Americans are world's top drug users

That's a very disappointing report. :(

At least those statistics about cocaine and marijuana include one-time-only use of such drugs. Regular use must be lower. (Please let it be much lower!)

But I'd like more information about why people do this to themselves. The article mentions that single, wealthy, young men are more likely to be regular drug users than people in other categories. Is it because they have more of a sense of physical and legal invulnerability? Are they more socially-isolated? Are they less-deterred because they are less-often caught or prosecuted? Maybe understanding motives would help us fight this problem more effectively.

At least we in the U.S. smoke cigarettes less than many European countries and (among men) much less than Japan.
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/hea_smo_pre_mal_of_adu-health-smoking-prevalence-males-adults
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/hea_smo_pre_fem_of_adu-health-smoking-prevalence-females-adults

It's also kind of amazing that so many Americans would confess to such crimes when for decades now there has been such a heavy legal reaction here. This suggests to me that a lot of people here take the Drug War so unseriously they're not only willing to use drugs but to tell total strangers they do so!

I think we (young wealthy males) like drugs because they are fun.

Why do people drink beer? It's a drug too you know. Is that included in the survey?

I've been a regular weed smoker for a few years smoking pretty much every day. Why? Cause I like being stoned. I've never done anything harder like coke/heroin but I have to admit that considering how overblown the marijuana scare is I'm almost wondering if the dangers of those drugs are overblown as well. Certainly I support full legalization of all drugs (by prescription for harder stuff but still available). Weed you should be able to buy wherever you buy beer.

BTW I recently (several weeks ago) quit my weed habit cold turkey. I do feel a little faster mentally (mainly just recall speed not ability) and I need slightly less sleep (about an hour less a night). Quitting was easy and I haven't had any weird cravings or anything (well less appetite as well but that's good in my case).

I pretty much quit because I wanted to know how hard it was. I will probably start up again in a year or two.

Any other questions?
 
Then shouldn't it be a LOT cheaper to buy? And I do a LOT of walking about in rural woodland/farmland and I've never seen any growing wild.. in spite of actively looking at times ;)

Old timers here in NC tell of the 'bad old days" pre WWII when the grass seed they bought to seed pastures came from Mexico and the producers used marijuana as "filler" seeds. They say the plant grew wild in every farm pasture in NC. Well, its gone now. So, as a weed its not too good at maintaining its presence.

A program of eradication will do that. There is a lot of weed grown outdoors but they either guard it or do it in very hidden / remote area. Just watch some of the cop shows where they bust these places. The DEA flys around in helicopters looking for it (California it's really common).

Anyway I was just pointing out that it's quite an easy plant to grow so it shouldn't have a street price of $5k per pound.
 
A program of eradication will do that. There is a lot of weed grown outdoors but they either guard it or do it in very hidden / remote area. Just watch some of the cop shows where they bust these places. The DEA flys around in helicopters looking for it (California it's really common).

Anyway I was just pointing out that it's quite an easy plant to grow so it shouldn't have a street price of $5k per pound.

Wow, really!!!??? Back in ancient times (early 70's) we used to buy kilos (from Mexico) for $200 - $250. I'm so out of touch.
 
Street price. I'm sure you can get a pound for only a couple of thousand. This is the good California medicinal stuff.
 
Wow, really!!!??? Back in ancient times (early 70's) we used to buy kilos (from Mexico) for $200 - $250. I'm so out of touch.
My active experience is of similar vintage. I stopped buying when an ounce moved beyond $35. I understand thats low by an order of magnitude for the "good stuff" these days.
 
I think we (young wealthy males) like drugs because they are fun. Why do people drink beer?
To diminish their ability to perceive threats?

See http://www.sfn.org/index.cfm?pagename=news_042908
and minute 72:57 -- http://www.theskepticsguide.org/skepticsguide/podcastinfo.asp?pid=145

It's a drug too you know. Is that included in the survey?
Alcohol use was included, as it should be, but not specific details about what kinds of alcohol. (Maybe you could find that in the original reports of each country's mental health agency.)

