Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you sure that (1) and (2) are necessary conditions of obstruction? I haven't heard that, and it doesn't appear in the relevant text (18 U.S.C. 1512).

Probably not exactly true. It might be enough to suspect that there was a crime, and impede the investigation into it.

The point is that motive matters. It has to be a malicious or corrupt act. Merely taking some action that hinders an investigation is not obstruction of justice. There's a whole lot of wishful thinking going on among people who think that the information available in the public sphere today is adequate for an obstruction charge.

I looked into 18 USC 1512, and I can't see how to apply anything at all in that statute. I suppose people might be keying on section c, which is basically a catch all for anything they didn't think of, but it begins with "corruptly". You have to prove corruption. If everything went down in the manner described in my hypothetical, there's no corruption, hence no charge.
 
....

I looked into 18 USC 1512, and I can't see how to apply anything at all in that statute. I suppose people might be keying on section c, which is basically a catch all for anything they didn't think of, but it begins with "corruptly". You have to prove corruption. If everything went down in the manner described in my hypothetical, there's no corruption, hence no charge.
Corruption you say?

Trump Organization isn't tracking profits from foreign governments: report
MSNBC reported Wednesday a pamphlet from the company says the Trump Organization doesn't "attempt to identify travelers who have not specifically identified themselves as being a representative of a foreign government entity."

The pamphlet also says the Trump Organization plans to estimate profits from foreign governments, instead of calculating them.
 
Fox used the "associated with" wording last night. The dishonesty of the wording was glaring.

Max Boot has a good piece on how Fox News has allowed itself to become a sensationalist information weapon for the Kremlin.

These spurious insinuations have been put forward (before being largely recanted) by a sometime Fox News contributor named Rod Wheeler. Never mind that Rich’s family, the Washington police force, CNN, the Washington Post, and the New York Times, among others, have debunked these conspiracy theories, showing there is no evidence that Rich was a WikiLeaks source, much less that his murder has anything to do with the stolen Democratic Party emails. Sean Hannity, one of the last of the old guard hired by Ailes to rule prime time, nevertheless devoted three separate segments of his show last week to the “DNC murder mystery.” On Sunday morning, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich was pushing the same allegation about Rich’s “assassination” on Fox & Friends. Lou Dobbs has spouted these theories on Fox Business Network, too.

...

The Russians have tipped their hand — and Fox’s as well. Hannity, Gingrich, and Dobbs are in overdrive selling the phony Seth Rich scandal because they think it will distract attention from the real scandals of Donald Trump. The president faces a special counsel investigation and the prospect of impeachment, in part because he keeps bragging about obstructing justice. Trump is reported to have told the Russian foreign minister and the Russian ambassador to the United States in an Oval Office meeting, “I just fired the head of the FBI. He was crazy, a real nut job.… I faced great pressure because of*Russia. That’s taken off,” adding, “I’m not under investigation.” Unable to defend Trump on the merits, the Fox crew wants to absolve him — and his helpers in the Kremlin — by concocting an elaborate fantasy. Hannity had the temerity to tweet: “If Seth was wiki source, no Trump/Russia collusion.”

...

That was a laudable ambition, but what Fox has become is far from laudable. Not only is it a toxic workplace where the harassment of women is rampant; it is also a no-fact zone. The Pulitzer Prize-winning website PolitiFact found that nearly 60 percent of the statements it checked on Fox News were either mostly or entirely false. Another 19 percent were only half true. Only Fox News viewers are likely to believe that climate change is a hoax, that there is a “war on Christmas,” that Obamacare would create “death panels,” that there is an epidemic of crime committed by immigrants (they actually have a lower crime rate than native-born Americans), that President Barack Obama forged his birth certificate and wiretapped Trump with the aid of Britain’s signals intelligence agency, and that the accusations bedeviling Trump are a product of “Russophobia.” FNC might as well stand for Fake News Channel, and its myths have had a pernicious, indeed debilitating, effect on U.S. politics.

...

There is now a conveyer belt spreading Russian disinformation that originates with RT and Sputnik — the former being Kremlin-funded and the latter an official Kremlin organ — and then makes it way to our shores via extremist websites such as Breitbart and InfoWars, before being presented to middle America by Fox. The irony is rich: Roger Ailes, who got his start in politics working for the old Red-hunter, Richard Nixon, created a news channel that now serves as a de facto information weapon for the Kremlin.
 
Probably not exactly true. It might be enough to suspect that there was a crime, and impede the investigation into it.

The point is that motive matters. It has to be a malicious or corrupt act. Merely taking some action that hinders an investigation is not obstruction of justice. There's a whole lot of wishful thinking going on among people who think that the information available in the public sphere today is adequate for an obstruction charge.

I looked into 18 USC 1512, and I can't see how to apply anything at all in that statute. I suppose people might be keying on section c, which is basically a catch all for anything they didn't think of, but it begins with "corruptly". You have to prove corruption. If everything went down in the manner described in my hypothetical, there's no corruption, hence no charge.
To be sure, impeachment doesn't require a proof that a law was broken at all.

Mind, I'm not saying that impeachment is likely at present.

ETA: I'm not sure that the above is relevant to your point, now that I think about it. You were merely disputing whether it was obvious that Trump obstructed.
 
Last edited:
GOP operative in Florida received hacked data from Russia.

The hacking spree that upended the presidential election wasn’t limited to Democratic National Committee memos and Clinton-aide emails posted on websites. The hacker also privately sent Democratic voter-turnout analyses to a Republican political operative in Florida named Aaron Nevins.

Learning that hacker “Guccifer 2.0” had tapped into a Democratic committee that helps House candidates, Mr. Nevins wrote to the hacker to say: “Feel free to send any Florida based information.”

Ten days later, Mr. Nevins received 2.5 gigabytes of Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee documents, some of which he posted on a blog called HelloFLA.com that he ran using a pseudonym.

Soon after, the hacker sent a link to the blog article to Roger Stone, a longtime informal adviser to then-candidate Donald Trump, along with Mr. Nevins’ analysis of the hacked data.

Mr. Nevins confirmed his exchanges after The Wall Street Journal identified him first as the operator of the HelloFLA blog and then as the recipient of the stolen DCCC data. The Journal also reviewed copies of exchanges between the hacker and Mr. Nevins. That the obscure blog had received hacked Democratic documents was previously known, but not the extent of the trove or the blogger’s identity
 
To be sure, impeachment doesn't require a proof that a law was broken at all.

Mind, I'm not saying that impeachment is likely at present.

ETA: I'm not sure that the above is relevant to your point, now that I think about it. You were merely disputing whether it was obvious that Trump obstructed.

Andrew Johnson was impeached for firing the Secretary of War without the permission of Congress (the technical charge was "Abuse of Power");something in no way a criminal offense.
 
If memory serves, isn't that exactly what Congress wanted? Or am I mixing up my events?

Johnson, because of long term disagreement with Edward Stanton over Reconsrtuction Policy in the South, fired Stanton. The Radical Republicans in Congress, who hated Johnson, were looking for an excuse to impeach him and claimed that Johnson 's firing of Stanton was an abuse of power;that he needed the approval of congress to fire a cabinent member. Johnson was impeached, but not convicted of the charge.
Nowdays it is very much established that although the President needs congressional approval of Cabinent members, once they are approved and appointed, they serve at the President's Pleasure, and can be fired at any time.
Only problem legally would be if something like obstruction of justice was involved.
 
Johnson, because of long term disagreement with Edward Stanton over Reconsrtuction Policy in the South, fired Stanton. The Radical Republicans in Congress, who hated Johnson, were looking for an excuse to impeach him and claimed that Johnson 's firing of Stanton was an abuse of power;that he needed the approval of congress to fire a cabinent member. Johnson was impeached, but not convicted of the charge.
Nowdays it is very much established that although the President needs congressional approval of Cabinent members, once they are approved and appointed, they serve at the President's Pleasure, and can be fired at any time.
Only problem legally would be if something like obstruction of justice was involved.

Ok so I was remembering correctly.
 
To be sure, impeachment doesn't require a proof that a law was broken at all.

Mind, I'm not saying that impeachment is likely at present.

ETA: I'm not sure that the above is relevant to your point, now that I think about it. You were merely disputing whether it was obvious that Trump obstructed.

Ultimately, impeachment is a purely political process. If you get the votes, you get a new president. The reason is a formality.

However, the constitution contains the clause "high crimes and misdemeanors", and that has created a kind of strong oral tradition that a president ought to be thrown out if and only if a crime has been committed. In addition, the language of the constitution uses the language of trials and convictions. I would be amazed to see a president, any president, impeached and convicted for anything other than a crime.

Perhaps I could see it for a blatantly unconstitutional abuse of power which is, nevertheless, not a crime. Perhaps an act of war which was incredibly unpopular, and with no congressional consultation might do it. I don't think that's a crime, but it would be an overreach of power. However, there has to be two components. It has to be unconstitutional, and it has to be unpopular. It's hard to get 2/3 of the Senate to go along with overturning an election.
 
Ultimately, impeachment is a purely political process. If you get the votes, you get a new president. The reason is a formality.

However, the constitution contains the clause "high crimes and misdemeanors", and that has created a kind of strong oral tradition that a president ought to be thrown out if and only if a crime has been committed. In addition, the language of the constitution uses the language of trials and convictions. I would be amazed to see a president, any president, impeached and convicted for anything other than a crime.

Perhaps I could see it for a blatantly unconstitutional abuse of power which is, nevertheless, not a crime. Perhaps an act of war which was incredibly unpopular, and with no congressional consultation might do it. I don't think that's a crime, but it would be an overreach of power. However, there has to be two components. It has to be unconstitutional, and it has to be unpopular. It's hard to get 2/3 of the Senate to go along with overturning an election.
Wrong. Specifics weren't included in the Constitution because everybody at the time knew what "high crimes and misdemeanors" meant (a catch-all for anything from bedding a foreign leader's wife to murdering the Senate majority leader during a joint session of Congress). It was intended to be vague so that Congress could retain the power to remove a President who according to their judgment was doing more harm than good. It's the check.
 
Johnson, because of long term disagreement with Edward Stanton over Reconsrtuction Policy in the South, fired Stanton. The Radical Republicans in Congress, who hated Johnson, were looking for an excuse to impeach him and claimed that Johnson 's firing of Stanton was an abuse of power;that he needed the approval of congress to fire a cabinent member. Johnson was impeached, but not convicted of the charge.
Nowdays it is very much established that although the President needs congressional approval of Cabinent members, once they are approved and appointed, they serve at the President's Pleasure, and can be fired at any time.
Only problem legally would be if something like obstruction of justice was involved.

The FBI director is not a part of the cabinet and does not serve at the pleasure of the President. He serves a ten year term and while he can be fired by the President, this only the second time it has happened. But that time it wasn't because he refused to halt an investigation it was because of numerous ethics violations.

A Justice Department report from January 1993 stated that Sessions routinely used FBI planes and cars and staff time for personal use. Ordered his bodyguards to fly a load of firewood from New York to Washington, D.C., commissioned FBI technicians to build a $22,500 cabinet for his office, and would fly to Los Angeles, Calif., once a year on FBI an plane to watch his daughter’s professional ballet performances.
 
Wrong. Specifics weren't included in the Constitution because everybody at the time knew what "high crimes and misdemeanors" meant (a catch-all for anything from bedding a foreign leader's wife to murdering the Senate majority leader during a joint session of Congress). It was intended to be vague so that Congress could retain the power to remove a President who according to their judgment was doing more harm than good. It's the check.

Sigh.

I don't know if you noticed this, but other than the "wrong", nothing you said contradicts anything I said. So congratulations. You are correct. That is usually the case when people agree with me. People should do it more often.
 
This concerns me because I just have to wonder what crazy thing he's going to have to do now to get it off the front pages. Undoubtedly blow something up real good. Like North Korea.
 
Jared Kushner Now Under FBI Scrutiny in Russia Probe, Say Officials

Jared Kushner, the president's son-in-law and one of his senior advisers, has come under FBI scrutiny in the Russia investigation, multiple U.S. officials told NBC News.

Investigators believe Kushner has significant information relevant to their inquiry, officials said. That does not mean they suspect him of a crime or intend to charge him.

The FBI's scrutiny of Kushner places the bureau's sprawling counterintelligence and criminal investigation not only on the doorstep of the White House, but on the cusp of the Trump family circle. The Washington Post first reported last week that a senior White House official close to Trump was a "person of interest," but did not name the person. The term "person of interest" has no legal meaning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom