Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

So now you're going to lash out and attack me? What the hell is the matter with you?


You and I both know for a fact that you and your kind would never accept any evidence offered to you as real evidence.


"Me and my kind"?!?

If that's the way you really feel about skeptics and the process of critical thinking, then what are you even doing here in the first place?

Why don't you take your little fantasies somewhere else, to some community of ghost hunters or spiritualists who'll believe anything, so you can all sit around and tell your little campfire stories without anyone letting unimportant things like facts, logic and deductive reasoning intrude on your fun?


Don't ask for evidence when you don't believe in any presented to you.


You haven't presented any.

You told a story and asked the skeptics for an explanation, and then when you got a number of explanations you didn't like, you altered your story to add contradictory details in an attempt to discount those explanations.

That's not evidence. That's telling a story and then changing your story in response to questioning, which is something that liars typically do.


It is all a fabrication, a trick


Believe me, I know. Do you really think that anyone here is incapable of seeing right through your fabrications?


nothing could convince you of anything unless you touched it and/or saw it for yourself. In which case you would simply consider it a very clever slight of hand or technological spectacle.


:boggled:
 
This. Her room and particularly her bed are probably infused with the odors of her powder (which probably dusted off of her and into the fabrics in the room) and perfumes. When you heat up the room with your body heat and humidify it with your breath, those odors are released.

I had a favorite dog who slept on a particular bed for many years. After she died, I would occasionally comfort myself by burying my face in her bed and breathing warm moist air into it until it released some of her familiar doggie odor. Same thing.
This will sound like a lie but it's the truth. She had never slept in the house where it happened because they moved a lot and she died years before this house was purchased. I am speaking of people who loved to move every couple of years. They moved into it and the man got Alzheimer's. Thinking she could run away from the stress of it (she told me later it, of course, was ineffective) she moved many more times. But it's true the bed itself went with them at each move.
 
No one is disputing that your former whatever smelt something flowery, or that he woke you up and you also smelt it. We're disputing your insistence on avoiding the most rational explanation available.
News Flash: irrational things happen in the universe! What a concept!
 
Fine. The fact that he was there discounts the "tale" even more. Whatever. When I said, "ceiling" I meant it was above us. The scent was not next to us or in the covers. And I would rather stick my head in a gas oven than even begin to discuss the multiple reasons for our breakup. Dreamer.

An odour has to be in your nose in order for you to sense it. If it doesn't reach your nose, you won't sense it.
The reasons for your break up may well be interesting, but they are not relevant.
 
You and I both know for a fact that you and your kind would never accept any evidence offered to you as real evidence. Don't ask for evidence when you don't believe in any presented to you. It is all a fabrication, a trick and nothing could convince you of anything unless you touched it and/or saw it for yourself. In which case you would simply consider it a very clever slight of hand or technological spectacle.
I'm one of his kind.
Where did you present the evidence?
And it's sleight of hand, not slight.
 
What's being said is that a scent up by the ceiling doesn't wake people lying in beds. Do you see where your story is starting to unravel?"
Nothing is unraveling as far as I'm concerned. It's unraveling to you. The scent was above us and it seemed to fill the space up there. I guess I shouldn't have said ceiling. So sue me. When two adults experience something like this no one could ever convince them it didn't happen. He said, "go away, granny" and I thought at the time it was noteworthy that he seemed to know who it was. I certainly didn't know. Maybe because she was the only person we knew in the family who had died at that time.
Perhaps you could learn how to use the quote function.
If I can master it, so can you.
 
Smell is weird stuff*. The tiniest trace of a scent, if evocative enough, can light up one's brain with memory. My wife recently received a shawl knitted by my mother and as soon as the box it arrived in was open, I could smell nothing but the perfume and moisturiser of my dear mater. She could have been in the room. The effect was undeniable, but gone in a few moments.

Deranged; I don't think anyone necessarily doubts that you and your partner smelled a scent in the night, or even that it might have been a scent strongly associated with a departed relative. The mechanisms by which it came about, however, were - we suspect - utterly mundane. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the respondents here could relate some story of a similar nature.

If you want to believe in life after death then go ahead, we can't stop you...look for evidence if you want. If you find it, I assure you we will be fascinated, but this is not it.

*That's, like, a science FACT.
 
What's being said is that a scent up by the ceiling doesn't wake people lying in beds. Do you see where your story is starting to unravel?"
Nothing is unraveling as far as I'm concerned. It's unraveling to you. The scent was above us and it seemed to fill the space up there. I guess I shouldn't have said ceiling. So sue me. When two adults experience something like this no one could ever convince them it didn't happen. He said, "go away, granny" and I thought at the time it was noteworthy that he seemed to know who it was. I certainly didn't know. Maybe because she was the only person we knew in the family who had died at that time.

I was going to go back through this thread and quote every single instance that you have hand waved or altered your story in the face of a logical explanation but that is almost every single post.

If the scent was at the level of your faces as it would have to be in order for you to smell it then the most likely answer is trapped scents inside the mattress. Regardless of how many houses it was in or how long she had been dead - if you you smelled her (and quite frankly you are simply taking your ex's word that thats what she smelled like) its because she slept on that mattress and not because her ghost smells like flowers.
 
FWIW, I just measured the distance from the back of my head to where my nostrils meet my face. Assuming that Deranged's head is broadly similar to mine in size, the maximum distance the smell could have been above the mattress is 9 inches.
 
I remember working as a door man at a gentle mans club. I wore the same pair of Dickies trousers to work almost every time and those pants still smell like vanilla and despair years later.

The also had a series of automated air fresheners that were on a timer at just above head height. Those things would get me in eyes all the time. Perhaps this room had one of those motion sensor air fresheners or a timed one?
 
This will sound like a lie but it's the truth. She had never slept in the house where it happened because they moved a lot and she died years before this house was purchased. I am speaking of people who loved to move every couple of years. They moved into it and the man got Alzheimer's. Thinking she could run away from the stress of it (she told me later it, of course, was ineffective) she moved many more times. But it's true the bed itself went with them at each move.

The odor was IN THE BED. It's really not that mysterious.
 
The odor was IN THE BED. It's really not that mysterious.

It couldn't have been because I forgot to tell you that the bed was steamed cleaned daily and just a week before this incident had been completely remanufactured with all new interior materials! Also the bed wasn't a bed it was futon. [/deranged]
 
Deranged,
For as long as I can remember, I have experienced hypnogogia from time to time. I wake up in the middle of the night and see silky, spiderweb-like strands around the bedroom. I will sit up, brush them around with my hand, etc. and retain full memory of this after I wake up the next morning. For years I didn't understand, not even knowing that there was a name for it. Now I can understand and even get some enjoyment out of the experience when it happens. But there isn't any way someone could convince me that I was being visited by ghosts, I was experiencing astral projection, or anything else than it is just a trick my mind is playing. I have no proof of any of this - this is my personal experience.

I think the point that most posters are making is that there may be other explanations for this experience other than paranormal. But you have to open yourself to the more mundane possibilities. Not as much fun or personally meaningful perhaps, but just as valid.
 
Once again, all sarcasm aside, why did you start this thread?


You and I both know for a fact that you and your kind would never accept any evidence offered to you as real evidence. Don't ask for evidence when you don't believe in any presented to you. It is all a fabrication, a trick and nothing could convince you of anything unless you touched it and/or saw it for yourself. In which case you would simply consider it a very clever slight of hand or technological spectacle.

Apparently it was to prove that we're all a bunch of closed-minded meanies who won't take a ghost story at face value.
 
smoke

I have smelled cigarette smoke and believed it to be my mother visiting from beyond...
 
I've heard of stories where people SAID they smelled roses when they are beside the bed of someone who had just died.

I have a relative who swears a ghost throws things in a different relative's house. A plate of spaghetti even sailed into the living room and smashed on a wall while they were sitting there.

The kitchen was not rigorously tested for the presence of a jackass in need of a whoopin'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom