"Zimbabwe Park to Cull 200 Lions, Cites Lack of Hunters"

Again, how is killing the most impressive male lions reduce the population? You know that lions are polygynous? You may change the male:female ratio and the gene pool but that doesn't mean the population is being reduced.

They hunt lionesses too. I don't know the details of how all the hunting is managed, but it really isn't far fetched to think that hunting controls to population levels. Even if they only hunt males, if you kill enough, it will reduce the population. Plus as mentioned by others, the remaining males can fight for dominance and possibly end up killing each other or cubs.

I think he's suggesting that minke wales will start killing swimmers if they become too numerous.

I think he's saying the zimbaweans are eating the lions.
 
I think the concern is the amount of revenue per acre.

If the revenue is higher for an acre of hunted wildlife preserve, than it is for an acre of agricultural subsistence farming, then those acres will be preserved for wildlife. If it is not, that land will go to subsistence farming, and I think we all know what impact that would have on wildlife.
 
I think he's suggesting that minke wales will start killing swimmers if they become too numerous.

This was entirely unintentional, but I just realized that this can be read to mean that minke wales kill swimmers when swimmers become too numerous, thus controlling the population of swimmers. I think that's even better than my intended meaning.
 
“Today, the hunters’ legends live again in the Bubye Valley, where populations of animals have had the time and the space to grow to maturity,” Bubye stated on its website. “Thriving herds live in balance on the open savannah, the mopani woodlands and in the dense riverine forests. The diverse habitats found in the Bubye Valley Conservancy now support an astonishing 35 species of wild, free-ranging game animals including the classic Big Five.”
And they want to upset that balance?

Leathem explained that the lions are a big threat to the park’s other denizens, which included antelope, giraffes, leopards, and a number of other native species.
Lions eat other animals? Who knew??? :boggled:
 
Is there any reason to believe that this is anything other than a sampling effect? That is, the deer being hunted now are being killed at a younger age, but are otherwise identical to the deer hunted in the 20's, 30's and 40's?

That's a good point and was one we took into account. For the past 30 years, we've let all the Big Buck grow old and our neighbor has cooperated with us - so there is a lot of land available as a "Big Buck" Haven.

Nevertheless, these bucks just never grew Big Antlers like in the olden days (which are just huge compared to the biggest set we've taken in the past 40 years).

The only other thing we could think of was that maybe something else changed...something that gave an advantage to smaller Bucks. We just don't know. We do know that there are fewer trees than there were back in the 20-40's. Also, there are a lot more deer today than were around back in the 1920's and 30's. Additionally, Coyotes have replaces a Wolf-like Critter (I swear, I think they were Red Wolves) as the primary Apex Predator.
 
Might have some unintended consequences though... (a lack of challengers for existing males running a pride might mean less intfacide that occurs when a male is deposed.)
But the infanticide may the power behind why trophy hunting controls the population. The new alpha male might eradicate ummm dozens? of youngsters? I don't knw how many breeding females there are in a pride, or size of litters.
That was kind of my point...

Killing a solo male keeps him from eating zebras and other animals. But if he survived and took over a pride, he'd kill the cubs, which means an even greater decrease in lion population. So, a lion cull might mean even more lions surviving to maturity.

Not sure if that would really happen, just a vague hypothesis.
 
That's a good point and was one we took into account. For the past 30 years, we've let all the Big Buck grow old and our neighbor has cooperated with us - so there is a lot of land available as a "Big Buck" Haven.

Nevertheless, these bucks just never grew Big Antlers like in the olden days (which are just huge compared to the biggest set we've taken in the past 40 years).

Another possibility: you've driven the deer to evolve through selection. They have smaller antlers because large antlers were selected against, but this decrease in antler size may not affect any other aspect of their fitness.

Would that be bad? Sure, in the sense that you like trophies with big antlers. But not necessarily in terms of the ecosystem and deer population health.

The only other thing we could think of was that maybe something else changed...something that gave an advantage to smaller Bucks.

Well of course something gave an advantage to smaller bucks: hunters. They preferentially kill big-antlered bucks.
 
1) Killing any lion leaves more meat on the hoof, even if the effect on the lion population is negligible.

2) Killing 1 pride lion (as opposed to a bachelor male) will most likely lead to the death of a handful of additional individuals from his pride: First, in the absence of a dominant male, the pride might be a bit more vulnerable to attack from hyenas or other lions. Next, when a new male does move in, he'll kill all the younglings. Thus, it's not too far-fetched for killing adult males to exert a bit of top-down population control.

3) Cecil's gone for one year and the park is 200 lions too many?

4) Racks of white-tailed deer are in part influenced by genetics and in part by age. The biggest determinant for antler growth, however, is nutrition. Over the past several decades, I suspect that the canopy has closed while the trees have matured. That slowly decreases forage quality for deer. Next, I bet there have been some fairly substantial land use changes in the surroundings. Acorns are fine for winter food, but it's protein in late spring–mid summer that will grow those racks big.
 
Seems I recall that the Boy Scouts had the rights to salvage the discarded antler in Yellowstone. They picked them all up, not letting them rot back into the soils. So there came the calcium depletion. Less calcium, smaller racks.

But also deer are browsers that like edge spaces- the edge of forest and field. Perhaps the latest farming techniques are to mow down the forest, plant more corn, leaving no edge for the deer.
 
One correction to previous posts. Solo male lions are scavengers. Males do not kill other animals (other than lion cubs). Only females do that. If a male lion has some females the females will do the killing and the males then come and eat what has been killed. The females and the cubs can have what the males does not want. A male lion is too visible for it to kill another animals.

Killing any male lions will not achieve much. You need to kill the cubs and female lions to control the population. Yes, this will need to be done by somebody. That is if there are no natural predators of the lions.
 
We I suppose they could mean that the population was already growing and now that the hunters are leaving, they'll have to take care of it themselves.
 
This. Not even a full year he's been gone, and already the population has exploded?
The population was already high, which is what ultimately got Cecil killed. There were already permits for hunts to lower the population, but one particular lion got killed who was a media darling. The resulting bad press made other hunters less likely to buy Safaris. The lions will still be culled. They can't escape that fate. Either culled by hunters in paid safaris, culled by park managers, or culled by starvation.

The only way out of a cull is expensive relocations to areas where lions are not overpopulated. The irony is that Zimbabwe can not afford it unless they sell paid hunts. So all these bleeding heart Belsky environmentalists actually have succeeded in doing is to insure more lions get killed, not less.
 
Last edited:
One correction to previous posts. Solo male lions are scavengers. Males do not kill other animals (other than lion cubs). Only females do that. If a male lion has some females the females will do the killing and the males then come and eat what has been killed. The females and the cubs can have what the males does not want. A male lion is too visible for it to kill another animals.

Killing any male lions will not achieve much. You need to kill the cubs and female lions to control the population. Yes, this will need to be done by somebody. That is if there are no natural predators of the lions.

Not sure if I missed your point(s) but these male lions seem to disagree.

http://www.viralbru.com/lions-attack-buffalo-right-in-front-of-tourists-in-kruger-national-park/

They might be pretending, but that buffalo is doing a pretty good impression of a dead thing.
 
Not sure if I missed your point(s) but these male lions seem to disagree.

http://www.viralbru.com/lions-attack-buffalo-right-in-front-of-tourists-in-kruger-national-park/

They might be pretending, but that buffalo is doing a pretty good impression of a dead thing.

Pride males are technically scavengers a lot of the time, coming in after the kill to the the "lion's share" for himself. As for lone males, of course they'll take a kill if they can, less work. But if they get hungry enough they'll get off their butts and hunt.
 
Not sure if I missed your point(s) but these male lions seem to disagree.

http://www.viralbru.com/lions-attack-buffalo-right-in-front-of-tourists-in-kruger-national-park/

They might be pretending, but that buffalo is doing a pretty good impression of a dead thing.

In addition to what was said in the previous post I would say that the manes of the lions was very short. We also do not know what happened before the movie started. Were the lions in hiding and the buffalo came too close? Or were the buffalo domesticated, ie did not know what a lion was?
 
The population was already high, which is what ultimately got Cecil killed. There were already permits for hunts to lower the population, but one particular lion got killed who was a media darling. The resulting bad press made other hunters less likely to buy Safaris. The lions will still be culled. They can't escape that fate. Either culled by hunters in paid safaris, culled by park managers, or culled by starvation.The only way out of a cull is expensive relocations to areas where lions are not overpopulated. The irony is that Zimbabwe can not afford it unless they sell paid hunts. So all these bleeding heart Belsky environmentalists actually have succeeded in doing is to insure more lions get killed, not less.

Why would they starve? Just send in some of those big bad hunters without their weapons, and the lions will have plenty to eat. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom