Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
That doesn't mean that in absence of evidence you know that the thing doesn't exist - as teek pointed out absence of evidence is not evidence of absence (I think that phrase is actually even attributable to Sagan, but anyway, he certainly said it a lot). All it means is you don't know, and again, as teek says, you might consider trying to find out. How? By looking for evidence.
This doesn't really apply to the dragon in the garage scenario. The absence of evidence quote only holds in an unlimited search space particularly when the evidence could anything at all. This seems always forgotten. The majority of times I hear this line trotted out, it is in an inapplicable situation. When you have reasonable expectations that the existence of anything would leave evidence where you can find, and you look, and find nothing, it is indeed evidence of absence. Please consider a few scenarios...
You are my boss, and I sweep the floor at your warehouse. You ask me what I was doing all day yesterday. I answer, "Right here sweeping the floors all day." But you’ve noticed that my time card wasn't punched, the floors don't look swept, and I don't appear on the surveillance tapes at any time during the day yesterday. I'd say you have pretty solid grounds for firing me. Case one, absence of evidence is evidence of absence.
If you tell me that you have a dog and he lives at your house with you, I would expect there to be some evidence. Let’s say that I come over and have a look. I find no leashes or toys. No hair on the carpet or furniture. No scat in the yard or any place the dog might reasonably be walked. I look all about and don't see any of the signs that are familiar to anyone that has ever owned a dog. If I was confronted with this, I'd have to conclude that you are daft or a liar.... unless there were some remarkable extenuating circumstances. Case two....
Let’s consider the case of the American Sasquatch, or Bigfoot if you prefer. While I can't strictly say there hasn't been any evidence at all, there hasn't been any that stands up to scrutiny or couldn't be readily faked. The United States is a pretty large place, granted. But, unless the Bigfoot breaks nearly every biological rule typical an animal that size, there must be more than a couple for the population to survive. A Bigfoot is large and large animals leave large tracks, trails, prints, scat, and most importantly corpses. So, we have large animals, leaving large evidence and no one can find any. We've had park rangers, hunters, lumber and woodsmen, and of course a legion of dedicated big foot hunters crawling all over this country, for decades, and no un-fake-able evidence. Why is there no hair collected from brush or trees (hair that doesn’t match the style, color, and/or DNA of known animals)? Why have there been no reliable traces at all? With modern biology and other forensic sciences, it doesn't take much to conclusively prove that there exists type of previously undocumented large animal, at the very least. Case 3......
In all three, reasonable searches have been conducted that would genuinely be expected to uncover some evidence if the purported event or phenomena really occurred/existed. Even in cases like a Bigfoot, where the search area is very large, it can be searched. Do any of these examples make for an iron clad indisputable case against? Nope, not a one. But every one does represent real evidence. Not just evidence, but fairly compelling evidence. In spite of it all, one good un-fake-able piece of positive evidence would be enough revive any those cases. If someone said they saw a Bigfoot, brought in (even a few) hairs that that yielded some DNA, and that DNA indicated an animal with plausible relation to anything could be a Bigfoot, my calculations concerning the its likelihood would be radically shifted.
Until some evidence is brought forward, I'll consider that the likelihood approaches zero in each of those cases. And has been said elsewhere in this thread, I remain completely open to any evidence that the future might uncover. My conclusion that Bigfoot probably doesn’t exist is always just once piece of evidence away from being overturned. But, I’m not holding my breath.
As the above example shows, absence of evidence often is evidence of absence. When the search space is finite and the kinds of evidence are reasonably known, that unqualified quotation “absence of evidence is not evidence of absence” is completely demolished. It doesn't apply to the dragon in the garage scenario at all.
Bringing up the "absence of evidence" bit in the context of the dragon story only misdirects. The real point is exactly the one that tkingdoll makes herself (in the vary same post, no less), about there being functionally no difference between a thing which could not be detected, even in principal, and that thing not existing at all (that, and the curious oddity of human nature that allows people to make analogous claims with all sincerity). Can such an ephemeral thing even right be claimed to exist, and even if can, does it matter? It seems not in either case.
And along a similar line of thought, that which can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence. I know I've heard Hitchens say essentially that recently. I am almost equally sure that someone said it before him. It wouldn't surprise much to find that Sagan was linked to that phrase as well.
And now addressing specifically A Christian Sceptic.... since all this dovetails so nicely into another point in which you've expressed interest lately, I'll carry it on a bit further here. This relates to your thread title "Show me that Science proves there is no go".
It is pretty tough, if not impossible, to disprove a generic unqualified definition of a god. In the generic god instance, the absence of evidence idea is very much true. It could be anywhere, with any properties at all, with no defined interactions at all. You could never know when you've exhausted the search space, or even if you had searched the space properly. But, the god that you are interested in is not a generic god. You, even by proclamation of your forum name, are interested and believe in a particular god, a well defined god, the God of the Bible. I've got some news for you. That God, the one described in the Bible, isn't a god that should be impossible to find. That God, if the Bible is to believed, should be pretty obvious. The search space is not unlimited and the properties and evidence are not unknown. The Earth is big, but there are many of us, and we've had a long time to gather the data.
I am presuming that I don't need to quote to you everything the Bible has to say about your God and the way he is purported to interact with us, the people of the Earth. With that, here are some things for you to think about.....
The Bible is purported to be the word of God, either written or inspired by him. It is the only reason someone would be Christian. There would be no Christian church and you would not believe what you do, were it not for the Bible. Let’s consider some things that would be true, if the Bible were correct.
Christians should be statistically healthier, have fewer accidents, and have fewer disasters befall them than atheists or believers of other faiths if the Bible and what is parroted in church each Sunday is to be believed. This is not true. Not only are Christians not statistically ahead in any of these categories, the correlation is quite the reverse when it comes to health. It doesn't matter if what size group you consider: family; community; or even nation..... Strength of religious affiliation is correlated with greater child and infant mortality, lower life expectancy, higher rates of STDs, etc etc...
Additionally, what the Bible says about prayer utterly demands that there exist a law of probabilities for Christians and a different law of probabilities for the rest of us. This simply is not born out by research. In things that are random (weather disasters and freak accidents), Christians are "cursed and blessed" at the same random rates as the rest of us. In categories of misfortune that might be avoided by proper use of knowledge and reason, Christians markedly lag behind. Besides the health related examples quoted above, virtually every measure of societal health follows the same pattern. Things like teen pregnancy rates, homicide rates, other violent crime rates, incarceration rates, right on down the list, the USA lags behind our more secular European brothers. The US doesn't even rate a spot in 10 best countries to live in any more.
Admittedly, correlation doesn't prove causation. But, it is a big problem for Christians when places to live are statistically ranked by secularist tendency (or conversely religiosity) and the lists sort out exactly the opposite of what Christian should expect by what they are taught and what is written in the Bible. This seems to be the case regardless of scale considered whether it be done internationally, nationally between the states, or even locally. Try to tell me that Christians, who supposedly have a sky buddy who’s got their back, don't expect the faithful to be better off in all those ways. What church doesn't preach that very idea?
A study that showed that people who received intercessory prayer (that wasn't a total fraud) did better during hospitalization would be evidence of your kind of god. It is the kind of evidence that should be expected. Apparently many Christians agree. That’s why they do these kinds of studies all the time. And they all come up with diddly. Case four....
Sorry for spewing that last bit in here, rather than in the proper thread. If you need to be dragged though all the gory detail in order to back all this up, we can do that in the proper thread.