luchog
Neo-Post-Retro-Revivalist
Not necessarily; that's a situation that varies widely by community. But in any case, that is not a risk that is substantially different from any number of essential and non-essential occupations (for example, police and firefighter disability insurance and pensions are paid for by the State). One could argue that there's a fundamental difference between necessary occupational risk and voluntary risk, however.I generally agree with you and thought that was a great post. But, I look at the "no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user" idea a bit more broadly:
Consider if 1) The BASE jumper fails and winds up paralyzed from the neck down and requires 24/7 care for the rest of his life and 2) He has no insurance and no means to pay for his care, so it is covered by the State.
The real issue, though, is that there's a valid argument to be made against publically-funded disability insurance (aka Social Security), based on just this type of scenario.
Of course, that's all probably academic, since basejumping is predominantly a rich-kid's sport, so there's an extremely low likelihood of your scenario happening. And laws are meant to cover generalities in any case; they don't handle exceptional cases well. "Difficult cases make bad law" and all that.
Not really. The monies are already there as part of the Social Security system, which the basejumper has been paying into already. If there is any "financial harm" above that, it's likely to be statistically insignificant. A truly robust system of law and government can absorb a few exceptional cases.Is it fair to say his failure at BASE jumping has not harmed anyone else? The cost of his failure is being born not only by him, but by all the citizens of the State.
I don't see the reason to elaborate beyond what I said, since I don't believe it's necessary; and once you start down the road of increasingly detailed and comprehensive coverage of all eventualities, you're far more likely to end up right back where we are now. The mechanism may be somewhat different, but the end resut is the same.So, I'd modify the idea to something like "As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user and the user has adequate insurance, there is no reason to legislate against it". I'm all for legalizing most drugs - as long as all users are required to have appropriate health and liability insurance with specific riders for use of the drug.
As noted earlier, much of the harm caused by illicit drug use stems directly from the fact that it's illegal. Inadequate quality control resulting in tainted or inconsistent products, artificially inflated prices, etc. A safer, more consistent product at a much lower price means that fewer users are going to have significant problems with it, can support their habit with less effort, and have far better resources for assistance in ending their dependence on it.