The chart shows that 91.6% of adults in the U.S. reported having consumed alcohol at least once in their lifetimes. That number is pretty close to that from New Zealand, Japan, and a few European countries listed. Other countries are all over the scale, South Africa coming in lowest (for this study) at 40.6%.

Here is the report: http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-document&doi=10.1371/journal.pmed.0050141

And here is the table I'm citing (I hope I'm reading it correctly):
http://medicine.plosjournals.org/pe...ble&doi=10.1371/journal.pmed.0050141&id=14269

I've been a regular weed smoker for a few years smoking pretty much every day. Why? Cause I like being stoned.
That motivation is incomprehensible to me.

But, at the risk of straying off the topic, let me ask this.... Do you identify as a skeptic, or maybe a rationalist? If you do, how do square that outlook with practices that diminish your ability to see the world as it really is?

BTW I recently (several weeks ago) quit my weed habit cold turkey.
Congratulations!

Any other questions?
Yes.

Are you not afraid that the DEA (or whoever) will find you and charge you based on your confession in this thread? Or in a mental health survey? I mean, social scientists may balk at the ethical breach, but cops disguised as researchers could use studies like this in sting operations.
 
That motivation is incomprehensible to me.
Really? You don't understand people who enjoy a cup of coffee or pepsi each morning? Don't understand someone who enjoys a bit of chocolate at their afternoon break? Don't understand having a cocktail after a particularly grueling day at the office?

I'm not arguing in favor of illicit drug use, but there are lots of things we use regularly that modify our "ability to see the world as it really is". Some less subtle than others. I don't find any of it incomprehensible - quite the opposite.
 

Really, but maybe I'm misunderstanding what is meant by "stoned". Doesn't this refer to a state comparable to being drunk? I picture people impaired as described in the third category in the chart here, if not the second category:
http://www.alcohol.vt.edu/Students/alcoholEffects/index.htm

I've known too many people who drink to get drunk, and I've never understood it. This is more than just a single drink at the end of the day. (And since I never drink alcohol, I guess I "just don't get" even that. Sorry. :con2:)

And how do caffeine or chocolate change perception (or, while I'm at it, cognition)? Caffeine and sugar give one a short-lived burst of "energy", and chocolate simply tastes good, but I've never heard of them impairing one's judgments about safety, right-vs.-wrong, or how to operate heavy machinery (such as cars). Addiction is possible, but not as likely as it is with the drugs we've made illegal. And these legal substances don't smell anywhere as awful as tobacco or marijuana smoke. :sour:

If I'm right about the small effects of caffeine, sugar, and chocolate, isn't that why these drugs are below regulatory concern?
 
Really, but maybe I'm misunderstanding what is meant by "stoned".
"Stoned" simply means "can feel the effects of" and can vary wildly in degree from feeling almost nothing to having to hold on to the floor because the Earth is spinning too fast and you might fly off.

I've known too many people who drink to get drunk, and I've never understood it. This is more than just a single drink at the end of the day.
I don't know of anyone who drinks alcohol simply because it tastes good. Taste is generally secondary to the effects. I love fine bourbon, but I doubt I would drink it if it contained no alcohol. People drink for the effects. At what point you call that "drunk" is debatable and somewhat subjective.

And how do caffeine or chocolate change perception (or, while I'm at it, cognition)? Caffeine and sugar give one a short-lived burst of "energy", and chocolate simply tastes good, but I've never heard of them impairing one's judgments about safety, right-vs.-wrong, or how to operate heavy machinery (such as cars)
I said nothing about impaired judgment, I simply parroted your "ability to see the world as it really is". Doesn't anything that alters your mood change your perception of the world? How can caffeine and sugar not change your perception given their physiological effects? Hasn't chocolate been linked to changing serotonin levels? I submit that all these things change ones "ability to see the world as it really is", though I admit the degree is less than marijuana.

My point is that people choose to use these things because of their effects. They drink coffee for the energy boost, they drink alcohol for the enhanced sociability, they smoke marijuana for the mild euphoria. To understand someone drinking coffee for the caffeine rush, but not to understand someone smoking a joint for the buzz surely must drive some cognitive dissonance.
 
Really, but maybe I'm misunderstanding what is meant by "stoned". Doesn't this refer to a state comparable to being drunk? I picture people impaired as described in the third category in the chart here, if not the second category:
http://www.alcohol.vt.edu/Students/alcoholEffects/index.htm

I've known too many people who drink to get drunk, and I've never understood it. This is more than just a single drink at the end of the day. (And since I never drink alcohol, I guess I "just don't get" even that. Sorry. :con2:)

And how do caffeine or chocolate change perception (or, while I'm at it, cognition)? Caffeine and sugar give one a short-lived burst of "energy", and chocolate simply tastes good, but I've never heard of them impairing one's judgments about safety, right-vs.-wrong, or how to operate heavy machinery (such as cars). Addiction is possible, but not as likely as it is with the drugs we've made illegal. And these legal substances don't smell anywhere as awful as tobacco or marijuana smoke. :sour:

If I'm right about the small effects of caffeine, sugar, and chocolate, isn't that why these drugs are below regulatory concern?

Do you do anything simply because you enjoy it? If so, then you should understand why other people do things because they enjoy it. I've never really understood the problem some people have with drugs. I enjoy falling off waterfalls and throwing myself down steep hills. There's no good reason really, I just enjoy it. So far, no-one has had a problem with me doing these things, they just understand that I enjoy it, even if they don't.

What is so different about drugs? Some people enjoy them. Great. Just because you don't or, more often, because you've never tried and have no idea if you'd enjoy it or not, why is it such a big deal? What is the difference between sending a day falling down a river and spending an evening having a few pints? They're both done for no reason other than enjoyment, beer is far cheaper and less risky than kayaking, and yet I get no criticism at all for kayaking and absolutely tons for getting drunk. It just doesn't make sense.
 
One could make the point that drugs are problematic simply because they are illegal. Were they not, we would not be seeing 1000+ murders over the last couple of years in Mexican border towns over smuggling "turf".
We would not be seeing billions of US dollars funneled to the cartels for these substances.
We would not see the largest percentage of incarcerated citizens of any "industrialized" nation.
It would be possible to adopt an entirely Libertarian viewpoint and let folks do what they wish with their own bodies; and when doing that becomes problematic, treat it as a public-health problem.
Or if the user violates other laws as a result of drug use, prosecute them for that offense.

Somehow this seems unlikely to happen. In the minds of what is arguably a majority of Americans, drugs are "evil". A dreadful scourge upon society, a corrupting influence in and of themselves.
The "War On Drugs" is seen as a good thing, brave law-enforcement authorities up against evil child-corrupting dealers. The billions being spent may not be doing much, but hey, they're trying.
The users and low-level dealers that fill our prisons are seen as losers, weak-willed individuals who have fallen prey to the corrupting influence of drugs. They are responsible for their own actions, and deserve what they get.

I think these attitudes are widespread. (they certainly are amongst my colleagues) and unlikely to go away soon. This impresses our fearless politicians, always eager to ride a popular tide and be portrayed as "tough on crime". Don't expect the DEA to be disbanded soon.
 
In the minds of what is arguably a majority of Americans, drugs are "evil". A dreadful scourge upon society, a corrupting influence in and of themselves.
In light of the original post, I think this is a very interesting point.

Why
are Americans like this?

Is it the idea that intoxication will keep you from experiencing God (which is apparently what Muslims think)? Is it a history of isolated, drunk frontier husbands, or working-class factory men in urban ghettos, beating their helpless wives, who then form groups like the WCTU? Is it a New England preference for rationality and clear thinking (my reason)? Or what?

And why is it that (according to the study cited in the original post) in countries with more liberal drug laws, a larger proportion of people choose not to use them? (I'm looking at you, Netherlands.) Are they happier to begin with? Are kids less interested in "the forbidden" because there isn't one?

How much of the trans-Atlantic cultural difference is a product of having a more-urban, socially-integrated culture in Europe? I remember hearing one German or Austrian man say that at community Krampusnight parties, teenagers sometimes drink alcohol and suddenly discover their personal limits. So, I wonder if this is an example of the difference between Europe and the U.S. There you have plenty of non-parent adults around who know the kids are drinking alcohol, sometimes for the first time, and can help the kids get home. And maybe (?) having mixed ages means you don't have isolated groups of inexperienced people who then compete against each other for the most extreme dosages.

And if this is true, does the cultural difference around alcohol transfer to other drugs?

I'm trying to avoid debating morality, so I think we should stick to history, sociology, and medical science. That might actually get us somewhere.
 
"Stoned" simply means "can feel the effects of" and can vary wildly in degree from feeling almost nothing to having to hold on to the floor because the Earth is spinning too fast and you might fly off.
There's a huge difference between "feeling the effects" of cannabis, and being "stoned"; just like there's a huge difference between "feeling the effects" of alcohol, and being drunk.
I don't know of anyone who drinks alcohol simply because it tastes good. Taste is generally secondary to the effects. I love fine bourbon, but I doubt I would drink it if it contained no alcohol. People drink for the effects. At what point you call that "drunk" is debatable and somewhat subjective.
The only thing keeping me from drinking a lot more of my favorite beers than I currently do is the alcohol content. I do not like being drunk, or even moderately impaired, so I have to keep my consumption fairly low. The effects of alcohol prevent me from being able to drink as much of it as I really want to. Well, that and the price. If I could find beer that tasted exactly the same as the stuff I drink now, without the alcohol effect, I'd easily triple or quadruple the amount I drink (assuming I could afford to, of course).
I said nothing about impaired judgment, I simply parroted your "ability to see the world as it really is". Doesn't anything that alters your mood change your perception of the world?
I have pretty severe hypoglycemia. Letting my blood sugar get out of whack alters my mood, and therefore my perception, far more than moderate cannabis use.
 
In light of the original post, I think this is a very interesting point.

Why
are Americans like this?
The same reason so many Europeans and Canadians are. European and Canadian drug laws, with the exception of the Netherlands, are not really all that different from American; particularly with regard to "hard" drugs and psychadelics.
 
There's a huge difference between "feeling the effects" of cannabis, and being "stoned"; just like there's a huge difference between "feeling the effects" of alcohol, and being drunk.
I believe you just illustrated my point that "stoned" is subjective. To some it means completely impaired and having to hold on cuz the Earth is spinning to fast. To others, it simply means they can feel the effects, however mildly. We have a legal definition of "drunk" (even though it varies state-to-state and country-to-country). We have no similar definition of "stoned".

The only thing keeping me from drinking a lot more of my favorite beers than I currently do is the alcohol content. I do not like being drunk, or even moderately impaired, so I have to keep my consumption fairly low.
OK, I may have to change my statement to "I know of only one..." But, have you honestly tried blind taste tests of NA beers? There are some good ones (Gerstel, Kaliber). Are you sure there is nothing in the effects of the alcohol from that one beer that you find enjoyable?
 
OK, I may have to change my statement to "I know of only one..."
I seriously doubt that you know only one.
But, have you honestly tried blind taste tests of NA beers? There are some good ones (Gerstel, Kaliber). Are you sure there is nothing in the effects of the alcohol from that one beer that you find enjoyable?
Kaliber tastes like ass. They all taste like ass. Admittedly, they don't taste any worse than mass-produced American or Canadian beer (or the low-end German stuff that they only export to dumbass Americans and Canucks); but they certainly don't taste any better. Kaliber is by far the worst of the lot. It tastes like something died in the bottle. I was going to say O'Douls was worse, but it can't be, since it doesn't actually have any flavour. Clausthaler could be considered tolerable, since it only tastes like overcooked bread with a mildly soapy flavour; but only if I've been stuck in the desert dying of thirst, and there's nothing else to drink.

When you can come up with an alcohol-free beer that is sufficiently indistinguishable from real beer -- eg. a good Pacific Northwest IPA, Belgian abbey-style tripel, British chocolate stout, Bavarian hefeweizen, or oude gueze lambic -- then I'll consider drinking one. If the best you can come up with is some crappy reproduction of mass-produced horse urine, then I think I'll stick with what I'm drinking now, thanks.
 
I seriously doubt that you know only one.
I "know" none, I know of but one... so far.

When you can come up with an alcohol-free beer that is sufficiently indistinguishable from real beer -- eg. a good Pacific Northwest IPA, Belgian abbey-style tripel, British chocolate stout, Bavarian hefeweizen, or oude gueze lambic -- then I'll consider drinking one. If the best you can come up with is some crappy reproduction of mass-produced horse urine, then I think I'll stick with what I'm drinking now, thanks.
Me? Nope, I have no interest in coming up with a good NA beer. I have no interest in beer at all - its all swill for the mindless masses in my opinion. Sure, I've had a few that were tolerable, but only because there was nothing else worth drinking. Given the choice of water or beer I'll opt for the water every time unless I fear the water is contaminated (I'm looking at you, Mexico).

Still, in the taste tests I saw a few years ago only a few could reliably pick the NA beer from a group of typical beers (granted - mass produced US stuff). But nearly all of them said the NA beer tasted worse when the test was not blind. What I get from that is that what they like about beer is the alcohol. No surprises there.

I'm sure you enjoy the ritual, enjoy the taste and the "mouth" of a good beer, etc.... But I find it hard to believe that none of what you like about beer is related to alcohol's effects. would you believe a marijuana smoker who said he simply liked the feel of the smoke in his lungs and didn't care for the high?

As I said, I enjoy good bourbon on occasion. I enjoy the taste, the aroma, and the relaxing ritual of pouring a glass and drinking it while I watch the sun set through the smoke of my cigar. But, I also enjoy the burn of the alcohol as it goes down and the euphoria that quickly follows. I am not afraid to admit that I like the feeling of a little alcohol in my system at the end of a hectic day. Much of the charm of the drink would be lost if those alcohol effects were removed.
 
I tend to think that there is a difference between being "stoned" or "drunk" or even "tripping". I mean, there's a big difference between the reaction of people when they have taken cocaine, compared to pot, compared to X, etc, etc.

So even I agree that there is a subjective element to it, there is also an observational difference.

Personally, I don't like feeling drunk. I've done pot only five times in my life and never really felt any difference, just more tired. What I enjoy far more than getting drunk or stoned is watching others getting into that state. Wierd, I know, and it gets stranger: I love the taste of whiskey. I would drink it even if there was no alcohol, although I rarely drink alcohol. Also, I don't like coffee, tea or carbinated soda.

But even with all of that, I can understand why people enjoy getting drunk or stoned: It's used as an escape from troubles, an ego booster, an excuse for doing things you wouldn't do, a process for creativity, a mental-sexual enhancement, a release of responsiblities, a way of relaxing, a way to rebel, a way of feeling "normal", a way to work better and faster...the reasons go on and on.
 
Personally, I don't like feeling drunk. I've done pot only five times in my life and never really felt any difference, just more tired. What I enjoy far more than getting drunk or stoned is watching others getting into that state. Wierd, I know, and it gets stranger: I love the taste of whiskey. I would drink it even if there was no alcohol, although I rarely drink alcohol. Also, I don't like coffee, tea or carbinated soda.
I despise feeling drunk - because I despise feeling I am not in control. I enjoy the buzz of one drink, maybe two. But, anymore than that in a short time frame and I stop having fun. This desire to feel in control pretty much makes me a teetotaler these days, at least as it pertains to recreational pharmaceuticals.

You're not at all alone in enjoying the "contact buzz" of being around inebriated people. You get the benefit of their loosened inhibitions - so the conversation is fun - but you avoid any words/actions brought on by the clouded reason of being high. Its voyeuristic and non-committal, but I enjoy others being buzzed moreso that I enjoy being buzzed myself. I have no problem being DD for my friends when they go out.

Wait, what was that?
I love the taste of whiskey. I would drink it even if there was no alcohol...
Crap - is that now two people on my list of those who enjoy alcoholic beverages but don't care for the alcohol?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom