2 Arab parties disqualified from Israel's election

What rights are Arab Israelis lacking that Jewish Israelis have? Honest question...

Well, I seem to recall an Israeli arab marrying someone from the west bank, and not being allowed to bring his spouse to live with him in Israel. Unfortunately, I cannot find the reference. I suppose you could say that this is discrimination against a non-Israeli citizen, but had this been a Jew marrying a non-Israeli Jew I doubt it would have been a problem.

I was also under the impression that there were restrictions on land ownership and where they could live, although this may have been only in the occupied territories.
 
i have full trust that Israel will act Democratic in regard of baning partys. there can be good reasons to do it. and if not, i am totaly convinced that they will not be banned from the elections.
 
i have full trust that Israel will act Democratic in regard of baning partys. there can be good reasons to do it. and if not, i am totaly convinced that they will not be banned from the elections.

What does it mean "act democratic?" If the majority want the party banned it will be banned? I think what we should expect is for Israel to act legally: that if parties are banned it will be for legitimate violations of the law. This is a question of minority rights, not majority rule.
 
Well, I seem to recall an Israeli arab marrying someone from the west bank, and not being allowed to bring his spouse to live with him in Israel. Unfortunately, I cannot find the reference. I suppose you could say that this is discrimination against a non-Israeli citizen, but had this been a Jew marrying a non-Israeli Jew I doubt it would have been a problem.
The story I know is of Jasmine and Osama. She was an Israeli Jew, he was an Arab from the West Bank. They ended up in Berlin, Germany.

I was also under the impression that there were restrictions on land ownership and where they could live, although this may have been only in the occupied territories.
These things have been discussed in the recent Hafrada is worse than Apartheid thread. The story of Jasmine and Osama is covered there too.
 
What does it mean "act democratic?" If the majority want the party banned it will be banned? I think what we should expect is for Israel to act legally: that if parties are banned it will be for legitimate violations of the law. This is a question of minority rights, not majority rule.

as i pointed out, there CAN be reason to ban them. I dont know the parties, nor the exact accusations against them.

the Israeli Supreme Court will handle it, and i am pretty sure it will be a just decision.
 
That would be great! No racism. No discrimination. No Apartheid. But then it wouldn't be a Jewish state would it?

There are plenty of states around the world that discriminate in terms of race and immigration, eg, Japan. To a certain extent, that's Japan's problem. That's not the same situation as israel/Palestine, though. In the case of Israel/Palestine it is going to be difficult to create a one race state where there is a pre-existing race that doesn't fit in with the one race plan. That's a recipe for trouble.
 
What rights are Arab Israelis lacking that Jewish Israelis have? Honest question...

they do not have complete freedom of choice when it comes to who they can marry.

Israeli Arabs get 50% as much in educational funding as Israeli Jews.

It is LEGAL to discriminate against Arabs when it comes to housing, employment, and land sales.

Israeli Arabs are NOT allowed to live in ANY of the Israeli settlements in the West Bank or the Golan.

Obviously being an Arab Israeli is not Hell on Earth...but it is no heaven either.

I will look for more.
 
Last edited:
they do not have complete freedom of choice when it comes to who they can marry.

Well, all your assertions above are not quite true. (Though some have some true elements in them.) Anyway, the one above is just ridiculous.
 
Parky76,

they were not disqualified for being "Arab". they were disqualified because some of the members have been to Lebanon and Syria

Were some of the members affiliated with terrorist groups? Why did they go to Lebanon and Syria?

the philosophy of the parties is equal rights for all israeli citizens...

It is hard to believe that some people would find equal rights under the law to be subversive or bad.

I can understand them visiting Syria and Lebanon and worries they might have been affiliated with terrorist groups (but I'm not sure how founded these worries are)

some in israel find such a suggestion to be intolerable.

Pretty sad when you think about it that some would find equal rights for all under the law to be intolerable.


Texas,

Because the ICC recently designated "Apartheid" a "crime against humanity". That my friend is serious business and it was placed there for a single reason ie Israel. It is no coincidence that the charges of "Apartheid" have have only recently been added to the list of "crimes" Israel has committed.

So they react so aggressively to accusations of Apartheid (calling critics Anti-Semites and Nazi's and such) because Apartheid is now a crime against humanity?


Parky76,

they do not have complete freedom of choice when it comes to who they can marry.

A person should be able to, reasonably speaking, marry whoever they want.

Israeli Arabs get 50% as much in educational funding as Israeli Jews.

So they don't get the same opportunities for education

It is LEGAL to discriminate against Arabs when it comes to housing, employment, and land sales.

Not surprising, but you can see how this is hugely immoral to deny people housing, employment and sales of land based on ethnicity.

Israeli Arabs are NOT allowed to live in ANY of the Israeli settlements in the West Bank or the Golan.

To make it worse, these settlements are connected by roads which you're not allowed to cross if you're not Jewish.

Obviously being an Arab Israeli is not Hell on Earth...but it is no heaven either.

They don't have anywhere near the freedoms Americans enjoy I can tell you that!

I will look for more.

Please do.


INRM
 
Parky76,



Were some of the members affiliated with terrorist groups? Why did they go to Lebanon and Syria?



It is hard to believe that some people would find equal rights under the law to be subversive or bad.

I can understand them visiting Syria and Lebanon and worries they might have been affiliated with terrorist groups (but I'm not sure how founded these worries are)



Pretty sad when you think about it that some would find equal rights for all under the law to be intolerable.


Texas,



So they react so aggressively to accusations of Apartheid (calling critics Anti-Semites and Nazi's and such) because Apartheid is now a crime against humanity?


Parky76,



A person should be able to, reasonably speaking, marry whoever they want.



So they don't get the same opportunities for education



Not surprising, but you can see how this is hugely immoral to deny people housing, employment and sales of land based on ethnicity.



To make it worse, these settlements are connected by roads which you're not allowed to cross if you're not Jewish.



They don't have anywhere near the freedoms Americans enjoy I can tell you that!



Please do.


INRM


I believe that Israel recently passed a law stating that Israelis cannot bring to Israel Palestinians that they have married. I think they can marry them, though.

But, marriages in Israel are governed by the Rabbinate...who refuse to recognize Muslim marriages. Pretty stupid.

I do believe that members of the Arab parties have met with members of Hamas and Hezbollah and the PFLP.
 
But, marriages in Israel are governed by the Rabbinate...who refuse to recognize Muslim marriages. Pretty stupid.

How about actually checking your facts, for a change?

Marriages in Israel are performed under the auspices of the religious authority of the religious community to which couples belong. The system is based on the Millet or confessional community system inherited from the times of the Ottoman Empire and not substantially modified during the British Mandate period nor since the establishment of the State of Israel. The system is also in use by several Muslim countries of the Middle East and beyond.
The religious authority for Jewish marriages is the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and there are parallel authorities for Christians, Muslims and Druze communities. Each authority regulates marriages and divorces for their own community. There is no provision for inter-faith marriages.
One of the functions of the Israeli Interior Ministry is the registration of marriages. It has no role in the recognition or validation of marriages, provided appropriate proof of marriage is produced.
Israel makes no provision for civil marriages to be entered into in Israel. However, civilian marriages entered into abroad are recognised. The issue of civil marriages is a major issue for secular Jews, as well as members of non-Orthodox streams of Judaism, who are required to meet the Orthodox standards to be capable of marrying in Israel.[1]
 
Ahh....so Jews cannot marry a Muslim. And the Rabbinate can refuse to recognize the marriage of those Jews who are not Orthodox.

Now that's what I call democracy.
 
Ahh....so Jews cannot marry a Muslim. And the Rabbinate can refuse to recognize the marriage of those Jews who are not Orthodox.

Now that's what I call democracy.

Oh god! :rolleyes:

Please read the link. The government body that registers marriages is the home office, and not the Rabbinate. It registers various types of marriages.

The Rabbinate is a religious Jewish body which conduces religious ceremonies. It is absurd to expect them to conduct any type of non-religious marriages. In any case it is not their role to recognize other types of marriages.

To your next point, regarding the marriage between a Jew and a Muslim. Here you are wrong again. There are two ways in which they can marry. If either one of them converts they can marry through (either) religious authority in Israel. Alternatively, they can get a civil marriage license abroad, say in Cyprus. In both cases the marriage will be recognized by the Israeli home office.

I know an Israeli couple which were married in Cyprus. They were both Jewish, but non-religious, and decided they do not want to marry through the Rabbinate. (They were unhappy with some Jewish customs which were set in ancient times, and do not treat both sexes equally.) Their marriage is recognized by the state of Israel.

Now the question on whether the state of Israel should allow for holding civil marriages in Israel. This is a good subject for discussion. My opinion is that it is past time that such an option would be available. If you are really interested we can also discuss why this has not been done already.

On a more basic level, what bothers me most is not the opinions you hold, though I may disagree with some of them. I do not expect everyone to agree with me. I would have been bored silly if that was the case. I am more bothered by the fact that you got your facts wrong, even after I have linked the correct information. It is hard to hold a meaningful discussion when basic facts any not agreed upon.
 
I am more bothered by the fact that you got your facts wrong, even after I have linked the correct information. It is hard to hold a meaningful discussion when basic facts any not agreed upon.

Debate the issues...not the members of JREF.

If I am wrong.....prove me wrong.

Anyways, so it is impossible in Israel for a Jew to marry a Muslim? There is NO civil marriage system at all that allows for this?

By allowing such a system to exist...the Israeli govt. has infact given its stamp of approval for such a situation.

I do not have to remind you of when was the last time it was illegal for a Jew to marry a non-Jew.

This is $&@##@@ disgusting. What kind of democracy acts this way?
 
Debate the issues...not the members of JREF.

If I am wrong.....prove me wrong.

Anyways, so it is impossible in Israel for a Jew to marry a Muslim? There is NO civil marriage system at all that allows for this?

By allowing such a system to exist...the Israeli govt. has infact given its stamp of approval for such a situation.

I do not have to remind you of when was the last time it was illegal for a Jew to marry a non-Jew.

This is $&@##@@ disgusting. What kind of democracy acts this way?

I have already proved you wrong. I have shown you two ways in which such a marriage can be held, and in both it will be recognized by the state. This was included in the link in my first reply. My second reply was just the same information in my own words. I have also stated that I believe that Israel should introduce civil marriages, as it is foolish that people will have to go to Cyprus, or mail papers to Paraguay instead.

You have ignored all that, and instead replied with rhetoric. Do you actually bother to read the replies and the links, or do you decide in advance you know all the facts?
 
Debate the issues...not the members of JREF.

If I am wrong.....prove me wrong.

Anyways, so it is impossible in Israel for a Jew to marry a Muslim? There is NO civil marriage system at all that allows for this?

By allowing such a system to exist...the Israeli govt. has infact given its stamp of approval for such a situation.

I do not have to remind you of when was the last time it was illegal for a Jew to marry a non-Jew.

This is $&@##@@ disgusting. What kind of democracy acts this way?

Well there are plenty of 'Western' countries that operate a political system that likes to call itself a democracy where people are not legally entitled to get married based upon their sexuality. So this discriminatory bigotry exists all over the place.
 
I have already proved you wrong. I have shown you two ways in which such a marriage can be held, and in both it will be recognized by the state. This was included in the link in my first reply. My second reply was just the same information in my own words. I have also stated that I believe that Israel should introduce civil marriages, as it is foolish that people will have to go to Cyprus, or mail papers to Paraguay instead.

You have ignored all that, and instead replied with rhetoric. Do you actually bother to read the replies and the links, or do you decide in advance you know all the facts?

No you haven't You've shown no wyas a Jew Cna marry a Muslim in Israel.

1] If one of them converts it then becomes Muslim marrying Muslim or Jew marrying Jew. NOT Jew marrying Muslim

2] Having to to another country to conduct the ceremony means it cannot be done in Israel.


At any rate it shows the religious discrimination and bigotry that still goes on in the world. People should be allowed to get married to who they like, regardless of the sexuality, race or religion. this kind of thing is nothing to do with the state, it's to do with the individuals forming their partnership

This kind of sectarianist bigotry is by no means limited to Israel.
 
No you haven't You've shown no wyas a Jew Cna marry a Muslim in Israel.

1] If one of them converts it then becomes Muslim marrying Muslim or Jew marrying Jew. NOT Jew marrying Muslim

2] Having to to another country to conduct the ceremony means it cannot be done in Israel.


At any rate it shows the religious discrimination and bigotry that still goes on in the world. People should be allowed to get married to who they like, regardless of the sexuality, race or religion. this kind of thing is nothing to do with the state, it's to do with the individuals forming their partnership

This kind of sectarianist bigotry is by no means limited to Israel.

Damn. Not only do I agree with TFT, but he beat me to it.

well, at leatst my thyping is betyter. ;)

IIRC, the orthodox rabbinate control of marriage and religious conversion is one of those bones that was thrown to the religious parties to keep them in coalition governments when Labor and Likkud were relatively evenly split.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom