A Call to Agatha Christie Fans

I thought you had to stay in the closet...yay, I can come out! I love Agatha Christie, especially on holdiays and camping etc. I've read loads of them.I think theyre charming now, I like the atmosphere. And now I got my first proper reading specs..well if I can tear myself from the pc I may get a stash from the library!
 
Run, don't walk to The Murder of Roger Ackroyd!

Me age 12 when first read it ---> :jaw-dropp i read 1984 at around the same time and my appreciation of literature was changed forever.
 
Last edited:
...Did this thread get moved to the "Literature snobs" subforum by mistake?

I'm surprised that I seem to be in the vast minority on this. Even with the murder-mystery whodunit fan population we have, it seems odd that this forum would have so many Christie fans.

My sister had a big Agatha Christie phase a few years ago and she begged me to read some of them and that's why, after a lot of pleading and wheedling, I picked up Orient Express. Bad writing. Bad writing.

Sis tried to get me to read Ten Little Indians but I refused.

Does anyone else hate her books? Anyone...? :D
 
I'm surprised that I seem to be in the vast minority on this. Even with the murder-mystery whodunit fan population we have, it seems odd that this forum would have so many Christie fans.

Why are you surprised? She was _only_ quite popular for how long?

My sister had a big Agatha Christie phase a few years ago and she begged me to read some of them and that's why, after a lot of pleading and wheedling, I picked up Orient Express. Bad writing. Bad writing.

By what standards?

I mean, that's really what it comes down to, isn't it -- nobody expects her books to be, say, War and Peace or other HighFalutin' Quality Literature, and I'm sure that's not what she wrote 'em as.

(At least I didn't. I always treated 'em as dated classic mystery paperbacks.)
 
I recommend virtually any of the Agatha Christie mysteries. The only stories I didn't like of hers were the Tommy and Tuppence novels, although those were more spy thrillers. Also, Curtain and Sleeping Murder which were published in the mid-1970s were written many years before their actual publication, so they're much better than the other novels she was writing around that time.

BTW, don't forget to check out her famed play, The Mousetrap.

ETA: She was an adequate writer, certainly. Not every genre fiction author can be a Chandler. But she was a master at intricate plotting. Her clues were always skillfully hidden in plain sight; one tip for any new Christie reader is that if everybody is talking about some seemingly insignificant thing, pay attention because that's one of her favorite ploys.
 
Last edited:
Translated into 56 languages and approximately 4 billion copies sold would tend to hint that you might be in the minority of people who don't find them enjoyable reads. Does everything have to be Great Literature to be worth a relaxing afternoon?
 
Translated into 56 languages and approximately 4 billion copies sold would tend to hint that you might be in the minority of people who don't find them enjoyable reads. Does everything have to be Great Literature to be worth a relaxing afternoon?

Only the Bible and Shakespeare have out sold her. All the more extraordinary since the Bible has been around for thousands of years and Shakespeare's plays have been selling for four centuries. Sigh.

Me against the world. :o Well, at least Raymond Chandler also knew her books were filled with clichés of English people and that her writing belonged in pulp magazines.

By what standards?

I mean, that's really what it comes down to, isn't it -- nobody expects her books to be, say, War and Peace or other HighFalutin' Quality Literature, and I'm sure that's not what she wrote 'em as.

(At least I didn't. I always treated 'em as dated classic mystery paperbacks.)

She wouldn't even rank among Dashiell Hammett or Sir Arthur Conan Doyle- and I'm not even a big fan of Sherlock Holmes stories or of Sam Spade.
 
Me against the world. :o Well, at least Raymond Chandler also knew her books were filled with clichés of English people and that her writing belonged in pulp magazines.

You keep writing opinions like "her writing belonged in pulp magazines" and "her books were filled with cliches" as if they were fact.
 
Well, art is obviously a matter of opinion and there is no way to prove that something is X, Y and Z.

You can compare opinions and point out elements you didn't like and things you think didn't work and listen to someone's defense of it but there's no way to really give evidence that something is bad or good. It's not a science.

For instance, I disliked the Nicholas Cage movie Knowing and so did the person I saw it with. Roger Ebert inexplicably gave it four stars and most of his readers loved it. I believe they are wrong but I find it hard to explain why I disliked it beyond simply stating that I thought it was ridiculous, that the special effects were bad, that it was mired in cliches, that the treatment of religion is idiotic, that the treatment of science is idiotic, that Nicholas Cage gives a bad performance, that the ideas are tired and that it's a mediocre popcorn flick.

You know a movie is a mediocre popcorn flick because it is one. It just is. If you can't see it, you can't see it. It's the same thing with a great movie- you know it's great because it is great. You can say that the acting was good, that the screenplay was clever and that this scene was powerful or this scene was funny but if someone can't see why it's so good, you can't explain it to them.

Edit: I'll admit that the one AC novel I read was years ago so it isn't fresh in my mind. Also, as much as I disliked it when I read it, it's entirely possible I might have a completely different opinion now.
 
Last edited:
You know a movie is a mediocre popcorn flick because it is one. It just is. If you can't see it, you can't see it. It's the same thing with a great movie- you know it's great because it is great. You can say that the acting was good, that the screenplay was clever and that this scene was powerful or this scene was funny but if someone can't see why it's so good, you can't explain it to them.

You cant know any of these things, you can only have an opinion on them.

It is like....you mentioned Raymond Chandler as an authority supporting your opinion, and I assume a writer you like. Me, on the other hand, I wouldn't give Chandler shelf room in my library, because I find his "hard boiled" formula writing not to my taste. Not to MY taste. I find it, for MY taste, boring, formulaic, and cliched. MY taste.

Assuming that your taste, no matter who else shares it, it the standard or authority for what is good and bad is, forgive me, snobbish and arrogant.
 
It's all a matter of opinion, certainly. It's just that one's opinion on a novel or movie or song is hard to convey to someone who just doesn't share it and doesn't see it. Someone asks you why you didn't like X and all you can say is "It's so mediocre!". It's something that's apparent to you but can't really be explained.

Some books are just not to every taste and that one can't expect that everyone will love or even like them, yes. I like Chandler but agree that his style isn't for everyone. I don't think you have poor taste just because you dislike his novels.

Same with opera, the humor of Seinfeld or Harry Potter - things I love but wouldn't expect everyone to enjoy.
 
And, just passing through my moods in reading, have enjoyed Aristophanes,Alger(my sixth grade teacher had a bunch), Aldiss, Asimov, Atwood, Sabatini, Sayers, Thane, Heinlein, Offutt, Voltaire, Rabelais, Cleland, Southern, Fisher, Salamanca, Clarke, Knight, Tolkein, Blish, Fielding, Twain, Hawthorne, Stevenson (R.L.), Christie, and a batch of others. Good reading is reading you are enjoying when you read it.

ETA and, drat it, I almost left out Michael Bond of the delightful Paddington Bear which I have read every story of multiple times AND the Monseur Pamplemousse and his dog Pommes Fritte who solve mysteries while rating restaurants.
 
Last edited:
Same with opera, the humor of Seinfeld or Harry Potter - things I love but wouldn't expect everyone to enjoy.

Well, we share two out of three then :)

I don't dislike opera, I've just not had the opportunity to be familiar with it. Its one of the things I hope to explore when I retire.
 
Oh, Alex, and here I was just beginning to really like you! :boxedin:

Agatha Christie is a hack. One of the worst popular writers that ever lived. A genius at great plots but third rate at everything else.

I've read one book of her's, Murder on the Orient Express- and that was enough for me!

You've dropped half a point in my book. :p

Edit: When I was in high school, I also borrowed out a book of her short stories from the library (the title escapes me now). I gave up after one and a half. Unreadable.

Fantastic, scripted comedy exists, which geniuses spend hours labouring over trying to perfect; practising and rehearsing. We laugh at that, but sometimes, we just need to laugh at farts.

That's really unlike me to be so blatant. I don't write nor speak that word. :D I feel this issue welcomes it though.

Not that Agatha is a flatulent. No, no, no. I'm just saying how we can't always judge things on their intricacy and whatnot, and instead, just enjoy it if we honestly do. If you honestly dislike Agatha's stories, then that's fine, but it's something special in my opinion. Her plots are stunning, her characters are fun and I love her books.

I read a lot. I have a huge interest in literature. Books, novels or whatever.

I heard a lot about Agatha (obviously) and desperately wanted to read some. Mum ran straight out and bought me By the Pricking of My Thumbs. I loved it and read it within 3 days. I then, as I've already mentioned, got many books from an old book shop for cheap, and I read through The Body in the Library in around 3 days, again. I started Murder on the Orient Express on Tuesday, and finished it today (again, three days).

Murder on the Orient Express, in my opinion, was the most enjoyable of the three.

I agree with you. She may not be a magnificent writer, very simplistic, not complex. But that assists what she's writing. Despite her amazingly intricate plots which she is so damn good at producing, they do not confuse the reader in the slightest. She is, undoubtedly, one of the world's most treasured writers. She hooks the reader in some ineffable way.

I'm curious what is it about her writing that makes it that revolting so as to repulse you to the point that her books like deterrents?

You're missing out on a lot of joy, in my opinion. A joy that has been shared by so many around the globe. The shock at the end, the denouement and the revelations, they're to die for.

You know what? I pity you. :D

Run, don't walk to The Murder of Roger Ackroyd!

Me age 12 when first read it ---> :jaw-dropp i read 1984 at around the same time and my appreciation of literature was changed forever.

Mmmm, I think that will be next. I have just finished Orient, and so I'll have to start another. I was a toss-up between the one you mentioned, and Death on the Nile.

Alex.
 
Last edited:
Without giving any spoilers, let me just suggest that you space out reading Ackroyd/Crooked House/Orient Express/Mousetrap. There is a certain similarity to those particular works that is more effective when you're coming to them fresh.
 
Alex, you've inspired me to read another one of Dame Agatha's books, either to remind myself why it's such junk or to give her another chance. It's been so long since I labored through Orient that I can't give you an valuable opinion of her work.

As soon as I'm through with Brideshead Revisited and the other books on my shelf, I'll read Ten Little Indians and then get back to you with my review.

How's that? :)
 
I look forward to it. :D

I haven't read it although it has a very good reputation.

NB: I think that Orient may just be an acquired taste. For example, the format. The individual chapters interviewing each character, and their second interviews. It's either one you really get into (as did I), or one which you labour through (as did you). So it mightn't have been a good one to start with.

Alex.
 
Well, it's not a book, but the movie, "Witness For The Prosecution" is one of my all time favorites. The screenplay was by Christie (based on her short story and play); it was directed by Billy Wilder and it has an all-star cast. When I meet someone who fears black and white movies, this is what I recommend to get them to believe. It works!

Man oh man, it's good.

Ward
 
I unfortunately now know the ending to The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.

I feel a little bit like a detective myself right now.

SPOILERS (I think):

I mean, I don't know for sure, but judging by the name of the final chapter and the fact that it is in the first person... am I right folks?

Damn, I know I am. :(

Alex.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom