Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
The first line in the article about Trump taking the 5th.

'In the summer of 1990, at the height of his bitter divorce from his first wife, Donald Trump was carrying on a very public extramarital affair with a former beauty queen, Marla Maples.'

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-pleading-the-fifth_us_57ed79dee4b024a52d2de46d

Very well. I didn't look at the article and only went by what The Don had written.

True, but the fact that Donald Trump himself invoked the 5th 97 times during his divorce from Ivana highlights his "flexibility" on such matters IMO.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-pleading-the-fifth_us_57ed79dee4b024a52d2de46d

Thanks for the correction.
 
The first line in the article about Trump taking the 5th.

'In the summer of 1990, at the height of his bitter divorce from his first wife, Donald Trump was carrying on a very public extramarital affair with a former beauty queen, Marla Maples.'

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-pleading-the-fifth_us_57ed79dee4b024a52d2de46d

Very well. I didn't look at the article and only went by what The Don had written.



Thanks for the correction.

Actually, now that I read it. Don't is right. Whooops.

:o
 
Actually, now that I read it. Don't is right. Whooops.

:o

Oh, you're right. I didn't even read the bit you quoted!

So, The Don is right, and my comment was apt, and you were way off base. And then so was I later on, but I blame you. Duh.
 
Oh, you're right. I didn't even read the bit you quoted!

So, The Don is right, and my comment was apt, and you were way off base. And then so was I later on, but I blame you. Duh.

Yea, it was me. I'm all to blame. I did it. I must now commit seppuku.
 
Looks as though Flynn might have to still obey the subpoena and show up to testify, even if all he does is simply say, "I decline to Answer on the grounds it might incriminate me"....
 
Skepticism is not to take an all or none position. There is a gradient:
We have no evidence one way or the other.
We have evidence that suggests a connection.
We have evidence that suggests no connection.
We have evidence that supports a connection. [This is where I see the evidence.]
We have evidence that supports no connection.
We have overwhelming evidence that supports the connection.
We have overwhelming evidence that supports no connection.​

The position, "We have no evidence one way or the other," is a stretch beyond credible.

I'd say that reality is somewhere closer to:
We have many speculations and allegations, and a small amount of evidence that suggests some level of communication, potentially a meaningful connection, but at present insufficient evidence to support an accusation of collusion.

There's more than enough to make us want to look much more closely.

There are lots and lots of accusations supported by unnamed anonymous sources who are not actually supposed to talk about it - they aren't at liberty to discuss the issue, nor to share what information they are sharing, and are actively breaching confidentiality in order to tell us the stuff they aren't allowed to tell us. But I'm sure that's all genuine honest whistle-blowing, none of that could possibly have political or personal motivations.

I think it's highly plausible. I just don't think there's actually enough solid evidence that any of us are privy to. The evidence might very well exist, but you and I haven't seen it.
 
For him to take the 5th it would have to be about something that could possibly be used against him in the prosecution of a crime. Money laundering, mob ties, rape allegations. But it seems that taking the 5th in this civil action probably didn't help the outcome.

This isn't correct. A person might very well plead the fifth to avoid incriminating themselves for something unrelated, or for the crime in question. But a person might also plead the fifth if they believe that their responses, even if not indicative of a crime, could be used against them. For example, if their responses could be used to damage their reputation in something unrelated, it may very well be reasonable to plead the fifth.

Given the behavior of a very large number of policemen in recent years, I'd be inclined to plead the fifth for pretty much anything that I were arrested for (on the very unlikely chance that I ever get arrested). I'm inclined to think that "anything and everything I say could be used against me"... so I'd really rather say nothing at all.
 
This isn't correct. A person might very well plead the fifth to avoid incriminating themselves for something unrelated, or for the crime in question. But a person might also plead the fifth if they believe that their responses, even if not indicative of a crime, could be used against them. For example, if their responses could be used to damage their reputation in something unrelated, it may very well be reasonable to plead the fifth.

Given the behavior of a very large number of policemen in recent years, I'd be inclined to plead the fifth for pretty much anything that I were arrested for (on the very unlikely chance that I ever get arrested). I'm inclined to think that "anything and everything I say could be used against me"... so I'd really rather say nothing at all.

The problem is this was NOT a criminal proceeding. In a criminal proceeding a jury is not supposed to be give any weight to say a defendant taking the 5th. This is not true in a civil proceeding.

If a cop takes the 5th, in many jurisdictions that amounts to the end of their career in law enforcement.
 
The problem is this was NOT a criminal proceeding. In a criminal proceeding a jury is not supposed to be give any weight to say a defendant taking the 5th. This is not true in a civil proceeding.

If a cop takes the 5th, in many jurisdictions that amounts to the end of their career in law enforcement.

Okay.

I still say that pleading the 5th isn't necessarily indicative of a crime, which is what you said:
For him to take the 5th it would have to be about something that could possibly be used against him in the prosecution of a crime.

So we both get to be right! :D
 
Last edited:
Okay.

I still say that pleading the 5th isn't necessarily indicative of a crime, which is what you said:


So we both get to be right! :D

I'd say so. But there appears to be plenty of evidence that Flynn lied to government investigators. I'll be shocked if Flynn doesn't go to prison minus a pardon. Which reminds me. Didn't Scooter Libby avoid prison through Presidential pardon?
 
This not good for Flynn.

Michael T. Flynn, President Trump’s former national security adviser, misled Pentagon investigators about his income from companies in Russia and contacts with officials there when he applied for a renewal of his top-secret security clearance last year, according to a letter released Monday by the top Democrat on the House oversight committee.

Mr. Flynn, who resigned 24 days into the Trump administration, told investigators in February 2016 that he had received no income from foreign companies and had only “insubstantial contact” with foreign nationals, according to the letter. In fact, Mr. Flynn had sat two months earlier beside President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia at a Moscow gala for RT, the Kremlin-financed television network, which paid Mr. Flynn more than $45,000 to attend the event and give a separate speech.

His failure to make those disclosures and his apparent attempt to mislead the Pentagon could put Mr. Flynn in further legal jeopardy. Intentionally lying to federal investigators is a felony punishable by up to five years in prison. Separately, he also faces legal questions over failing to properly register as a foreign agent for lobbying he did last year on behalf of Turkey while advising the Trump campaign, which is also a felony.
 
I'd say so. But there appears to be plenty of evidence that Flynn lied to government investigators. I'll be shocked if Flynn doesn't go to prison minus a pardon. Which reminds me. Didn't Scooter Libby avoid prison through Presidential pardon?

Maybe he will cut some sort of deal where he tells Mueller everything he knows to avoid prison.

And Libby got his prison sentence commuted (he was still a convicted felon and had to do the other parts of the sentence). Cheney was very angry at Dubya for not giving Libby a full pardon.
 
Yeah, that's a big ol' felony right there.

I want to know what game Chaffetz is playing. He is the committee chairman and he's playing some running out the clock game doing as little as humanly possible. Between him and Nunes I detect something very fishy.
 
I want to know what game Chaffetz is playing. He is the committee chairman and he's playing some running out the clock game doing as little as humanly possible. Between him and Nunes I detect something very fishy.

Sorry for a bit of a derail.... Here's my speculative scenario.

Chaffetz gets out without doing any damage to Trump, but not doing anything reprehensible to defend him, either.

He'll take a commentator gig with Fox through the '18 mid-term elections and then....?

Either Hatch resigns(or dies) and Chaffetz gets drafted to take his seat, or when Hatch inevitably announces that he won't run in 2020 (he'll be 88), Chaffetz is in a position to face-off with Mia Love in the 2020 primary. I don't believe for a second that he intends to leave politics. He's getting out of the line of fire and trying to have his cake and eat it, too. Come 2020 he can choose to go the "I did right by the party and wouldn't press issues against our President" route.
 
Sorry for a bit of a derail.... Here's my speculative scenario.

Chaffetz gets out without doing any damage to Trump, but not doing anything reprehensible to defend him, either.

He'll take a commentator gig with Fox through the '18 mid-term elections and then....?

Either Hatch resigns(or dies) and Chaffetz gets drafted to take his seat, or when Hatch inevitably announces that he won't run in 2020 (he'll be 88), Chaffetz is in a position to face-off with Mia Love in the 2020 primary. I don't believe for a second that he intends to leave politics. He's getting out of the line of fire and trying to have his cake and eat it, too. Come 2020 he can choose to go the "I did right by the party and wouldn't press issues against our President" route.

Nope, he's planning on running for gov of Utah, all this is calculated to sever ties to Trump at an opportune moment. The Trump Fed is a mess, retreat back to the state line.

Chaffetz avoids re-election battle, eyes Utah governor race
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom