A unique proposal for The Randi

I made a serious proposal here, and my claims are valid. Please feel free to calculate the odds, because they already exceed any test that has been suggested here. I also invite you to contact the [web master] at the site referenced below, as I have no moderating rights, and even if I did everything is time stamped.

It's real easy for people without paranormal ability to whine that they don't like the method for obtaining the odds, but the math doesn't lie. It seems to me that "critical thinking" here, has become little more that jealous criticism.

So I picked the #4 and the #8 eight storm, for reasons that tie into a prior prophecy against NASA. If you'll recall, the shuttle Endeavour had to [return early] due to hurricane #4 Dean. That's a highly unusual and historical fact, and one, which conservatively increases [the odds] of my claim by a factor of about fifty, according to former Astronaut [Buzz Aldrin.] Not to mention the fact that when combined with hurricane Felix, the "plague of wind" included the first ever double CAT 5 landfall in world history, and which just happened to look exactly like a set of train tracks running across the Caribbean. Two straight parallel lines running for better than a thousand miles EACH! So the [entire basis(see reply 11)] for my picking Dean in the first place, turned into an [amazing first] in history.

Because my hurricane predictions were being ignored, I switch over to sports, with great success. Out of 33 college football bowl games, I picked only one. Not only was the winner the widely held underdog, but the winner's score happened to match the numbers 4 and 8.
Final Score 48 to 28 MOUNTAINEERS​

I am moderately impressed by your hurricane predictions. You picked 2 hurricanes that eventually made landfall 1 and 2 months before they happened, respectively. That is pretty good, but not unthinkable. The fact that you didn't make predictions about the others takes away from the value of those predictions. How hard is it to say that a hurricane is going to be deadly?

The fact that you did pick two that were deadly gives you room to make another prediction. The thing you need to do to prove your ability is to make a large number of predictions that are as specific as possible. Two predictions don't mean much, particularly when you are talking about objects that are not quantifiable in terms of odds.

On the subject of football, I am not impressed by your prediction. Every year, upsets happen at bowl games; it was not unreasonable to think West Virginia would win, the odds of randomly guessing correctly were 1:2, and besides all that, this year a cat nearly out-picked the experts.

The easiest way to unequivocally prove your power would be to do something as boring as picking large numbers of coin tosses or dice throws. Other ideas would also work, but when you are talking about things that are beyond lab scale, predictions can easily be vague and difficult to say with certainty whether or not they came true (and if you are wrong, you can look at another event and say "oh, what I really meant was that Raul Castro would have pasta for dinner").
 
How to be a Psychic.

How to be a psychic or at least play one on the Internet.
1) Make lots and lots of predictions.
2) Ignore the vast majority in which you were wrong.
3)Trumpet very loudly about the ones in which you were right.

Easy. :D
 
After the first attempt on Benazir Bhutto's life, I said to my wife, I said, "Pet," I said "Love," I said "Pet, next time she might not be so lucky." My wife answered, "Oh shush! Andrea's always making baseless accusations."

M.

 
I am moderately impressed by your hurricane predictions. You picked 2 hurricanes that eventually made landfall 1 and 2 months before they happened, respectively. That is pretty good, but not unthinkable. The fact that you didn't make predictions about the others takes away from the value of those predictions. How hard is it to say that a hurricane is going to be deadly?

I predicted the lowest pressure in the Atlantic and costliest hurricane to hit the U.S. mainland, last year.
If you're "moderately impressed," then at least get the story right.

I'll tell you what I'm NOT impressed with, and that's this crowd's ability to do simple math while skirting the question of comparative odds. I don't roll dice. I do predict natural disasters and football games. Five in a row, to be exact.

My gift is linked to demonstrating the need for repentance. So my ability is tied to this. I am willing, however, to do the odds calculation for you, which you can pretend are dice.
 
Last edited:
OK, RW here is a test that will impress me, and it does not involve dice. I will generate a 5 digit random number & PM it to chillzero, a forum moderator. all you need to do is post that number. Fair?
 
I predicted the lowest pressure in the Atlantic and costliest hurricane to hit the U.S. mainland, last year.
If you're "moderately impressed," then at least get the story right.

I'll tell you what I'm NOT impressed with, and that's this crowd's ability to do simple math while skirting the question of comparative odds. I don't roll dice. I do predict natural disasters and football games. Five in a row, to be exact.

My gift is linked to demonstrating the need for repentance. So my ability is tied to this. I am willing, however, to do the odds calculation for you, which you can pretend are dice.

And my brother routinely predicts where hurricanes will make landfall with greater accuracy than the weather bureau. It isn't that this is unimpressive, it is more a question of what your ability actually is. Are you psychic, or a good guesser? If you are psychic (in any sense of the term), then you should be able to do dumb, simple crowd pleasing tricks, and honestly, that is all we want to see at this point.

From your linked blog:
As some of you may remember, "the number four" has been on my mind a lot lately, in terms of prophetic utterances, here and on the Mars Rover Blog, so if I were a gambling man, I'd have my eye on hurricane "Dean."

Likewise, ["By four ways and in two parts,"] might also indicate that the eighth storm could be significant, so I'm also placing a mental wager on #8, "Humberto." That's about all I can say right now. I've never been great with storm names per se, but I'll wade into the water this year.

Saying "I'd have my eye on Hurricane Dean" and "I'm also placing a mental wager on #8" are both pretty vague. Now, they both made landfall and caused damage. However, there were 14 named storms last year; 6 of them were hurricanes. You picked 2 of these; The odds of picking 2 correctly are 3/14 or 21.4%. A one-in-five chance isn't great, but that is easier than picking one die throw correctly.

Also, your criteria of picking #8 was actually thrown off, because Tropical Depression Ingrid was actually named 2 days before Humberto, and it did not cause significant damage.
(See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Atlantic_hurricane_season)
 
My gift is linked to demonstrating the need for repentance. So my ability is tied to this.

Please elaborate more. You say your ability is tied to this, so to accurately test anything we need to know the following: What exactly _can_ you predict, and how does "the need for repentance" tie into it?

Also, you can count me in among those who are singularly _unimpressed_ with your postdictions; I do not care how many hurricanes, football games, or whatever you claim to have predicted accurately in the past. It is simply not relevant to the question of what you can do _right now_.

I want to know what you are willing to claim you can predict IN THE FUTURE; and once we hash that out, then we can discuss the matter of making an actual prediction. All the rest is just hand-waving and obfuscation.
 
It seems to me that "critical thinking" here, has become little more that jealous criticism

Understand that every month or two someone comes to the forum to tout their particular eccentric superpower. Each is rife with detailed explanations as to why it only works a certain way, how it might work involving every manner of new age or mythic or religious woo and each overflowing with equal parts confidence and refusal to establish a specific protocol (even informally) to show us. From numerology to psychic dice tossing, it's all preceded you.

Time and again they await our awed adulation and shock at their magic. When we make demands or point out flaws they invariably whine about how we don't understand their skill, the math involved or the hyperdimentional whatever that makes it all so incredible and paranormal.

So, I'm sorry to say that your skills, whatever they may be, are tarnished by the hoaxes and delusions of posters past. They have jaded the audience here. Further, many of us have come by whatever path to the conclusion that there are no real paranormal powers out there. This makes us immediately skeptical of new claims, mostly because they smack so clearly of old and debunked claims.

But take heart. The very path of the skeptic gives you an easy tool to simultaneously shut us all up and make us eat crow. Hoist us by our own rules, our own beliefs. All you must do, and this is key, is follow those same scientific rules to show us that you can magic up some foreknowledge of the future in a way that is both statistically significant and very, very difficult to cheat. Clearly you want us to both believe and be impressed by your nebulous talent, so here is the direct path to that end.

The other option is to go win the lottery and soothe your pride with stacks of money.
 
Sorry, It's not as impressive as you think.

If I wanted to nit-pick, according to the national weather service,

(http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/2007atlan.shtml)

Dean was the First hurricane, before that, the others were tropical storms. Strictly speaking, there were only 6 Hurricanes, so Dean wasn't the 4th and the 8th never happened.






But what the heck, in the interest of being fair, we'll throw in tropical storms, since they get named as well.




But now you have another problem.

If you predicted that the hurricane that did the most damage would hit on a specific day and time, more than a month in advance, that might be interesting.

But you said the "Fourth" hurricane would be the lowest pressure. Your odds? According to the national weather service, for the 2007 Hurricane season, there were 15 hurricanes. So your odds were 1 in 15. You did it twice, which I'm sorry doesn't rate more than a raised Eyebrow.

One other thing I have to ask, is can you think of things you've made predictions of that Didn't pan out? In the interest of full scientific disclosure, you should mention those as part of the data, as well.
 
To be honest, I am still confused as to why this guy is so obsessed with the numbers 4 and 8.
 
To be honest, I am still confused as to why this guy is so obsessed with the numbers 4 and 8.

Ditto. Also, why aren't the 4th and 8th hurricanes the worst every year? As a Floridian, I would be happy to make plans to get out of Dodge every 4th and 8th hurricane each summer. Alas, it doesn't seem to pan out. (Katrina = 11th)
 
I'll tell you what I'm NOT impressed with, and that's this crowd's ability to do simple math while skirting the question of comparative odds. I don't roll dice. I do predict natural disasters and football games. Five in a row, to be exact.

My gift is linked to demonstrating the need for repentance.

Using your powers to call the winners of football games demonstrates the need for repentance?

I think you overestimate the significance of pro-sports.
 
Ditto. Also, why aren't the 4th and 8th hurricanes the worst every year? As a Floridian, I would be happy to make plans to get out of Dodge every 4th and 8th hurricane each summer. Alas, it doesn't seem to pan out. (Katrina = 11th)

Yeah, no kidding... were you around for the 2004 season? Holy crap, we got nailed hard, and often! And, I guess if Katrina was 11th, Charley, Frances, Ivan, and Jeanne were 10th, right?
 
I predicted the lowest pressure in the Atlantic and costliest hurricane to hit the U.S. mainland, last year.
If you're "moderately impressed," then at least get the story right.

No you didn't. You said that you see something about the Hurricane #4 and something about #8. It turned out that 4 (or 5th, depending how you count) was the lowest pressure and 8 was the costliest. You would have been happy to claim victory if 4 (or 5) or 8 had turned out to have the highest wind speeds, longest path, greatest loss of life, or highest energy, or the first landfall, most eyewall replacement cycles, or whatever. (Of course these things are correlated, but not exactly---Felix, Noel, and Karen had higher ACE than Humberto, for example) You would have been happy if it turned out that the 4th or 8th named *hurricane*, ignoring tropical storms, had any interesting properties. You would have been happy if the 4th or 8th *landfall* had topped some list. In other words, you made a vague prediction, then data-mined until you found an excuse for calling it successful.
 
...
In other words, you made a vague prediction, then data-mined until you found an excuse for calling it successful.

Bingo.



RW, you could always make a new prediction, couldn't you? One a bit more precise? Or one which provides a large data sample size, e.g. predicting an entire week of football results? Or any large gameday in any sport: Just tell us in advance what you will do.

You could of course simply bet on said games and show us the sizable check while you laugh all the way to the bank.
 
And my brother routinely predicts where hurricanes will make landfall with greater accuracy than the weather bureau. It isn't that this is unimpressive, it is more a question of what your ability actually is. Are you psychic, or a good guesser? If you are psychic (in any sense of the term), then you should be able to do dumb, simple crowd pleasing tricks, and honestly, that is all we want to see at this point.

From your linked blog:


Saying "I'd have my eye on Hurricane Dean" and "I'm also placing a mental wager on #8" are both pretty vague. Now, they both made landfall and caused damage. However, there were 14 named storms last year; 6 of them were hurricanes. You picked 2 of these; The odds of picking 2 correctly are 3/14 or 21.4%. A one-in-five chance isn't great, but that is easier than picking one die throw correctly.

Also, your criteria of picking #8 was actually thrown off, because Tropical Depression Ingrid was actually named 2 days before Humberto, and it did not cause significant damage.
(See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Atlantic_hurricane_season)

Your arguments are noted, but I started ["the contest"] by giving [my two picks.] I don't think you can just dismiss this. I asked for two hurricanes with two characteristics, and I gave two. "Vague" or not, I nailed it, and you can dismiss the wording I used, but the rules were clearly stated in the post immediately prior. Speaking of words, you seem to over look that Ingrid never became a "hurricane." The contest clearly stated, "Make your hurricane predictions here." This actually increases the odds of the predictions I made, because not only did I specify the characteristics of two storms, but I assumed correctly that the storms would grow to become hurricanes, in order to qualify. You've just added another multiplier to my calculations.
Thank You. :)

Like hurricane Dean, hurricane Humberto was very unique, in that it went on to break an unusual historic record.

["Hurricane Humberto set a record for being the quickest storm to change from tropical depression to Hurricane and make landfall. That all happened in just over 12 hours from the time it formed." Link] - 09.14.07 NASA

In other words, this was more than just a good call, like hurricane Dean, my second pick also made unique history.

I realize that there is limited understanding here, generally, for what I can and will do in the future. You can dismiss the method for obtaining the odds, but like Noah building the Ark, my job is to warn. I can only hope that I'm not throwing my pearls before swine, here.
 
Last edited:
Just been looking into your predictions Raptor and I am far from impressed. You will have to make some more predictions for me to take you seriously. As we asked you to do that more than 2 weeks ago and you have ignored those requests then I can only assume that you do not have any special abilities.


Please do not feed the trolls.
 
Most hurricane seasons have upwards of 10 named storms. Last year, there were 17. Within the first 10 named storms, 3 were hurricanes. In 2006, there were 5 hurricanes of 10 storms. In 2005, 4 of the first 10 were hurricanes. For making a guess about hurricanes, it is reasonable to pick one of the first 10, because there is lower probability that there will be more than 10. In the last three years, 40% of the first 10 storms of the hurricane season have been hurricanes. Guessing two hurricanes out of 10 options (assuming there are 4 hurricanes in 10) has a probability of 13.3%.

As I say, I am somewhat impressed by your predictions. However, the fact that you are giving us predictions about 2 hurricanes and 1 football game gives us little to go on. Are these the only predictions you have ever made? If not, then what were the results of other predictions? What is your accuracy level?

The point is, if I play the odds long enough, eventually, I am going to win. Once I win, I can talk very loudly about my successful prediction, and it will appear that I am a great forecaster. The truth, however, is that I make a lot of predictions.

For example, your prediction that there would be a massive attack by al Qaeda on 9/11 last year doesn't seem to have worked out too well. Personally, I'm glad.
 
Please elaborate more. You say your ability is tied to this, so to accurately test anything we need to know the following: What exactly _can_ you predict, and how does "the need for repentance" tie into it?

Also, you can count me in among those who are singularly _unimpressed_ with your postdictions; I do not care how many hurricanes, football games, or whatever you claim to have predicted accurately in the past. It is simply not relevant to the question of what you can do _right now_.

I want to know what you are willing to claim you can predict IN THE FUTURE; and once we hash that out, then we can discuss the matter of making an actual prediction. All the rest is just hand-waving and obfuscation.


My ability isn't tied to the need for money, or the need to impress for personal gain. I plan to start a thread, where I'll post specific predictions. However, cryptic predictions are given more often, not to be vague, but to prevent the course of history from being altered by men.


Understand that every month or two someone comes to the forum to tout their particular eccentric superpower. Each is rife with detailed explanations as to why it only works a certain way, how it might work involving every manner of new age or mythic or religious woo and each overflowing with equal parts confidence and refusal to establish a specific protocol (even informally) to show us. From numerology to psychic dice tossing, it's all preceded you.

Time and again they await our awed adulation and shock at their magic. When we make demands or point out flaws they invariably whine about how we don't understand their skill, the math involved or the hyperdimentional whatever that makes it all so incredible and paranormal.

So, I'm sorry to say that your skills, whatever they may be, are tarnished by the hoaxes and delusions of posters past. They have jaded the audience here. Further, many of us have come by whatever path to the conclusion that there are no real paranormal powers out there. This makes us immediately skeptical of new claims, mostly because they smack so clearly of old and debunked claims.

But take heart. The very path of the skeptic gives you an easy tool to simultaneously shut us all up and make us eat crow. Hoist us by our own rules, our own beliefs. All you must do, and this is key, is follow those same scientific rules to show us that you can magic up some foreknowledge of the future in a way that is both statistically significant and very, very difficult to cheat. Clearly you want us to both believe and be impressed by your nebulous talent, so here is the direct path to that end.

The other option is to go win the lottery and soothe your pride with stacks of money.


What more can I say, than ... Hear! Hear!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom