A Dragon in my Garage - Questions

Personally, I think think his main point is in this phrase:

Sagan said:
If there's no way to disprove my contention, no conceivable experiment that would count against it, what does it mean to say that my dragon exists?


Sure, he is also stating that it is reasonable to come to the tentative conclusion (his qualifier) to not believe in the dragon. But his larger point, I think this is from The Demon Haunted World, is that the real question is not so much whether or not the dragon is real, but to determine what has so utterly convinced the believer.

This is why when approached by a theist who wants me to believe that their version of god is real, my first question is always, "Why do you believe?" The answer could be some type of concrete evidence (footprints in the flour), or other reasoning. Please do not take offense, but as of today, I still haven't had an answer that I personally find compelling.
 
So I read A Dragon In My Garage by Carl Sagan.

http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/Dragon.htm

Am I correct in concluding that what Carl Sagan was saying is this:

"In the absence of scientific evidence that there is __________ don't believe in _________"?

Anyone know of anywhere where he talked about this selection?


It's not so much the lack of evidence, but the impossibility to either proof or disproof it.
See falsifiability.
Any statement that isn't falsifiable is useless.

The skeptics attitude is indeed pretty much to only believe in what you know.
The things you don't know, you don't know.
No point in believing either way. We want to know for sure.
And for reliable knowledge you need evidence.
 
It is indeed in "Demon Haunted World", and as I posted in another thread, the key phrase for me is this;

...the only sensible approach is tentatively to reject the dragon hypothesis, to be open to future physical data, and to wonder what the cause might be that so many apparently sane and sober people share the same strange delusion.

So whilst being (quite rightly) careful to qualify his opinion with the words "tentatively" and "be open", there's little doubt that I can see that he is saying it is not sensible to believe in an unfalsifiable thing. As you know this ended up being the crux of my argument on the other thread vis scepticism and religious belief.

If I had to sum up the piece in one sentence, it would be that "things that are impossible to dis/prove might as well not exist".
 
Last edited:
So I read A Dragon In My Garage by Carl Sagan.

http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/Dragon.htm

Am I correct in concluding that what Carl Sagan was saying is this:

"In the absence of scientific evidence that there is __________ don't believe in _________"?

Anyone know of anywhere where he talked about this selection?
Bertram Russell was one of the first to argue this. If you want a justification of it, read his essays.

I wish to propose a doctrine which may, I fear, appear wildly paradoxical and subversive. The doctrine in question is this: that it is undesirable to believe a proposition when there is no ground whatever for supposing it true.
http://www.positiveatheism.org/hist/russell4.htm
 
A Christian Skeptic said:
"In the absence of scientific evidence that there is __________ don't believe in _________"?
I'd say that's pretty good. Remember not to confuse belief with faith. Belief is when you hold something to be true due to evidence; faith is when you hold something to be true without evidence. Certainly you can have faith in whatever you like.

And don't forget what Yahzi said:

If the existence of a thing is indistinguishable from its nonexistence, we say that thing does not exist.


~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. This is important to remember because sometimes there is no evidence for something...yet. And that's what inspires people to keep looking for the evidence. This is science. "I have observed that this flower grows. I think it may be something to do with water but there's no proof". A few months and some hard work later...there's the proof. And anyone can go and get the same proof for themselves with experimentation. Of course, that particular proof was made ages ago.

However...if a thing continually defies attempts to prove its very existence, then what is the difference between it existing and not existing? None. For all intents and purposes (other than religious worship), it is a useless thing.

Now, what you must further factor in is the motives and behaviour of those making the claim.

"I have an invisible dragon in my garage and sometimes he grants wishes. You can come and sit in my garage and talk to the dragon directly from your mind. He may or may not grant your wish. In return I would like some money. Oh, also, there are some rules for living which people who talk to the dragon have to live by. No gays."

Does the claimant have anything to gain in this scenario?
 
Last edited:
So I read A Dragon In My Garage by Carl Sagan.

http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/Dragon.htm

Am I correct in concluding that what Carl Sagan was saying is this:

"In the absence of scientific evidence that there is __________ don't believe in _________"?
Well I don't know what Sagan would say - he's not here anymore.

But if by that you mean "don't think you know the answers to questions that you don't know the answer to", then yeah, I think Sagan woud have agreed with that.

That doesn't mean that in absence of evidence you know that the thing doesn't exist - as teek pointed out absence of evidence is not evidence of absence (I think that phrase is actually even attributable to Sagan, but anyway, he certainly said it a lot). All it means is you don't know, and again, as teek says, you might consider trying to find out. How? By looking for evidence.
 
Belief is when you hold something to be true due to evidence; faith is when you hold something to be true without evidence.

That's pretty silly even if it is the standard accepted definitions.

I don't know anyone ever to have faithed without any evidence whatsoever. They may be interpreting evidence differently, however.
 
The concept of falsifiability is a little tough for non-scientists to grasp. I read a post on another board today where a person claimed evolution wasn't falsifiable because every time they found some new evidence that hadn't been covered by evolution, they simply rewrote the theory to include it. That is not what it means at all.

Here is the question that you should ask yourself as to whether your belief is falsifiable or not:

What would it take to make you change your mind?

For every positive belief I have, I can concieve of some piece of evidence, however unlikely, that would disprove it. If you cannot think of anything that would cause you to lose belief in a thing, then your belief is not rational because it is not conditional upon evidence.
 
That's pretty silly even if it is the standard accepted definitions.

I don't know anyone ever to have faithed without any evidence whatsoever. They may be interpreting evidence differently, however.


One man's evidence is another man's fancy. For instance, it's evident to me that you fancy your wishes are evidence of .. something. To the empiricist, faith is knowledge without evidence. Now, if you want to go about redefining empiricist, we're swirling ad absurdum.
 
In my belief system invisible dragons can turn into intangible fish gods.

Prove me wrong.

I have here in my hand this HOLEY BOOK. It says you are wrong.

Oh. Wait!

holey
One entry found.

holey

Main Entry:
hol·ey Listen to the pronunciation of holeyPronunciation:
\ˈhō-lē\ Function:
adjective Date:
13th century
: having holes

My bad. Sorry. :confused:
 
T'ai said:
I don't know anyone ever to have faithed without any evidence whatsoever. They may be interpreting evidence differently, however.
Like all things in real life, the belief/faith thing is a spectrum. So is the quality of evidence.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom