2 Arab parties disqualified from Israel's election

I somewhat disagree, but as you will see, its somewhat semantic.

The marriage process in Israel is composed of two steps. First step is getting a certificate from one of the religious authorities. Second is registering with the interior ministry. A Jew and a Muslim can't do the first in Israel, but can do the second.

As long as we agree on this I do not care how you wish to call it.

IIRC, the orthodox rabbinate control of marriage and religious conversion is one of those bones that was thrown to the religious parties to keep them in coalition governments when Labor and Likkud were relatively evenly split.

I agree. However, I believe it started well before the time when Labor and Likkud were evenly split. Still, the motivation was to include some religious parties in the coalition.
 
I somewhat disagree, but as you will see, its somewhat semantic.

The marriage process in Israel is composed of two steps. First step is getting a certificate from one of the religious authorities. Second is registering with the interior ministry. A Jew and a Muslim can't do the first in Israel, but can do the second.
I don't think it's semantic. It's the question what fundamentally a marriage is. A marriage is a state-sanctioned contract between two people. The state bestows certain benefits on married people, so it is also up to the state to perform the whole procedure. This is the doctrine under Napoleonic law, in all of continental Europe. Most of the founders of the state of Israel came from a Napoleonic law country, I might add. What a rabbi, imam or pastor does to those two people should not in the slightest matter to the state. It is up to the state to ascertain that two people who want to get married fulfill the preconditions and that they indeed want to get married. Their "yes" word in front of a rabbi should not have any value whatsoever to the state; they should say "yes" in front of a civil servant.

(Note that this criticism also applies to the practice in the US and the UK; but at least, in those countries civil marriages also exist).

No you haven't You've shown no wyas a Jew Cna marry a Muslim in Israel.

1] If one of them converts it then becomes Muslim marrying Muslim or Jew marrying Jew. NOT Jew marrying Muslim

:D It amounts to plain and simple discrimination on grounds of religion. The Israeli Supreme Court could only, in my eyes, shoot down the existing marriage laws for that reason.

2] Having to to another country to conduct the ceremony means it cannot be done in Israel.
Moreover, it shows what an utter failure the state is in this respect that it cannot implement its own rules.

Let's try an analogy. Suppose a state were to have such cumbersome rules for incorporation that entrepreneurs would resort to incorporate off-shore because it's easier there. How long would the state survive?

At any rate it shows the religious discrimination and bigotry that still goes on in the world. People should be allowed to get married to who they like, regardless of the sexuality, race or religion. this kind of thing is nothing to do with the state, it's to do with the individuals forming their partnership
Agree with you on all counts. It'll still take some time with the same-sex marriages. We won't even see all the blue states adopt it in the next 5 years (California Prop. 8 anyone?). The idiocy in the Israeli system is that they not only recognize foreign same-sex marriages, but even allow same-sex couples to adopt children. But even for two Jewish people, it can be a burden to meet the requirements as they're meted out by the Orthodox rabbis who impose standards that not all Jews adhere to. In particular, they don't approve of all conversions. That has everything to do with that there is no agreement on what a Jew is.

How would, say, a Jew and a Presbyterian every get married in Israel? :D

I agree. However, I believe it started well before the time when Labor and Likkud were evenly split. Still, the motivation was to include some religious parties in the coalition.
For one, before Begin they never were evenly split; Labour was always the bigger one. For two, either of the big parties in Israel always needed other parties to form a coalition. So they had to throw a bone.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's semantic. It's the question what fundamentally a marriage is. A marriage is a state-sanctioned contract between two people. The state bestows certain benefits on married people, so it is also up to the state to perform the whole procedure. This is the doctrine under Napoleonic law, in all of continental Europe. Most of the founders of the state of Israel came from a Napoleonic law country, I might add. What a rabbi, imam or pastor does to those two people should not in the slightest matter to the state. It is up to the state to ascertain that two people who want to get married fulfill the preconditions and that they indeed want to get married. Their "yes" word in front of a rabbi should not have any value whatsoever to the state; they should say "yes" in front of a civil servant.

(Note that this criticism also applies to the practice in the US and the UK; but at least, in those countries civil marriages also exist).

Your criticism would only apply if the US and the UK had a Napoleonic legal system. Fortunately, the US and the UK are Common Law Countries which means that the Napoleonic code is irrelevant, no matter how quaint its practices may seem to its adherents. The fact that some of the founders of Israel came from Napoleonic countries may be evidence of the terrible persecution that Jews suffered in those countries but it does not imply that Israel should conform to some silly notion of what constitutes a valid marriage.

There is absolutely no need to have a religous ceremony and to have a civil servant witness another marriage ceremony.

Let's try an analogy. Suppose a state were to have such cumbersome rules for incorporation that entrepreneurs would resort to incorporate off-shore because it's easier there. How long would the state survive?

Your vaunted Napoleonic law countries aren't noted for being particularly business friendly. Perhaps this stems from their apparent need to have contracts signed in front of civil servants in order to have effect.

Israel should have a way to recognise mixed marriages but there is absolutely no need to force people to conform to the Napoleonic code.
 
One of the parties say they will work to form their own parliament if the ban is not overturned:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1055524.html

Israeli Arab political party Balad, recently banned from the upcoming general elections by Israel's central elections committee, warned on Wednesday that if the court upholds the committee's decision, the party will call for a boycott of the elections and establish an alternative Arab parliament.

Balad Chairman MK Jamal Zahalka told Haaretz on Wednesday that "if the High Court of Justice upholds the ban, our call for the establishment of an Arab parliament will gain immense momentum. If we can't be elected to parliament, we'll establish one of our own."
 
I believe that Israel recently passed a law stating that Israelis cannot bring to Israel Palestinians that they have married. I think they can marry them, though.

But, marriages in Israel are governed by the Rabbinate...who refuse to recognize Muslim marriages. Pretty stupid.
Its a broader issue with the rabbinate, who only recognize orthodox Jewish marriages and cause quite a headache for reformed Jewish marriages or any marriage for that matter that occur outside of Israel.

So Muslim marriages, along with any marriage that's non-Orthodox, is not recognized. Its a bloody headache. So not only isolated incident discriminating against Muslims.

I do believe that members of the Arab parties have met with members of Hamas and Hezbollah and the PFLP.
The leaders of Balad in the knesset, Azmi Bishara, was accused of high treason by the knesset with the following charges:

"assisting the enemy in wartime, transmitting information to the enemy, contact with a foreign agent and money-laundering to be publicized"

-Gag Order on investigation of ex-MK Bishara to be lifted wednesday. Haaretz May 2 2007

Aiding Hezbollah in providing strategic locations to strike Israel, among other things.
 
That would be great! No racism. No discrimination. No Apartheid. But then it wouldn't be a Jewish state would it?
You keep throwing around this term apartheid without stating as to why its deemed apartheid, compared to South African apartheid. So inapplicable.
 
So Muslim marriages, along with any marriage that's non-Orthodox, is not recognized. Its a bloody headache. So not only isolated incident discriminating against Muslims.


Muslim marriages have nothing to do with the Rabbinate. There is a similar Islamic religious authority which handles Muslim marriages, as well as Druze and Christian ones. All are supervised, and funded, by the Israeli ministry of religions.

I agree with your point about the Rabbinate stands.
 
I fail to see how this improves anything. A parliament with no official legal standing can elect officers and hold debates and pass resolutions and not much else.

I agree.
I think it was intended as a threat. But some, like Avigdor Lieberman, would probably love it if it happened.
 
I fail to see how this improves anything. A parliament with no official legal standing can elect officers and hold debates and pass resolutions and not much else.

I disagree. I think what is needed is symbolic, yet powerful acts like this. Violence is mostly counterproductive. Passive resistance, publicity and symbolism can be more powerful if done well. I can remember one of my teachers from high school saying once, "There is nothing so powerful as an idea whose time has come".
 
Last edited:
I wonder... how does one determine what an "Arab Party" is? ==snip== How many "Arab Parties" are there?
More importantly: do they serve beer at Arab parties, or just goat's milk? :confused:

As to the news article, I wonder why a court would not act as previously?
 
The Israeli supreme court have reversed the parliament committee decision:
Israel's Supreme court overruled on Wednesday a parliamentary panel which had decided to bar Israeli Arab parties from running in next month's parliamentary election.

The court issued its decision in response to an appeal filed by Arab politicians against the ban. A spokesman for the Courts Administration said judges overturned the ban in an unanimous vote Wednesday.
I am not surprised by this.
 
The Israeli supreme court have reversed the parliament committee decision:
I am not surprised by this.

The deed is done, it was reported that Israel discriminated against two Arab parties. This was the sole purpose of the thread.

I wonder if FireGarden would have started a thread about this overruling?
 
Last edited:
The deed is done, it was reported that Israel discriminated against two Arab parties. This was the sole purpose of the thread.

I wonder if FireGarden would have started a thread about this overruling?

Even if the Court overruled the committee, it's pretty clear what the majority of Israeli parliamentarians think.

If you read the article, it's pretty clear they haven't given up the fight, either.

The requests to ban the Arab parties were filed by two ultra right parties Yisrael Beiteinu and National Union-National Religious Party.

In response to the Supreme Court's decision, Yisrael Beitenu Chairman Avigdor Lieberman on Wednesday called the ruling "unfortunate, since no boundary was established to prevent the disloyalty of some of the Arab MKs toward the state of Israel."

Lieberman added that "[former chief justice] Aharon Barak once said that a democracy does not need to kill itself to prove its vitality. The court threw away this declaration and in fact gave the Arab parties license to kill the state of Israel as a Jewish democratic state," adding that his party will not back down. "In the next Knesset, we will pass a citizenship law that will prevent the disloyalty of some of Israel's Arabs," he said.

The new Meretz movement welcomed the court's decision in a statement, saying "we are happy that the Kahanism that has characterized that political establishment, including Kadima and Labor, hasn't reached the justice system," referring to the party of Meir Kahane, which was in fact banned from participating in parliamentary elections over its extreme right wing views.

"Kadima and Labor will have to do some deep soul searching over their populist, senseless decisions that sought to prevent the representation of Israel's Arab citizens in parliament," Meretz's statement said.

What do we have here? Another case of extremists destroying the middle grounds hopes for peace and compromise. By drawing a line in the sand, and forcing a choice, we see more moderate politicians being weak and siding with the extremists, in the fear that doing the right thing will be seen as weak and siding with the other side. It's called wedge politics, and it's ugly, and it works. Many critics of the Gaza intervention have noted it's over reaction is a result also of wedge politics, with elections coming up soon, you have to look 'tough'.
 
The deed is done, it was reported that Israel discriminated against two Arab parties. This was the sole purpose of the thread.

I wonder if FireGarden would have started a thread about this overruling?

Perhaps you should read the OP again, where I stated that such a ruling had been overturned before.

You seem to imply that the overturning of the ruling makes the ruling itself a non-story. Have you considered what the opinions are of the parties likely to win Israel's upcoming election? Some polls put Lieberman's party in 3rd place. And the other parties didn't exactly rush out to support democracy.
 
That's not the point, would you have started a thread about the overruling if there hadn't already been one, or, would you have posted a followup about this story, to show it had been overturned?

You don't need to answer.

It's like when someone is being accused of a crime, it's the first thing reported in the news, because that sort of things sells. But then it turns out the person is innocent, but the news doesn't do a follow up. The harm is done, the person is now guilty in the mind of the mass, no matter what he does. This was the only point of this thread.
 
Last edited:
That's not the point, would you have started a thread about the overruling if there hadn't already been one, or, would you have posted a followup about this story, to show it had been overturned?

Yes. I would have.

It's like when someone is being accused of a crime, it's the first thing reported in the news, because that sort of things sells. But then it turns out the person is innocent, but the news doesn't do a follow up. The harm is done, the person is now guilty in the mind of the mass, no matter what he does. This was the only point of this thread.

Utter rubbish.
As anyone who read the OP would know: I said that a previous such ruling had been overturned. I reported that. I would have reported this one too.
 
That's not the point, would you have started a thread about the overruling if there hadn't already been one, or, would you have posted a followup about this story, to show it had been overturned?

You don't need to answer.

It's like when someone is being accused of a crime, it's the first thing reported in the news, because that sort of things sells. But then it turns out the person is innocent, but the news doesn't do a follow up. The harm is done, the person is now guilty in the mind of the mass, no matter what he does. This was the only point of this thread.

It doesn't concern you at all that the court system had to be used to overturn the ruling? That Isreals democratic sysem produced such a ruling in the first place? As the Haaretz link says, they haven't given up yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom