Arizona school to "whiten" mural image

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ynews/20100604/ts_ynews/ynews_ts2425

Apparently, having a "dark" child showing soo prominently on the mural caused soooo many complaints.

I am definitely NOT going to Arizona any time soon.
Tucson is not that bad. It is an island of conservatism in an sea of fascism. Keep in mind that what most of the nation is hearing about is the will of the slim majority of the voting public, and the ***hats on the radio, and that slim majority is shrinking by the day. l

I most assuredly do not believe that the entire town is racist. On the other hand it is more than just one (prominent) racist in that town - "R.E. Wall,... told the Republic that local residents driving by the mural as [the artists] were painting it — sometimes with children helping — shouted ethnic slurs."
I see you live on the gulf coast.... glass houses. My anecdotal evidence based on working in an academic environment in Tucson for 11 years, and Houston for the last 5, leads me to believe that AZ has nothing on Texas when it comes to the incidence of overt racists. I can't see the rest of the gulf coast being that much better.

Daredelvis
 
I see you live on the gulf coast.... glass houses. My anecdotal evidence based on working in an academic environment in Tucson for 11 years, and Houston for the last 5, leads me to believe that AZ has nothing on Texas when it comes to the incidence of overt racists. I can't see the rest of the gulf coast being that much better.

Daredelvis

I apologize if I appeared to be calling this town (or this state) racist. I was merely pointing out that the number of racists in this town was a number greater than one. We are not talking about a single individual who exposed his racist attitude.

I have no evidence whatsoever whether this town is more or less racist than Houston.
 
I apologize if I appeared to be calling this town (or this state) racist. I was merely pointing out that the number of racists in this town was a number greater than one. We are not talking about a single individual who exposed his racist attitude.

I have no evidence whatsoever whether this town is more or less racist than Houston.

No need to apologize. They are everywhere.

Daredelvis
 
Racism can seem reasonable, innocent, naive, and honest close up. Racism does not exist purely in the domain of extremists - but in the everyday.

When an elected official gets to a point of advocating the literal whitewashing of publicly supported viewpoints that are other than his own - it is time to stop and reflect. And if not, it would not be the first time that a recall election was demanded by city residents.

I'd agree that a portion of Prescott, of not most of Arizona is in need of exposure to a broader and more diverse perspective than we get.

Ah sweet:
Latest news is that a broad citizen protest in favor of the mural has caused the 'whitewashing' decision to be reversed - the mural will be completed as originally intended. I also heard that Blair lost his radio show.

...And AM radio broadcasts, well that's just scary. No politician should be allowed there. That demographic is mostly old frightened white people huddled up in their mobile homes waiting for Armageddon with their guns, Chihuahuas and three years of food. :eek:
 
this argument needs a name like Godwin's Law.
The urban dictionary gives these explanations.
In honor of Steve Blair and his irrefutable logic, when ever someone begins an argument with "I am not a racist but," the argument is officially over and you have been "Blaired." Let it be known from today forward this argument is known officially as Blair's Law.:D
You know you're racist when you begin a phrase with "I'm not racist, but," or "i'm not racist, I have black friends". ;) Call it the contradictory racist law.
 
Last edited:
Some linky's because I know u love them.
My favorites were actually callers from the radio show transcripts. To some extent I think Blair was sucked in by the AM radio demographic...

Of all this, I am not very comfortable with the idea of sitting politicans having radio shows. I have a basic distrust of power and that seems over the line. So call me a paranoid.

Blair fired
Steve Blair has been fired by KYCA, due to his comments regarding the new mural on Miller Valley School at the corner of Whipple Street and Miller Valley Road.

http://www.prescottenews.com/news/latest/steve-blair-fired-by-kyca

Mural dedication
http://www.prescottenews.com/news/latest/rewind-the-may-21-dedication-of-the-mural

The actual radio show transcript
http://www.prescottenews.com/news/current-news/what-did-steve-blair-actually-say-read-the-transcript

Snippets:

Caller
What I wanted to talk about was that outrageous mural at Miller Valley Elementary School. When I first came here from Los Angeles, California, I went to substitute teach in Prescott Unified, and I used to sub over there, and I always liked the school and then when they put that mural up there, I was totally offended. It looks like a bunch of freaking illegals jumping over a fence and this one person with a spigot in his hands - what is that about? How did that pass muster with Prescott City Council?...

Caller
I was born in Torrance, California. My dad was a doctor in the LA harbor town of Wilmington, California, and we went back there two years ago, and I looked at his office, he's passed away, since, and now his office sign says (something in Spanish). Give me a break. Southern California is nueva Mexico, and that's why we left. They don't want to assimulate, and they want to take back the country, and it just drives me nuts.


way ta go californians!

yesterday's protest slideshow
http://www.examiner.com/x-31346-Pho...Prescott-Arizona-Proves-It-Has-A-United-Voice
 
Last edited:
Tucson is not that bad. It is an island of conservatism in an sea of fascism. Keep in mind that what most of the nation is hearing about is the will of the slim majority of the voting public, and the ***hats on the radio, and that slim majority is shrinking by the day.

This brings up an interesting question that I've been pondering for some time: what are the demographic trends in AZ these days? Is it becoming more and more ethnically diverse, following most national trends? In addition, is there - as there is on the national level - a correlation between political affiliation & ethnicity?

I ask because my hypothesis is that what we're seeing from AZ with these kind of issues is a kind of pushback from some conservative, Republican members of a white population who see themselves losing majority status in the coming decades (and thus political influence as well). It's similar to the reaction we've seen from some on the right-wing regarding the election of our first non-white (well, technically, half-white) President; they just seem to be unable to wrap their minds around the fact that it won't be "their" country anymore.

Btw, in my opinion, much of this whole race discussion is silly, as I think most of us are mutts. For example, taking a look at my avatar ( <----- ) one might be surprised to know that I have a considerable amount of Choctaw Indian in me.

ETA: Oh yeah, and this Blair clown is a major asshat. I'm glad he got fired.
 
Last edited:
I see you live on the gulf coast.... glass houses. My anecdotal evidence based on working in an academic environment in Tucson for 11 years, and Houston for the last 5, leads me to believe that AZ has nothing on Texas when it comes to the incidence of overt racists. I can't see the rest of the gulf coast being that much better.

Daredelvis

If you want to talk overt racism outside of the South, check out Utah. The majority of Utahns are Mormon, and a kind of implicit racism forms the very foundation of much of their theology. For example, for non-whites who are Mormon, they are taught that they'll go to a "lower level" of heaven than white Mormons. That's right, even in heaven the non-whites get to sit on the back of the bus!

If you pass through that state and get a chance to talk candidly to anyone who isn't white, especially Indians, you'll hear plenty about the racism there.
 
Ordinarly I'd suggest an official inquiry, but no doubt this one would be a whitewash :boxedin:
 
On the demographic question, I think I'm pretty safe about the link between trailer dwellers and AM radio being hard to find. :)

The US census bureau has good data (sometimes dated), but even a quick glance shows that it can provide complex results. There is a temptation (even for me who definitely knows better) to start with a conclusion and work backwards to see if there is data to support it. Somewhere in there is that trailer vs AM radio coverage data. :D

You'd need to be 'good at this' to get data that was meaningful and true (that is, based on scientific methods).

US Census Bureau
http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/04/04025.html

I like the census site because it can quickly sort by county, city, both, or either.
My own advice would be to compare counties rather than individual cities. It is not that county data is somehow more accurate than city, but makes for more of an 'apples to apples' comparison.

Maricopa county is where the Phoenix metro area lies. This is an urban county and the most powerful political and economic force in the state.

Yavapai is the county of Prescott. The Prescott area is one of the more rapidly growing in the state, and is now nicknamed the "tri city" area: Chino Valley, Prescott, and Prescott Valley. Still pretty small.

Coconino is the county of Flagstaff ('poverty with a view' - where I live). So don't count me an expert on Prescott, although my daughter attended college there and I know the city fairly well.

Generally, if there is Arizona census data that does not make us look good, well, that is probably the accurate data. :) Yavapai county has more white people but lower median income, and far lower people with college degrees.

I will also note that distances seem different here. I consider Prescott a neighboring city, but it is a two hour drive and 180 mile round trip.

Arizona could be 'divided' several ways, but an important one is rural and metro. Another would be by education and income. The Phoenix metro area is the major economic and political force in the state.
 
If you want to talk overt racism outside of the South, check out Utah. The majority of Utahns are Mormon, and a kind of implicit racism forms the very foundation of much of their theology. For example, for non-whites who are Mormon, they are taught that they'll go to a "lower level" of heaven than white Mormons. That's right, even in heaven the non-whites get to sit on the back of the bus!

If you pass through that state and get a chance to talk candidly to anyone who isn't white, especially Indians, you'll hear plenty about the racism there.
And Idaho, and Montana. Like I said, they are everywhere, but so are logical reasonable people who think they are idiots.
This brings up an interesting question that I've been pondering for some time: what are the demographic trends in AZ these days? Is it becoming more and more ethnically diverse, following most national trends? In addition, is there - as there is on the national level - a correlation between political affiliation & ethnicity?

I ask because my hypothesis is that what we're seeing from AZ with these kind of issues is a kind of pushback from some conservative, Republican members of a white population who see themselves losing majority status in the coming decades (and thus political influence as well). It's similar to the reaction we've seen from some on the right-wing regarding the election of our first non-white (well, technically, half-white) President; they just seem to be unable to wrap their minds around the fact that it won't be "their" country anymore.
This is the way I see it. The bigots are dying at a faster rate then they are being replaced. In years past there was enough critical mass, and people were isolated enough, to keep the recruitment rates high enough to replace those that were dying and just plain getting a clue. With expanding offspring of immigrant population, and the schools indoctrinating children with the liburl notion that skin color doesn't matter, it is getting harder and harder for the neanderthals to cope. Look at the changing attitudes towards gays illustrated by DADT.

The bigots will always be with us, but they are going to be more marginalized, and likely more radical with each passing year.

Daredelvis
 
This brings up an interesting question that I've been pondering for some time: what are the demographic trends in AZ these days? Is it becoming more and more ethnically diverse, following most national trends?

In addition to Kopje's link, here are some others about Arizona overall. To compare 2000 to 2006/08 look at these results: http://factfinder.census.gov/servle...=en&_sse=on&geo_id=04000US04&_state=04000US04 That chart has two tabs for the different years.

If I'm reading this right, Arizona was 75.5% "White alone" in 2000, and 77.7% in 2006/08. All other racial categories were quite steady, except for American Indian and Alaska Native figures dropping somewhat. Using the website to calculate 1990 data shows 80.9% "White", but that census doesn't seem to have allowed for mixed-race identification.

By my calculations, all other racial categories increased more in 1990-2000 than they did in 2000-2006/08. We may want to wait until the 2010 data is published, because it is the actual census (so maybe more accurate than the ACS?) and the interval is the same.

Yet, at the same time, "Hispanic or Latino (of any race)" in 2000 was at 25.3% and 29.6% in the latter survey. The 1990 census reports 18.8% "Persons of Hispanic origin".

Greater detail for demographic data for Arizona in 2000 is listed here: http://factfinder.census.gov/servle...U_QTP5&-ds_name=DEC_2000_SF1_U&-redoLog=false

I agree that county data might tell you more about what local people perceive. You might also want to take into account the age of the various people observing and being observed, sense of economic and cultural threat, and the news profile of things like SB1070 and the "controversies" of the sitting President's race and nationality.



In addition, is there - as there is on the national level - a correlation between political affiliation & ethnicity?

There is increasingly so, according to an article in the Las Vegas Sun.

[QUOTE='Republican Senate candidates eager to exploit Arizona sentiment', by Michael Mishak (Las Vegas Sun, May 9, 2010)]
According to surveys and data compiled by the Pew Hispanic Center, Republicans have been hemorrhaging Hispanic support. In summer 2008, with the presidential contest in full swing, the group found Democrats had a 39-percentage-point edge over Republicans in party identification — the widest gap in a decade. As recently as 2006, the gap was just 21 points.

Attitudes about the parties also differ greatly. A poll by the consulting firm Latino Decisions this year found that 10 percent of Latinos find the Republican Party welcoming toward their race, versus 33 percent who feel welcomed by the Democrats.[/QUOTE]

(Links in the original, and I made sure they still work.)
 
The most incredible aspect of this bizarre situation is this:

"Faces in the mural were drawn from photographs of children enrolled at Miller Valley, a K-5 school with 380 students and the highest ethnic mix of any school in Prescott."

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-06-04-altered-mural-arizona-race-debate_N.htm

Why pick mixed race or African American kids? Because those are the kids that go to that school. I guess you could argue there was some agenda in picking the kids they picked, but it's not like they just made up some nonsense.

How can a mural depicted actual kids in the actual school not be representative of the community? Even if it's a small minority, they're still there.
 
The most incredible aspect of this bizarre situation is this:

"Faces in the mural were drawn from photographs of children enrolled at Miller Valley, a K-5 school with 380 students and the highest ethnic mix of any school in Prescott."

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-06-04-altered-mural-arizona-race-debate_N.htm

Why pick mixed race or African American kids? Because those are the kids that go to that school. I guess you could argue there was some agenda in picking the kids they picked, but it's not like they just made up some nonsense.

How can a mural depicted actual kids in the actual school not be representative of the community? Even if it's a small minority, they're still there.

How is this fundamentally different than the reasoning given by the person in question?

"I am not a racist individual," Blair said on a radio show last month, "but I will tell you depicting a black guy in the middle of that mural, based upon who's President of the United States today and based upon the history of this community, when I grew up we had four black families — who I have been very good friends with for years — to depict the biggest picture on that building as a black person, I would have to ask the question, 'Why?' "

Suppose they had picked a white kid and he instead had said, "This school has the highest ethnic mix in Prescott. When I grew up most of the families I knew would be considered non-white. To depict the biggest picture on that building as a white person, I would have to ask the question, 'Why?'"

Does this make the news? Does he still get fired? Is he still a racist?
 
In real life people are judged by what they actually say or do, not what they might say or do in a more or less fictional context.

I do think that if the mural showed all white children, the mural would not have the public support it does. Nearby is Prescott College, a fairly liberal private college where students (and staff) wear sandals and ride used bicycles. Across the street is a neighborhood known locally as the 'barrio'. The barrio area is a largely Hispanic community mixed with college students and working people.

Blair's radio show sort of rambles around among arguments of why he does not like the mural. He tries to say that a historic old building is in some way being defaced, that he loved the old red brick wall [and the ambiance it presumably gives the nearby intersection]. This argument starts to drift - sounding like the mural is great but is in the wrong place - it would be much nicer 'that-a-way' in some poor Mexican section of downtown Los Angeles. (excuse my paraphrasing)

He tries another tack - if they are really trying to be diverse, they should have a child of each race on the wall. Japanese, white, Hispanic, black, Native American, etc. Uh, that doesn't sound right...

As he shifts to each argument I have the vague sense he is hearing what he sounds like out loud - and doesn't really like it. He tries something new with similar effect. Then he starts to get clearly racist callers siding with his views and applauding his courage in speaking out against the alien invaders. He is on his slippery slope to political purgatory.

He admits on the air that he was supposed to attend the dedication in his role as a public official, but hid across the street in a parked car instead. The eventual package view is that he is embarrassed that passerby's might get the impression that this is a neighborhood with - non whites: A Less Desirable neighborhood than the one he grew up in... with the four black neighbors. [more shameless kopji paraphrasing]

We call this a train wreck in these here parts. Yeehah.

He misses that the mural is not so much of something that might be in a Utopian world, but what the school is like with real students.

He ends up arguing that racial divisions don't exist in beautiful Prescott, and by implying so, the artists are causing Evil Discontent where everyone is peaceful and happy.

And this attitude I think is a blindness. That because I'm happy we all are. Maybe we all have our moments of racism or prejudice - we do because we are human. So I don't think he was fired for being a racist, he was fired for being a public embarrassment.

The mayor is asking for his resignation too. He's not having a very good week. On the bright side, an honest hard working college student or two might have job openings for them.
 
So I don't think he was fired for being a racist, he was fired for being a public embarrassment.

I've said this before, but it's worth repeating. I find "political correctness" pretty damned annoying at times because it gets extended into "personal correctness" in that we as individuals are held to ridiculous standards. However, as a voter I want a politician who understands what it is and knows when to shut up. My representative is no good to me if he loses his clout over some stupid remark that is misconstrued or that reveals a personal viewpoint that has little bearing on what he can do for my district.

So, in that sense, I think the guy is an idiot. The time to express objections is in private long before the first paint hit the walls. After that, just keep your mouth shut or spin it in a way that keeps you from looking like jackass.
 
Suppose they had picked a white kid and he instead had said, "This school has the highest ethnic mix in Prescott. When I grew up most of the families I knew would be considered non-white. To depict the biggest picture on that building as a white person, I would have to ask the question, 'Why?'"

Does this make the news? Does he still get fired? Is he still a racist?

If he's of a non-white ethnicity, then technically, yes, he's a racist. But there's an important issue of power dynamic that needs to be considered. When a member of a historically oppressed minority is being discriminated against by a member of the ethnic majority who has historically oppressed them, it's quite a big difference then when it's the other way around.

Look, I abhor "political correctness" as much as any reasonable person, but what we basically have here is a white guy in a position of power saying he doesn't want to have to look at a picture of a black child. That's bigotry no matter how you slice it.
 
How is this fundamentally different than the reasoning given by the person in question?

"I am not a racist individual," Blair said on a radio show last month, "but I will tell you depicting a black guy in the middle of that mural, based upon who's President of the United States today and based upon the history of this community, when I grew up we had four black families — who I have been very good friends with for years — to depict the biggest picture on that building as a black person, I would have to ask the question, 'Why?' "

Suppose they had picked a white kid and he instead had said, "This school has the highest ethnic mix in Prescott. When I grew up most of the families I knew would be considered non-white. To depict the biggest picture on that building as a white person, I would have to ask the question, 'Why?'"

Does this make the news? Does he still get fired? Is he still a racist?

I literally have no idea what you're asking.

Note the bolded. The "black guy" was a kid who went to the school. Ask "why" and the answer is that they picked 4 kids who went to the school. The artist decided to make the "black guy" the biggest.

That's where the story ends...except for the racists screaming slurs at the artist. Then a radio host pisses a fit about the "community" and its history.

Would it be a big deal if a school on the South Side of Chicago put up a mural with a white kid on it, people screamed racial slurs at the artist, then a local reverend went on a rant? Sure. Probably not as big of deal as this case, but then again the two aren't analagous because of this little thing called "history."

It's bizarre to pretend like race relations in the US are perfectly symmetrical and something profound can be created by simply reversing the race of the main players.
 
I ask because my hypothesis is that what we're seeing from AZ with these kind of issues is a kind of pushback from some conservative, Republican members of a white population who see themselves losing majority status in the coming decades (and thus political influence as well). It's similar to the reaction we've seen from some on the right-wing regarding the election of our first non-white (well, technically, half-white) President; they just seem to be unable to wrap their minds around the fact that it won't be "their" country anymore.

A hypothesis with which I heartily concur, and have independently arrived. I think it's one of the driving forces behind the Tea Party.

Notice that the bigot in question randomly brings up our non-white president? Clearly, the man feels threatened by a changing world he no longer understands.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom