A Call to Agatha Christie Fans

I'm surprised that I seem to be in the vast minority on this.

Perhaps the fact that you've only read one novel and one and a half short stories explains it.

I'm not saying you necessarily would like her if you read more, but it seems like it works as an explanation of the discrepancy.
 
Knowing the poem is not a spoiler for Ten Little Indians, since the poem is framed over the fireplace in the house and constantly referred to.
 
I took a Mystery Novel course in College and we read "the Murder of Roger Ackroyd." We were told to stop before the last two chapters and write an analysis paper on who we thought the murderer was. I'm proud to say that I was only one of two people in the class who correctly predicted who the murderer was. I would paste it here, but it has many spoilers.

Otherwise I tend to enjoy the non-Poirot/Marple books more.
 
Spoilers:
Didn't she write a book where the narrator was the perpetrator?

<<sssshhhh!>>

Only the Bible and Shakespeare have out sold her. All the more extraordinary since the Bible has been around for thousands of years and Shakespeare's plays have been selling for four centuries. Sigh.

Me against the world. :o Well, at least Raymond Chandler also knew her books were filled with clichés of English people and that her writing belonged in pulp magazines.

She wouldn't even rank among Dashiell Hammett or Sir Arthur Conan Doyle- and I'm not even a big fan of Sherlock Holmes stories or of Sam Spade.

"Pulp magazines" actually started many good writers on their careers. Look at all the SF greats whose work first appeared in pulps.

As for Agatha - I think my favorite is The Big Four - it's so of its period, and has a large tip of the hat to Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler.

Did anyone see the recent episode of "Dr. Who" that explained where Agatha was during those two weeks she disappeared and never would say afterwards what happened?
 
<<sssshhhh!>>



"Pulp magazines" actually started many good writers on their careers. Look at all the SF greats whose work first appeared in pulps.

As for Agatha - I think my favorite is The Big Four - it's so of its period, and has a large tip of the hat to Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler.

Did anyone see the recent episode of "Dr. Who" that explained where Agatha was during those two weeks she disappeared and never would say afterwards what happened?
"Of course we did!" he buzzed waspishly.:D
 
Read them all, no reason why not. :) Pick them from a library - they're not that good to be worth the price, to be honest. And they're everywhere.


I find them in second-hand book shops for single digit amounts... less than $5. But the problem is that I can't find all of them (I live in Perth, see?).


You can often find multiple Christie novels collected in one volume at bookstores that solve the problem of spending too much on them.

I know a few years ago they released several volumes that included seven novels in each.

I highly recommend The Murder on the Links. My jaw literally dropped open when I got to the ending of that one.
 
Alex, I will stun you.

I'm halfway through Ten Little Indians and...I really like it.

So much better than I expected it to be.

A solid B plus book.
 
Finished Ten Little Indians.

Good book and I'm pleased to say I actually guessed the identity of the killer! And sort of figured out one piece of the mystery.

Thanks for making me read it! :)
 
I love Agatha Christie! :D

It's been too long since I've read any of her books. I might just have to pick up a few at the library this weekend.

My favorite character is Hercule Poirot, probably because I share some of his traits -- I'm logical, intelligent, and have to have everything neat and straight! ;)

I avoided the Miss Marple stories at first because I had the misfortune to read a short story where she functioned as a deus ex machina, but I've since given them a chance and have come to appreciate them.
 
Finished Ten Little Indians.

Good book and I'm pleased to say I actually guessed the identity of the killer! And sort of figured out one piece of the mystery.

Thanks for making me read it! :)

Ha!

Have fun with your next books.

Alex.
 
My favorite Poirot is Murder in Retrospect (has kind of a Rashomon flavor); favorite Miss Marple is Murder at the Vicarage. When I was young, I read them for the puzzles; now it's for the sense of place.

Granting Christie is no stylist--on the other hand she's not the least pretentious, either. After reading her for a while, everyone else's stuff can start to sound a wee bit precious.
 
I finished A Murder is Announced and am now on Death on the Nile.

Here's another criticism of her work: there are so many characters- about a dozen suspects in each book and usually three or four sleuths- that one sometimes can't keep track of any of them or keep straight who is who.

Also, once you know the solution to the mystery, it all makes very little to no logical sense.

Qualities you have to appreciate are the irony and black humor. Like all the Sherlock Holmes stories, they are very self aware and very tongue in cheek.
 
Incidentally, two new Poirot short stories have been discovered.

It is the first book by John Curran, who describes himself as "an arch-fan". He has previously only published pieces in Christie fan magazines and took a sabbatical from his day job at Dublin city council to pore over her archives.

Curran taught himself to read what he calls Christie's "bloody awful handwriting", to make sense of 73 notebooks covering her working life from the 1920s right up to her last year. They were never intended for public consumption, and are a mass of memos, trial sentences and paragraphs, possible character and place names, written without order and often without dates, mixed in with shopping lists, and packing plans for when Greenway was requisitioned by the navy during the second world war.
 
Agatha Christie

hi.
My favourite AC short stories are from the book
"Parker Pyne Investigates".
Novels?
"The Hollow"
"They Came to Baghdad".
 
Fortunately my mom's love of porcelain cows and kitschy nick-nacks did not rub off on me too badly, but her fondness for mystery novels did. :) I could always count on a slightly used Christie book laying around to read. I like the Poirot's by far the best - he's such a total arrogant jerk.

If I have a complaint it is that her plots are so imitated that it is hard to be surprised anymore by reading the earlier works.

The Ten Little Indians is a notable exception - a great mystery work and still might surprise a reader pretty well. If you have not seen the 1965 movie, imho it is also pretty good, especially considering it was from the mid 60's when movies sucked. The movie ends very differently. Definitely a popcorn/snowstorm movie.
 
Fortunately my mom's love of porcelain cows and kitschy nick-nacks did not rub off on me too badly, but her fondness for mystery novels did. :) I could always count on a slightly used Christie book laying around to read. I like the Poirot's by far the best - he's such a total arrogant jerk.

If I have a complaint it is that her plots are so imitated that it is hard to be surprised anymore by reading the earlier works.

The Ten Little Indians is a notable exception - a great mystery work and still might surprise a reader pretty well. If you have not seen the 1965 movie, imho it is also pretty good, especially considering it was from the mid 60's when movies sucked. The movie ends very differently. Definitely a popcorn/snowstorm movie.

The movie's ending came from the play that Dame Agatha wrote herself. Much better way of dealing with the last needed glut of exposition for the stage. The Judge's confession letter works perfectly for the book, though.

To be honest, the Judge's method of disposing of the revolver at the end was quite unworkable in reality. If someone could come up with a more plausible way of the Judge getting the gun out the door after shooting himself, then a movie could be set in the time period and done exactly as Christie wrote the book - only the Judge could explain to Vera (the one who let the young boy drown) how he committed the crimes after she has hung herself. Picking up the chair she'd just pushed off from, setting it against the wall (as the book has it), and then sitting down and explaining it all as Vera fights for breath and life just as her ward did? It would probably win a couple of Oscars for editing and directing if done right.
 
I just finished Hallowe'en Party. A so-so book. Promising premise, don't really follow through.

The earlier books are better. The ones written in the 60s and 70s just don't have what the WWI to WWII books did.
 
Agatha Christie is awesome! I think Poirot is better than Marple in my opinion. I really liked the book "Sad Cypress." Was Agatha Christie at her best.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom