Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

So now you're going to lash out and attack me? What the hell is the matter with you?





"Me and my kind"?!?

If that's the way you really feel about skeptics and the process of critical thinking, then what are you even doing here in the first place?

Why don't you take your little fantasies somewhere else, to some community of ghost hunters or spiritualists who'll believe anything, so you can all sit around and tell your little campfire stories without anyone letting unimportant things like facts, logic and deductive reasoning intrude on your fun?





You haven't presented any.

You told a story and asked the skeptics for an explanation, and then when you got a number of explanations you didn't like, you altered your story to add contradictory details in an attempt to discount those explanations.

That's not evidence. That's telling a story and then changing your story in response to questioning, which is something that liars typically do.





Believe me, I know. Do you really think that anyone here is incapable of seeing right through your fabrications?





:boggled:
I neither lied nor fabricated. If you think I did, then you must think it was a really outrageous story that couldn't possibly have happened! Yes; it was really quite a unique experience. Just grand.
 
They're dead in the sense that they're no longer alive. Everyone gets one go at the game. No continues, no reloading an old save, no restarting. The dead certainly aren't hanging around producing flowery scents and cryptic clues as to where the fish knives were left.
Some are doing just that. It is so cool !
 
I once saw the ghost of a purple unicorn. My husband was with me, and he saw it, too. I won't provide any evidence to verify what we both saw, but you should take my word for it because I claim to have had a witness.

Now, does that make my alleged experience more credible?



FIFY.

You recited a fantastical memory about smelling the dead on a forum dedicated to critical thinking. Did you somehow expect everyone would "oooh" and "aah" and not respond with logic? Or question the shifting goalposts?
It wasn't really logical or rational or scientific. But it was more logical to me than it would ever be to you because of our belief systems. Mine's more exciting.
 
I neither lied nor fabricated. If you think I did, then you must think it was a really outrageous story that couldn't possibly have happened! Yes; it was really quite a unique experience. Just grand.

Its your explanation for why you smelled flowers that people don't believe.
 
Seems that way.


This also did not happen.


Sure you do. Sure he does.


Your best friend died and you smelled an old lady?

Did you miss this part?
My best friend died and I smelled an old lady? I don't get it. Two different experiences and the scent was of flowers. Both times. Many years apart.
 
OP, have you considered sharing your story on /x/ instead of here? I think they'd be much more receptive and happy to tell you what you want to hear.
 
It wasn't really logical or rational or scientific. But it was more logical to me than it would ever be to you because of our belief systems. Mine's more exciting.

That wholly depends on what you mean by exciting. Or what you find exciting.

I find wish-thinking boring after two minutes myself.
 
The scent was up by the ceiling. Believe what you wish. Thanks.

I suspect that once you'd been in the mattress for a while, the scent would be released and probably be everywhere in the room. I'm sure it would have been near the cealing, in the corner, hic et ubique. Then olfactory fatigue sets in and you smell it less and less until you don't really smell it any longer

I don't think you need ghosts to explain the scent of perfume and bath powder in a room formerly occupied by an elderly woman.


ETA; I didn't realize just how long this thread had gotten when I replied. It's been pretty well covered, and the OP doesn't seem to have a very open mind. She should watch this; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T69TOuqaqXI
 
Last edited:
OP, have you considered sharing your story on /x/ instead of here? I think they'd be much more receptive and happy to tell you what you want to hear.

We're (hopefully) here to consider claims of the paranormal using logic, as it should be. (Though a few, imo, were unduly obnoxious from the start.)

The fact that the OP came to potentially hostile territory, tells me there's some chance what is being presented by the OP is what the OP believes to be a true account of what happened.
 
Last edited:
The fact that the OP came to potentially hostile territory, tells me there's some chance what is being presented by the OP is what the OP believes to be a true account of what happened.
And I don't think any of us have doubted that she and her partner really did smell flowers that night. The problem is that Deranged has already made her mind up as to what the cause was and is totally opposed to any other explanation. No one here is going to give Deranged what I suspect she really wants: confirmation of her belief. If that is what she wants, there are other places on the internet that will be far better suited to her needs. We'll still be here if/when she is willing to open her mind.
 
We're (hopefully) here to consider claims of the paranormal using logic, as it should be. (Though a few, imo, are being unduly obnoxious.)

The fact that the OP came to potentially hostile territory, tells me there's some chance what is being presented by the OP is what the OP believes to be a true account of what happened.

Even as a true account, it hardly seems in the realm of the paranormal. My house creaks in a heavy wind and the pipes often make noise. The only difference between the OP's story and mine is one of attribution, not of unaccountability.
 
Even as a true account, it hardly seems in the realm of the paranormal. My house creaks in a heavy wind and the pipes often make noise. The only difference between the OP's story and mine is one of attribution, not of unaccountability.

And this is hardly the first time any of have seen this tactic from someone claiming a paranormal experience. All testing is impossible, all rational explanations are shunned, everything but the paranormal is rejected, and then rational thought is mocked in favor of beliefs. Hand wave, rinse and repeat.

It's not clever and it's not original.

ETA: mostq recently I recall some guy taking ***** photos and claiming they are of the spirit world. When we didn't stroke his ego he claimed we couldn't see the ghost because we didn't believe.
 
Last edited:
It wasn't really logical or rational or scientific. But it was more logical to me than it would ever be to you because of our belief systems. Mine's more exciting.

I suppose believing in a fantasy might be more exciting, if that's what you get off on. Since I don't, I don't happen to agree with you.

And I don't think any of us have doubted that she and her partner really did smell flowers that night.

I don't know. According to Deranged, the scent was "strong enough to wake the dead", yet she slept through it...twice. After the first time, the next morning, her partner asked if she had smelled it, and offered to wake her up if it happened again. The next night, she continued sleeping until he woke her up to tell her the scent was apparent again and to ask if she could smell it.

The power of suggestion shouldn't be discounted.

As well, for all we know, the scent was there all along. Deranged claims the room was entirely scent free, which is impossible. That possibility shouldn't be discounted, either.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom