A taste of our own medicine...perhaps??

A "Movement" can be defined thus:



Given that you are diffusely organised, you are people, and you favour the goal of spreading your beliefs, you are thus a "movement". "The Debunking Movement" is the suitable epithet.

Let's hear no more quibbles about this please.


I don't see the forum members here trying to spread our beliefs so much as trying to stop the spread of yours.

We aren't going around the internet spamming links to the 9/11 commission report on football forums saying "9/11 Was NOT an Inside Job!!1!1!! Do your research sheeple!!!!!!!".

We don't produce endless rambling videos full of lies and distortions aimed at fooling people into believing a load of baseless speculations, that's your job.

Debunkers aren't about trying to convert anyone to a particular political agenda, debunkers want people to honestly assess the facts and use their critical thinking to arrive at logical conclusions. If that is a "movement" then so is science.

OK then, debunkers are members of the "Science Movement". We want to open a new investigation into the properties of sub-atomic particles!!! We want to uncover the secrets hidden in the Human Genome!!! We want to have the Scientific Method taught in Public Schools!!!... etc etc etc...
 
I think if your agreeing with Pardalis over me, you have some pretty serious thinking to do!

I should say that if you do not favour the goal of letting people know your beliefs about 911, then why do you propagate them? Or more to the point, if the whole world (or majority) believed what you and your ilk deemed to be the truth about 911 and its CTs, is this something you would favour or tend towards?
Well, I was partially agreeing with you, except for the "favouring the goal of spreading (my) belief".

I don't think I've ever posted in any other 9/11 related forum, tried to convince anyone one-on-one about what I think about 9/11 or tried to "spread my beliefs" other than following the discussion here.

I'm certainly no crusader for the 9/11 official theory any more than I am "favouring the goal of spreading my belief" that Sylvia Browne is a sham, homeopathy has no scientific basis, and dowsing is a load of bull.
 
Last edited:
i dont think them calling us the "debunking movement" is an attempt to trivialize or marginalize us, in fact i think its the opposite, they are trying to manufacture a large and organized counter-movement to their own in an attempt to legitimize themselves and fuel their galileo delusions

i find irony that they call the counter-movement "debunking" almost as an admission that their movement is chracterized by bunk
 
i dont think them calling us the "debunking movement" is an attempt to trivialize or marginalize us, in fact i think its the opposite, they are trying to manufacture a large and organized counter-movement to their own in an attempt to legitimize themselves and fuel their galileo delusions

i find irony that they call the counter-movement "debunking" almost as an admission that their movement is chracterized by bunk

That is an interesting perspective, one I hadn't thought of, but for some of them, you may be right.

TAM:)
 
I don't see the forum members here trying to spread our beliefs so much as trying to stop the spread of yours.

We aren't going around the internet spamming links to the 9/11 commission report on football forums saying "9/11 Was NOT an Inside Job!!1!1!! Do your research sheeple!!!!!!!".

We don't produce endless rambling videos full of lies and distortions aimed at fooling people into believing a load of baseless speculations, that's your job.

Debunkers aren't about trying to convert anyone to a particular political agenda, debunkers want people to honestly assess the facts and use their critical thinking to arrive at logical conclusions. If that is a "movement" then so is science.

OK then, debunkers are members of the "Science Movement". We want to open a new investigation into the properties of sub-atomic particles!!! We want to uncover the secrets hidden in the Human Genome!!! We want to have the Scientific Method taught in Public Schools!!!... etc etc etc...
Excuse me. So you favour the goal of stopping the spread of my beliefs. You still favour a goal, collectively, and are thus a movement. This was incredibly easy to understand.

The fact that you, collectively, sit their scratching your noggins asking each other "Are we a movement??... I dunno... This is a really interesting argument!" illustrates merely that you are indeed, a rather obtuse one.
 
Last edited:
i dont think them calling us the "debunking movement" is an attempt to trivialize or marginalize us, in fact i think its the opposite, they are trying to manufacture a large and organized counter-movement to their own in an attempt to legitimize themselves and fuel their galileo delusions

Bingo.

also, by their paranoid nature, they see anything that is opposing their beliefs as an organized movement.
 
I was not debating it mjd. My comments were concerning the motive behind the "movement" label, and other labels, the "truthers" are placing on those of us here who try to expose their lies.

TAM:)
 
So you favour the goal of stopping the spread of my beliefs. You still favour a goal, collectively, and are thus a movement. This was incredibly easy to understand.


Well, we probably collectively favour the goal of not dying just yet, but I don’t think that makes us a “movement”.

The fact that you, collectively, sit their scratching your noggins asking each other "Are we a movement??" illustrates merely that you are a a rather obtuse one.


It could be that you’re just wrong, of course.
 
[SouthPark]Simpsons did it![/SouthPark]

Oh, wait, it wasn't the Simpsons, it was me!



its-a-question-of-identity.png


This is just the latest step in a dance they've been doing for quite some time now. It started with them trying to claim that they are the "true skeptics", and now they're trying to label us as the "CTs" or "woos".

It's just exactly like the Creationists tying to assert that evolution is a religion and ID is science, or believers trying to assert that atheism is a belief system. They know that being skeptical and scientific is considered to be a good thing, so they try to co-opt it for themselves, while also trying to label us as irrational. Despite the rising tide of irrationality in our society, science still has the power to persuade people, and the credulists hate that.

So take heart, this just means the CTists are as desperate as the creationists!
 
Well, we probably collectively favour the goal of not dying just yet, but I don’t think that makes us a “movement”.




It could be that you’re just wrong, of course.
The people who would fall into this category would not be "diffusely organised", since they would all fall under one pretty clear umbrella of living human beings. Further, the persistence of ones life is not a general goal, rather an individual one.

Thus, I repeat my assertion. You are a movement, and one that is incredibly obtuse. This thread illustrates it better than I could have dreamed, in fact.
 
Excuse me. So you favour the goal of stopping the spread of my beliefs. You still favour a goal, collectively, and are thus a movement. This was incredibly easy to understand.

In the same sense that teaching people how to read is aimed at stopping the spread of illiteracy. Does that mean that school teachers are part of the "Literacy Movement"?

The fact that you, collectively, sit their scratching your noggins asking each other "Are we a movement??... I dunno... This is a really interesting argument!" illustrates merely that you are indeed, a rather obtuse one.

Like TAM said, mostly I am trying to figure out why Truthers think that I am part of a movement, when all I really want is for people to stop lying to me in the name of truth.
 
You are a movement, and one that is incredibly obtuse. This thread illustrates it better than I could have dreamed, in fact.



Or it could illustrate that fact that we enjoy debating questions without concern for the ultimate answer. I know I do, when the topic is less than earth-shattering, such as whether or not we qualify as a "movement".
 
I prefer to wait for the final report on WTC7 to make a judgment on what happened to it.

I don't claim to know more than the trained engineers who study it in detail, but that's just me.
 
The people who would fall into this category would not be "diffusely organised", since they would all fall under one pretty clear umbrella of living human beings. Further, the persistence of ones life is not a general goal, rather an individual one.

Thus, I repeat my assertion. You are a movement, and one that is incredibly obtuse. This thread illustrates it better than I could have dreamed, in fact.



That seems to happen practically every time that you post here. If people don’t immediately agree with what you’re saying, then you suddenly become inconsolably and uproariously incensed. It’s the strangest thing. I simply cannot imagine what it must be like to go through life like that.
 
In the same sense that teaching people how to read is aimed at stopping the spread of illiteracy. Does that mean that school teachers are part of the "Literacy Movement"?



Like TAM said, mostly I am trying to figure out why Truthers think that I am part of a movement, when all I really want is for people to stop lying to me in the name of truth.
1. There is a very simple way to answer that question. Does the school teacher favour the goal of stopping illiteracy? If this is the case, then, by the dictionary definition, he/she will be part of the literacy movement. It is that simple, please dont make me have to tell u again.

2. Jeezus.... Ok, well other than the obvious "movement" ignorance, about which I may leave you scratching your head with your friends, why don;t you answer #28/#41. You would be the first of your ilk to do so....
 
Mjd, do you have any examples of 9/11 debunking meets, conventions or demonstrations? How about organisations, societies or clubs?

I can think of examples of those things for scepticism in general, but not specifically for scepticism concerning 9/11 conspiracies.
 
Mjd, do you have any examples of 9/11 debunking meets, conventions or demonstrations? How about organisations, societies or clubs?

I can think of examples of those things for scepticism in general, but not specifically for scepticism concerning 9/11 conspiracies.
This is one example of what could be called a convention- "debunkers" meet, in a debunker administrered environment, to discuss debunking. Granted, it is open, and there are a few from the other side of the fence, but it is still, overwhelmingly, a one sided convention of people favouring a certain goal. There are many of these on the net.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom