato it is constrained by the fact that I had to draw from 52 cards of a certain type not all available cards and fruits.

And when I am playing Poker... what cards I discard and how many cards I request is constrained by what cards I already have... but I am still drawing random cards from a constrained deck which has already lost some of its cards so it is constrained even further.

So evolution is more like a game of poker than a game of war??? But it is all random ... constrained by the details... but still random.

Evolution is
Constrained random mutations punctuated by environmental constraints
​


And now Watch this video to which acbytesla gave the link above (thanks so much acbytesla).


Watch starting @minute 15:04 or just click on the hyperlink above (it will automatically take you there)


Watch carefully the analogy to Poker... and shuffling cards to express the RANDOMNESS of evolution which is as I said

Evolution is
Constrained random mutations punctuated by environmental constraints
​

Akin to playing Poker.... it is satisfying to see others much more informed and much cleverer than myself drawing the same analogy.
 
Last edited:
And now Watch this video to which acbytesla gave the link above (thanks so much acbytesla).


Watch starting @minute 15:04 or just click on the hyperlink above (it will automatically take you there)


Watch carefully the analogy to Poker... and shuffling cards to express the RANDMONESS of evolution which is as I said

Evolution is
Constrained random mutations punctuated by environmental constraints
​

Akin to playing Poker.... it is satisfying to see others much more informed and much cleverer than myself drawing the same analogy.

What I like is Forrest does an excellent job of making something that is very complicated understandable. If you're into serious geekdom when it comes to Evolution, Forrest and Gutsick Gibbon are hard to beat. GG is a young woman primatologist. Her channel beats up on Creationism a lot. Here is her channel.
https://youtube.com/@GutsickGibbon
 
Tim Minchin on the randomness of sexual selection.


Thanks... I needed the laughs... excellent and hilarious.
:D:D:D:thumbsup::thumbsup:


What I like is Forrest does an excellent job of making something that is very complicated understandable. If you're into serious geekdom when it comes to Evolution, Forrest and Gutsick Gibbon are hard to beat. GG is a young woman primatologist. Her channel beats up on Creationism a lot. Here is her channel.
https://youtube.com/@GutsickGibbon


Yes... he did a great job with those videos.... his explanation of the mitochondria being foreign bacteria incorporated into our biology and thus is BORN WITH a human out of the same Egg+Sperm... was something new for me and :jaw-dropp

And thanks for the other link... I will check it out.:thumbsup::thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Thanks... I needed the laughs... excellent and hilarious.
:D:D:D:thumbsup::thumbsup:

Yes... he did a great job with those videos.... his explanation of the mitochondria being foreign bacteria incorporated into our biology and thus is BORN WITH a human out of the same Egg+Sperm... was something new for me and :jaw-dropp

And thanks for the other link... I will check it out.:thumbsup::thumbsup:

That fascinated me too. He shows what it is, what it does, how it became incorporated into our bodies. And how we know this. It sure beats the 'God did it' answer that explains absolutely nothing.


.
 
"In science, 'truth' can only mean 'confirmed to such an extent that it would be perverse to withhold provisional consent'."

- Steven Jay Gould (no relation)

According to quantum mechanics (I have never understood why people insist on capitalising that), it is "truth" that the universe is nondeterministic on the quantum scale.
 
According to quantum mechanics (I have never understood why people insist on capitalising that), it is "truth" that the universe is nondeterministic on the quantum scale.
Correct. But even if there was no randomness the interactions between particles/waves are so complex that in practical terms it might as well be random. The idea that an 'intelligent creator' could keep track of it all with sufficient precision to predict what will happen to us in the future (except in the broadest terms) is laughable.

But it is very easy to imagine a god which is omnipresent, omniscient, omnibenevolent etc. despite the logical absurdities it invokes. This is where religion gets its power. Simply declare that your god is all those things and people will believe it because they want to. The human mind has evolved the ability to imagine something desirable and turn it into reality. The problem is that it isn't always capable of filtering out the possible from the impossible.

The supernatural is so named not because there are some things science can't yet explain, but because people can so easily imagine impossibilities and then believe they are real. The afterlife is one of those things. Simple observation tells you that when you are dead that's it, but we don't want to believe that so we invent the afterlife.

Now you may think you are immune to such foolishness, but even smart logical people often fall into the trap. How many dream that one day soon we will go to Mars and set up colonies there? It's a nice fantasy, but you don't need to do much math to realize that's all it is.
 
What if god travels at the speed of light relative to our universe, hence our future has already happened from his position, and he uses special divine wormholes to peer into different parts of our timeline like reading a book?
 
Last edited:
What if god travels at the speed of light relative to our universe, hence our future has already happened from his position, and he/she/it uses special divine wormholes to peer into different parts of our timeline like reading a book?

Now your just being silly. Tralfamadorians have been doing that like forever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom