Americans are world's top drug users

Why should anyone take the War on Drugs seriously?
Because it has cost hundreds of billions of dollars and ruined millions of lives and created a dangerous and corrupt subculture on both sides of the law. But I know what you mean.
 
... and New Zealand is #2.

Apparently. Not that I would know anything about it. Really.


Not for cocaine use though I would assume...

Marijuana is a weed you grow in a pot, that makes you act like a dope around Mary Jane,blunts your mind, loosens your joint, and will find you lying on the grass giggling like a reefer while you stare up at the stars and spliff your ganja.

So I heard...
 
Because it has cost hundreds of billions of dollars and ruined millions of lives and created a dangerous and corrupt subculture on both sides of the law. But I know what you mean.

I concur. But what is the obverse? Many would say that the war on drugs causes more harm than would the drugs in the absence of the war. I'm not sure if this is correct (but I could be persuaded given even one case study). Certainly alcohol has caused quite a bit of pain. More so than during prohibition? I don't know.
 
Depends what your definition of top drug. If you mean most commonly taken probably caffeine.
If you mean most addictive, then nicotine will come close.
 
Incidentally, what is the "world's top drug"?


Sugar.

Sugar comes waaaay in front of any of the others.

The next one might be milk. Despite lactose intolerance being more common than not, milk is extremely widely abused.

Only after those can you start talking about nicotine, caffeine, etc.
 
Last edited:
Sugar.
Sugar comes waaaay in front of any of the others.
... The next one might be milk.

Wait a minute. My sarcasm meter is broken. Are you being serious? :confused:

Where did you get this information? If it's true, I'd like to find the details.

I really hope you're wrong, or I may have to completely re-evaluate everything I eat.
 
Sugar.

Sugar comes waaaay in front of any of the others.

The next one might be milk. Despite lactose intolerance being more common than not, milk is extremely widely abused.

Only after those can you start talking about nicotine, caffeine, etc.

How do you define "sugar"? If you're including corn syrup/high fructose syrup kinds of stuff in that category then I agree.
 
I concur. But what is the obverse? Many would say that the war on drugs causes more harm than would the drugs in the absence of the war. I'm not sure if this is correct (but I could be persuaded given even one case study). Certainly alcohol has caused quite a bit of pain. More so than during prohibition? I don't know.

There are too many factors, both tangible and intangible, contributing to both sides to make a definitive, concrete statement either way; particularly as many of the intangibles are based on a particular non-universal value system. There is also the question of weight given to various factors, which again depends on the value system of the evaluator.

Some of the tangible factors involved with unrestricted drug use are harm caused to the user by overuse/overdose, harm caused by users under the influence, and harm caused by use while pregnant. Some of the intangible factors are potential economic harm (through loss of earning potential, etc), ease of becoming dependent, difficulty in quitting, and various individual and cultural effects.

The tangible and intangible factors involved in prohibition are more complex. Tangible factors include harm caused to illicit users by unregulated products (including accidental overdose due to inconsistency of products); harm caused to others by users of unexpected/unfamiliar substances substituted for or adulterated by the expected/familiar by unscrupulous purveyors (eg, reactions to methamphetamine substituted for more expensive MDMA, or various substances adulterated with PCP); the percentage of government resources spent on enforcement activities; harm caused by black market activites, particularly violent conflicts over distribution, manufacture, and import channels and territories; harm caused by errors in enforcement activities; harm caused by illicit users attempting to cover the artificially inflated costs of the substances; costs and harms resulting from the creation of a new criminal classes, including prosecution and incarceration. Intangible and less-tangible factors include the creation/encouragement of a culture of corruption in law enforcement and government; creation/encouragement of an untaxed underground economy, and community dependence on such an economy; abridgement and infringement of liberties and civil rights resulting from enforcement policies; creation of an illicit underclass; difficulty in obtaining effective treatment for dependency due to reduction in availability, as well as social stigmas and legal restrictions; overall impact of the underground culture and black market economy, and concurrent appeal of illicit activity; increasingly adversarial/paternal government/LE vs. citizen culture; and the "gateway effect", that is, the tendency for users of illicit substances to become users of other illicit substances due to close association in the underground culture.

Some of these things can be measured and pointed to, most notably due to the failed experiment of alcohol prohibition; and post-legalization/decriminalization experiences in the Netherlands, Canada, and other regions.

Harm resulting directly from drug use -- harm to users, and harm caused by users under the influence -- appears to be similar regardless of legal status, with a somewhat greater level of harm occurring under prohibition, due to the inconsistency in available substances resulting from lack of quality control regulation for some substances. This last factor can be excluded for some substances, such as cannabis, providing a much better picture of usage patterns pre- and post-legalization/decriminalization. Legalization typically results in a brief, short-term spike in usage, followed by a levelling off to usage levels at or below prohibition levels. This pattern appears to hold true for substances other than cannabis. So by that measure, the tangible factors resulting directly from substance use appears to be equivalent either way; and is therefore not a significant factor in the decision.

References:
"The available evidence suggests that removal of the prohibition against possession itself (decriminalization) does not increase cannabis use. ... This prohibition inflicts harms directly and is costly. Unless it can be shown that the removal of criminal penalties will increase use of other harmful drugs, ... it is difficult to see what society gains."
- Evaluating alternative cannabis regimes. British Journal of Psychiatry. February 2001.
http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=1017&full=1
"The lessons of Prohibition remain important today. They apply not only to the debate over the war on drugs but also to the mounting efforts to drastically reduce access to alcohol and tobacco and to such issues as censorship and bans on insider trading, abortion, and gambling.[1]

Although consumption of alcohol fell at the beginning of Prohibition, it subsequently increased. Alcohol became more dangerous to consume; crime increased and became "organized"; the court and prison systems were stretched to the breaking point; and corruption of public officials was rampant. No measurable gains were made in productivity or reduced absenteeism. Prohibition removed a significant source of tax revenue and greatly increased government spending. It led many drinkers to switch to opium, marijuana, patent medicines, cocaine, and other dangerous substances that they would have been unlikely to encounter in the absence of Prohibition."
-- Alcohol Prohibition Was a Failure by Mark Thornton O. P. Alford III Assistant Professor of Economics at Auburn University.
"The Law Revision Commission has examined laws from other states that have reduced penalties for small amounts of marijuana and the impact of those laws in those states. ... Studies of [those] states found (1) expenses for arrest and prosecution of marijuana possession offenses were significantly reduced, (2) any increase in the use of marijuana in those states was less that increased use in those states that did not decrease their penalties and the largest proportionate increase occurred in those states with the most severe penalties, and (3) reducing the penalties for marijuana has virtually no effect on either choice or frequency of the use of alcohol or illegal 'harder' drugs such as cocaine."
- Connecticut Law Review Commission. 1997. Drug Policy in Connecticut and Strategy Options: Report to the Judiciary Committee of the Connecticut General Assembly. State Capitol: Hartford.
"There is no strong evidence that decriminalization affects either the choice or frequency of use of drugs, either legal (alcohol) or illegal (marijuana and cocaine)." - C. Thies and C. Register. 1993. Decriminalization of Marijuana and the Demand for Alcohol, Marijuana and Cocaine. The Social Sciences Journal 30: 385-399.
"The available evidence indicates that the decriminalization of marijuana possession had little or no impact on rates of use. Although rates of marijuana use increased in those U.S. states [that] reduced maximum penalties for possession to a fine, the prevalence of use increased at similar or higher rates in those states [that] retained more severe penalties. There were also no discernible impacts on the health care systems. On the other hand, the so-called 'decriminalization' measures did result in substantial savings in the criminal justice system."
- E. Single. 1989. The Impact of Marijuana Decriminalization: An Update. Journal of Public Health 10: 456-466.
"The available evidence suggests that those jurisdictions which have decriminalized personal cannabis use have not experienced any dramatic increase in prevalence of use." - National Drug and Alcohol Research Center. 1994. Patterns of cannabis use in Australia. Monograph Series No. 27, Australian Government Publishing Service: Canberra, Australia.

These are just a few examples of a much larger body of studies demonstrating no increase in cannabis use after legalization/decriminalization. Since a similar patterns was seen with regard to prohibition and legalization of alcohol -- which, unlike cannabis, possesses a substantial physical addiction component -- these findings can very likely be extrapolated to other currently prohibited drugs as well.

Taking that into account, it becomes clear that harm and cost of drug prohibition is substantially higher than legalization.
 
As someone who doesn't do illicit drugs, drink or smoke I'm not too sure how to feel about this.
 
As someone who doesn't do illicit drugs, drink or smoke I'm not too sure how to feel about this.

I find it a very simple issue to decide on. The real question is simply "Do you believe that other people have the right to do whatever they want with their own bodies, provided they do not cause harm to someone else?"

For example: skydiving vs. urban basejumping. Or even urban vs. non-urban basejumping.
Skydiving is a risky activity. Several things can go wrong which can result in the death of the skydiver. Basejumping is similarly risky, despite being an almost identical activity.

In skydiving and non-urban basejumping, the risk is entirely to one's self; the chances of someone else being harmed by it are minimal. Urban basejumping, on the other hand, carries not only a relatively high risk to one's self, but a significant risk of harm to others as well. Skydiving is legal, non-urban basejumping varies greatly in legality, and urban basejumping is illegal pretty much everywhere.

Drug use for the most part carries almost no risk of harm to anyone other than the user. (This does not include incidental harm, such as theft or robbery committed to pay for a drug habit, as this is essentially an artifact of prohibition conditions, and not a consequence of the drug use itself.) There are a few drugs, however, which can carry a substantial risk of harm to others, due to the (often unpredictable) nature of the drug's effect -- typically severely altered judgement, loss of inhibitions, and heightened aggressive behaviour -- eg. alcohol, methamphetamine, and dissociatives like PCP. Level of risk for these drugs is typically dosage-dependent, and most are low-risk except at very high doses, or when combined with certain other drugs.

As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user, there's no reason to legislate against it.
 
And why is it that (according to the study cited in the original post) in countries with more liberal drug laws, a larger proportion of people choose not to use them? (I'm looking at you, Netherlands.) Are they happier to begin with? Are kids less interested in "the forbidden" because there isn't one?

How much of the trans-Atlantic cultural difference is a product of having a more-urban, socially-integrated culture in Europe? I remember hearing one German or Austrian man say that at community Krampusnight parties, teenagers sometimes drink alcohol and suddenly discover their personal limits. So, I wonder if this is an example of the difference between Europe and the U.S. There you have plenty of non-parent adults around who know the kids are drinking alcohol, sometimes for the first time, and can help the kids get home. And maybe (?) having mixed ages means you don't have isolated groups of inexperienced people who then compete against each other for the most extreme dosages.

Good points. I am from the Netherlands. My personal experiences and those of my teenage friends when we were young:

Started drinking wine with my parents on special occasions around 14 years. beer at 15 or 16. A lot of kids are allowed to do that. They still drink more than their parents like on when they are alone (more on this later)
Most parents try to teach their kids a 'healthy' way of approaching alcohol because alcohol is accepted in society.

I got really really drunk for the first time at age 17 at a party. I went home on my bike (cause we can't drive here before 18) I felt sick the next day. I decided I didn't like that. I never got wasted like that anytime again, sure I ended up a little drunk at parties and in college, but never so bad that it made me sick. I haven't been drunk in the last 7 years at all

smoking weed. Ok I tried it also at age 17 I think. I used it for a few years, with school buddies on friday and saturday nights. No heavy users in that group of about 10 people, 9 out of 10 stopped using it when they got older. i have not smoked it since 1999 I think and don't feel the need to do so ever again


I think most (male) teens go through this in some way around here. Experiment with the 'cool' stuff. Impress the ladies. Most stop using when they settle down.

Ok so it's legal here? 99% of the parents still forbid their children to use weed and when the kids become adults the parents still don't like it. As a father I wouldn't want my kids smoking it, not if they are 16 and not when they are 20 years old. However I was born in the seventies, my parents are flower power baby boom generation, so they used more soft drugs themselves I guess (as a generation, I don't think my mum ever got near the stuff lol)

Back to alcohol. Here in Holland we have youth related alcohol problems. Too many young kids drink regularly. too many stories of boys getting into hospital! for drinking. Because the very young have low income, they cannot go buy beer in the club or bars (+ they are underage* so even if they had the money they should not be able to buy * = below 16) So what do they do? They get an old van or cabin and buy beer in the supermarket and they meet with their friends in the cabin, and drink and drink... a whole youth culture.. it's getting a problem in some areas.
Then we had the Breezer riots, where young girls were addicted to Bacardi Breezers because it just tastes like lemonade, and some got in the news because they offered sexual services to boys in exchange for these drinks.

Personally I think alcohol is more dangerous than weed.

About the kids + adults thing. Indeed in Western Europe there are many holidays or events where the whole population is partying in some way, and where everybody (read : a lot of people) drinks alcohol. Think of Carnival, a Catholic festival from origin. Or a national holiday. (Queensday in holland, Quatorze Juillet (Bastille Day) in France or Oktoberfest in Germany.) On those days the whole town joins the festivities and much alcohol is consumed and nobody thinks twice when teenagers drink beer in public.

To conclude. I think Europe basically has a good culture fro young people to grow up and learn about these things, but it has it's flaws and dangers and we have problems as well. But maybe (arguably) less problems than at the other side of the ocean.
 
I find it a very simple issue to decide on. The real question is simply "Do you believe that other people have the right to do whatever they want with their own bodies, provided they do not cause harm to someone else?"

For example: skydiving vs. urban basejumping. Or even urban vs. non-urban basejumping.
Skydiving is a risky activity. Several things can go wrong which can result in the death of the skydiver. Basejumping is similarly risky, despite being an almost identical activity.

In skydiving and non-urban basejumping, the risk is entirely to one's self; the chances of someone else being harmed by it are minimal. Urban basejumping, on the other hand, carries not only a relatively high risk to one's self, but a significant risk of harm to others as well. Skydiving is legal, non-urban basejumping varies greatly in legality, and urban basejumping is illegal pretty much everywhere.

Drug use for the most part carries almost no risk of harm to anyone other than the user. (This does not include incidental harm, such as theft or robbery committed to pay for a drug habit, as this is essentially an artifact of prohibition conditions, and not a consequence of the drug use itself.) There are a few drugs, however, which can carry a substantial risk of harm to others, due to the (often unpredictable) nature of the drug's effect -- typically severely altered judgement, loss of inhibitions, and heightened aggressive behaviour -- eg. alcohol, methamphetamine, and dissociatives like PCP. Level of risk for these drugs is typically dosage-dependent, and most are low-risk except at very high doses, or when combined with certain other drugs.

As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user, there's no reason to legislate against it.

Ummm, actually I was only "not sure how to feel" about the US being the top drug user......but an interesting post none-the-less.
 
... As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user, there's no reason to legislate against it.

I generally agree with you and thought that was a great post. But, I look at the "no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user" idea a bit more broadly:

Consider if 1) The BASE jumper fails and winds up paralyzed from the neck down and requires 24/7 care for the rest of his life and 2) He has no insurance and no means to pay for his care, so it is covered by the State.

Is it fair to say his failure at BASE jumping has not harmed anyone else? The cost of his failure is being born not only by him, but by all the citizens of the State.

So, I'd modify the idea to something like "As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user and the user has adequate insurance, there is no reason to legislate against it". I'm all for legalizing most drugs - as long as all users are required to have appropriate health and liability insurance with specific riders for use of the drug.
 
As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user, there's no reason to legislate against it.

I can't quite agree with this. As a first point, harm to a user will almost always cause problems for others as well. If you kill yourself skydiving, someone else has to clean up the mess, and that's not going to be a pleasant job. In addition, there are all the people your death will affect - friends, family, the people you were jumping with, people who saw you land and so on. Humans live in a very social environment and there is almost nothing you can do that will not affect others in some way.

Secondly, harm to others is certainly a major reason for a lot of legislation, but I don't agree it is, or should be, the only one. Take, for example, a person committing suicide by overdosing on paracetamol. Ignoring the issues already mentioned, the only person affected is the user. So should we just ignore this? Well, it was recently made illegal in the UK to sell more than a small amount of paracetamol in one transaction. The result? Suicides decreased. Not just suicides by overdosing on paracetamol, total suicides decreased. If someone really wanted to kill themselves that badly, having to visit a couple more shops would not be a major obstacle. Clearly many of the people did not really want to kill themselves, it was just a spur of the moment thing and they could likely have been helped.

So, should this legislation exist? The only person harmed is the person who kills themselves, so by your argument we should not try to stop them. However, I think that society has a responsibility to help people, and legislation like this is one way of doing so.

The same applies to many other, less extreme, situations. Food, sports activities and so on all have legislation to reduce risk to the individual and generally help people have better lives. Of course, there is an important difference between sensible laws and simply having a nanny state, and I think that the line between the two is crossed in many cases, especially in recent years. However, that does not mean we should not have any laws along these lines. The simple fact is that people often are stupid and often don't know what's best for themselves, and there are plenty of situations where laws are appropriate to counter this.
 
I generally agree with you and thought that was a great post. But, I look at the "no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user" idea a bit more broadly:

Consider if 1) The BASE jumper fails and winds up paralyzed from the neck down and requires 24/7 care for the rest of his life and 2) He has no insurance and no means to pay for his care, so it is covered by the State.

Is it fair to say his failure at BASE jumping has not harmed anyone else? The cost of his failure is being born not only by him, but by all the citizens of the State.

So, I'd modify the idea to something like "As long as an activity carries no substantial risk of harm to anyone but the user and the user has adequate insurance, there is no reason to legislate against it". I'm all for legalizing most drugs - as long as all users are required to have appropriate health and liability insurance with specific riders for use of the drug.



This is why the nanny state is hugely bad for personal freedom. They say "we will take care of you" and then they start attaching string to it. If they want to do that there needs to be a way to opt out and go for private insurance instead of paying those taxes.
 
The simple fact is that people often are stupid and often don't know what's best for themselves, and there are plenty of situations where laws are appropriate to counter this.

This is essential trading freedom for security. Anti-suicide laws are retarded.
 
I did my part last weekend. I couldn't score any blow, but I smoked lots of pot and did acid on Thursday and again on Saturday. Whatver it takes to keep the USA in the #1 spot!
 
There was a very interesting study done in 2001 in the EUREGIO, the region where Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands border. They asked 40.000 pupils of secondary schools about their usage of drugs. The article is in german so i'm going to try that table thingy to show you the results. Belgium and NRW/Germany have a similar drug policy where you don't go to jail for consuming cannabis products but it's illegal and you can get into problems if catched. In the Netherlands, consumation is tolerated and you can buy the stuff at "coffee shops".

|Germany|Belgium|Netherlands
been drunken during the last four weeks|29%|29%|23%
consumed Cannabis during the last four weeks|13%|13%|10%
consumed Extacy during the last four weeks|1,9%|2,1%|1,5%
consumed hard drugs during the last four weeks|3,1%|3,1%|1,7%
 
There was a very interesting study done in 2001 in the EUREGIO, the region where Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands border. They asked 40.000 pupils of secondary schools about their usage of drugs. The article is in german so i'm going to try that table thingy to show you the results. Belgium and NRW/Germany have a similar drug policy where you don't go to jail for consuming cannabis products but it's illegal and you can get into problems if catched. In the Netherlands, consumation is tolerated and you can buy the stuff at "coffee shops".

|Germany|Belgium|Netherlands
been drunken during the last four weeks|29%|29%|23%
consumed Cannabis during the last four weeks|13%|13%|10%
consumed Extacy during the last four weeks|1,9%|2,1%|1,5%
consumed hard drugs during the last four weeks|3,1%|3,1%|1,7%


Well, that is just weird, since the three groups have comparable access to the stuff (it being the border area and all). You would be tempted to think there is some reverse-psychology effect...

Germany/Belgium:
- Parental Unit: Cannabis is bad!!
* Angsty Adolescent: Cannabis is cool!!

Netherlands:
-Parental Unit: Hey honey, when are you going to invite your friends over to smoke pot? I haven't seen them in a while.
* Angsty Adolescent: Cannabis is very uncool :(
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom