And why is it that (according to the study cited in the original post) in countries with more liberal drug laws, a larger proportion of people choose not to use them? (I'm looking at you, Netherlands.) Are they happier to begin with? Are kids less interested in "the forbidden" because there isn't one?
How much of the trans-Atlantic cultural difference is a product of having a more-urban, socially-integrated culture in Europe? I remember hearing one German or Austrian man say that at community Krampusnight parties, teenagers sometimes drink alcohol and suddenly discover their personal limits. So, I wonder if this is an example of the difference between Europe and the U.S. There you have plenty of non-parent adults around who know the kids are drinking alcohol, sometimes for the first time, and can help the kids get home. And maybe (?) having mixed ages means you don't have isolated groups of inexperienced people who then compete against each other for the most extreme dosages.
Good points. I am from the Netherlands. My personal experiences and those of my teenage friends when we were young:
Started drinking wine with my parents on special occasions around 14 years. beer at 15 or 16. A lot of kids are allowed to do that. They still drink more than their parents like on when they are alone (more on this later)
Most parents try to teach their kids a 'healthy' way of approaching alcohol because alcohol is accepted in society.
I got really really drunk for the first time at age 17 at a party. I went home on my bike (cause we can't drive here before 18) I felt sick the next day. I decided I didn't like that. I never got wasted like that anytime again, sure I ended up a little drunk at parties and in college, but never so bad that it made me sick. I haven't been drunk in the last 7 years at all
smoking weed. Ok I tried it also at age 17 I think. I used it for a few years, with school buddies on friday and saturday nights. No heavy users in that group of about 10 people, 9 out of 10 stopped using it when they got older. i have not smoked it since 1999 I think and don't feel the need to do so ever again
I think most (male) teens go through this in some way around here. Experiment with the 'cool' stuff. Impress the ladies. Most stop using when they settle down.
Ok so it's legal here? 99% of the parents still forbid their children to use weed and when the kids become adults the parents still don't like it. As a father I wouldn't want my kids smoking it, not if they are 16 and not when they are 20 years old. However I was born in the seventies, my parents are flower power baby boom generation, so they used more soft drugs themselves I guess (as a generation, I don't think my mum ever got near the stuff lol)
Back to alcohol. Here in Holland we have youth related alcohol problems. Too many young kids drink regularly. too many stories of boys getting into hospital! for drinking. Because the very young have low income, they cannot go buy beer in the club or bars (+ they are underage* so even if they had the money they should not be able to buy * = below 16) So what do they do? They get an old van or cabin and buy beer in the supermarket and they meet with their friends in the cabin, and drink and drink... a whole youth culture.. it's getting a problem in some areas.
Then we had the Breezer riots, where young girls were addicted to Bacardi Breezers because it just tastes like lemonade, and some got in the news because they offered sexual services to boys in exchange for these drinks.
Personally I think alcohol is more dangerous than weed.
About the kids + adults thing. Indeed in Western Europe there are many holidays or events where the whole population is partying in some way, and where everybody (read : a lot of people) drinks alcohol. Think of Carnival, a Catholic festival from origin. Or a national holiday. (Queensday in holland, Quatorze Juillet (Bastille Day) in France or Oktoberfest in Germany.) On those days the whole town joins the festivities and much alcohol is consumed and nobody thinks twice when teenagers drink beer in public.
To conclude. I think Europe basically has a good culture fro young people to grow up and learn about these things, but it has it's flaws and dangers and we have problems as well. But maybe (arguably) less problems than at the other side of the ocean.