Arizona school to "whiten" mural image

The irony is that if Arizona is anything like Queensland in Australia, skin cancer rates will be high and white skin will be dying out naturally over time anyway. India still makes a virtue of 'wheaten' skin, (from the time of the aryan invasion), even though this natural evolution has already happened over it's history, with dark skin that tolerates the sun better being the norm.
 
I literally have no idea what you're asking.
Actually, you do.

That's where the story ends...except for the racists screaming slurs at the artist.
Unrelated to the quote.

Would it be a big deal if a school on the South Side of Chicago put up a mural with a white kid on it, people screamed racial slurs at the artist, then a local reverend went on a rant? Sure. Probably not as big of deal as this case, but then again the two aren't analagous because of this little thing called "history."
Actually, they are comparable, just not identical.

It's bizarre to pretend like race relations in the US are perfectly symmetrical and something profound can be created by simply reversing the race of the main players.
Who pretended they were symmetrical? The only way race relations are going to get better is for every side to look at things from different perspectives. We need to understand that the concept of race is a social one based on superficial physical characteristics and cultural heritage, not on fundamental biological differences that set us apart. Under the hood we are very much the same.

We need to acknowledge that we're social animals, and like social animals we find strength in our pack and have a natural resistance to those from other packs. It's natural to react in some way to those who are "different" from us, but it's what we do about those reactions that counts. It's also important to concentrate less on the differences and more on the similarities, since we're all part of the human race.

So, when people look at a mural like that, they are going to wonder to themselves why certain choices were made. I would say that pretty much everybody is going to think about that to a certain degree. Merely discussing the issue is not necessarily a bad thing. Maybe, and it doesn't look like it in this case, wondering why the kid was "black" looking is not all that different than somebody else wondering why a "white" looking kid was chosen.
 
Who pretended they were symmetrical? The only way race relations are going to get better is for every side to look at things from different perspectives. We need to understand that the concept of race is a social one based on superficial physical characteristics and cultural heritage, not on fundamental biological differences that set us apart. Under the hood we are very much the same.

While I agree with the spirit of your post, I disagree strongly with the bolded excerpt.

It's not a matter of "looking at things," it's a matter of centuries of persecution that have left a legacy of structural inequity. We just need to "feel the pain" of the African American community and all these years of violence and terrorism will just wash away.

Sure, we're the same under the hood. Then explain why the gap between the races continues to grow:

Blacks remain twice as likely to be unemployed, three times more likely to live in poverty and more than six times as likely to be imprisoned compared with whites, according to the group's annual State of Black America report issued Wednesday.

http://www.cnn.com/2009/US/03/25/black.america.report/index.html

Just a matter of perspective?

Dog bits man, no story, man bites dog, story. Racial relations in this country are not reciprocal.

So, when people look at a mural like that, they are going to wonder to themselves why certain choices were made. I would say that pretty much everybody is going to think about that to a certain degree. Merely discussing the issue is not necessarily a bad thing. Maybe, and it doesn't look like it in this case, wondering why the kid was "black" looking is not all that different than somebody else wondering why a "white" looking kid was chosen.

Well, this racist DJ should certainly hire you as his PR agent, you've done a wonderful job of cloaking his overt racism in friendly sounding euphamisms.

He was "merely discussing" and simply wondering "why" in a completely neutral, non-racist way. It's pure coincidence that these harmless musings occured in the racially charged AZ atmosphere as people drove by hurling racial slurs at the artist.

The exact same thing would have happened if the kid had been white.
 
While I agree with the spirit of your post, I disagree strongly with the bolded excerpt.

It's not a matter of "looking at things," it's a matter of centuries of persecution that have left a legacy of structural inequity. We just need to "feel the pain" of the African American community and all these years of violence and terrorism will just wash away.
And this precludes looking at things from different perspectives how? It's a false dichotomy.

Sure, we're the same under the hood. Then explain why the gap between the races continues to grow:
Is this supposed to be evidence of fundamental biological differences? I ask because that's what I was referring to. Many believe believe that there are major genetic differences among the so-called races, but there aren't.

Just a matter of perspective?
You introduced the word "just" of your own volition. I never said anything about "just" looking at things from other perspectives. I said it was a prerequisite, and it is.

Take, for example, my stance of English only in government. The knee-jerk reaction here in Arizona is that I must be anti-brown. That's not the case. You're a lawyer, so you understand more than most just how important language is. Laws and contracts use specific words with specific legal meanings, and other languages do not have direct translations. It's difficult even in ordinary writing to translate things without altering the meaning to some degree. Therefore, I argue that we all have an obligation to understand a single language, and in the USA, that's English.

To translate into just one other language, Spanish in Arizona, is in my opinion favoring one group (Spanish speakers) over other groups, such as my European family and friends for whom English is a second or third language. I also wonder whether the notices I see in Spanish are accurate translations such that they understand what I understand. Given the poor writing I see far too often coming from schools and governments, I think this is rather likely.

I understand where people are coming from with wanting to translate things into Spanish and offer Spanish speaking services. If we could do that for every language out there, I would be okay with it provided we could afford it. But since we don't, my perspective is that some groups are treated unfairly.

Unfortunately, my message is not even discussed rationally because other some other people don't try to see it that way. They look at the very real anti-brown movement and paint everybody with the same brush. Ironically, that's exactly what the anti-brown movement does that they find so horrible.


Dog bits man, no story, man bites dog, story. Racial relations in this country are not reciprocal.
No duh!

Well, this racist DJ should certainly hire you as his PR agent, you've done a wonderful job of cloaking his overt racism in friendly sounding euphamisms.
You should really spend more time reading my posts since I wrote that my possible interpretation does not look to be the situation in this case. In other posts I have criticized the guy for taking it public after the fact instead of addressing it in private when I'm sure the discussions probably took place.

He was "merely discussing" and simply wondering "why" in a completely neutral, non-racist way. It's pure coincidence that these harmless musings occured in the racially charged AZ atmosphere as people drove by hurling racial slurs at the artist.
Thank you for demonstrating exactly the type of behavior I am talking about. You save me needing to give an object lesson.
 
So, when people look at a mural like that, they are going to wonder to themselves why certain choices were made.

Really? What people are those? Like most everyone else, I am bombarded with images of people everyday on television, the internet, print media, advertising, etc. Never once have I wondered why the man trying to sell me Gatorade is one ethnicity or why the woman reading the news is another. I innately accept that in a multi-cultural society, I'm bound to see some multi-culturalism.

The fact that you want to frame the questioning of this child's ethnicity as borne of some kind of natural curiousity we all would have is... strange.
 
And this precludes looking at things from different perspectives how? It's a false dichotomy.
...

Your claim is that the DJ did not make a racist statement and the local push to whiten the faces is not racist?
 
Really? What people are those? Like most everyone else, I am bombarded with images of people everyday on television, the internet, print media, advertising, etc. Never once have I wondered why the man trying to sell me Gatorade is one ethnicity or why the woman reading the news is another. I innately accept that in a multi-cultural society, I'm bound to see some multi-culturalism.

The fact that you want to frame the questioning of this child's ethnicity as borne of some kind of natural curiousity we all would have is... strange.

I have a background in marketing. People identify (or not) to some degree with the imagery presented. When that imagery is not what they expect, they will often wonder why the choices were made. When it is what they expect, they don't think much about it consciously because subconsciously they have already formed an opinion.

Truth is, a lot of discussion goes into making these types of choices so that people don't wonder all that much. That's why the image of the person eating granola is not a Pygmy and the lady reading the news isn't an Eskimo in an national campaign in the USA. Every once in a while you'll see a blog where somebody points out the "same" ad in different parts of the country/world will have somebody of a different ethnicity "Photoshopped" in place of somebody else.

We've seen it in this thread. Some people expected the kid to be of "mixed race" or "brown" or whatever because of the background of the school. They certainly expected it to be a kid rather than an adult. Had it been a Hopi in full costume, a lot of people would have wondered about it.
 
Your claim is that the DJ did not make a racist statement and the local push to whiten the faces is not racist?

I did not comment on the DJ because I did not listen to the radio show. I did not comment on the local push to lighten (not whiten, that's your word), because I did not see enough information behind the scenes to form an opinion. One official, who is not related at all to the guy making these other statements, was reported as saying:

http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/2010/06/04/20100604arizona-mural-sparks-racial-debate.html
Wall said school Principal Jeff Lane pressed him to make the children's faces appear happier and brighter.

"It is being lightened because of the controversy," Wall said, adding that "they want it to look like the children are coming into light."

Lane said that he received only three complaints about the mural and that his request for a touch-up had nothing to do with political pressure. "We asked them to fix the shading on the children's faces," he said. "We were looking at it from an artistic view. Nothing at all to do with race."

Do I find that implausible? No, not really. You'd be amazed what kind of crap goes on when you create artwork for people. Some of us refer to it as pixel-***********. I've had people pore over hundreds of images trying to decide just which one is the "right" one. They will agonize over the most minute details, make a decision, then two days later go with something else. A month later they can't remember which one they picked or why, but at the time it was the most important thing in the world.

Ever hear of Pantone? They make a bundle off of being very exact with colors. Take a look at these various color charts. People agonize over the most subtle of shades when, according to some tests people here took regarding their ability to distinguish colors, they are not really seeing the differences they think they see. Couple that with the fact that the lighting and other factors (nearby colors) will swamp the tiny differences they perceive.

Anyway, my point is that I don't at all find it surprising that people will want to mess around with shading. It also wouldn't surprise me to learn that they had racial motivations or even financial/political motivations. I just don't have enough information to comment either way, so I won't.
 
I have a background in marketing. People identify (or not) to some degree with the imagery presented. When that imagery is not what they expect, they will often wonder why the choices were made. When it is what they expect, they don't think much about it consciously because subconsciously they have already formed an opinion.

Why would somoene in Arizona not expect to see a black or Hispanic person in a mural?

Truth is, a lot of discussion goes into making these types of choices so that people don't wonder all that much. That's why the image of the person eating granola is not a Pygmy and the lady reading the news isn't an Eskimo in an national campaign in the USA.

That's probably because you don't see too many Pygmies and Eskimos in the U.S. But black and Hispanic people are fairly common.

We've seen it in this thread. Some people expected the kid to be of "mixed race" or "brown" or whatever because of the background of the school. They certainly expected it to be a kid rather than an adult. Had it been a Hopi in full costume, a lot of people would have wondered about it.

And I suppose had it been a polar bear in a tutu on a unicycle, that also might have struck some people as odd. But it was a portrayal of a Hispanic child. In the American Southwest. Who actually attends that school. Why would that be unexpected?
 
Last edited:
This brings up an interesting question that I've been pondering for some time: what are the demographic trends in AZ these days? Is it becoming more and more ethnically diverse, following most national trends? In addition, is there - as there is on the national level - a correlation between political affiliation & ethnicity?

I ask because my hypothesis is that what we're seeing from AZ with these kind of issues is a kind of pushback from some conservative, Republican members of a white population who see themselves losing majority status in the coming decades (and thus political influence as well). It's similar to the reaction we've seen from some on the right-wing regarding the election of our first non-white (well, technically, half-white) President; they just seem to be unable to wrap their minds around the fact that it won't be "their" country anymore.

I live here, and that seems to be right on the money.

If you want to talk overt racism outside of the South, check out Utah. The majority of Utahns are Mormon, and a kind of implicit racism forms the very foundation of much of their theology. For example, for non-whites who are Mormon, they are taught that they'll go to a "lower level" of heaven than white Mormons. That's right, even in heaven the non-whites get to sit on the back of the bus!

If you pass through that state and get a chance to talk candidly to anyone who isn't white, especially Indians, you'll hear plenty about the racism there.

AZ has the second largest Mormon population.
 
Last edited:
Why would somoene in Arizona not expect to see a black or Hispanic person in a mural?
Arizona is just lines on a map, so to say "someone in Arizona" is pretty much meaningless. Like everywhere else in the world, it comes down to communities. Unlike most other places in the world, Arizona's cities are very separate (with the exception of the Phoenix metropolitan area). There is literally nothing between Phoenix and Prescott but highway cut through mountains. Go to Google Maps to see what I mean.

Even within the Phoenix metro area there are big differences in the adjoining cities. And by adjoining, I mean nothing in between and connected by roads of the same name.

City: White vs Black Percentage (2000 Census numbers)
Phoenix: 71.1 vs 5.1
Tempe: 77.5 vs 3.7
Mesa: 81.7 vs 2.5
Scottsdale: 92.2 vs 1.2

Percent Reporting as Hispanic
Phoenix: 34.1
Mesa: 19.7
Tempe: 17.9
Scottsdale: 7.0

Prescott is 92.9% white, 0.5% black and 8.2% reporting hispanic while Sierra Vista is 73.3% white, 10.9% black and 15.8% reporting hispanic. In other words "someone in Arizona" is a mythical being when it comes to perception of those around them.

That's probably because you don't see too many Pygmies and Eskimos in the U.S. But black and Hispanic people are fairly common.
Which does not undermine my point.


And I suppose had it been a polar bear in a tutu on a unicycle, that also might have struck some people as odd. But it was a portrayal of a Hispanic child. In the American Southwest. Who actually attends that school. Why would that be unexpected?
Some thought the kid looked "black" for lack of a better term. In a city where only 1 out of every 200 people you see identifies themselves as black, it's a) not surprising if people get confused about what "black" looks like in a stylized drawing and b) would express surprise at that choice. BTW, there are about 3X as many American Indian or Alaska Native persons as "black" people in Prescott.

I'm not trying to justify anything. I'm taking the rather moderate position that it's not unexpected that some perfectly reasonable people would cock a brow and wonder about the choice made. I'm not going to get all worked up about it and force people to into corners. It's the whole looking at it from different perspectives thing.
 
AZ has the second largest Mormon population.
That is not correct. It's #4 by population and #5 by percentage in the USA.
http://www.mormonwiki.com/Membership_Statistics_U.S.

About 1/4 of the residents of Mesa are Mormon, and that 1/4 represents about 1/4 of the statewide population of Mormons. In other words Mormons make up about 25% of Mesa and 5% of the rest of Arizona.

Maybe it will be a Jeopardy question.
 
We call this a train wreck in these here parts. Yeehah.

Right in me back yard! Down the street I think... I live close to the medical center:rolleyes: and I didn't know any of this stink was flyin'.:D
 
Here's the artist's rendition that allows a closer view of the full mural already linked.

The principal of a Prescott, AZ elementary school has ordered that a mural — depicting current students at his school — have the skin tones lightened, after a series of racial slurs were hurled at the painters.

So now the PC thing to do is change what the bigots don't like? It's a no win situation; if the white kid was in the forefront, Al Sharpton would be rallying in front of the picture. The way I see it, only a racist or someone trying to be a vicitm would be concerned with what race was the biggest image.
 
So now the PC thing to do is change what the bigots don't like? It's a no win situation; if the white kid was in the forefront, Al Sharpton would be rallying in front of the picture. ...
What nonsense. Cite a single case where Sharpton protested a school mural that wasn't black enough. The issue here is not what the mural artist chose to depict. The issue is the racist who objected to the mural images the artist chose to depict.
 
A point of accuracy. The principal appeared before a protest crowd and simply and plainly said that he was wrong to order the 'correction'. The mural remains painted as originally intended.

My daughter attended college a couple blocks from where this is located. Although not the Mona Lisa, it reflects the character of the area and will hopefully be a source of pride for the city. Certainly next time I'm down that way I'll stop by to see the 'famous mural' and maybe buy a taco too.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom