A unique proposal for The Randi

The largest earthquake to hit the UK in 20 years happened last night. That would have been very clear and easy for you to predict, clearly, in advance.

Why didn't you?
 
Please elaborate more. You say your ability is tied to this, so to accurately test anything we need to know the following: What exactly _can_ you predict, and how does "the need for repentance" tie into it?

Also, you can count me in among those who are singularly _unimpressed_ with your postdictions; I do not care how many hurricanes, football games, or whatever you claim to have predicted accurately in the past. It is simply not relevant to the question of what you can do _right now_.

I want to know what you are willing to claim you can predict IN THE FUTURE; and once we hash that out, then we can discuss the matter of making an actual prediction. All the rest is just hand-waving and obfuscation.

My ability isn't tied to the need for money, or the need to impress for personal gain.

This is just more hand-waving and obfuscation. I'm not interested in what you can't do; I'm interested in what you can.

Again, what _can_ you predict, and how does the "need for repentance" tie into it?

Raptor Witness said:
I plan to start a thread, where I'll post specific predictions.

Then I suggest you do exactly that, and spend less time explaining the past; it's not something I care about.

However, cryptic predictions are given more often, not to be vague, but to prevent the course of history from being altered by men.

I am not interested in any "cryptic" predictions that you can interpret after the fact; I am no gullible open-mouthed child to believe such things. I am only interested in specific predictions about the _future_ that are not open to interpretation. Can you produce any of those?

I am also not interested in excuses about "preventing the course of history from being altered." If this is such a concern to you, select things that cannot be conveniently altered by men without being incredibly obvious.
 
Sorry, It's not as impressive as you think.

If I wanted to nit-pick, according to the national weather service,

(http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/2007atlan.shtml)

Dean was the First hurricane, before that, the others were tropical storms. Strictly speaking, there were only 6 Hurricanes, so Dean wasn't the 4th and the 8th never happened.

But what the heck, in the interest of being fair, we'll throw in tropical storms, since they get named as well.

But now you have another problem.

If you predicted that the hurricane that did the most damage would hit on a specific day and time, more than a month in advance, that might be interesting.

But you said the "Fourth" hurricane would be the lowest pressure. Your odds? According to the national weather service, for the 2007 Hurricane season, there were 15 hurricanes. So your odds were 1 in 15. You did it twice, which I'm sorry doesn't rate more than a raised Eyebrow.

One other thing I have to ask, is can you think of things you've made predictions of that Didn't pan out? In the interest of full scientific disclosure, you should mention those as part of the data, as well.


First, thank you for the thoughtful reply. Using your reasoning, the odds increase if the named storm actually becomes a hurricane, because the contest specifies this. The reason is simple, there's no way for the contestant to know that his pick will achieve this status. This is actually a numeric factor that I had not taken into account.

When I have a little more time, I'll present my mathematical model, which needs some adjustment, and I sincerely appreciate the forum members here for helping me with this. While I don't agree with everyone,
I admire some of the minds I'm finding.

As to the past failures I may of had. This contest was the first time I specifically tried naming a hurricane, or any event of nature. I have had some luck with cryptic methods, which I may also present, but this is honestly the first time in my life that I proposed doing something like this. I have occasionally looked at a set of data and forecast storms in amateur fashion, but never blindly like this. So I couldn't compare the two, given the difference in motive and method.

I still don't hear anyone speculating as to the unusual correlation between the two hurricanes, and the [Fiesta Bowl] prediction. The number 48 repeating like that, is a little strange, and even my most skeptical friends were amazed by this, or perhaps they made money on the ball game, I'm unsure. :o I haven't even tried to calculate this multiplier, but it must be factored into the overall odds, given that the motive for this game pick, and score, was an extension of the hurricane contest. I also don't think that the historic route of NASA from the International Space Station by hurricane Dean can be left out, because my arguments with NASA were the basis for these hurricane picks in the first place.

The odds of what I have done, go way beyond a simple hurricane contest, because the motive for picking these storms, were clearly stated, and these motives made unique history, also.

The question of, can I repeat this, is a reasonable one. However, what I have done in the public forum already is much more interesting that what some of the members here have proposed, because what I have done tells a story on top of revealing the odds.

I understand that some may have come here proposing this or that, but I have yet to read about anyone who's ability is tied to unique historical facts. This, in turn, makes the message I have to present, unique.
 
Last edited:
This is just more hand-waving and obfuscation. I'm not interested in what you can't do; I'm interested in what you can.

Again, what _can_ you predict, and how does the "need for repentance" tie into it?

I am not interested in any "cryptic" predictions that you can interpret after the fact; I am no gullible open-mouthed child to believe such things. I am only interested in specific predictions about the _future_ that are not open to interpretation. Can you produce any of those?

I am also not interested in excuses about "preventing the course of history from being altered." If this is such a concern to you, select things that cannot be conveniently altered by men without being incredibly obvious.

Raptor, you seem to have ignored my above post completely. Can you respond to it, please?

When I have a little more time, I'll present my mathematical model, which needs some adjustment,

I do not care about your mathematical model. Just predict something in the future. There will be plenty of time to discuss "how" it all is done (ad infinitum, ad nauseam) after it is shown that it _can_ be done in the first place.

So. Show us. Predict something in the _future_.

Raptor Witness said:
I still don't hear anyone speculating as to the unusual correlation between the two hurricanes,

That is because unusual correlations show up all the time, and indeed, are... nothing unusual.

Raptor Witness said:
The question of, can I repeat this, is a reasonable one.

And it's one you seem unwilling to answer.

Raptor Witness said:
However, what I have done in the public forum already is much more interesting

What you've done is completely uninteresting to me because it deals with past events. I can predict past events with near-100% accuracy, so I find it neither unusual or interesting, and indeed not even in need of explanation at all.

Raptor Witness said:
...but I have yet to read about anyone who's ability is tied to unique historical facts. This, in turn, makes the message I have to present, unique.

So now we know that your 'ability' is tied to both repentance and unique historical facts. Great. For the nth time, what do you claim to be able to predict?
 
Raptor, you seem to have ignored my above post completely. Can you respond to it, please?

I do not care about your mathematical model. Just predict something in the future. There will be plenty of time to discuss "how" it all is done (ad infinitum, ad nauseam) after it is shown that it _can_ be done in the first place.
Natural disasters are what I am best able to predict. I think I explained this. The football games were a side line or tool, used to point back to the hurricane predictions earlier, and quite successfully, given the winning score of the only college bowl game I selected.

It's important to present my mathematical model for the successes I had last year, whether you like it or not, because it will help establish how the odds can be compared, to say, a series of dice rolls. Also, I'd like to evaluate the critical thinking here, as much as you may want to evaluate me. If the members here don't understand statistics, then I'll be wasting my time.

If the concept of repentance escapes you, I gave you an [example.]

I will begin a thread for the specific predictions, as soon as I have one. I made six specific predictions last year, but I expect more this year. Of those six, I got six correct. This isn't how I earn a living, so you'll forgive me if I'm not as rapid fire as you are. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Natural disasters are what I am best able to predict. I think I explained this. The football games were a side line or tool, used to point back to the hurricane predictions earlier, and quite successfully, given the winning score of the only college bowl game I selected.

It's important to present my mathematical model for the successes I had last year, whether you like it or not, because it will help establish how the odds can be compared, to say, a series of dice rolls. Also, I'd like to evaluate the critical thinking here, as much as you may want to evaluate me. If the members here don't understand statistics, then I'll be wasting my time.

If the concept of repentance escapes you, I gave you an [example.]

I will begin a thread for the specific predictions, as soon as I have one. I made six specific predictions last year, but I expect more this year. Of those six, I got six correct. This isn't how I earn a living, so you'll forgive me if I'm not as rapid fire as you are. :rolleyes:

Bolding mine. But not earthquakes? As pointed out above, you seem to have missed that one.
 
Can you predict every natural disaster or only some of them? There are many earthquakes a day. Pick one of these earthquakes and tell me what would be the location, strength the date and time it will happen.

If you can get the strength, location date and time right then that would be impressive. Also say how accurate your figures will be.

So far you have not made any predictions in this thread. That is not good.
 
Natural disasters are what I am best able to predict. I think I explained this.

You may have, but it makes it so much simpler for everyone concerned when it's stated concisely. Thank you.

Raptor Witness said:
It's important to present my mathematical model for the successes I had last year,

No, it's really not, see. Those are all in the past, and as such are irrelevant to what you can do in the future, except from the perspective of giving yourself confidence that you can.

I mean, let's put it simply; if you make a specific prediction of a natural disaster (as rjh01 said, location, date, time, and intensity are good specifics), that's going to stand up all on its own, and there won't be any need for a mathematical model. In fact, the mathematical model just gets in the way of what we're really interested in here: You say X will happen, and then X happens.

Raptor Witness said:
Also, I'd like to evaluate the critical thinking here, as much as you may want to evaluate me. If the members here don't understand statistics, then I'll be wasting my time.

I don't understand why you'd be wasting your time. After all, if you predict X will happen and X happens, there's no need for statistics to evaluate that -- it's very straightforward.

Regardless, I can assure you that you will find more than enough critical thinking and capacity for statistical analysis here to satisfy any future desire.

Raptor Witness said:
If the concept of repentance escapes you, I gave you an [example.]

From the linked post:

Raptor Witness said:
In [post #5,] I demonstrated that I could pick two hurricanes, and correctly select the lowest pressure in a region and greatest damage in a geographical area. That's a lot better than Dr. Gray of Colorado State University, who makes the news every time he spits out his broad assertions. Then, after carefully explaining why I picked the numbers 4 and 8 to begin with, and afterwards complaining that no one was paying me any attention, I switched to sports, specifically football. Out of 33 bowl games, I just happened to select the winner and winning score of the Fiesta Bowl, which turned out to be 48.

You know what I think? I think that anything less than the plagues of Egypt, would fall of deaf ears here. Then after the death of the first born, you would still ride out into the desert and drown.

I'm not here to juggle for you, or pull rabbits out of hats. I'm here to win. Not for the money, but because I [can.]

I don't see anything about repentance here. Perhaps you could be more specific -- how exactly does "The need for repentance" tie into your claimed ability to predict natural disasters?

Raptor Witness said:
I will begin a thread for the specific predictions, as soon as I have one.

Excellent. I look forward to your first.
 
Why didn't you predict the unusual, virtually unprecedented earthquake that struck the UK last week?
 
My ability isn't tied to the need for money, or the need to impress for personal gain. I plan to start a thread, where I'll post specific predictions. However, cryptic predictions are given more often, not to be vague, but to prevent the course of history from being altered by men.

I realize that there is limited understanding here, generally, for what I can and will do in the future. You can dismiss the method for obtaining the odds, but like Noah building the Ark, my job is to warn. I can only hope that I'm not throwing my pearls before swine, here.
[my bolding added]

So, your job is to warn us, but just vaguely enough so that we can't do anything to stop whatever it might be from happening anyway?

Maybe I'm a little dense, but that doesn't seem to be a particularly useful ability, even if you could successfully demonstrate it (which I haven't seen here).

Seriously, how is this supposed ability better than not having predicted anything at all?
 
To be honest, I am still confused as to why this guy is so obsessed with the numbers 4 and 8.

Here's why:

If you take 4 and multiply it by 8 or ATE...
which is also HATE which also translates
into MATE, the divide by CRAY then
multiply by ZEE with is also 8:

4x2=8

Do you see?

Suddenly I'm hungry for a corn dog...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom