• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Zimmerman's NBC Lawsuit Tossed

Unabogie

Philosopher
Joined
Aug 5, 2005
Messages
9,692
Location
Portland, OR
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/george-zimmerman-libel-suit-nbc-thrown-out

A Florida judge on Monday threw out George Zimmerman's libel case against NBC Universal, ending the former neighborhood vigilante's pursuit of damages from the media company over an edited audio clip of a 911 call.

The Orlando Sentinel reported that Circuit Judge Debra S. Nelson ruled shortly before 9 a.m. ET that Zimmerman is not entitled to any money from NBC over the edited clips that aired four times in March of 2012 — a month after Zimmerman fatally shot unarmed teenager Trayvon Martin.

The audio of Zimmerman's 911 call to dispatchers was shortened, making it sound as though he gratuitously mentioned that Martin was black. Zimmerman also alleged that NBC erroneously reported that he had uttered a racial epithet during the phone call.

But in her 15-page order, Nelson ruled that there is "no clear and convincing evidence that defendants knew that the information published was false at the time it was published, or recklessly disregarded the truth or falsity of those statements."

She also noted that throughout the month in question, NBC repeatedly quoted Zimmerman's family members who insisted that he is no racist.

Well, he always has the option to kill another unarmed black kid.
 
Quelle Suprise! He never had a chance again them. Guess now he'll have to go get a JOB. Moving around from one friend's couch to another doesn't sound like fun to me!
 
Hail, Hail, the gang's all here!

Step 1: Edit 911 recording so that nobody could draw a conclusion other than somebody is a racist.
Step 2: "Allow" family member to defend said person as not being a racist.
Step 3: Case dismissed.

The NBC edit last 9 seconds.
The original recording (which allows the proper context) was 13 seconds.

Regardless of your opinion of this horrible event, if you can't comprehend the deliberate intent of NBC by editing this recording, well, words escape me...
 
No shock here, although we'll see if it gets turned around on the inevitable appeal. It's hard to see how he was set up by NBC, given the public reaction *before* his police call was released by Sanford's mayor - not to mention the wide variety of other media outlets that also had the police call recording, and played it in full. This is hardly like Dateline faking explosive gas tanks on cars.
 
No shock here, although we'll see if it gets turned around on the inevitable appeal. It's hard to see how he was set up by NBC, given the public reaction *before* his police call was released by Sanford's mayor - not to mention the wide variety of other media outlets that also had the police call recording, and played it in full. This is hardly like Dateline faking explosive gas tanks on cars.

Does he have the money for an appeal? His legal bills must be astronomical by this point.
 
So, the take away from yet another Zimmerman case is that is difficult to prove guilt?
 
Does he have the money for an appeal? His legal bills must be astronomical by this point.

He owed $2.5 million for the murder defense:
http://articles.orlandosentinel.com...131129_1_mark-o-mara-trayvon-martin-zimmerman

I don't know what he owes for this lawsuit. Maybe the lawyers were working on contingency?

His defense attorney (for the murder trial) was hoping for some of this money:
O'Mara told CNN's Anderson Cooper last week that he hopes Zimmerman will get some money from a defamation suit he filed against NBCUniversal Media LLC.
 
I'm sure George would have no problem finding trouble if he went and looked hard enough.

You don't understand. The black kid that he killed, the cop that he shoved, the mistress he choked, the wife he threatened, the drunk girl at the party whose ankle he sprained, the father in law he punched, the photos he stole, and that rapper that he wanted to box...they were all actually attacking him. Those aren't evidence of his lawlessness, in any way. Just random, out of the blue attacks that he had to defend himself from.

So you see, it's totally disingenuous to suggest that he'd turn to violence or law-breaking for a superficial reason.
 
Last edited:
You don't understand. The black kid that he killed, the cop that he shoved, the mistress he choked, the wife he threatened, the drunk girl at the party whose ankle he sprained, the father in law he punched, the photos he stole, and that rapper that he wanted to box...


How could you possibly forget the cousin that says Zimmerman raped her multiple times over the course of 10 years?

He is so unlucky.
 
How could you possibly forget the cousin that says Zimmerman raped her multiple times over the course of 10 years?

He is so unlucky.

I (still) leave it out, because it started when he was 10 when that started, and at that age it's very possible that it means that he was being molested by an adult.
 
I (still) leave it out, because it started when he was 10 when that started, and at that age it's very possible that it means that he was being molested by an adult.

No excuse for inflicting that abuse on another child. GZ is an amoral, hot tempered, rootin' tootin' gun carrying, evil person. If I truly believed in a burning Hell, I'd believe that's where he's heading.
 
No excuse for inflicting that abuse on another child. GZ is an amoral, hot tempered, rootin' tootin' gun carrying, evil person. If I truly believed in a burning Hell, I'd believe that's where he's heading.

And as I said, Zimmerman is both a domestic abuser and a clear-cut racist murderer - as we've seen by him, say, threatening his wife and smashing her belongings, or shoving his mistress out of her own house, or flying into a rage because a black kid was walking down the street. Even so, a kid who acts out sexually, is often *being* abused.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom