A Call to Agatha Christie Fans

Well, it's not a book, but the movie, "Witness For The Prosecution" is one of my all time favorites.
The short story is very good. In my judgment, the short story is better than the movie because the movie added too many twists. The short story had really two twists, one in the final pages of the story, and the other
in the last WORD of the story.
 
I'll confess that I have not read the short story, but now I'll have to. I just think the movie represtents everyone at the top of their game. The performances are fantastic, Billy Wilder's direction is impeccable, and it's just so much fun. When I know people who won't watch a black and white movie, this is the one I make them watch. It's a gateway drug.

Ward
 
"Death on the Nile" is good and the movie ain't too bad.

"Ten Little Indians" is good but all of the movies/plays are inferior.

"The Mousetrap" is a fun play to read, but it seemed a tad too obvious for my taste.

"Murder on the Orient Express" is a lot of fun, but the solution is (or solutions are) just a tad hard to swallow. The movie is ... okay. (I prefer Ustinov as Poirot over Finney.)

"Death in the Air" (or "Death in the Clouds") sucked big time, in part because some of the most important clues were so specific to time and place that no one in the modern age could ever spot them. This story did have the best red herring in it that I've ever seen, though.

"The Murder of Roger Ackroyd": When I read it, I knew what the twist was, and it struck me not so much as a clever ploy but as a dirty trick.
 
Last edited:
I'll confess that I have not read the short story, but now I'll have to. I just think the movie represtents everyone at the top of their game.
Don't get me wrong, I liked the movie, too, especially Charles Laughton.
 
Christie is good fun. Have read almost all her books - I really liked "Death comes at the end". only problem is that it is not much fun to re-read as the problem is the entire focus of the book.

If you want better writing try Dorothy L Sayers - more difficult to get hold of (although there was a new edition out a few years ago).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom