10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
If what he's talking about is the small areas of red at the bottom of the first picture, they look like flags to me. I can't use photoshop here, but at home, I blew this pic up (Not with explosives, I assure you :p ) and that's what they appeard to be.

Linky to the picture I'm talking about since this is a reply to a reply:

http://www.amanzafar.com/WTC/wtc38.JPG

The red objects are indeed flags on that thing that looks like a big fan (an air boat perhaps)
 
The red objects are indeed flags on that thing that looks like a big fan (an air boat perhaps)
I believe he's actually talking about the reflections off the windows on WTC7, which is off to the left and towards the bottom part of the visible portion of the building.
 
Good grief CB

What part of " the penthouse took 5 to 7 seconds to collapse"
didn't you understand?

So the penthouse took 5 to 7 seconds to collapse but the "building" took 6 seconds AFTER the penthouse had collapsed. That is what you are saying correct? The penthouse is therefore not part of the "building".

Now don't go telling me I am being all wordy and such. This is what you are now saying.

Christopher 7 writes:

As it turns out, there is clear evidence for office fires on several floors in the area of the initiating event.

The statement is a summary of statements in the FEMA and NIST reports.

It is true. [see post #1282 for references]


Food for thought

All the severe debris damage to the west half of the south side of WTC 7 could make the west end of the building collapse first but it could not make the east central part collapse first.
Funny you should use the word bearing because the columns in the west half and central part of WTC 7 would be bearing the load of the missing perimeter columns.

Actually the missing perimeter columns would be adding both vertical load to the western columns, AND shear loading as the load from core to perimeter is now a catenary load.

Here's a senario:
This would be pulling the core columns to the south and west. The heavy flooring at the 5th and 7th floor may have been transferring this shear throughout the building. That would mean that all core columns would be under shear force pulling them south and west certainly utilizing the design margins in the columns for that type of force.
Then the fires further weaken the steel until the column(s) 79,80,81 fail to be able to hold the load any longer. This also serves to increase the shear load on the rest of the core west of the failed column(s). It also puts a very large shear load on the transfer trusses 1&2 pulling them west. Those trusses are anchored very securly to the east so they themselves may not fail but their connections to the west columns would be more likely to. This would serve to detach the portion of the building below floor 7 and west of the line of columns 79,80,81 from the portion of the building east of those columns. That reduces the ability of the western section to resist the shear forces pulling those columns further west at the 5th to 7th floor. As they are pulled in that direction they pull the upper section of the building, at the core, downward. The columns, now being well off their center cannot support the mass above them and fail completely allowing the screenwall/west penthouse to start to fall. The cantilever trusses carrying the mass of the upper 41 stories above the existing Co-Ed building are also pulled west at their south end causing them to fail and pull inward and down on the north facade, while the upper 41 stories also are drawn inward and down by the collapse of the core. the north end of the cantilever trusses were extended beyond the north facade, As they were twisted and tilted they would also be drawn southward causing the north face columns they were attached to, to buckle southward thus dropping the north face downward.

If the tranfer truss #1 let go, then as the eastern section collapsed it would be caused to twist to the NE as it fell.

This senario IMHO, explains the collapse of the east penthouse, the sequence of collapse of the screenwall/west penthouse and perimeter as well as the direction of collapse of the western and eastern portions of the building.

Could this all have been acomplished by using explosives? Yes. Could what Darryl heard be an explosive? Yes. But it would also require that the resultant from this one explosion act in such a way as to cause the structure to do what was seen to occur.

You always talk about what else it could have been but you just can't bring yourself to admit that it also could have explosive devices going off all together or in very rapid succession.

Chris, Chris , Chris, I have always said that I find the evidence supporting DD/F to be much more convincing that that supporting the CD hypothesis. What part of that don't you understand?

Now IF this was a multitude of explosives going off in very quick succession
such that they are indistinquishable from one large explosion the sequence of collapse that was observed would not occur. Instead the entire core section would collapse at the same time not inthe relatively slow horizontal progression.
 
http://www.dailymotion.com/related/2609178/video/x5tv6_wtc7cutter/1

Look at the top right side of the building... looks like several puffs.

What's the cause?
OK, I'm going to speculate. Want to make it clear it's speculation, because I have no way of knowing.
However, if we're looking at the same thing, it could be from where the penthouse has just collapsed, leaving a hole in the roof. Then, as it collapsed, smoke gets forced out the hole.
Reasonable? Or am I just blowing smoke?:D
 
Already read it. Are you saying this list:

is in chronological order, because you did not specify that it was.

If it was in chronological order, then was Daryl watching the penthouse section fall?
My bad. Let me clear that up.

The penthouse took 5 - 7 seconds to collapse

Daryl did not hear the penthouse fall.

He heard "....sounded like a clap of thunder.....it looked like there was a shockwave ripping through the building.....about a second later the bottom floor caved out...."

The bottom floor caving out is the beginning of the exterior walls falling.

The 5 - 7 second collapse of the floors under the penthouse he did not hear.

How about the 'horizontal' collapse, they happened about a half second before the exterior walls.

1 core column supposedly pulled 5 core columns sideways until they all snapped making a sound like a clap of thunder.


What Daryl heard and saw fits hand in glove with a CD.

You can deny that if you want. You say "it must have been something else" but can you bring yourself to admit that what Daryl heard and saw could have been a CD?

Note: every CD it tailored to the task at hand.
 
How do you know? Structural engineering is full of counterintuitive things. For instance, .....
I don't know. I'm not a structural engineer. And neither are you.
I'm a carpenter and i understand the basic principles of framing.

They are pretty much the same for wood or steel.

The surrounding columns would bear the weight of the failed columns.

The stress would be bourn by the entire building because it is essentially one piece.
 
He heard "....sounded like a clap of thunder.....it looked like there was a shockwave ripping through the building.....about a second later the bottom floor caved out...."

The bottom floor caving out is the beginning of the exterior walls falling.

The 5 - 7 second collapse of the floors under the penthouse he did not hear.

How about the 'horizontal' collapse, they happened about a half second before the exterior walls.

1 core column supposedly pulled 5 core columns sideways until they all snapped making a sound like a clap of thunder.


What Daryl heard and saw fits hand in glove with a CD.

You know it also fits hand in glove with a standard, 1-each, building collapse due to structural damage and fire.

What about the timeline? Daryl could have heard the penthouse sections collapsing as the thunder. You haven't produced any timeline to dispute this. How does he know it wasn't the penthouse and structure underneath collapsing if he wasn't watching the penthouse collapse.

Where was Daryl when he heard this? How far from the building?
 
You know it also fits hand in glove with a standard, 1-each, building collapse due to structural damage and fire.
If you say so.

What about the timeline? Daryl could have heard the penthouse sections collapsing as the thunder.

You haven't produced any timeline to dispute this. How does he know it wasn't the penthouse and structure underneath collapsing if he wasn't watching the penthouse collapse.
What part of "about a (1) second later the bottom floor caved out" don't you understand?
 
What part of "If he didn't watch the penthouse structure fall how in hell does he know what he heard wasn't the final stages of the penthouse collapsing" do you not understand?

Edited to make my point more clear.

This is my understanding of what you're saying:

The penthouse collapsed in about 5 to 7 seconds, then Daryl heard the thunder, then about a second later the bottom floorm caved out.

IF HE WAS NOT WATCHING THE PENTHOUSE FALL, HOW DOES HE KNOW HE WASN'T HEARING THE PENTHOUSE AND STRUCTURE BENEATH THE PENTHOUSE CRASHING DOWN ON THE BOTTOM FLOORS? According to your time line he heard the thunder just at the 7 second mark. What makes it impossible for this thunder to be the final stages of the penthouse collapse?
 
Last edited:
What part of "If he didn't watch the penthouse structure fall how in hell does he know it was a second later" do you not understand?
He didn't see or hear the penthouse fall.
The (1) second later refers to the exterior walls starting to fall.

By the numbers

1) penthouse starts to fall

2) 4 - 6 seconds later there is a

3) clap of thunder

4) 1 second after that, the bottom floor caves out
[exterior walls start to fall]

Note:
The exterior walls started falling 5 - 7 seconds after the penthouse started falling.

I hope this clears up any remaining confusion.
 
Thanks!

1) penthouse starts to fall

2) 4 - 6 seconds later there is a

3) clap of thunder

Where was Daryl standing when he heard the thunder? How far away? How can you discount the penthouse falling as the thunder clap if the penthouse took 5 to 7 seconds to fall, and he heard the sound 4 to 6 seconds into the penthouse collapse event?
 
He heard "....sounded like a clap of thunder.....it looked like there was a shockwave ripping through the building.....about a second later the bottom floor caved out...."

The bottom floor caving out is the beginning of the exterior walls falling.

The 5 - 7 second collapse of the floors under the penthouse he did not hear.

Every CD I've watched now is accompanied by a series of sharp cracks, akin to the sound of fireworks.

Thunder, on the other hand, produces a deep rumbling sound.

Taking his words at face value, what he's describing doesn't sound like a CD. It sounds like a building actually in the process of collapse.
 
By the numbers

1) penthouse starts to fall

2) 4 - 6 seconds later there is a

3) clap of thunder

4) 1 second after that, the bottom floor caves out
[exterior walls start to fall]

So you're saying that the event you're identifying as charges going off took place 4-6 seconds after the initiating event?

Dave
 
I'm a carpenter and i understand the basic principles of framing.

They are pretty much the same for wood or steel.

The surrounding columns would bear the weight of the failed columns.

The stress would be bourn by the entire building because it is essentially one piece.

The basic principles of framing have been understood for hundreds of years, and yet it's only been in the last century that we've had the technology to build skyscrapers. Only a few decades that we've been able to build the light, steel-framed structures like WTC7.

So, I would say that your carpentry experience is insufficient to understand the principles involved here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom