Your Friend the Virus

Nature (sometimes called "Mother" Nature) is just the personification of a set of laws that govern how living things survive and evolve.
 
My brief comment touched on a lot...
Not really. It was rather vague. I've asked for some clarification, but none has been offered in your response. What exactly do you mean when you say "nature is your friend" in the context of dismissing concerns for COVID-19? What exactly do you mean when you say "there is no 'random nature of reality'"?

I consider it to likely be a waste of time to discuss these issues here. Never argue with fundamentalists or how that book was titled.
It's feeling a bit like you lack confidence in your ability to provide a cogent defense of your statement, or even a clear explication of what you meant. Do you believe that nature has some agency and is actively protecting us? If so, why didn't it actively protect people from the Black Death, or any other natural disasters that killed masses of people?
 
Got a friend who thinks if things are pure and all natural, they are good for you. I offered a uranium sandwich with mercury dressing and a sprinkle of arsenic. We don't talk much anymore.

Must be an urban thing. Out here in God's country we give them a delicious pokeberry salad garnished with sauteed Amanita Verna and a little chopped deadly nightshade. They don't talk much. Why by sundown they hardly even whimper anymore!
 
Must be an urban thing. Out here in God's country we give them a delicious pokeberry salad garnished with sauteed Amanita Verna and a little chopped deadly nightshade. They don't talk much. Why by sundown they hardly even whimper anymore!

Poison is the weapon of the weak and the dishonest.
 
I think it worth mentioning that one of the common traits shared by conspiracy theorists is a fear of random events. Conspiracy theories are constructed and adhered to as a means of offering the believer a sense of security: if events can be perceived as being controlled, even if it is by a shadowy cabal, this is more reassuring than accepting that things do indeed happen by chance.
 
I think it worth mentioning that one of the common traits shared by conspiracy theorists is a fear of random events. Conspiracy theories are constructed and adhered to as a means of offering the believer a sense of security: if events can be perceived as being controlled, even if it is by a shadowy cabal, this is more reassuring than accepting that things do indeed happen by chance.

And that even the most powerful and influential people are ultimately about as organized and in control as a troop of capuchin monkeys clinging to a log in a violent river rapids.
 
Even the weakest fundamental force known kills an estimated 684,000 people annually, with no appreciable warning. Since the moment we are born (if not sooner), there are a plethora of natural organisms actively trying to kill us, as well as a multitude of natural substances everywhere able to do the same. Just go outside and start nibbling on random natural items - you'll soon be very ill, or very dead. Anytime the term "natural" is used as the main hype for a product, I chuckle to myself about the ignorance they are appealing to.
 
...
The pro-disease and "But muh freedums!" arguments don't bare the respect of being addressed for the billionth time just to listen to the same pre-recorded nonsense but the "But it's nature" fallacy is at least worth addressing.

It's nonsense.

There it's now been fully addressed.
:thumbsup:

I think that says it all. One could add that in the US alone the COVID death toll is over 900K, closing in on a million. Do you think anyone will throw a party for the remaining significant others of the guy who is the one millionth death? Perhaps it will be a whole congregation that will have a wake for the deceased.
 
Last edited:
I think it worth mentioning that one of the common traits shared by conspiracy theorists is a fear of random events. Conspiracy theories are constructed and adhered to as a means of offering the believer a sense of security: if events can be perceived as being controlled, even if it is by a shadowy cabal, this is more reassuring than accepting that things do indeed happen by chance.

Well, I never thought about it that way. It might explain religion. Or at least the religious impulse.
 
There’s only a very tiny part of nature that humans can even survive in. The surface of one planet. And not even very much of it. The majority - the vast majority of the universe is intensely hostile to human existence.
 
I do occaisionally wonder about whether a deterministic nature/reality can do or be random. For example, 'random', as in random mutations, is an important part of evolution.
I can understand this if random in this case means unknown, as in, we don't understand the pattern or sequence so we call it random.
 
Nature has no agency; does what it does, oblivious of human needs or wants. When we talk about respect for nature, what we're really saying is be careful out there, it'll **** you up. Nature can be beneficial, harmful, or in between; it isn't our friend nor our enemy, and doesn't care a **** about us. An icicle falling from a Chicago skyscraper and impaling you was just a random accident, but explainable through physics, though that doesn't make you less dead. We are also part of the natural world, thus the impulse to anthropomorphize it.

Just one opinion.

I'm not disagreeing with your highlighted above - but I will admit I would not make these claims with certainty.
re 'agency', because physics can explain an event doesn't mean there was no agency . . . physics can explain a toss of a ball for example. Re agency, does physics know anything about agency? We can detect muscle and nerve events, but not agency.
 
Randomness is critically important to Life. But you can even it out through massive reproduction numbers or error correcting mexhanisms.
 
Speaking of the wonderful life of nature and the evil conspiracy of the anti-natural, I mentioned in another thread, and will here again, the news I just read that the dreaded and widespread African "guinea worm" disease, a product of drinking infected water, has been nearly extinguished. In 1986 or so, there were over thirty million cases of the disease a year in 20 countries. Last year there were 14. The near-eradication of this disease is due to chemical purification of water, and education on drinking it. Guinea worms are very natural.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom