Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
But again, how is ending an investigation for a better negotiating position (whatever that means) a better explanation? Still sounds like firing Comey to impede the Russia investigation, just that he wanted to impede for negotiating, not to keep his ass out of trouble.

I think that you misunderstand me. No one claims that Trump fired Comey for a better negotiating position. The claim is that Trump mentioned the firing and the investigation for a better position.

Obviously, such mention gives the impression that the firing was related to the investigation, but a Trump defender may aptly point out that shading the truth in diplomacy is hardly a new practice.

Again, I think the simpler explanation is that Trump did fire Comey, at least in part, because of the investigation. But simplicity doesn't imply obvious truth.
 
I think that you misunderstand me. No one claims that Trump fired Comey for a better negotiating position. The claim is that Trump mentioned the firing and the investigation for a better position.

Obviously, such mention gives the impression that the firing was related to the investigation, but a Trump defender may aptly point out that shading the truth in diplomacy is hardly a new practice.

Ok, I at least see the gambit.

How does the comment to Holt combined with the loyalty oath and pressure put on Comey by Trump, himself, fit into that narrative?

My position is that it is the combination of what's known that restricts the available explanations.

Again, I think the simpler explanation is that Trump did fire Comey, at least in part, because of the investigation. But simplicity doesn't imply obvious truth.

I understand you're trying to recreate the argument, so obviously, I'm not arguing with you, directly.

I still don't see how the explanation helps, unless you take each item one by one and accept contradictory explanations for each, independent of the other. As a group, none of the explanations provided work.
 
I just did. Is determining what cases to examine an executive power? Then the Constitution says it is vested in the president.

You're wrong. This is NOT an EXECUTIVE POWER vested to the President. While the President has broad authority to manage National affairs, it is subject in domestic affairs to both the judicial and legislative branches. He is NOT a law enforcement official.
 
Ok, I at least see the gambit.

How does the comment to Holt combined with the loyalty oath and pressure put on Comey by Trump, himself, fit into that narrative?

My position is that it is the combination of what's known that restricts the available explanations.



I understand you're trying to recreate the argument, so obviously, I'm not arguing with you, directly.

I still don't see how the explanation helps, unless you take each item one by one and accept contradictory explanations for each, independent of the other. As a group, none of the explanations provided work.

Trump's comments to Holt were as incoherent and ambiguous as one has come to expect from this master of communication.

Here's what he said:

He had made a recommendation. But regardless of recommendation, I was going to fire Comey knowing there was no good time to do it

And in fact, when I decided to just do it, I said to myself -- I said, you know, this Russia thing with Trump and Russia is a made-up story. It's an excuse by the Democrats for having lost an election that they should've won.
​

Here's one interpretation of the above that does not entail that Russia is the reason for the firing. This is my own interpretation, not one I've seen elsewhere, but I think it's consistent with the above jumble of half-thoughts. I'm not saying it's what Trump meant, because who the **** knows what Trump means when he opens his mouth? (Even Trump seems puzzled by his own utterances.)


I had decided to fire Comey. I realized, however, that this might interfere with the ongoing Russia investigation, but I decided to do it anyway since the Russia investigation is pointless. There was no collusion, so interfering with an investigation bound to fail is not a significant issue.​

Of course, the common interpretation around here is something like this:

Comey is fixated on this Russia investigation and we need to get past it, so I fired him.​

That is also consistent with what he said.
 
You're wrong. This is NOT an EXECUTIVE POWER vested to the President. While the President has broad authority to manage National affairs, it is subject in domestic affairs to both the judicial and legislative branches. He is NOT a law enforcement official.

I'm having trouble understanding your second sentence.

Is your argument that choosing what to investigate is not an executive power or that it isn't vested in the president?
 
Determining what is and is not worthy​ of an investigation is his and his alone.

You obviously think that is the case, despite that being a minority view.

Do you think that should be the case?
 
So?

Are you arguing real world facts or just quibbling about semantics again?

Wait, I already know that answer. :rolleyes:

Efforts to impeach a president for obstruction of justice doesn't actually inform anything about the president's powers around obstruction of justice. It is a legal debate trying to use an event that isn't a legal debate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom