A unique proposal for The Randi

In [post #5,] I demonstrated that I could pick two hurricanes, and correctly select the lowest pressure in a region and greatest damage in a geographical area. That's a lot better than Dr. Gray of Colorado State University, who makes the news every time he spits out his broad assertions. Then, after carefully explaining why I picked the numbers 4 and 8 to begin with, and afterwards complaining that no one was paying me any attention, I switched to sports, specifically football. Out of 33 bowl games, I just happened to select the winner and winning score of the Fiesta Bowl, which turned out to be 48.

You know what I think? I think that anything less than the plagues of Egypt, would fall of deaf ears here. Then after the death of the first born, you would still ride out into the desert and drown.

I'm not here to juggle for you, or pull rabbits out of hats. I'm here to win. Not for the money, but because I can.
We have no interest in your unverified claims about what you did, because anyone can claim the same thing-for example, yesterday I predicted that you would say exactly what you said in your last post. My evidence is the prediction you see before you and the words of your last post. See how useless that was? The question is, can you make a prediction that has yet to come true? Are you willing to fill out the application?
 
I'm not here to juggle for you, or pull rabbits out of hats. I'm here to win. Not for the money, but because I [can.]

Nobody wants you to juggle. Just predict something that will happen, say, next Monday (Oh, pick your own date next week) that cannot be known in advance. It's pretty simple really. Cut to the chase, and actually, you know, instead of talking about it, actually do it. Post-dictions do not count. If you are unwilling to do this, you are nothing but pointless hot air, and I suspect just full of it.

Norm
 
Tell you what, here's an easy one: Predict what the bonus ball will be on the UK National Lottery this Saturday (16th Feb 2008). The numbers run from 1-49, so a 1 in 49 chance is good enough to get us at least to start taking you seriously. The bonus ball means nothing to sway the odds, so it's not like us asking for the winning numbers.

Go ahead, pick a number BEFORE 7pm on Saturday and post it here, and do not edit your post. I'm guessing you want to go for 48?
 
However, if you study the odds of everything I accurately predicted last year, it's the equivalent of seeing a pair of die, stand on their corners.

I can make 14 million predictions for the next UK Lottery draw. And if you study the odds of everything I accurately predicted... :cool:
 
Prophesies are BAD CHOICES for the MDC unless you're incredibly specific. A short line of verse with a vague statement in it won't cut it. It has to be something like "At 11:20 am Eastern Standard Time, there will be an earthquake in Boston, MA that registers 6.7 on the Richter scale."

As a geologist, I can say with confidence that there will not be an earthquake in Boston within the next week, on any day, that registers anywhere near 6.7.

However, I can make this prediction: In the next 100 million years, there will be a major earthquake in what we now call Boston. And when it happens, I want my million!
 
I'm not here to juggle for you, or pull rabbits out of hats. I'm here to win. Not for the money, but because I can.

I'm not asking you to juggle or pull rabbits out of hats. I'm simply explaining to you what it will take to do a proper demonstration. You cannot claim the MDC based on past predictions. As others have pointed out, you will have to predict a future event, and the prediction will have to be precise enough to preclude the need for judgement, and should be something that can't reasonably be guessed using available information.

I don't speak for JREF, but I know that they encourage people to test out their abilities before applying. If you are willing to do that here, what's your prediction?

I think that predicting the outcome of a lottery draw would be a very good demonstration, for what it's worth, and I highly recommend it.

Here's another option. Do your stuff to determine the outcome of 10 rolls of two 10-sided dice (that is, 10 rolls of a number between 00 and 99). Create a hash of this and send it to a trusted third person, say a member of this Forum. I will then do my ten dice rolls and post the hash of my results. The third person and you will post your hash and we'll see if they match each other and mine (meaning you got all 10 right). If they don't, we'll post the original data and compare and see how many, if any, you matched from the list.

What kind of accuracy would you claim for this kind of a test, if you're willing to do it? How many out of 10? (Also, I'd stipulate that you'd have to get each number completely right in order for it to count. For example, if I roll "48" you'd have to provide "48" in your list of predictions, not "84"). Would you agree to this? It sure would go a long way towards demonstrating to the skeptics here that you've got something going on, and I'd be very happy to help.
 
The criteria for passing just the preliminary test is to perform a feat that would not happen by coincident 1 time in 10,000.

10,000 / 365 = 27.4 years.

Not to be morbid, but I think it's a safe guess that Mr. Randi will pass away within the next 27.4 years.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Witness, if you have a paranormal ability, then demonstrate it. That is all that is required. We neither want nor need all the philosophical/religious nonsense you seem particularly keen to share with us.

Just show us, simply, what you can do.

Thanks.

M.

Actually I think he already is
 
I have a counter-proposal for the MDC.
I have the paranormal ability to thwart Raptor Witness's ability to predict Mr. Randi's date of death. I am prepared to do this any number of times, with 100% accuracy. If I win the MDC, I will donate my winnings to JREF, minus $23 for a bottle of Tullamore Dew.
Thus showing your good taste!!:)
 
Last edited:
If there is no actual claim to be made, and he doesn't show interest in applying for the MDC, shouldn't this thread be moved to a more appropriate forum?
 
[Edited]
I note you didn't attempt to guess the simple bonus ball challenge. The actual ball drawn was 22: http://www.national-lottery.co.uk/player/p/results/results.do

I'm guessing all your stupid pictures you posted today predicted this?

Please attack the argument. I took out the personal insult.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is it an insult to suggest that this person appears to have a mental illness?

Because I don't intend it that way, I do believe that there is a short circuit in his brain that makes him think he successfully prophesized these events and I do not believe he is a fraud out for financial gain. I think it is a medical problem that is no fault of his own.
 
Thread moved from the Million Dollar Challenge since there is no serious proposal being put forward for a potential MDC application.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
I would like to propose a method for determining my ability to foresee events, in the following way:

If I can predict the exact day, Eastern time, that Jeff Randi will die, I get a million dollars awarded to my favorite charity.

This is not meant to be threatening in any manner, but it's probably the easiest way that I can demonstrate what I can do, and satisfy his followers.

Since I would not like to know the exact day that I'm going to die, I would also recommend that the date be kept private, and held in some agreed upon, third party's hand. The death would also have to be either purely accidental or natural in cause.

My abilities are not "publicly" known yet, because if you can really do "publicly" what Mr. Randi is proposing, they threaten to kill you, and "they" don't like to be named. :boxedin:

This is a serious proposal.

I find your proposal to be both morbit and offensive. I personally hope that Mr. Randi will be with us for some time more. Yes, I know he is an older man and I know nothing of his health other than his heart issues a couple years ago. A person with a bypass who recovers has a very good prognosis and there's no reason to think Mr. Randi won't be with us for another ten years or more. Those who make it to age 80 in the US and in otherwise good health have a good probability of living to 90, 95 or better.

This "they" bull is just that. It's bull.

The only way you could know when someone would die would be to kill them yourself, as mentioned.


That having been said, if you *could* foresee Mr. Randi's death or predict when it would happen then I would say it is morally and ethically incumbent on you to tell him when and the manner of death so that it could therefore be avoided.

Nearly all causes of death could be averted or reduced with enough knowledge before hand. If you could predict Randi's death in a car accident or some other event, then telling him would be easily able to stop that. If you foresee Randi's death by cancer then predicting it would mean he could have the tumor zapped when it's still tiny and has not spread. If you predict a heart attack then he could be be prepared for it with medics, a defibrillator and cardiac drugs ready. If he is to die of a stroke, then he could have a stent put in the artery that would cause it or have other preventative actions taken.


Therefore, it is entirely incombant on any who could predict such a thing to warn the person of it such that it could be avoided. Very few causes of death cannot be avoided, or at the least, have their chances reduced if there is information sufficiently ahead of time.


How about this:

if you can predict when people will die so well, just give us a few celebrities who will die this year and give the exact date and time?
 
I find your proposal to be both morbit and offensive.

<snip>

if you can predict when people will die so well, just give us a few celebrities who will die this year and give the exact date and time?

How is that any less morbid or offensive?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom