Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
That quite depends on the nature and context of the contacts, for starters? Not enough information is not enough information, after all. An old Russian friend of a minor Trump campaign member e-mailing the member to wish them luck and them responding with a thank you could potentially be two of the contacts, with that much information. Kislyak e-mailing Pence to offer Russian resources to help and Pence thanking Kislyak for the offer, but neither accepting nor denying the offers in his responses could well count as some of the contacts as well and also not be reason for prosecution, as well. That he didn't directly refuse such and publicly denounce the Russians for even offering, in that case, though, would be easy to use as a nasty political tool against him, if revealed. Raw numbers of undisclosed contacts are certainly cause for concern, yes, but, especially in this age where world-wide communication is incredibly easy, are not necessarily cause to assume guilt.
So you missed that part about Flynn discussing sanctions with Kislyak among other things?
 
I have absolutely no idea what you are trying to say.

I'm pretty sure she wanted to take the opportunity to slyly call the US a banana republic and went with it even though she couldn't make it work as a double entendre.
 
So you missed that part about Flynn discussing sanctions with Kislyak among other things?

I don't think Aridas has missed anything and his/her opinion only differs from yours in their willingness to suspend judgement for more evidence.
 
I isolated the part that didn't make sense to me (i.e. "more information in a notably skewed fashion") and explained why it didn't. The context didn't change that. Possibly a reading comprehension error on my part or a clarity problem on your part or some combination - you are free to clarify if you'd like.

If the information wasn't being presented in a skewed fashion, how much outrage would be warranted, regardless of intentions?

I was laying out points of agreement here, not "arguing".

Two things of note. First, go back a little further and you're the one who brought up the "act of war" thing as part of your backing for your claim that there is lots of unreasonable outrage. It's quite worth noting, though, when your backing seems to be practically non-existent in reality. There is agreement that such is overblown where it's happened. There is disagreement that it is happening to any appreciable extent. Second, I was using argument in the neutral fashion, not in an adversarial fashion.

Okay? That isn't saying much.

Which is part of the point, in a somewhat different way than you likely intended that. That was just gone into above, though.

I don't think you're characterizing the claim I was responding to accurately (see above). And for the above statement of yours ("Furthermore, it's entirely reasonable..."), I've given several reasons why I disagree. Relative ability to affect change in one's own government versus another country's, a degree of responsibility for the actions of one's own government and negative consequences resulting from the action's of one's own government.

I'm not sure why you think I'm ignoring "the nature of outrage". I've also not been making claims about "how people should feel". In fact, I stated that my argument was not about what emotions people are internally feeling. I was talking about the amount of public outrage and attention / focus.

And public outrage is directly the expression of widespread emotional outrage in a population. There's no real way to separate the two.


(Bolding mine). Not regardless of whether they're outraged by the actions of our government messing with other countries as well. I haven't heard any of them (i.e. the politicians expressing outrage over this) acknowledge that we do it too, nor acknowledge all the far worse, actual militaristic interfering that we're currently carrying out in other countries, but if they did then I would grant you that it would no longer be reasonable to call it hypocritical.

Bolding mine. Are you working under the impression that politicians compose the entirety of the federal government, for the purposes of this? The overwhelming majority of the federal government isn't politicians. And, by and large, you wouldn't ever have the chance to hear the opinions of most of them in the first place. Even when it comes to most of the politicians, most of the time, they learn about things so long after the fact that there's frequently not much point in commenting until such time as the topic is directly raised to them. There is something of an exception, though, with regards to "actual militaristic interfering." Most openly known cases of "actual militaristic interfering" with recognized governments have attracted notable criticism, bearing in mind that entities like ISIS are not recognized as such. Of course, how much of the Republican side of the criticism is entirely partisan is remarkably hard to tell, given how much it seems directly linked to whether the person doing the ordering is officially a Republican or not.

You'll have to clarify what goal post moving you're referring to.

Of the multiple that could be? The most immediate one there is that "The proportion of people in the federal government elected by voters is not telling the whole story" has effectively nothing at all to do with any actual points that either of us made previously.


Sorry, I thought I'd made it clear with "I never said anything about equal responsibility across the board." You are correct, I had not said that explicitly.

Thank you for accepting that. It will be kept in mind here, as well.


I don't think I'm failing to factor it in. It was one of many, many factors that may have swayed an election.

Yes, but you still seem to be trying to ignore the actual point being made there that things that affect one's self and loved ones will fairly inevitably elicit far stronger reactions than things that happen to total strangers, generally even if what was done to the strangers was much worse.


I don't agree that I've abused or misused the concepts. As far as I can tell, this just boils down to a misunderstanding in which you thought I was arguing for equal responsibility across the board, when I was not. But if there's an objection I'm missing, feel free to clarify.

The biggest single issue that wraps around all of this is that you're trying to selectively ignore why public outrage actually happens with a false separation between the basic reason for why it happens and the widespread manifestation of such. Yes, voters certainly do bear some extent of responsibility for the actions of their government. However, that responsibility that they bear generally has effectively no impact at all on the fundamentally emotional reaction of outrage or the taking of actions based on the emotional outrage en masse that constitutes public outrage. There's just too many levels of near complete separation and too much dilution in general for there to be any meaningful impact from that particular factor, which very much makes me wonder why you keep trying to push it as if meant anything at all with regards to that? At very best for that, that factor can affect how some of that outrage is expressed, but has little to do with the cause and strength of it.
 
Last edited:
So you missed that part about Flynn discussing sanctions with Kislyak among other things?

No. Do we really need to continue with this tiresome foolishness, though? What, exactly, are you hoping for? That I'll just conclude, without proper evidence, that Trump, Pence, and so on definitely colluded with Russia to steal the election? Sorry, that's not going to happen. It does seem reasonably likely, yes, but that still doesn't mean that all the arguments presented that point in that direction are good arguments and here, like for just about everything else that I've posted on these boards, I'm notably more concerned with the logic being employed than the conclusion itself.
 
"When you have your staff taking the Fifth Amendment, taking the Fifth so they are not prosecuted, when you have the man that set up the illegal server taking the Fifth, I think it is disgraceful." —Donald Trump
 
No. Do we really need to continue with this tiresome foolishness, though? What, exactly, are you hoping for? That I'll just conclude, without proper evidence, that Trump, Pence, and so on definitely colluded with Russia to steal the election? Sorry, that's not going to happen. It does seem reasonably likely, yes, but that still doesn't mean that all the arguments presented that point in that direction are good arguments and here, like for just about everything else that I've posted on these boards, I'm notably more concerned with the logic being employed than the conclusion itself.

CE won't answer this for obvious reasons, so how 'bout you?

Are you under the impression that there are no ties between Trump, his campaign and the Russian government?
 
"When you have your staff taking the Fifth Amendment, taking the Fifth so they are not prosecuted, when you have the man that set up the illegal server taking the Fifth, I think it is disgraceful." —Donald Trump

After the hypocrisy of the head scarf, i no longer believe there is ANY topic that Trump won't show hypocrisy over.
 
After the hypocrisy of the head scarf, i no longer believe there is ANY topic that Trump won't show hypocrisy over.

It's amazing how quickly he's doing everything he attacked Clinton over. It's almost like he has a list he's checking off to ensure he gets every single instance.
 
We haven't heard what Trump thinks of Flynn's 5th yet, so calling hypocrisy is a little premature in this case. That said, Flynn is his bff (read: Trump is confident of Flynn's undying loyalty) so the odds are Trump is unlikely to decry this action.
 
2MePyWB.png
 
Yes, we know what he's said about it previously, but do we know what he's said about it now? He may still feel the same way, ergo no hypocrisy.

The fact that Flynn is taking the 5th does not make DT a hippo.
Sure, Trump is in all likelihood aware of what is going on, and in all likelihood the reason provided will be "I'm/He's doing it on the advice of lawyers" which is really the only time he'll admit say that something was not his decision.
 
Yes, we know what he's said about it previously, but do we know what he's said about it now? He may still feel the same way, ergo no hypocrisy.

The fact that Flynn is taking the 5th does not make DT a hippo.
Sure, Trump is in all likelihood aware of what is going on, and in all likelihood the reason provided will be "I'm/He's doing it on the advice of lawyers" which is really the only time he'll admit say that something was not his decision.

True, but the fact that Donald Trump himself invoked the 5th 97 times during his divorce from Ivana highlights his "flexibility" on such matters IMO.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-pleading-the-fifth_us_57ed79dee4b024a52d2de46d
 
I don't think Aridas has missed anything and his/her opinion only differs from yours in their willingness to suspend judgement for more evidence.

IOW he/she dodged the question with an alt-version of what we know about the contacts.
 
True, but the fact that Donald Trump himself invoked the 5th 97 times during his divorce from Ivana highlights his "flexibility" on such matters IMO.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-pleading-the-fifth_us_57ed79dee4b024a52d2de46d

Mr. Double Standard.

For Trump, it makes sense. At least he's not lying if he's not talking.

But I am a little bit wary of this report because it says he took the 5th Amendment during a deposition for a divorce case. Divorce is not a criminal action. So how can he invoke the 5th? Also adultery is not a crime. I was under the impression the 5th was protection only against self incrimination. ???????
 
No. Do we really need to continue with this tiresome foolishness, though? What, exactly, are you hoping for? That I'll just conclude, without proper evidence, that Trump, Pence, and so on definitely colluded with Russia to steal the election? Sorry, that's not going to happen. It does seem reasonably likely, yes, but that still doesn't mean that all the arguments presented that point in that direction are good arguments and here, like for just about everything else that I've posted on these boards, I'm notably more concerned with the logic being employed than the conclusion itself.

I asked you what would be enough. You said we'd need to know what was said in the contacts. I brought up an example of what we do know about the contacts. Now you revert back to saying we don't know what was said.

Come on, how many specious connections between Trump's inner campaign staff and Russia does it take for a person to stop using the, "we don't know" rationalization? How many denials of contacts that were later shown to have occurred does it take before one should stop chalking it up to, 'we don't know'?

My point is more than a few people in this discussion are denying there is any evidence when there is a whole boatload of evidence.

Skepticism is not to take an all or none position. There is a gradient:
We have no evidence one way or the other.
We have evidence that suggests a connection.
We have evidence that suggests no connection.
We have evidence that supports a connection. [This is where I see the evidence.]
We have evidence that supports no connection.
We have overwhelming evidence that supports the connection.
We have overwhelming evidence that supports no connection.​

The position, "We have no evidence one way or the other," is a stretch beyond credible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom