A taste of our own medicine...perhaps??

This is one example of what could be called a convention- "debunkers" meet, in a debunker administrered environment, to discuss debunking.


So are the people posting in the Humour subforum part of some sort of humour movement?


Granted, it is open, and there are a few from the other side of the fence, but it is still, overwhelmingly, a one sided convention of people favouring a certain goal. There are many of these on the net.


It's only one sided because twoofers either run away when confronted with evidence, or they break the membership agreement.
 
I have been noticing as of late, perhaps the last 6-8 months, that the truthers have begun to label certain aspects of the "other side".

examples:

1. The "official" account is now referred to as the "Official Conspiracy Theory"
2. Debunkers here are now referred to as part of the "Debunking Movement"

My first thoughts on this was "so what", but now I am seeing it for what it is, which is an attempt to try and depreciate the effort many of us make here. The official account is referred to as a CT because they know how much contempt we have for CT's as a whole. Our mocking of the "truth movement" has resulted in them labeling what we do as the "Debunking Movement".

As to the motive behind this, the obvious one is anger at us for what we do. We are the thorn in their side, and they know it. It is the reason why the term "JREFer" has become a curse word on truth sites.

But then there is, what I think, a more subtle reason. I think the truthers are trying to trivialize our efforts, so they can rationalize us away, like they do with so many other things. It is much harder for them to accept that their most ardent and adamant opponents on the 9/11 issue are a bunch of educated, ordinary people with NO REWARD, and honesty and truth as their only motives. Much easier, is to try and label us as a group of extremists, who will tolerate only one version of the truth, apologists for the Neocons, etc....

And then, my final thoughts, are concerning how we in fact, treat them the same way. Do we do so for the same reasons? When we call them "truthers" or "Twoofers" or "Denialists", when we call them Kooks, are we doing so to trivialize them? If we do, why do we trivialize them and their cause...is it because it is stupid and trivial? Is it because it is easier to trivialize it than confront it? I dunno?

They are, in fact, doing to us, exactly what a lot of us have done to them. Do we deserve it? I dunno.

What do you think??

TAM:)


TAM,
You prove to be a good poster and a valuable asset to the forum because you are willing to question your own methods of argumentation, logic, etc. This is far too rare.

I think you already know that labeling in general is a subtle way of marginalizing your opponent. It's poor strategy and belies a defensive position.

Psychologically, seeing your opponent, adversary, enemy, etc in a particularly negative light, is projecting the subconscious fear of facing this perspective.

It's particularly odious when the claim is pulled out that Gravy or anyone else is entitled or forgiven from ad hominem attacks because the argument has been addressed so often. This is neither logical nor accurate since ad hominem attacks are presented even for recent developments.

I'm sure I'm not telling you something you don't already know, but your OP is very impressive for its honesty and I can only hope that my perspective is considered as sincere. Mine are only observations, but honest ones.
 
Is there a reason why Troothers like to sound smarter than their education level and use bigger words than they usually use in their offline lives?
 
Good. So you adopt the position that anyone who has said anything that disagrees with you suffers from some sort of cognitive failure. I seem to remember Gravy saying in his recent HF shambles that some of the people who talked about explosions in the TT's may well have been suffering from post traumatic stress disorder, which is why they woudl have said that. It's amazing.

Cognitive failure? Where did I say that? Are you saying that being on the ground in NY on 9/11 wasn't a traumatic experience? Are you saying that people don't ever panic in stressful situations? Are you saying that people in stressful situations never misspeak?

I will repeat what I have said before- the OT movement, and the misguided parts of the CT movement, have so many similarities, it is astonishing. It is too bad that the feeble minded have so much of a sway in matters of such importance.

You actually think that what people type here has a lot of sway in world politics? You think we are deluded?
 
So are the people posting in the Humour subforum part of some sort of humour movement?





It's only one sided because twoofers either run away when confronted with evidence, or they break the membership agreement.
1. You should stop asking different variants of the same question. The definition of it is there. Try and understand it please- the answer doesnt change.

2. We are seeing who runs away right here, right now, and it is pretty clear who the guilty party is. Very clear.

3. The mods here are ideologically biased, and the moderation system is structurally biased (I have posted on this on the forum management board)
 
You know... by mjd1982's application of the definition of the word movement, every single person on this planet is part of one or more unofficial "movements"...

This is just the latest step in a dance they've been doing for quite some time now. It started with them trying to claim that they are the "true skeptics", and now they're trying to label us as the "CTs" or "woos".

It's just exactly like the Creationists tying to assert that evolution is a religion and ID is science, or believers trying to assert that atheism is a belief system. They know that being skeptical and scientific is considered to be a good thing, so they try to co-opt it for themselves, while also trying to label us as irrational. Despite the rising tide of irrationality in our society, science still has the power to persuade people, and the credulists hate that.

So take heart, this just means the CTists are as desperate as the creationists!


Seems quite probable. I've heard the same thing said about the Republicans, too (apparently, modern Republicans are far more like Democrats than they were of old): that one of the successful tactics in defeating your political enemy is to co-opt their messages and goals and use them as your own.

That way, you can merely focus on making yourself more popular than your opponent, rather than convincing the public your ideas and goals are worth supporting.

This rather sudden and relatively vocal claim that the truthers are doing this "for the victims and their families" seems to fit into that, too, I think.
 
Last edited:
You know... by mjd1982's application of "movement", every single person on this planet is part of one or more unofficial movements...




Seems quite probable. I've heard the same thing said about the Republicans, too (apparently, modern Republicans are far more like Democrats than they were of old): that one of the successful tactics in defeating your political enemy is to co-opt their messages and goals and use them as your own.

That way, you can merely focus on making yourself more popular than your opponent, rather than convincing the public your ideas and goals are worth supporting.

This rather sudden and relatively vocal claim that the truthers are doing this "for the victims and their families" seems to fit into that, too, I think.
Its not my application of the term- its the dictionary's. I'll leave you 2 to argue.
 
1. You should stop asking different variants of the same question. The definition of it is there. Try and understand it please- the answer doesnt change.


So you are saying that anyone posts on an internet subforum is part of a movement based around the subject of said subforum? Just so we're clear.


2. We are seeing who runs away right here, right now, and it is pretty clear who the guilty party is. Very clear.


Given that you are one of but a few twoofers consistantly active in this forum I would have to agree.


3. The mods here are ideologically biased, and the moderation system is structurally biased (I have posted on this on the forum management board


Very well. Unlike you I have no intention of derailing this thread.
 
So you are saying that anyone posts on an internet subforum is part of a movement based around the subject of said subforum? Just so we're clear.





Given that you are one of but a few twoofers consistantly active in this forum I would have to agree.





Very well. Unlike you I have no intention of derailing this thread.
1. No, I am saying to apply the dictionary definition to a term, if you want to define that term. Whether you can do this accurately is possibly unlikely, but there is nothign I can do there.

2. The thread is entitled "A taste of our own medicine". I am duly obliging.
 
What dictionary are you using? Mine says "body of persons for special object". I'm not even sure what that's supposed to mean.
 
Encarta said:
effort by many to achieve something

a collective effort by a large number of people to try to achieve something, especially a political or social reform

  • the civil rights movement

people organised to effect change

the people who organize themselves in order to achieve some political or social reform


It’s reasonably subjective, I suppose.
 
Well said sir, and you have hit the nail on the head wrt why I posted this topic. Self reflection is always good. As well, however, I posted this as a place to analyze this "rhetoric" element of the "duel" if you would call it.

TAM:)

Well, shoot, this is definitely a worthy topic, but unfortunately we have a temporary derailment into the difference between the denotative meeting of a definition and the practical, in-spirit achievement of such. But regardless of whether we're a movement in that we meet the "diffuse organization" criteria and favor some sort of common goal, or that we mirror (or fail to mirror) others in true organization, common actions, and fervor - a difference that ultimately does not matter as anything other than a rhetorical point - what truly matters is that we adhere to skeptical principles and logic and rational thought. That matters more than any label others choose to stick on us, whether deserved or not.

Anyway, trivialization. Again, this is something to think about. I started by thinking of all the times I've ridiculed truthers or the arguments, and that those incidents are not really events to be proud of, but I honestly don't know if I can call that "trivialization". It's a different sort of fault that I and others commit by resorting to ridicule, but I'm not sure I can apply the word "trivialize" to it. "Disdain", yes; there are plenty of examples here of sardonic posts. "Mock", yes, that's an honest characterization of some of my arguments, and of many others. But I just can't think of any times right now where I've reduced or treated as unimportant any of this subject, or any of the conspiracy fantasists arguments. I think the closest anyone's come - not me, I tend to avoid discussion of this topic - is the ridicule by some of Dylan Avery's lack of career opportunities outside of Loose Change. That, to me, is an unfair commentary, given the difficulty of entering the filmmaking profession in general, and given that it really only does take one successful work to be considered a member of that profession, but I've seen the insult made. There's plenty of criticism to be made of Loose Change as a work, and I don't think there's any need for insult-by-reduction of the filmmakers' professional statures.

I'm starting to ramble... TAM, are there any incidents or posts that lead you to thinking about this topic? I know from your OP that you started on this due to the terminology that's more frequently being applied, but(assuming I'm not reading too much into this), it seems to me that the labels were more the tipping point in your thesis, rather than the origin of it. Correct me if I'm wrong in thinking that, but are there other incidents leading you to the self-reflection?
 
1. The "official" account is now referred to as the "Official Conspiracy Theory"


The first time i've heard (and used) that term was in 2002.

2. Debunkers here are now referred to as part of the "Debunking Movement"


The first and only (before opening this thread) time i've heard that term was this weekend when i watched the hardfire call-in show. Pat of SLC called in and thanked Gravy for being an inspiration for the "Debunking Movement". Mark and Ron didn't object. I really had to laugh out loud.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom