Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry for a bit of a derail.... Here's my speculative scenario.

Chaffetz gets out without doing any damage to Trump, but not doing anything reprehensible to defend him, either.

He'll take a commentator gig with Fox through the '18 mid-term elections and then....?

Either Hatch resigns(or dies) and Chaffetz gets drafted to take his seat, or when Hatch inevitably announces that he won't run in 2020 (he'll be 88), Chaffetz is in a position to face-off with Mia Love in the 2020 primary. I don't believe for a second that he intends to leave politics. He's getting out of the line of fire and trying to have his cake and eat it, too. Come 2020 he can choose to go the "I did right by the party and wouldn't press issues against our President" route.

He's not issuing subpoenas when it is obvious they are called for.
 
IOW he/she dodged the question with an alt-version of what we know about the contacts.

Oh, of course. "Dodged" by directly answering the specific question that you actually asked. As for "alt-version," I was under the impression, based on Maddow's description, that the 18 undisclosed were new things to add to the list and thus, Flynn discussing the sanctions with Kislyak was not included among them. Either way, you're trying to twist things really hard here and I'm thoroughly unimpressed.

I asked you what would be enough. You said we'd need to know what was said in the contacts.

No. I didn't. And no, you didn't. I said that if we don't actually know the nature or anything about the context, there's really, really not enough information. Sessions coming in contact with the Russian ambassador briefly, in public, at an official event counts as a contact and is apparently one of the ones that was not initially disclosed to Congress when questioned. It can truthfully be called an undisclosed contact, in short, and there's not much of a case for it being nefarious. Trump aides flying halfway around the world and meeting with fairly close associates of Putin for a day or two, on the other hand, is quite a bit more suspicious.

As for what you said, you asked about the number of undisclosed contacts, specifically, and how many would be required before wrongdoing is assumed. Your attempt to lie about that is remarkably unimpressive.

I brought up an example of what we do know about the contacts. Now you revert back to saying we don't know what was said.

About the 18 undisclosed number that was in various headlines? I pointed out earlier in the post that I was working from Maddow's statement that the 18 figure was regarding "new" undisclosed contacts. Is this inaccurate? But then, even Flynn's discussion with Kislyak about the sanctions is less damning, in and of itself, than you seem to want it to be, distinctly problematic as it was.

Come on, how many specious connections between Trump's inner campaign staff and Russia does it take for a person to stop using the, "we don't know" rationalization? How many denials of contacts that were later shown to have occurred does it take before one should stop chalking it up to, 'we don't know'?

A better question is whether you're so convinced of collusion that evidence doesn't actually matter to you, unless it's confirming your position further? And that you don't actually care about whether it's valid evidence or a valid argument or not, so long as its confirming your position?

My point is more than a few people in this discussion are denying there is any evidence when there is a whole boatload of evidence.

And at no point have I even suggested that there's no evidence. I've said the exact opposite on a number of occasions, no less. The evidence is strong enough to make serious investigation the only responsible course of action, certainly, but not currently sufficient to convict. I can clarify again, though, that I don't consider all that has been claimed to be evidence to actually say much or, to go back to the actual start of this little conversation, that an argument that doesn't hold up to even simple scrutiny constitutes a valid argument to use.

Skepticism is not to take an all or none position. There is a gradient:
We have no evidence one way or the other.
We have evidence that suggests a connection.
We have evidence that suggests no connection.
We have evidence that supports a connection. [This is where I see the evidence.]
We have evidence that supports no connection.
We have overwhelming evidence that supports the connection.
We have overwhelming evidence that supports no connection.​

The position, "We have no evidence one way or the other," is a stretch beyond credible.

It's rather sad for you to be trying to lecture me about this, when it's pretty clear from a number of my actual posts, in this thread, no less, that the issue that you're trying to address here is not one that applies to me. We do have "evidence that supports a connection." Not all "evidence" claimed is necessarily valid evidence, though.
 
Last edited:
Would recusing imply that he no longer has access to any of the information, or only that he will abstain from taking part in the decision?
No longer have access.

I'm pretty sure that it's the latter more than the former, in this case, given that he still officially has clearance for such, given his position on the relevant committee. Continuing to access the information treads on rather questionable ground, yes, given that just keeping up with things isn't actually wrong, but actually discussing it with just about anyone becomes notably more problematic.
 
Come on, how many specious connections between Trump's inner campaign staff and Russia does it take for a person to stop using the, "we don't know" rationalization? How many denials of contacts that were later shown to have occurred does it take before one should stop chalking it up to, 'we don't know'?

My point is more than a few people in this discussion are denying there is any evidence when there is a whole boatload of evidence.


The position, "We have no evidence one way or the other," is a stretch beyond credible.

A better description might be "your circumstantial evidence in no way eliminates the most likely innocent scenario: Trump and team support Russia for financial and worldview reasons, and Russia helped Trump for similar reasons, without collusion."
 
We also can't say those are not fictional creations of the journalist
Not a big fan of twitter and anonymous sources. However. Most of the rumours to date have been surprisingly accurate. The rumours have been exaggerations sometimes. No arrests so far, for example.

The Donald himself has been the most useful verification for much of the information. E.g. The Comey sacking.
 
Oh, you're right. I didn't even read the bit you quoted!

So, The Don is right, and my comment was apt, and you were way off base. And then so was I later on, but I blame you. Duh.

Have you learned nothing from President Trump ?

You should insist that you are correct, that facts that happen to disagree with you are "fake news" and then go on to make baseless accusations against a third party over something completely different :D
 
I always find that reasoning ridiculous. The 5th exists so that innocent people don't incriminate themselves. To assume that taking the 5th means you're guilty is to completely miss the point.

I think the context matters when it comes to this. Not allowing people to see evidence because it could be incriminating is a much different situation than not answering questions.
 
I always find that reasoning ridiculous. The 5th exists so that innocent people don't incriminate themselves. To assume that taking the 5th means you're guilty is to completely miss the point.

Exactly, if only President Trump and his campaign had applied this.....

Instead they sought to portray anyone taking the 5th as guilty. It would be equally hypocritical if someone from the "other side" now suggests that this indicates Flynn is guilty if they said that Hillary's IT guy was fine to take the 5th. :mad:
 
I actually had never understood that the fifth amendment applies to evidence as much as it does to answering questions. I guess it sort of makes sense, but I always thought evidence was....well, evidence. You couldn't refuse it, but then I also suppose that Senate proceedings are not the same as a criminal case, so different rules apply?
 
It's a clear case of Privilege in the literal sense:

Private Law

One law for Trump and his friends, another for the rest.
 
I actually had never understood that the fifth amendment applies to evidence as much as it does to answering questions. I guess it sort of makes sense, but I always thought evidence was....well, evidence. You couldn't refuse it, but then I also suppose that Senate proceedings are not the same as a criminal case, so different rules apply?

Yeah that confused me as well.

The Don: Yes, I understand the issue of hypocrisy in this case.
 
Not a big fan of twitter and anonymous sources. However. Most of the rumours to date have been surprisingly accurate. The rumours have been exaggerations sometimes. No arrests so far, for example.

The Donald himself has been the most useful verification for much of the information. E.g. The Comey sacking.

Every single new claim requires going through the process of openly presenting all your evidence​. No reporter gets a pass regardless of how correct they have been before.
 
I actually had never understood that the fifth amendment applies to evidence as much as it does to answering questions. I guess it sort of makes sense, but I always thought evidence was....well, evidence. You couldn't refuse it, but then I also suppose that Senate proceedings are not the same as a criminal case, so different rules apply?

It really doesn't. For example in Flynn's case. Documents he may have already created would not be protected by the 5th. However, it is my understanding that the subpoena actually asks him to create new documents listing foreign contacts. That would be viewed as testifying against himself. This is where Flynn gets into real trouble. Flynn omissions and outright lies about foreign contacts and payments cannot be reasonably be suggested to be ignorance. Flynn has been in government service a long time. These are not new rules.
 
I looks to me like a negotiation tactic by Flynn to get immunity.

Absolutely. Flynn definitely committed multiple crimes and he's trying to get out from underneath them. The irony is that he led that chorus of ' lock her up' at the RNC. But the noose is tightening now that there is a special council.
 
Yes, and they should just give it to him. It's been obvious for months that it would take that, so they should just get on with it.

Only if what he is prepared to give is of some value. It would be a travesty if the information he provides after he gets immunity is either irrelevant to investigating Trump and his administration or available from other sources.
 
Only if what he is prepared to give is of some value. It would be a travesty if the information he provides after he gets immunity is either irrelevant to investigating Trump and his administration or available from other sources.

Why would that be a travesty? Because he got away with a victimless crime?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom