Arizona school to "whiten" mural image

Looks to me like a mixed race child which seems like a very appropriate choice for any school mural.

What idiots the complainers are.

Tell me, how is your claiming there is an "appropriate" choice of "race" for the school morally superior to his? Same misguided attitude, different recommendation.

If you want to be pragmatic about it, Prescott is lilly white, so on that level your suggestion also fails.
 
It's also interesting to realise that I've never seen a successful argument that started with "I'm not racist, but..."
this argument needs a name like Godwin's Law.
The urban dictionary gives these explanations.
In honor of Steve Blair and his irrefutable logic, when ever someone begins an argument with "I am not a racist but," the argument is officially over and you have been "Blaired." Let it be known from today forward this argument is known officially as Blair's Law.:D
 
Tell me, how is your claiming there is an "appropriate" choice of "race" for the school morally superior to his? Same misguided attitude, different recommendation.

If you want to be pragmatic about it, Prescott is lilly white, so on that level your suggestion also fails.

As of the census[16] of 2000, there were 33,938 people, 15,098 households, and 8,968 families residing in the city. The population density was 915.6 people per square mile (353.5/km²). There were 17,144 housing units at an average density of 462.5/sq mi (178.6/km²). The racial makeup of the city was 92.93% White, 0.50% Black or African American, 1.27% Native American, 0.83% Asian, 0.06% Pacific Islander, 2.77% from other races, and 1.63% from two or more races. 8.17% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race.
But yet there *are* other people besides whites there, and it is quite likely it's a diversity for diversity's sake thing. Which is both good and bad..

ETA: .. oops, someone pointed out to me that 8.17% are hispanic/latino.. Huh.. that's 1 in 12... maybe there was a reason?

ETA2: Also it being whitened due to arizona is not a defense against people wishing to lighten the color. It's .. an excuse.
 
Last edited:
Rika, I think Yimmy's idea was that there's no NEED for the child to be more one colour than another, it should be purely up to the artist.
 
Oh. Sorry, tired and my humor sense is definitely gone. My apologies

Cactus: OK, that makes sense. Again, tired. Probably should just go to sleep instead of posting then.

In your defense, this *is* Arizona. Anything is possible. Living here makes it hard to make fun of Chicago or the Marion Barry days in DC.
 
Tell me, how is your claiming there is an "appropriate" choice of "race" for the school morally superior to his?

She never said her suggestion was "morally superior." You seem to be making that claim yourself, and ascribing it to her. There's a name for that.
 
She never said her suggestion was "morally superior." You seem to be making that claim yourself, and ascribing it to her. There's a name for that.

She called the complainers idiots and said her solution of "mixed race" was more appropriate. I combined that statement with my prior knowledge of SGs comments about race and discrimination to draw a conclusion. She, of course, is welcome to correct me, and since SG holds the JREF record for Most Claims of Straw Man, I don't think she'll have any problems if I misstated her position.
 
Personally, I love how the guy's complaint is about a black child, when the child is pretty obviously not.
Racial classification is never obvious, and for what it's worth the child looks black to me (although heavily stylized like everything else in the mural, including the birds).
 
She called the complainers idiots and said her solution of "mixed race" was more appropriate.

I thought she was saying the lead kid (with the flag) looked like a mixed race kid to her anyway (compared to the kneeling kid who looks more typically black), hence the complainers were idiots, and that including the mixed race kid seemed like an appropriate choice by the artist.
 
Last edited:
Oh, so they're saying the kid in the middle is black. Again, that doesn't surprise me. He's wearing urban style clothes and people will see what they choose to see. That's stereotypes at work.
 
I thought she was saying the lead kid (with the flag) looked like a mixed race kid to her anyway (compared to the kneeling kid who looks more typically black), hence the complainers were idiots, and that including the mixed race kid seemed like an appropriate choice by the artist.

Saying that her choice of "race" is okay is no different than the person quoted in the OP wondering aloud "why" they chose a black kid.
 
I'm Sorry

Also, I read the quote from the bigot several times and still can't parse it into a coherent sentence. Can someone tell me why he brings up the president?

Sorry if this has been addressed... He mentions it because the majority in this state is so daft that one of our Senator's (McCain) is successfully campaigning on protecting our state from President Obama.... obviously this guy wants in on that.

So from me on behalf of the not so idiotic Arizonans, I'm Sorry.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom