Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

The old lady might have even spilled some bath powder or fragrance onto the mattress at some point, or even sprinkled on there deliberately. These are all far more plausible options than attributing it to ghosts or other such things which have never even been demonstrated to exist in the first place.
 
The scent was above us whatever that means to you is just fine with me.

It must have been around you, otherwise you would not have been able to smell it. Assuming your ex-husband slept on his back, face up, it can have been no more than 9 inches above the mattress.

Besides; what difference does it make if it was above or next to us?

The difference is that you brought up the idea of it being above you to discredit the idea of the smell originating from the mattress. If it wasn't above you, then this objection to that theory disappears.

When people say, "in the air" they tend to look UP.

We are surrounded by air.
 
You seem to be unable to understand how a scent can seem to disappear. Understand that there is a phenomenon called "olfactory fatigue". You may smell your perfume when you put it on, but eventually you can't smell it any longer. This isn't because it stops smelling, it's because you've become used to it.

To expand on this slightly, there's a good reason for this. We have lots and lots of input to our poor little brains every second of every day. Our brain has to filter out a lot of it from our conscious notice otherwise we'd never get anything done due to sensory overload. From an evolutionary standpoint what's more important than smelling (or hearing or feeling) things as they are, is noticing a change in smell (or sound, or touch). A change in background smell (or...etc.) could mean the presence of a predator, or that there's fresh water just over that hill. Therefore when something new like a smell occurs, we notice. Then that data is no longer important so we stop noticing.

Deranged, have you ever been in a room and then suddenly noticed that the clock has stopped ticking while previously you hadn't been thinking about the clock at all? Or only noticed the background hum from the fridge when it turns itself off? Same thing.
 
So really neither the room nor the mattress nor anything in the room had any connection to your ex's grandmother. The only reason you have for thinking you smelled his dead grandmother is that your ex said, "Go away granny" and you have heard that the dead communicate by smelling like roses.

You can see how that's less than compelling can't you. There is nothing paranormal about your story. Sleeping, waking, smelling are all normal things. Why you think anything unusual happened is beyond any of us.
 
Maybe you did have a witness. But how can we know? All we have is your word. And even if you did have a witness, how does that help anything? An anecdote is not data, and the plural of anecdote is not data, either.
You can't know I had a witness next to me; that's true. I could have made the whole thing up also. You each chose whether or not to believe me. Now I'll go take my meds. lol
 
Last edited:
One time I was walking through a park and I smelled grass. My friend swatted at a bee and said, "go away bee." Why that bee smelled like grass is beyond me.
 
Smell is weird stuff*. The tiniest trace of a scent, if evocative enough, can light up one's brain with memory. My wife recently received a shawl knitted by my mother and as soon as the box it arrived in was open, I could smell nothing but the perfume and moisturiser of my dear mater. She could have been in the room. The effect was undeniable, but gone in a few moments.

Deranged; I don't think anyone necessarily doubts that you and your partner smelled a scent in the night, or even that it might have been a scent strongly associated with a departed relative. The mechanisms by which it came about, however, were - we suspect - utterly mundane. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the respondents here could relate some story of a similar nature.

If you want to believe in life after death then go ahead, we can't stop you...look for evidence if you want. If you find it, I assure you we will be fascinated, but this is not it.

*That's, like, a science FACT.
'Deranged; I don't think anyone necessarily doubts that you and your partner smelled a scent in the night..." Yes, most definitely doubt it happened. Far as "looking for evidence of life after death" I don't do that. Sometimes it seems as if it's finding me.
 
So really neither the room nor the mattress nor anything in the room had any connection to your ex's grandmother. The only reason you have for thinking you smelled his dead grandmother is that your ex said, "Go away granny" and you have heard that the dead communicate by smelling like roses.

You can see how that's less than compelling can't you. There is nothing paranormal about your story. Sleeping, waking, smelling are all normal things. Why you think anything unusual happened is beyond any of us.
"So really neither the room nor the mattress nor anything in the room had any connection to your ex's grandmother. The only reason you have for thinking you smelled his dead grandmother is that your ex said, "Go away granny" and you have heard that the dead communicate by smelling like roses."
The groom , as you put it, had a connection to the grandmother. He was her grandson. I had never, at that point, heard about the dead and roses or flowers. That knowledge, if you will, came decades later. For all I know it could have been a distant relative of his who died but I simply believe it was his grandmother.
 
You can't know I had a witness next to me; that's true. I could have made the whole thing up also. We each choose whether or not to believe me. Now I'll go take my meds. lol

No one really cares about the veracity of your story as there is nothing extraordinary about smelling flowers. Despite the obvious inconsistencies I think most people are willing to accept the over all narrative with out to much evidence required.

Its the explanation for why you smelled flowers that is the problem. That does require evidence because it is an extraordinary explanation.

Your unwillingness to accept any other explanation is what makes us incredulous to your entire story and motives for posting here.
 
"Do you really think that anyone here is incapable of seeing right through your fabrications?" This amuses me. To think I'd take the time away from Honey Boo Boo to fabricate anything so involved. You are all capable of seeing through fabrications but this isn't one of them. Funny.
 
"Things" are not irrational, only people.
Many things are irrational having nothing to do with people. For instance: where is the end of the universe? How can something go on forever with no limits? Or have you found a brick wall in your telescope.
 
So what was the purpose of your next two posts?

Skeptics aren't going to convince you that you're mistaken, and you're not going to convince skeptics that you actually smelt a ghost. Now what?
Wrong again. Receiving messages from forum members saying not only that they believe me but that their relatives experience similar phenomena.
 
The groom , as you put it, had a connection to the grandmother. He was her grandson.

What groom? I never mentioned a groom at all nor have you up to this point IIRC.

I had never, at that point, heard about the dead and roses or flowers. That knowledge, if you will, came decades later. For all I know it could have been a distant relative of his who died but I simply believe it was his grandmother.

And you believe all of this despite that fact that there is zero evidence that the dead make us smell roses and despite the fact that there are much more realistic and plausible explanations for why you smelled roses that night.

The beauty of the natural world is that you do not have to believe, you get to understand and to know.
 
I'm one of his kind.
Where did you present the evidence?
And it's sleight of hand, not slight.
I cannot provide evidence. I can only say what happened.
If you flew over a crop circle in a helicopter and it lost power , quickly dropped within 20' of the ground then went back up again would you think it was an irrational experience? No; you'd think it was coincidence even if you began hearing the same thing from other pilots who flew over them. If your watch stopped running during the same exercise then began running again you would call it coincidence. It's just your personality. So far, anyway.
 
One reason people may connect the scent of flowers with deceased relatives may be a psychological connection. The last time you are with your relatives is generally a funeral with lots of flowers. Smelling that type of flower again might remind of someone long dead - this does not mean the dead person caused that smell - without even realizing that was the scent from the funeral.

Other important moments, holiday dinners, weddings, birthdays, often have flowers as well. These are often the events we remember when thinking of our dead relatives.

I know for me the smell of shepherd's pie always reminds me of my grandmother.
 
I was going to go back through this thread and quote every single instance that you have hand waved or altered your story in the face of a logical explanation but that is almost every single post.

If the scent was at the level of your faces as it would have to be in order for you to smell it then the most likely answer is trapped scents inside the mattress. Regardless of how many houses it was in or how long she had been dead - if you you smelled her (and quite frankly you are simply taking your ex's word that thats what she smelled like) its because she slept on that mattress and not because her ghost smells like flowers.
That's silly . "At the level of my face." If I had a rotting slice of sausage on top of a bookshelf and I smelled it would you say it , the sausage, was at the level of my face when it was eight feet above my face?
 
I cannot provide evidence. I can only say what happened.
If you flew over a crop circle in a helicopter and it lost power , quickly dropped within 20' of the ground then went back up again would you think it was an irrational experience? No; you'd think it was coincidence even if you began hearing the same thing from other pilots who flew over them. If your watch stopped running during the same exercise then began running again you would call it coincidence. It's just your personality. So far, anyway.

Lets stick with your actual claims. We can't argue individual reactions to events that have not occurred.
 
I've heard of stories where people smell roses when they are beside the bed of someone who has just died. Another story is that Heaven smells like roses.
Interesting. I've heard that Mary, the mother of Jesus, smells like roses but I've never heard that the dead smell like anything . Only that dogs can smell death. Don't misunderstand: I mean a dead person with his body in the room smelling like roses is foreign to me but I'm not doubting you. I guess you mean "sometimes." When my mother died I went right up to her and there was no scent at all. I had to wait until a week after she died but that's too sacred for me to post on JREF.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom