2 Arab parties disqualified from Israel's election

FireGarden

Philosopher
Joined
Aug 13, 2002
Messages
5,047
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3654866,00.html

Balad was disqualified by a vote of 26 to three, with one abstention, while 21 committee members voted in favor of disqualifying the United Arab List-Ta'al, with eight members voting against and two members abstaining. The Central Elections Committee is comprised of members of all party factions.

Last time this happened, in 2003, the supreme court reversed the ruling before the election.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2641227.stm
 
Israel bans Arab parties in Parliament

http://haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1054867.html

Um....this is not what democracy looks like. Democracies do not ban political parties that have unpopular views. They ONLY ban political parties that seek to subvert or destroy democracy.

In Germany, Nazis parties are of course banned. Thats because they seek to destroy democracy. The Arab parties do not seek to destroy democracy. They do seek to transform the state into one that fully recognizes the rights of all its civilians.

If turning Israel into a nation that recognizes the full rights of all its citizens..and treats all citizens equally..is a THREAT to Israel...then Israel needs to change.

The Supreme Court will make the final decision on this matter. I pray they take the side of democracy and human freedom...and not racism and bigotry.
 
I also hope this is overturned. I wonder... how does one determine what an "Arab Party" is? The article mentions that Arabs may still run for seats in the Knesset, and non-Arab Parties have Arab representatives. How many "Arab Parties" are there?
 
A few points, with no particular order,

1. There is already thread about this. Can we please merge them. I would also ask Parky to bother to look before starting a new thread. Its not the first time this week.

2. Arab parties are ones which mainly appeal to that constituency. In addition to the two parties disqualified, there is the communist party, which always have a mixture of Arab and Jewish politicians. I believe there are also smaller parties, which could not win any seats in the last elections.

3. If Parky would have done minimal research, he would have found that the criteria that allow to disqualify parties are not arbitrary as he implies. The criteria for disqualification are: (1) negation of the existence of the State of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state; (2) incitement to racism; (3) support of an armed struggle against Israel by supporting an enemy state or a terrorist organization. The two parties were accused of (1) and (3).

4. Personally, I do not see any evidence which would justify such a move, and would bet that the supreme court would overturn the decision. It seems the attorney general is of the same opinion:
Attorney Dana Briskman, speaking on behalf of Attorney-General Menahem Mazuz, told the committee prior to the vote that the attorney-general had not found sufficient evidence to disqualify Balad or UAL.
In fact, I suspect that this decision is just election posturing, and was taken knowing that the supreme court would allow the committee members an easy way out. If this sounds cynical it is because I am.
 
Last edited:
By participating in the Israeli Knesset..they are giving their tacit approval to the Jewish State of Israel and its government.

Whats next....requiring all men in the Knesset to wear a kipa?
 
By participating in the Israeli Knesset..they are giving their tacit approval to the Jewish State of Israel and its government.

Whats next....requiring all men in the Knesset to wear a kipa?

Lol, what?

Are you trying to convince me that you are unable of having a rational discussion? Because that is my conclusion based on your recent posting history.
 
I must admit that this is a surprise. Why undermine your credibility as a democracy when they only control 7 of 120 seats?
 
Democracy? That's a hoot. More than half the people were turfed out the 'country' when it was created. Did the rest who had their land stolen vote for this during the subsequent expansionism.

The news that Israel bans Arab parties in Parliament comes as no surprise to me whatsoever.

The Haaretz report says:

Arab lawmakers Ahmed Tibi and Zahalka, political rivals who head the two Arab blocs in the Knesset, joined together in condemning yesterday's decision.

"It was a political trial led by a group of fascists and racists who are willing to see the Knesset without Arabs and want to see the country without Arabs," said Tibi.



And the ADL has the gall to accuse people of Anti-semitism if they compare Israel to the Nazi regime.

We see such blatant behavior from Israel and the world stands by and does nothing. Some even condone it. The world has a too short a memory IMO
 
Is it just me or is there a deliberate and concerted effort to probe the news to find anything that puts Israel in a bad light?
 
And the ADL has the gall to accuse people of Anti-semitism if they compare Israel to the Nazi regime.

We see such blatant behavior from Israel and the world stands by and does nothing. Some even condone it. The world has a too short a memory IMO

Let us know when they open up the gas chambers. Let us know when they line up thousands in fields to be shot. Let us know when Israel starts euthenizing retarded and mentally handicapped folks. Let us know when Israel starts doing horrible experiments on Palestinian civilians. Let us know when Israel starts murdering homosexuals.

Then you can compare Israel to the Nazis.

Indeed....the world has a very short memory.
 
Is it just me or is there a deliberate and concerted effort to probe the news to find anything that puts Israel in a bad light?

please provide a link to the post where you said something nice about Arabs or Muslims.
 
Lol, what?

Are you trying to convince me that you are unable of having a rational discussion? Because that is my conclusion based on your recent posting history.

Funny. I have know this exact thing about you for months now.
 
Is it just me or is there a deliberate and concerted effort to probe the news to find anything that puts Israel in a bad light?

Maybe so. However, in contrast to other posts, this would be news if this was the first time that such a decision was made. It is not. This is a disgusting little game which happens before almost every election. All sides involved know very well that in the end no party will be disqualified. All sides play along as it helps them with their constituencies.

BTW, if any of the responders above think I am wrong, are you confident enough to bet on this? If so, PM me.
 
Let us know when they open up the gas chambers. Let us know when they line up thousands in fields to be shot. Let us know when Israel starts euthenizing retarded and mentally handicapped folks. Let us know when Israel starts doing horrible experiments on Palestinian civilians. Let us know when Israel starts murdering homosexuals.

Then you can compare Israel to the Nazis.

Indeed....the world has a very short memory.
You reap what you sow Parky, look at the thread topics you start, inevitably truthers and antisemites will pollute any discussion.

Don't go complain about it.

Just look at your avatar, isn't that an invitation to Godwin?
 
Last edited:
anti-Semite?



your statements and views hide behind your false accusations because you know your side of the Israel-Gaza war is indefensable. your posts resort to name calling and personal attacks because if you stick to actual debating of the subject matter and the events at hand...you have no ammo whatsoever.

pathetic and sad.

how dare you accuse me of anti-Semitism.
 
Last edited:
I didn't call you an antisemite did I? :confused:

I'm just saying your obsession with Israel inevitably attracts these kinds of people into the discussions. Just look at the past ten threads you've started this week, they've all degenerated.
 
yes. they have been degerated by degenerates and racists who refuse to accept that Israel can do wrong. ONLY Arabs and Muslims and Goys can commit war crimes and crimes against humanity.

ONLY Muslims and Arabs and Goys can commit ethnic cleansing. ONLY Arabs and Muslims and Goys can commit prejudice, and racism, and Apartheid.

I am sick of it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom