Split Thread Atheism and lack of belief in the afterlife

It's either proven or not. It's that simple. If (as you say) science is not about proof then we don't have something that is proven.


That is a stupid strawman argument.

I have NEVER EVER said that we should discard QM because its conclusion that the universe is indeterministic doesn't make this an immutable fact.

I think you do misunderstand how theories are used and what they are.

For instance, QM was not created to prove whether reality was indeterministic or not, that is not where the various formulations of QM came from. QM was posed as a theory to explain certain empirical observations/measurements.

As it accurately explained those observations it was further considered and folk started to extend it or rather explore the mathematics as QM, QED etc are a mathematical theory, the solutions to the equations indicated that if we looked in X we should find Y.

One of the implications was that randomness is at the heart of reality. Another area was whether there was a further set of - as they are often called - "hidden" variables that would demonstrate that things weren't random - that is the great debate that Einstein is often associated with.

The maths is excruciating and beyond my personal ability to understand so I must rely on imprecise English language explanations, but we could in fact test for whether there was another layer of reality underpinning the mathmatics of QM that would explain the randomness we have found. By dint of work by some extraordinary talented researchers we have created empirical experiments that we can run and we have found there isn't.

When "QM" (and of course we are only using QM as a shorthand for all the current off shoots) is revised or replaced it won't change what we now know by empirical measures, which is that reality at its most fundamental scales is indeterminate. Think of it this way, Newton's physics weren't supplanted by a theory that said apples will fall upwards. Theories don't change the empirical evidence, they remain when the theories change.

So I will disagree with many of the members here and say we have proved that the universe is indeterministic at its fundamental scale.
 
ETA: It does of course mean we do need to be mindful of the limits of what we do know. For instance we know we don't have a TOE yet...

Huh... :confused:

I have 10 of them :D

What is a TOE??


I'm with Roger Ramjets on this point. I know there is a tendency to want to leave the word "proven" to be applied to only one science i.e. mathematics but I think it can be used for many other claims in other sciences.


Yes... :thumbsup:


There is no reason to add a "as far as we know" or any other qualifier. The idea that we can't have certainty in anything is nothing but an age old philosophical question that we long ago answered with a "yes we can".


But that is what it is all about isn't it ... OLD CODSWALLOP that they want to keep relentlessly clenching onto in order to keep that BLIND FAITH in the "true god" going by hook or by crook.


I was being serious asking psionl0 about the moon being made from green cheese or rather is it proven the moon is not made of green cheese.


Ah... but what about Brie??


We have proved conclusively that the moon is not made of green cheese in a myriad of ways, everything from seismic activity, gravity, density, tidal forces, direct sampling, spectrography.


But are you sure Brie Cheese doesn't pass all those UNPROVEN "science" claptrap too?

Until you have "PROVEN" that Brie Cheese is not it you cannot dismiss the possibility that it is.... no?

And if you ever manage to convince me that it is not Brie then you have to also show that it is not Queso Manchego.

And then you have to also show that it is not all Baloney just like the "true god".


We know lots of things we don't know but we do know some things.


AHA... bingo... you do not know if the "true god" and "intelligent forces" do not exist... ergo... BLIND FAITH is fully legitimate and justified... unless you are not CONCERNED about being like those nasty atheists who are just like the fundamentalist theists and who have science for their religion.


.
 
Last edited:
The highlighted part is your basic mistake. It is NOT that simple. We can only ever know anything based on our observations. Science is about refining our observation methods to be as reliable, repeatable, accurate, and objective as possible. It can never be perfect.

We know that the Moon is not made from cheese because all evidence direct and inferred points to that conclusion. For short, we say it has been proven, but to say something is proven is not simple; it is a simplification.

This thread has been a lot about determinism. You have said the universe is either deterministic or not deterministic, but that is also not simple, it is not even a valid simplification, because for all levels we are able to observe, the universe is both. It has both deterministic and non-deterministic properties.

Take snowflakes. All snow crystals are hexagonal in layout, that is deterministic. All snow crystals are made of ice, that is deterministic. No two snow crystals are alike, that is not deterministic.

:bigclap


I think you do misunderstand how theories are used and what they are.

For instance, QM was not created to prove whether reality was indeterministic or not, that is not where the various formulations of QM came from. QM was posed as a theory to explain certain empirical observations/measurements.

As it accurately explained those observations it was further considered and folk started to extend it or rather explore the mathematics as QM, QED etc are a mathematical theory, the solutions to the equations indicated that if we looked in X we should find Y.

One of the implications was that randomness is at the heart of reality. Another area was whether there was a further set of - as they are often called - "hidden" variables that would demonstrate that things weren't random - that is the great debate that Einstein is often associated with.

The maths is excruciating and beyond my personal ability to understand so I must rely on imprecise English language explanations, but we could in fact test for whether there was another layer of reality underpinning the mathmatics of QM that would explain the randomness we have found. By dint of work by some extraordinary talented researchers we have created empirical experiments that we can run and we have found there isn't.

When "QM" (and of course we are only using QM as a shorthand for all the current off shoots) is revised or replaced it won't change what we now know by empirical measures, which is that reality at its most fundamental scales is indeterminate. Think of it this way, Newton's physics weren't supplanted by a theory that said apples will fall upwards. Theories don't change the empirical evidence, they remain when the theories change.

So I will disagree with many of the members here and say we have proved that the universe is indeterministic at its fundamental scale.


Exactly!!!! :bigclap


BUT... unfortunately and depressingly... just like Flat Earthers refuse to believe the live feed of the ISS... the above will not help stem BLIND FAITH in "intelligent forces".
 
Theory of everything - often used to describe the theory that will replace QM & GR with one unified model.


Ah yes... for combining all the strong and weak and gravity and electro-magnetic forces... I am just not good at acronyms.

But... I'm CONCERNED that they also need to include "intelligent forces" too... or else it will remain forever not "true" "science" and will be a religion for those nasty atheists.
 
Last edited:
...Do you think YHWH was the janitor or the stables cleaner? And Jesus as the son of the janitor god, is sitting on a throne beside his daddy... but not of the type christians think??...


This is kind of a kind with your over-the-top style of commenting; and call me shallow, I won't mind, I do enjoy watching old Three Stooges and Mr Bean vids; but I laughed out loud at this! :thumbsup:
 
Random or not random
Deterministic or not determinstic.

These words have colloquial and scientific definitions. The colloquial definitions include conscious thought or intention. So from a colloquial perspective, one's answers depends on whether you are superstitious and believe in fairy tales or not.

But science is not superstitious. It does not even consider the supernatural. Methodological naturalism is its modus operandi. It is also not in the business of proof. It provides today's best answers to the available data.(BTW, proof is a mathematical term)

So from a scientific perspective, there are elements in the universe that are is deterministic and there are elements that are random. There are also elements that may be both or either deterministic and random at the same time. Similar to Schrödinger's cat. But there are also elements that aren't known as of yet. Also similar to Schrödinger's cat.

But absolutely none of this opens the door for a designer or creator. Maybe if believers presented us with identifiable characteristics. As opposed to nonsensical or amorphous words like "timeless" and "spaceless."

Want us to take your God hypothesis seriously? Offer us something we can test for.

As opposed to word salads straight from your ass.
 
Last edited:
Random or not random
Deterministic or not determinstic.

These words have colloquial and scientific definitions. The colloquial definitions include conscious thought or intention. So from a colloquial perspective, one's answers depends on whether you are superstitious and believe in fairy tales or not.

But science is not superstitious. It does not even consider the supernatural. Methodological naturalism is its modus operandi. It is also not in the business of proof. It provides today's best answers to the available data.(BTW, proof is a mathematical term)
So from a scientific perspective, there are elements in the universe that are is deterministic and there are elements that are random. There are also elements that may be both or either deterministic and random at the same time. Similar to Schrödinger's cat. But there are also elements that aren't known as of yet. Also similar to Schrödinger's cat.

But absolutely none of this opens the door for a designer or creator. Maybe if believers presented us with identifiable characteristics. As opposed to nonsensical or amorphous words like "timeless" and "spaceless."

Want us to take your God hypothesis seriously? Offer us something we can test for.

As opposed to word salads straight from your ass.

Highlighted: Allow me to (again) quote sir Arthur C Clarke: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic". We all know technology that was magic just a few decades ago.

Science does not deny the supernatural. It just denies that it is magic. IF something .. uh, say, dowsing, works, then science will test it, map it, try to find what makes it work, and it will be ... science. Dowsing has been tested and shown NOT to work.

But other things have worked: It has long been known that homing pigeons could somehow navigate across considerable distances. Magic? No, eventually experiments showed that they have a sense that enables them to perceive Earth's magnetic field. In fact other species may also have that sense.

IF there is intelligence in the way the universe works, science will seek to find what drives this intelligence. God will not be magic. God will be ... something explainable. ... Actually, that would be a real downer to certain religious people. ;)

Hans
 
Highlighted: Allow me to (again) quote sir Arthur C Clarke: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic". We all know technology that was magic just a few decades ago.

Science does not deny the supernatural. It just denies that it is magic. IF something .. uh, say, dowsing, works, then science will test it, map it, try to find what makes it work, and it will be ... science. Dowsing has been tested and shown NOT to work.

But other things have worked: It has long been known that homing pigeons could somehow navigate across considerable distances. Magic? No, eventually experiments showed that they have a sense that enables them to perceive Earth's magnetic field. In fact other species may also have that sense.

IF there is intelligence in the way the universe works, science will seek to find what drives this intelligence. God will not be magic. God will be ... something explainable. ... Actually, that would be a real downer to certain religious people. ;)

Hans

Science doesn't deny the supernatural. It just doesn't "do" the supernatural. As I said, methodological naturalism. You can't test the supernatural.

The explanation is NEVER God or magic. They explain nothing.

I prefer Pierre-Simon LaPlace's answer;

"Je n'avais pas besoin de cette hypothèse-là."
 
Last edited:
...

But absolutely none of this opens the door for a designer or creator. Maybe if believers presented us with identifiable characteristics. As opposed to nonsensical or amorphous words like "timeless" and "spaceless."

Want us to take your God hypothesis seriously? Offer us something we can test for.
As opposed to word salads straight from your ass.


They cannot and will never do so.... because God was and has always been right from the onset of the postulation of the concept... nothing but

... word salads straight from [their] ass.

[imgw=400]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_5128262e1da1f0fe2e.jpg[/imgw]​
 
Hmm... 37 pages...

Did anyone manage to find any atheists that believe in an afterlife yet?

And has anyone managed to explain that the mechanisms of 'natural selection' and 'sexual selection' do not meet any definition of random?
 
Hmm... 37 pages...

Did anyone manage to find any atheists that believe in an afterlife yet?


Well... I am still trying to start my new religion of afterlife without a god... no takers yet.:mad:


And has anyone managed to explain that the mechanisms of 'natural selection' and 'sexual selection' do not meet any definition of random?


Well... natural selection is rife with randomness such as earthquakes and volcanoes and droughts and pestilence... think what happened to Europe after almost 2/3 of its population was naturally selected out of existence by the bubonic plague which was the result of yet another pestilence called Christianity making witches a sin and killing their familiars the cats.

Additionally, sexual selection is also filled to the hilt with randomness... such as rapine and raping an pillaging being the savoir faire of most the existence of humanity... who knew which woman was going to be raped instead of clobbered... or even both... let alone which man was going to be the one to do it out of the pillagers of the villagers.

Even in the more halcyon days of cavemen where not much rapine or pillaging was going on... there was still the raping which depended on which tribe happened to encounter another while hunting and gathering.
 
Last edited:
As opposed to word salads straight from your ass.

[imgw=400]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_5128262e1da1f0fe2e.jpg[/imgw]​

I absolutely hate when theists describe God as "timeless" or"spaceless." Or "that God exists outside of space and time." These words have no meaning. They are also impossible. Existence is necessarily temporal.

It's also isn't describing what God is, but what it isn't.
 
Science doesn't deny the supernatural. It just doesn't "do" the supernatural. As I said, methodological naturalism. You can't test the supernatural.
It doesn't deny that the supernatural is fantasy, but it does deny that it exists. Because it doesn't - by definition. The definition that theists themselves use.

They want to have it both ways. They say science can't test the supernatural because it is outside nature, and science can only test things in the natural world. Therefore the supernatural can be anything they dream up, and logic, evidence, and the laws of nature don't apply. Yet they also assert that it can't be disproven, even though they have defined it as false!

People who want us to believe that God and the afterlife exist will get nowhere while they themselves refuse to allow it to exist. But they can't do that because then it would become testable, and the gig would be up.
 
Last edited:
I absolutely hate when theists describe God as "timeless" or"spaceless." Or "that God exists outside of space and time." These words have no meaning. They are also impossible. Existence is necessarily temporal.

It's also isn't describing what God is, but what it isn't.

It doesn't deny that the supernatural is fantasy, but it does deny that it exists. Because it doesn't - by definition. The definition that theists themselves use.

They want to have it both ways. They say science can't test the supernatural because it is outside nature, and science can only test things in the natural world. Therefore the supernatural can be anything they dream up, and logic, evidence, and the laws of nature don't apply. Yet they also assert that it can't be disproven, even though they have defined it as false!

People who want us to believe that God and the afterlife exist will get nowhere while they themselves refuse to allow it to exist. But they can't do that because then it would become testable, and gig would be up.


Indeed!!!

Also not to mention that the god-peddlers keep hawking about the pleasure they got when this absentee deadbeat sky daddy of theirs pokes his "finger" into this universe and spends time repeatedly giving them the elations of being with them and helping them find their car keys and killing their enemies' children for them and steering the wheel of their cars when they have an accident and helping them win football matches and etching his face on a toilet door... in men's restrooms of course because he is not Trans.
 
Last edited:
I absolutely hate when theists describe God as "timeless" or"spaceless." Or "that God exists outside of space and time.".
It's just words. They might as well talk about the 4 sides of a circle.

The more they try to inoculate their god against reason and logic, the more ridiculous it gets. A god so powerful that He knows everything and can do anything, yet does stupid stuff like flooding the world to fix something He didn't see coming. A perfect God who can only do good, who created everything out of nothing, including evil. And then gets upset about it.
 
It's just words. They might as well talk about the 4 sides of a circle.

The Vice President shot the Secretary of the Treasury over "just words".

Language means a lot. Con artists use words to separate marks from their money.
 
Last edited:
It's just words. They might as well talk about the 4 sides of a circle.

The more they try to inoculate their god against reason and logic, the more ridiculous it gets. A god so powerful that He knows everything and can do anything, yet does stupid stuff like flooding the world to fix something He didn't see coming. A perfect God who can only do good, who created everything out of nothing, including evil. And then gets upset about it.


And who commands the killing of babies (1 Samuel 15:3) and smashing their heads on rocks (Psalms 137:9) and taking little girls as sex slaves after massacring their entire kin and kith and country (Numbers 31:1-18) and then makes people who do not like him eat their children (Jeremiah 19:4-15)... and commands a husband chop off the hand of his wife WITHOUT PITY because she HELPED HIM against attackers attacking him (Deuteronomy 25:11-12)

And then goes on to rape a married young girl to impregnate her with his ill begotten son who demands people hate their kin and kith (Luke 14:26, Matthew 10:34-35) and abandon them unprotected and unprovided for and leave their dead parents unburied (Matthew 8:21-22) to go join his mystery death cult and to castrate themselves for his sake (Matthew 19:12).
 
And who commands the killing of babies (1 Samuel 15:3) and smashing their heads on rocks (Psalms 137:9) and taking little girls as sex slaves after massacring their entire kin and kith and country (Numbers 31:1-18) and then makes people who do not like him eat their children (Jeremiah 19:4-15)... and commands a husband chop off the hand of his wife WITHOUT PITY because she HELPED HIM against attackers attacking him (Deuteronomy 25:11-12)

And then goes on to rape a married young girl to impregnate her with his ill begotten son who demands people hate their kin and kith (Luke 14:26, Matthew 10:34-35) and abandon them unprotected and unprovided for and leave their dead parents unburied (Matthew 8:21-22) to go join his mystery death cult and to castrate themselves for his sake (Matthew 19:12).

Most Christians that sit in the pews every Sunday and sometimes Saturday really don’t have a clue just how awful their religion is. It's all Jesus loves me. He gave his life for me. (Never mind he didn’t do that.) At most, he had a bad weekend.

Never mind that the book is racist and sexist. That it makes women permanent second class citizens. And tells them to make slaves of non-believers. That they can beat their slaves as long as they don't die with a couple of days. Never mind that polygamy is fine. That men can have multiple wives and female sex slaves. That a rapist is forced to marry their victims. There are verses used to coerce people into shunning their neighbors, friends and family.

I grew up going to church, bible camp etc. I had a good time. The one positive about church is community. But the Bible lessons were almost always BS. And they really avoid teaching anyone the cruel and disturbing parts of the Bible.

I get what goes on in the minds of the believers. They have a routine. A way of life. Not believing upsets their apple carts. It changes everything. It changes their relationships to everyone around them. So they hold on tight.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom