Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I suspect the 18 omitted contacts with Russians have been 9 accounts of Melania and Barron enjoying Pelmeni incognito somewhere in NYC...

Really, this stuff is so stoopit. It will backfire massively. You will relive the experience of November 2016. And you deserve it.

Maybe you're right. Maybe they were all innocent. Could they have just forgotten them? Which may be a reasonable explanation.

Flynn's contacts definitely don't seem very innocent.

But admittedly, I need more info. Consciousness of guilt alone is not very good evidence. It's another brick in the story. Is there more? Right now, it sure seems there is a lot of consciousness of guilt. Trump asking Comey to halt the investigation. His firing of Comey. His comments to Lester Holt. His comments to the Russians.

If all there was was not mentioning every single contact with the Russians I'd say maybe this was just blown out of proportion. But with all these pieces to the puzzle, it doesn't seem very innocent to me.
 
To be fair, it's actually not only those who are being focused on who have apparently falsely denied having met with Russians. It's really not only the guilty or those who have done wrong. Investigation is very certainly warranted in this case, but that's nowhere close to reason for to conclude guilt. Heck, remarkably unlikely as it is, one or more of the undisclosed contacts between the Trump campaign and the Russians could have been them calling them up to thank the Russians for their actions on Trump's behalf, but to please tone down their support a little and the denial had much more to do with a general strategy of trying to avoid more claims of illegitimacy and trying to increase plausible deniability. It would be completely in character for Pence, either way, when he's already brazen enough to publicly claim that it was the first time that he's heard of something... that he had already tweeted about before.
I think you missed the point. It wasn't could all those contacts have been innocuous, it was why deny and lie about them if they were?

In addition, a couple overlooked or forgotten encounters, sure, but dozens? No.
 
Really, this stuff is so stoopit. It will backfire massively. You will relive the experience of November 2016. And you deserve it.

At this point, it's highly unlikely that it will backfire in any meaningful way, though. Given Trump's nature, history, and the circumstances, even if there really is nothing to it, it was a pretty safe gamble, politically, from the start, and one that was immediately rewarded with numerous people affiliated with him that committed perjury specifically related to Russia. The sheer amount of lying, alone, would be plenty to justify "investigation" and supporting that "investigation" is pretty much the only responsible course of action, regardless. Doing the responsible thing is generally not cause for backlash, if you needed that clarified. It gets even safer when it's quite likely that serious investigation will turn up a bunch of other dirt to work with on top of that (and has), which fits nicely into the calls specifically for investigation into the matter. How many people remember Whitewater compared to Monica Lewinsky, for reference?

Either way, it's fairly certainly currently acting as one more factor to invigorate the more Democratic leaning base and depress the more Republican leaning base, so... your warnings are heard, but sound like little more than poorly thought through attempts to stifle things. It's certainly true, though, that the Democrats are unlikely to win without also making it clear that they will also be working to better the US in ways that are much better for its people than what the Republicans have been. That an opponent is bad doesn't mean that your candidate is any better, after all.
 
Last edited:
I think you missed the point. It wasn't could all those contacts have been innocuous, it was why deny and lie about them if they were?

In addition, a couple overlooked or forgotten encounters, sure, but dozens? No.

I'm pretty sure that I got the point, but that I also disagreed with it. There are a number of potential reasons for the denial and lying, only some of which are nefarious. The nefarious potential options are the ones to actually be concerned about and give cause for investigation, after all. Either way, as I specifically said, investigation is very much warranted to try to determine if there actually was something nefarious going on compared to whether it was just the usual mostly harmless politician lies, which generally aren't grounds for much.
 
I'm pretty sure that I got the point, but that I also disagreed with it. There are a number of potential reasons for the denial and lying, only some of which are nefarious. The nefarious potential options are the ones to actually be concerned about and give cause for investigation, after all. Either way, as I specifically said, investigation is very much warranted to try to determine if there actually was something nefarious going on compared to whether it was just the usual mostly harmless politician lies, which generally aren't grounds for much.

So the cumulative number of denied contacts doesn't concern you?:eye-poppi
 
So the cumulative number of denied contacts doesn't concern you?:eye-poppi

Of course it does. I just don't agree with presuming the worst reasons automatically, before the results of any investigation into the matter and without any real context about the nature and content of the contacts. To be clear, though, that Trump, Pence, and company are inveterate liars is fairly well established, either way, and that should very much be held against them.
 
Of course it does. I just don't agree with presuming the worst reasons automatically, before the results of any investigation into the matter and without any real context about the nature and content of the contacts. To be clear, though, that Trump, Pence, and company are inveterate liars is fairly well established, either way, and that should very much be held against them.
What's your threshold for presumption (not proof) of guilt as opposed to presumption of innocence? 18? 40? 100?
 
Last edited:
What's your threshold? 18? 40? 100?

That quite depends on the nature and context of the contacts, for starters? Not enough information is not enough information, after all. An old Russian friend of a minor Trump campaign member e-mailing the member to wish them luck and them responding with a thank you could potentially be two of the contacts, with that much information. Kislyak e-mailing Pence to offer Russian resources to help and Pence thanking Kislyak for the offer, but neither accepting nor denying the offers in his responses could well count as some of the contacts as well and also not be reason for prosecution, as well. That he didn't directly refuse such and publicly denounce the Russians for even offering, in that case, though, would be easy to use as a nasty political tool against him, if revealed. Raw numbers of undisclosed contacts are certainly cause for concern, yes, but, especially in this age where world-wide communication is incredibly easy, are not necessarily cause to assume guilt.
 
What I was responding to wasn't worth much more of a response to, though, given that you tried to isolate one part of what was said and then decided to address that out of context. Your position is worthless if it only amounts to being able to do that.

I isolated the part that didn't make sense to me (i.e. "more information in a notably skewed fashion") and explained why it didn't. The context didn't change that. Possibly a reading comprehension error on my part or a clarity problem on your part or some combination - you are free to clarify if you'd like.

Meed said:
I'm glad we agree that the information being out there isn't a bad thing, and that illegally accessing people's information is a bad thing. I'll note you also agreed with me that "this is an act of war" is too extreme, so to at least some extent we are in agreement that the outrage is overblown.
Aridas said:
For those who are saying that "this is an act of war" or similar, certainly. I've seen very few people who are making claims on par with that in the first place, though, and plenty with far more reasonable levels of concern or outrage, so it's hard for me to consider that to be anything remotely like a serious argument.

I was laying out points of agreement here, not "arguing".

Seriously, to compare my personal experiences with it, I think I've seen far more unreasonable and nasty outrage with regards to, for example, Birtherism, than I've seen regarding Russia's attempts to interfere with us.

Okay? That isn't saying much.

Aridas said:
Furthermore, it's entirely reasonable that people be more concerned about what others are trying to do to them than what others are trying to do to others who they aren't even likely to ever have contact with, which means that your claim which is directly contrary to that is rather unreasonable.
Meed said:
I disagree for reasons already stated. You could argue it's reasonable from an entirely selfish perspective, but even then the actions of our own government have real effects on what others do to us and how seriously the rest of the world is going to take it when we complain about other countries.
Aridas said:
You still don't have much of a leg to stand on, here, though. If the argument that I was making was, for some nonsensical reason, that there should be no outrage at what our government does to others, you would have a point. It was never even remotely that, though. Rather, it's more along the lines of the simple fact that it's entirely irrational to try to ignore the nature of outrage and, furthermore, human nature when making claims about how people should feel.

I don't think you're characterizing the claim I was responding to accurately (see above). And for the above statement of yours ("Furthermore, it's entirely reasonable..."), I've given several reasons why I disagree. Relative ability to affect change in one's own government versus another country's, a degree of responsibility for the actions of one's own government and negative consequences resulting from the action's of one's own government.

I'm not sure why you think I'm ignoring "the nature of outrage". I've also not been making claims about "how people should feel". In fact, I stated that my argument was not about what emotions people are internally feeling. I was talking about the amount of public outrage and attention / focus.


*sigh* Need this be traced back even further before you admit that you've been moving the goalposts quite a bit here? So! Here we go through the relevant parts!

...

So, from this and your continued insistence, you're still pretty clearly arguing that anyone in the federal government is a hypocrite if they're outraged at other countries trying to mess with us, regardless of whether they're outraged by the actions of our government messing with other countries as well and whether they are in any position to either know about or affect decisions or policy in any meaningful way.

(Bolding mine). Not regardless of whether they're outraged by the actions of our government messing with other countries as well. I haven't heard any of them (i.e. the politicians expressing outrage over this) acknowledge that we do it too, nor acknowledge all the far worse, actual militaristic interfering that we're currently carrying out in other countries, but if they did then I would grant you that it would no longer be reasonable to call it hypocritical.

You'll have to clarify what goal post moving you're referring to.

As for

Meed said:
The people carrying out the actions bear the most responsibility, as I've said.

I do need to ask... where did you say that? The closest things to that that you said in our discussion, by the look of it, are differentiating between the federal government and not the federal government, differentiating between being in the country and not being in the country, and clarifying that you didn't say that responsibility should be spread out equally, none of which equates to that.

Sorry, I thought I'd made it clear with "I never said anything about equal responsibility across the board." You are correct, I had not said that explicitly.

And you're failing to factor in the comparative effect that it has actually (potentially) had on people's lives and still trying to ignore what outrage actually is and why people feel it in the first place.

I don't think I'm failing to factor it in. It was one of many, many factors that may have swayed an election.

Meed said:
What I'm saying isn't that complicated. Voters bear some responsibility for the actions of their government, and should be concerned about how their government behaves for that reason (among others).
Aridas said:
And that was never actually being disputed.

Glad to hear it.

Rather, you've been trying to abuse and misuse the concepts and that abuse and misuse is the only thing that was being objected to in relation to them.

I don't agree that I've abused or misused the concepts. As far as I can tell, this just boils down to a misunderstanding in which you thought I was arguing for equal responsibility across the board, when I was not. But if there's an objection I'm missing, feel free to clarify.
 
Last edited:
So you've managed to convince yourself that I'm "right-wing" now? Good job. More challenging tasks will await you if you plan to continue to go along with the agenda, though.

Your frantic defense of the extreme right-wing marks you as an enemy of classic liberalism and democracy. It's your own damned fault for making your bed with the bad guys.
 
Your frantic defense of the extreme right-wing marks you as an enemy of classic liberalism and democracy. It's your own damned fault for making your bed with the bad guys.
Yes.


I have come across the phrase, "regressive left" to describe such people as George Galloway. They do tennd to be quite happy with right wing authoritarians, just not small "L" liberal values.

The magazine, "Living Marxism" became "Spiked" which is pretty right wing. The most vocal self-proclaimed racist on these boards claims to have previously been a Marxist.

It's almost as though there's personality that is repelled by nuance and thus attracted to the certainties of authoritarianism regardless as to where it is on the left-right axis.
 
Only the guilty runs..

Of course not. There's a big difference between denying something that's easy to ascertain for no explicable reason and impulsively running away from police or running away from a murder scene.

If they had played it smart they could've acknowledged that they had been in contact with Russians but explained that these contacts were perfectly innocuous and not suspicious at all.

Jeff Sessions could've publicly disclosed that he had previously been in contact with the Russian ambassador during his senate disposition and made sure that his actions didn't seem very suspicious. After all if he's totally upfront and honest about that it makes him seem like he's got nothing to hide. He didn't and it's this irrational self-sabotage is whats so suspicious. Why are they seemingly denying all contacts with Russian officials and agents?
 
Of course not. There's a big difference between denying something that's easy to ascertain for no explicable reason and impulsively running away from police or running away from a murder scene.

If they had played it smart they could've acknowledged that they had been in contact with Russians but explained that these contacts were perfectly innocuous and not suspicious at all.

Jeff Sessions could've publicly disclosed that he had previously been in contact with the Russian ambassador during his senate disposition and made sure that his actions didn't seem very suspicious. After all if he's totally upfront and honest about that it makes him seem like he's got nothing to hide. He didn't and it's this irrational self-sabotage is whats so suspicious. Why are they seemingly denying all contacts with Russian officials and agents?

Yes, it is like walking into the kitchen and seeing a child turn, in haste, towards you with their his hands behinds his back. The child then says "I didn't take any cookies." We don't "know" that the child took a cookie, and we don't have any direct evidence either. However, one can see the situation and induce that the child did, indeed, take a cookie and ask to see what's behind his back to verify if the child took the cookie or not. Right now, Trump is not letting anyone investigate what is behind his back.
 
Yes, it is like walking into the kitchen and seeing a child turn, in haste, towards you with their his hands behinds his back. The child then says "I didn't take any cookies." We don't "know" that the child took a cookie, and we don't have any direct evidence either. However, one can see the situation and induce that the child did, indeed, take a cookie and ask to see what's behind his back to verify if the child took the cookie or not. Right now, Trump is not letting anyone investigate what is behind his back.

Someone else, not I, might "refute" it thus:

Yeah because the reason you felt the need to type that load of babble isn't that the injustice that bananas aren't growing in your republic is so obvious.

What, it hasn't convinced you?

:rolleyes:

I actually have no idea what that fallacy is, except for a massive non-sequiter
 
Last edited:
Someone else, not I, might "refute" it thus:

Yeah because the reason you felt the need to type that load of babble isn't that the injustice that bananas aren't growing in your republic is so obvious.

What, it hasn't convinced you?

:rolleyes:

I actually have no idea what that fallacy is, except for a massive non-sequiter

Yea, I'm not sure what the empress is trying to imply. Maybe the empress is saying we're denying that we live in a banana republic. I think Trump is good evidence that we are living in a banana republic actually. The collusion with Russia is more evidence of it.
 
Yea, I'm not sure what the empress is trying to imply. Maybe the empress is saying we're denying that we live in a banana republic. I think Trump is good evidence that we are living in a banana republic actually. The collusion with Russia is more evidence of it.

I think that maybe it's the opposite, and the fact that Putin's candidate won the EC means that the US is not a banana republic.

Regardless of that, I don't think that Arcade is claiming that (s)he(?) lives in any type of republic.
 
Do you live in bizarro world?

A parallel world with the same history as ours, only told through an alternative narrative where everything the US does is evil, evil, evil, and everything Russia or the USSR did is never to be spoken about without first trying to divert the conversation back to how evil, evil, evil the US is.

Alternative facts isn't something made up by Kellyanne Conway. They've been in play, promoted by publications such as CounterPunch since before the beginning of the Cold War.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom