Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ultimately, impeachment is a purely political process. If you get the votes, you get a new president. The reason is a formality.

However, the constitution contains the clause "high crimes and misdemeanors", and that has created a kind of strong oral tradition that a president ought to be thrown out if and only if a crime has been committed. In addition, the language of the constitution uses the language of trials and convictions. I would be amazed to see a president, any president, impeached and convicted for anything other than a crime.

<snip>


As you say, the reason is a formality.

We have already seen that ta Republican controlled HoR will cheerfully impeach on the flimsiest of excuses, ones which they would totally ignore when done by one of their own.

Given a sufficiently large majority, nothing would prevent a conviction in the Senate aside from the personal ethical integrity of the Senate members of that same political stripe.

Given their track record, I don't think that counting on such integrity is a wise bet.

Under such circumstances seeing a President convicted of anything at all (providing he wasn't also a Republican) wouldn't surprise me in the least.

We have yet to plumb the depths of the Republicans' total lack of regard for propriety or integrity. Using past performance as a guide I suspect it is a bottomless pit.
 
But the FBI Director still serves at the "Pleasure Of The President". Trump had the power to fire him. There is no debate about that.
The question becomes why did Trump fire him and this is where the Obstruction of Justice issue arises.
And the last paragraph really has little to do with the issue at hand. I don't like Sessions any more then you do,but digging up some pretty penny ante stuff does not serve much of a purpose.


Why are tens or more likely hundreds of thousands of dollars of misappropriated government funds "penny ante"?
 
Last edited:
You mean as opposed to firing him because he wanted to impede the investigation?

Now slow down, just because Trump said that's why he did it, I mean, how do you really know? We could all be brains in a vat, after all. Let's be proper skeptics about this.

First we need to establish we're not a world where Keanu Reeves can dodge bullets, then we can talk about this so called "evidence".
 
You mean as opposed to firing him because he wanted to impede the investigation?

Yeah, but we only have President Trump's word that he fired Comey to impede the investigation - and we all know that we should take him seriously but not literally :boggled:
 
Now slow down, just because Trump said that's why he did it, I mean, how do you really know? We could all be brains in a vat, after all. Let's be proper skeptics about this.

First we need to establish we're not a world where Keanu Reeves can dodge bullets, then we can talk about this so called "evidence".

To be perfectly clear, Trump has not explicitly said he fired Comey to impede the Russia investigation. He did say that he thought about the investigation when he came to the decision, but he could have meant that he dismissed the investigation as unimportant and not reason enough to keep Comey on.

As usual, Trump's inability to communicate means that we have to do some interpretation.

Just to be clear, I think that he intended to fire Comey because of the investigation and other signs that Comey was not loyal to Trump personally. I also think that in his addle-headed manner, this is what he was alluding to when he spoke to Holt, further made plausible by his comments to the Russians.

But that said, this isn't a smoking gun. These are quite plausible interpretations, but not the only such.
 
To be perfectly clear, Trump has not explicitly said he fired Comey to impede the Russia investigation. He did say that he thought about the investigation when he came to the decision, but he could have meant that he dismissed the investigation as unimportant and not reason enough to keep Comey on.

That makes no difference: he willingly interfered with the investigation.
 
To be perfectly clear, Trump has not explicitly said he fired Comey to impede the Russia investigation. He did say that he thought about the investigation when he came to the decision, but he could have meant that he dismissed the investigation as unimportant and not reason enough to keep Comey on.

And then told the Russians that the heat was off - the investigation would end.

But that said, this isn't a smoking gun. These are quite plausible interpretations, but not the only such.

I think it's perfectly possible that he fired Comey because he was pissed about having his stupid wiretapp tweet undercut, and that he was also very pleased that outing a guy who upstaged him would end the investigation.

I don't see how that's materially different from an investigative perspective.

What plausible interpretation of "taking the pressure off" is there that doesn't include being pleased about hamstringing the investigation?
 
Also, Wall Street Journal reports that a GOP strategist admits to working with Guccifer and Roger Stone to pass around the hacked material:

Nevins confirmed to the Journal that he told hacker Guccifer 2.0 to “feel free to send any Florida based information” after learning that the hacker had tapped into Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) computers last summer. From the DCCC, Guccifer 2.0 released internal assessments of Democratic congressional candidates, known as “self-opposition research,” to GOP operatives using social media. Nevins told the Journal that, after receiving the stolen documents from the hacker, he “realized it was a lot more than even Guccifer knew that he had.” The stolen DCCC documents also contained sensitive information on voters in key Florida districts, breaking down how many people were considered dependable Democratic voters, undecided Democrats, Republican voters and the like. Nevins made a war analogy, describing the data he received to Guccifer 2.0 as akin to a “map to where all the troops are deployed.”

[...]

“I just threw an arrow in the dark,” Nevins, who set up a Dropbox account for Guccifer 2.0 to transfer data, told the Journal. “If your interests align,” the operative concluded, “never shut any doors in politics.”

Original WSJ article is behind a pay wall. Link to a summation: http://www.salon.com/2017/05/25/gop...an-hackers-to-hurt-hillary-clinton-democrats/
 
And what is in the president's power to stop an investigation that he thinks is BS? Doesn't that also include investigations targeting him?

The President doesn't have that authority. While he may be able to hire and fire. It is NOT a part of the President's authority to order the police what needs or doesn't need to be investigated.
 
Last edited:
That makes no difference: he willingly interfered with the investigation.

I'm not at all clear on the necessary conditions for obstruction. An interviewee on PBS said that if Trump really meant only to convey that Flynn is a good guy who has suffered enough and this is a good reason to drop the investigation, then it wouldn't be obstruction, even though it "interferes" with the investigation.

I'm sorry I don't recall the credentials of the interviewee, but he had a law background in the appropriate subject. I'm in no position to say whether he's right or wrong.
 
And then told the Russians that the heat was off - the investigation would end.



I think it's perfectly possible that he fired Comey because he was pissed about having his stupid wiretapp tweet undercut, and that he was also very pleased that outing a guy who upstaged him would end the investigation.

I don't see how that's materially different from an investigative perspective.

What plausible interpretation of "taking the pressure off" is there that doesn't include being pleased about hamstringing the investigation?

The defense offered by the administration is that the comment was meant to put Trump in a better negotiation position: Russia's actions put him in a tight spot, and they should remember that going forward.

It's not the most plausible interpretation, but it's not obviously false either. It's in keeping with Trump's ridiculous belief that diplomacy is about personal relationships and favors.

And, in any case, being pleased with a result doesn't mean that the result was your motivation. If Comey was fired for other reasons, does Trump's relief at hamstringing the investigation make it obstruction? (Not a rhetorical question -- I don't know.)

ETA: Again, let me say that all of this looks very plausibly like obstruction and dirty shenanigans to me. It's just not quite as obviously obstruction as some say around here, at least not from my perspective.
 
Last edited:
It is who's.? You don't mean the President? The President isn't a law enforcement officer. This one isn't a lawyer either.

He is bigger than that

The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.

All power possessed by a federal cop or DA is fully and unconditionally a privelige of the president.
 
The defense offered by the administration is that the comment was meant to put Trump in a better negotiation position: Russia's actions put him in a tight spot, and they should remember that going forward.

It's not the most plausible interpretation, but it's not obviously false either. It's in keeping with Trump's ridiculous belief that diplomacy is about personal relationships and favors.

And, in any case, being pleased with a result doesn't mean that the result was your motivation. If Comey was fired for other reasons, does Trump's relief at hamstringing the investigation make it obstruction? (Not a rhetorical question -- I don't know.)

But again, how is ending an investigation for a better negotiating position (whatever that means) a better explanation? Still sounds like firing Comey to impede the Russia investigation, just that he wanted to impede for negotiating, not to keep his ass out of trouble.
 
He is bigger than that

All power possessed by a federal cop or DA is fully and unconditionally a privelige of the president.

No its NOT. Show me in the US Constitution or legislated law where this is one of the President's powers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom