Split Thread Atheism and lack of belief in the afterlife

It's super simple:
- Is the universe deterministic or indeterministic?

The universe follows a number of rules (natural laws), but is not entirely deterministic, as random functions exist.

- If the universe is deterministic then does randomness exist or is there only pseudo-randomness?

If the universe was deterministic, there would be no randomness. Pseudo random is not really random.

- If there is only pseudo randomness then where did the "blueprint" for the universe come from?

Well, in a hypothetic deterministic universe, the blueprint could be invariable physical laws, including such that would govern processes that currently seem random to us.

You see, there is a crunch here: It is probably impossible to prove that a given process is random. All you can do is prove some processes are not. The reason for this is that you will not be able to observe all instances of the random process, because you would have to observe it for an infinite time.

Take a random number generator: If it turns out to repeat its sequence after a time, it is pseudo-random. If not, it may be true random, or it may generate a sequence that is so long that you have not yet seen it repeat. In the latter case, unless you can inspect the apparatus generating it, you cannot distinguish between pseudo random and true random.

These questions are so unbearable for many here to consider that the tactic becomes "destroy the arguer". Hence we get all this nonsense about me being incomprehensible/dishonest etc. :rolleyes:

I suggest you get over your persecution complex. Sure, not all people agree with you. Get over it.

Hans
 
It is in the business of showing which assumptions are consistent with our most successful theories about the nature of the universe. If you choose to make different assumptions you are indulging in baseless speculation. Which is fine, as long as you acknowledge that is what you are doing.
It is fine to say something like "According to QM, the universe is indeterministic".


But most people go straight to "The universe is indeterministic". When asked how they know, they respond with something like "QM says so" - as if QM "proves" that the universe is indeterministic.

But as you say, "science is not in the business of proof". So basically, you have a theory which is consistent with the assertion that the universe is indeterministic.
 
And by god you are meaning "something that created the universe"?
Obviously but since I have no information regarding "lesser gods", that can't be definitively ruled out.

At best you can say that you have no reason to consider these gods in any context.
 
But most people go straight to "The universe is indeterministic".


As opposed to you just bare asserting that it is not???


When asked how they know,


How do you know it is not???


they respond with something like "QM says so" - as if QM "proves" that the universe is indeterministic.


As opposed to you bare asserting it is determined by a Magical Imp???


But as you say, "science is not in the business of proof". So basically, you have a theory which is consistent with the assertion that the universe is indeterministic.


As opposed to BLIND FAITH in a magical imp... right???
 
Last edited:
Obviously but since I have no information regarding "lesser gods", that can't be definitively ruled out.


WOW :eek::eye-poppi:boggled:

What about leprechauns and pixie fairies???


At best you can say that you have no reason to consider these gods in any context.


Why not??? Can't they have helped just like the elves help Santa make the toys or at least the magic reindeer distribute them??
 
Last edited:
It is fine to say something like "According to QM, the universe is indeterministic".
As long as you understand (and make it clear to anyone who doesn't) that QM is not "just a theory" (as that word is used in the vernacular) but explains all previous observations, successfully predicted many more, is the foundation of many important inventions and has stood unchallenged for nearly a century and then say "but I'm going to assume it's fundamentally wrong about everything and baselessly speculate about what the universe might be like in that case" before proceeding to do so.

But most people go straight to "The universe is indeterministic". When asked how they know, they respond with something like "QM says so" - as if QM "proves" that the universe is indeterministic.
Unless they actually use the word 'proof' (which anyone who knows enough about QM to know what it says is unlikely to do) they're more likely saying that as if it can be justifiably assumed, until or unless there is good reason to reconsider that assumption.

But as you say, "science is not in the business of proof". So basically, you have a theory which is consistent with the assertion that the universe is indeterministic.
A theory which is also consistent with all previous observations, successfully predicted many more, is the foundation of many important inventions and has stood unchallenged for nearly a century.
 
Last edited:
****** tfy.

Get the message yet or is it your intention to continue deleting "proven" so that you can continue to lie about what I post?


I fixed that for YOU.

You do not know what that word means... just like randomness.

But... you have not told me yet why do you dismiss other gods and leprechauns and pixie fairies?

Have you PROVEN they are nonexistent?

And if you are just in favor of your "true god" because he is the KING... why do you dismiss the entire COURT... the king after all has ministers and ambassadors and pages and cooks and janitors.

Do you think YHWH was the janitor or the stables cleaner? And Jesus as the son of the janitor god, is sitting on a throne beside his daddy... but not of the type christians think??

.
 
Last edited:
ftfy.

Get the message yet or is it your intention to continue deleting "proven" so that you can continue to lie about what I post?

Your continuing fixation with that word, as if it is one anyone who knows anything at all about science would ever use, is mystifying. The fact that no scientific theory can ever be 100% proven does not justify simply ignoring the scientific knowledge and understanding painstakingly accumulated by generations of humanity's greatest minds.

Speculate about what the universe might be like if it was all wrong if you want, but don't expect such baseless speculation to be given serious consideration.
 
Your continuing fixation with that word, as if it is one anyone who knows anything at all about science would ever use, is mystifying. The fact that no scientific theory can ever be 100% proven does not justify simply ignoring the scientific knowledge and understanding painstakingly accumulated by generations of humanity's greatest minds.


Ah... but therein lies the GAP... there is hung the whole BLIND FAITH in their god of the gaps.



Speculate about what the universe might be like if it was all wrong if you want, but don't expect such baseless speculation to be given serious consideration.


But it is given BILLION$$$$$$ of funding to keep that gap open and to subvert all reason and science in order to have atheists CONCERNED not be labeled nasty fundamentalist atheists who are just like the dogmatic theists and science is nothing but faith anyhow.
 
Last edited:
Your continuing fixation with that word, as if it is one anyone who knows anything at all about science would ever use, is mystifying.
It's either proven or not. It's that simple. If (as you say) science is not about proof then we don't have something that is proven.

The fact that no scientific theory can ever be 100% proven does not justify simply ignoring the scientific knowledge and understanding painstakingly accumulated by generations of humanity's greatest minds.
That is a stupid strawman argument.

I have NEVER EVER said that we should discard QM because its conclusion that the universe is indeterministic doesn't make this an immutable fact.
 
The fact that no scientific theory can ever be 100% proven
But is that actually true?

Definition of proven
demonstrated by evidence or argument to be true or existing.​

A theory that is logical, mathematically rigorous and fits the facts perfectly is proven. Take Newtonian physics for example. Yes, it needs a correction for relativistic speeds, but that doesn't make it wrong. NASA still uses it for their space missions.

An 'intelligent designer' OTOH is illogical, not supported by any math and has no evidence for it. It's not even a theory developed to explain observations, but an apologist's argument dreamed up to support a silly fantasy. It's not just not proven, it's disproven.
 
It's either proven or not. It's that simple. If (as you say) science is not about proof then we don't have something that is proven.
But you seem to be attaching significance to this which is entirely unwarranted.

I have NEVER EVER said that we should discard QM because its conclusion that the universe is indeterministic doesn't make this an immutable fact.

But you harp on about it as if it's significant, as if it leaves open the possibility of meaningful and arguable alternatives, when it really isn't and doesn't.
 
Your continuing fixation with that word, as if it is one anyone who knows anything at all about science would ever use, is mystifying. The fact that no scientific theory can ever be 100% proven does not justify simply ignoring the scientific knowledge and understanding painstakingly accumulated by generations of humanity's greatest minds.

Speculate about what the universe might be like if it was all wrong if you want, but don't expect such baseless speculation to be given serious consideration.

I'm with Roger Ramjets on this point. I know there is a tendency to want to leave the word "proven" to be applied to only one science i.e. mathematics but I think it can be used for many other claims in other sciences.

I was being serious asking psionl0 about the moon being made from green cheese or rather is it proven the moon is not made of green cheese.

We have proved conclusively that the moon is not made of green cheese in a myriad of ways, everything from seismic activity, gravity, density, tidal forces, direct sampling, spectrography.

There is no reason to add a "as far as we know" or any other qualifier. The idea that we can't have certainty in anything is nothing but an age old philosophical question that we long ago answered with a "yes we can".


ETA: It does of course mean we do need to be mindful of the limits of what we do know. For instance we know we don't have a TOE yet. We know lots of things we don't know but we do know some things.
 
Last edited:
It's either proven or not. It's that simple. If (as you say) science is not about proof then we don't have something that is proven.

*snip*

The highlighted part is your basic mistake. It is NOT that simple. We can only ever know anything based on our observations. Science is about refining our observation methods to be as reliable, repeatable, accurate, and objective as possible. It can never be perfect.

We know that the Moon is not made from cheese because all evidence direct and inferred points to that conclusion. For short, we say it has been proven, but to say something is proven is not simple; it is a simplification.

This thread has been a lot about determinism. You have said the universe is either deterministic or not deterministic, but that is also not simple, it is not even a valid simplification, because for all levels we are able to observe, the universe is both. It has both deterministic and non-deterministic properties.

Take snowflakes. All snow crystals are hexagonal in layout, that is deterministic. All snow crystals are made of ice, that is deterministic. No two snow crystals are alike, that is not deterministic.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom