Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
One warning - this thread is not a thread to discuss libertarianism or other political ideologies or theories. Any further discussions in this direction will result in at least an infraction but more than likely a suspension.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: darat
 
One warning - this thread is not a thread to discuss libertarianism or other political ideologies or theories. Any further discussions in this direction will result in at least an infraction but more than likely a suspension.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: darat

Damn, just when it was getting interesting. :(
 
The witness hints at what he would say and the investigators take their cue from that when preparing a proffer. They agree to what is basically to be testified to and if the witness double crosses and says something entirely different the immunity offer is voided. It's a dance. .

The basic rule is one that is one of the first things first year law students learn : Never ask a witness a question in court unless you know what the answer is going to be.
 
This is the first time a US official has directly, publicly said Trump team and Russians were in communication.

Questioned aggressively by leading panel Republican Rep. Trey Gowdy of South Carolina, Brennan repeatedly pushed back against saying if he saw “evidence” of “collusion” between Trump and Russia – a framing favored by the White House and its GOP allies, who argue no such collusion exists.

“I don’t do evidence, I do intelligence,” Brennan said, saying the FBI was the proper agency to follow up as to whether the identified ties amount to evidence – a term with legal connotation and implication – of what Gowdy called “collusion, collaboration or conspiracy.”

“I don’t know whether or not such collusion – that’s your word – existed, I do not. But I know there was a sufficient basis of information and intelligence that required further investigation by the bureau to determine whether U.S. persons were actively conspiring, colluding, with Russian officials,” Brennan said.
 
We also can't say those are not fictional creations of the journalist

Technically, sure. But I'm inclined to think that journalists aren't just making things up out of whole cloth. I think there's plenty of room for things to be exaggerated, or for rampant speculation. But I really doubt that journalists would completely invent a non-existent source for this.

I suspect there are actual sources involved. What I question is 1) the credibility of the information those sources are providing (are they actually high enough up to have the information or are they reporting things they got second hand) and 2) the materiality and import of the information (are they saying something is a really big deal when it real is not).
 
I actually had never understood that the fifth amendment applies to evidence as much as it does to answering questions. I guess it sort of makes sense, but I always thought evidence was....well, evidence. You couldn't refuse it, but then I also suppose that Senate proceedings are not the same as a criminal case, so different rules apply?

It doesn't apply to evidence collected in any other fashion. It applies exclusively to people not being forced to incriminate themselves.

IIRC, there has been a fair amount of discussion regarding whether obligating a person to type in the password to an encrypted computer constitutes a violation of the 5th amendment. The laptop itself is certainly evidence. But if the cops don't have the password, they can't get in to it, regardless of whether they have a warrant. Can a person be compelled to give that password to law enforcement, if access to the computer would incriminate them?

I recall the discussion, but I can't recall where it landed at the end of the day. It's not a scenario I really anticipate every being in, so it didn't really stick.
 
Only if what he is prepared to give is of some value. It would be a travesty if the information he provides after he gets immunity is either irrelevant to investigating Trump and his administration or available from other sources.

I'm not a lawyer, but it seems like they should be able to revoke that immunity if the information provided is useless. Otherwise it seems like criminals would be asking for immunity all the time just to get out of the charge.
 

That's what I kept coming up with, but for me, the page is mostly blank. All it says is:
A new letter from the leading Democrat on the House oversight committee, Rep. Elijah Cummings, reveals new information about former national security adviser Michael Flynn and what he told investigators about his ties to foreign governments when he was interviewed about his security clearance.
Nothing else.


The House letter, written by Representative Elijah E. Cummings of Maryland, was made public hours after Mr. Flynn formally rejected a subpoena from senators investigating Russian interference in the 2016 election and chose to instead invoke his right against self-incrimination, a person familiar with his decision said.
It's the actual letter, which is claimed to have been made public, that I'd like to read, not articles about the letter.
 
Technically, sure. But I'm inclined to think that journalists aren't just making things up out of whole cloth. I think there's plenty of room for things to be exaggerated, or for rampant speculation. But I really doubt that journalists would completely invent a non-existent source for this.

I suspect there are actual sources involved. What I question is 1) the credibility of the information those sources are providing (are they actually high enough up to have the information or are they reporting things they got second hand) and 2) the materiality and import of the information (are they saying something is a really big deal when it real is not).

I will also add that I have a fairly large amount of concern about the sheer volume of classified and confidential information that is being shared. These sources are almost all reported as being privy to information from closed meetings, about either classified or confidential information. They are all claiming anonymity on the premise that they aren't actually allowed to share the information that they're sharing.

Does anyone else see that as troubling? I don't care what party they support, I disagree with the methods being employed here.
 
Last edited:
I don't see what the big deal is about.

Flynn takes the hit for everything and is convicted.

Trump immediately fully pardons him in perpetuity.

He survives that brouhaha just like he has all the others.


Hey, if he can do it for the turkey...
 
Last edited:

Thank you!!!!! :D

That is some difficult reading. It seems extremely likely that Flynn failed to disclose things that he should have disclosed during his security review. But there's also some really slippery wording in there.

Is RT actually owned by the Russian government? Is it a part of the government? If not, then Flynn could conceivably make a case that he did not take any payments from a foreign government, nor receive any benefit from them. He received benefit and intermediary handled payments from a foreign company. If however, RT is owned by the government in some fashion, that statement would be false.

I'm glad I'm not a lawyer trying to figure this out. But I do look forward to the results of the inquiry.
 

What do you think he means by "contacts and interactions," then?

But Brennan revealed that starting in late July, his “unresolved questions” about such “contacts and interactions” with Russian officials that led him to pass highly classified intelligence to the FBI for what would become the ongoing FBI investigation of Trump’s associates, now helmed by former director Robert Mueller.

While Brennan left open the prospect those ties “might have been benign,” they came in the context of Russia’s summer 2016 push to interfere in the presidential election, Brennan said, and so “seeing these types of contacts and interactions in the same amount of time raised my concern.”
 
Thank you!!!!! :D

That is some difficult reading. It seems extremely likely that Flynn failed to disclose things that he should have disclosed during his security review. But there's also some really slippery wording in there.

Is RT actually owned by the Russian government? Is it a part of the government? If not, then Flynn could conceivably make a case that he did not take any payments from a foreign government, nor receive any benefit from them. He received benefit and intermediary handled payments from a foreign company. If however, RT is owned by the government in some fashion, that statement would be false.

I'm glad I'm not a lawyer trying to figure this out. But I do look forward to the results of the inquiry.

C'mon. Now you are being ridiculous. Flynn knew what was required. He lied. Pure and simple. He says his trips were funded by US companies. But RT a Russian company and known propaganda company employed by the Russian government paid $45,000 for Flynn's presence and paid his travel expenses. The clearance form he filled out required that he list ANY contact he had with a foreign government. You don't think Putin qualifies?

Quit being an apologist. This is the tip of the iceberg. The Turkey stuff is worse.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom