MRC_Hans
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2002
- Messages
- 24,967
It's super simple:
- Is the universe deterministic or indeterministic?
The universe follows a number of rules (natural laws), but is not entirely deterministic, as random functions exist.
- If the universe is deterministic then does randomness exist or is there only pseudo-randomness?
If the universe was deterministic, there would be no randomness. Pseudo random is not really random.
- If there is only pseudo randomness then where did the "blueprint" for the universe come from?
Well, in a hypothetic deterministic universe, the blueprint could be invariable physical laws, including such that would govern processes that currently seem random to us.
You see, there is a crunch here: It is probably impossible to prove that a given process is random. All you can do is prove some processes are not. The reason for this is that you will not be able to observe all instances of the random process, because you would have to observe it for an infinite time.
Take a random number generator: If it turns out to repeat its sequence after a time, it is pseudo-random. If not, it may be true random, or it may generate a sequence that is so long that you have not yet seen it repeat. In the latter case, unless you can inspect the apparatus generating it, you cannot distinguish between pseudo random and true random.
These questions are so unbearable for many here to consider that the tactic becomes "destroy the arguer". Hence we get all this nonsense about me being incomprehensible/dishonest etc.![]()
I suggest you get over your persecution complex. Sure, not all people agree with you. Get over it.
Hans

