• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Muslims respond with "Draw Holocaust Day"

I'd still like to know how non-violent, non-harrassing Holocaust-denial, from the comfort of one's home, is a non-peaceful act.
 
Thunder said:
I'd still like to know how non-violent, non-harrassing Holocaust-denial, from the comfort of one's home, is a non-peaceful act.
Click to expand...

Because we Jews say it is 'not peaceful' to crush criticism of Jews. We make people scared to be label anti-Semite. You know how this work. It OK to deny mass murder of Armenian, to deny mass murder of Palestinian, but not OK to deny mass murder of Jews. It illegal in many country in Europe. This achievement for Jews.
 
I just think this thread is kinda pointless (no offense to you very talented debaters). I think the whole issue is simple, some Muslims were so offended by "Everybody Draw Mohammad Day" that they had to find an active way to retaliate. They chose the "Everybody Draw the Holocaust Day". They have the right to express themselves and vocalize their opinions.

I think history is against them, since the Holocaust has a wide amount of evidence, but nobody can honestly stop them. The question is are they justified to do this as retaliation, I really don't know. But they do have the right to.
 
Hadron said:
I just think this thread is kinda pointless (no offense to you very talented debaters). I think the whole issue is simple, some Muslims were so offended by "Everybody Draw Mohammad Day" that they had to find an active way to retaliate. They chose the "Everybody Draw the Holocaust Day".
Click to expand...

Again, that would be true if it were really everybody make fun of the holocaust day. The problem is a significant number of those folks are not making fun of it -- however disgusting that may be -- but denying it happened at all, in all seriousness.
 
Hadron said:
I just think this thread is kinda pointless (no offense to you very talented debaters). I think the whole issue is simple, some Muslims were so offended by "Everybody Draw Mohammad Day" that they had to find an active way to retaliate. They chose the "Everybody Draw the Holocaust Day". They have the right to express themselves and vocalize their opinions.

I think history is against them, since the Holocaust has a wide amount of evidence, but nobody can honestly stop them. The question is are they justified to do this as retaliation, I really don't know. But they do have the right to.
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure that everyone in this thread agrees. What we are saying is that it is just more evidence that these specific Muslims are stupid, hateful, asshats who expect others to follower their completely made up rule. Even more completely made up than the rules that actually appear in the Quran.
 
Skeptic said:
Again, that would be true if it were really everybody make fun of the holocaust day. The problem is a significant number of those folks are not making fun of it -- however disgusting that may be -- but denying it happened at all, in all seriousness.
Click to expand...

I feel you on that one. There is a difference between making fun of something and actually making a statement about something's authenticity. If however, the participants in the Holocaust Drawings were just using that (Holocaust Denial) as a joke (a prop if you would) would that possibly just level everything back down to making fun of something?
 
Last edited:
I would, of course, be insulted by people "make fun of the holocaust day", but if it was really making fun of it, as opposed to denying it, I would see the point. I would in fact considered it a genuine improvement in type of protest over the "we'll kill you all!" response. I certainly wouldn't threaten people with death over it.
 
Skeptic said:
I would, of course, be insulted by people "make fun of the holocaust day", but if it was really making fun of it, as opposed to denying it, I would see the point. I would in fact considered it a genuine improvement in type of protest over the "we'll kill you all!" response. I certainly wouldn't threaten people with death over it.
Click to expand...

so you accept that Mohammed was send by Allah as the last prophet? or do you deny that?
 
Wow. DC, do you think before you post at all?

You do know that historical facts and religious beliefs are not the same thing, right?
 
the intent of me asking him a question was geting an answer from him.
 
Pardalis said:
What is the meaning of your question? Towards what argument do you want it to lead to?
Click to expand...

you know for those that deny the holocaust, the holocaust is no fact, they have never read the reports and all kind of thing.

but to them propably its a historical fact that mohammed was send by allah, we deny that without looking at the evidence, or did you read the Suras?
 
i have less troubles with people denieing the holocaust, than people actually making fun of it. when you know its true, its kinda not funny in any way.
 
DC said:
you know for those that deny the holocaust, the holocaust is no fact, they have never read the reports and all kind of thing.

but to them propably its a historical fact that mohammed was send by allah, we deny that without looking at the evidence, or did you read the Suras?
Click to expand...

OK. So I ask you again, do you understand that historical facts and religious beliefs are not the same thing?
 
Pardalis said:
OK. So I ask you again, do you understand that historical facts and religious beliefs are not the same thing?
Click to expand...

i do. but do religous people understand that? or atleat those Sceptic points his anger to?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom