Your Friend the Virus

Foster Zygote

Dental Floss Tycoon
Joined
Jun 24, 2006
Messages
23,522
Over in the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum, Childlike Empress made the following post.

Childlike Empress said:
There is no "random nature of reality". That's an impression caused by a fundamentalist ideology. But that would be a topic for another thread and I have no intention to discuss it with you, because that would be a waste of time, at least at the moment. Free yourself from your fears. Nature is your friend.

This comment was made regarding COVID-19 conspiracy theories, but it seems to be diverting into territory more appropriate to this sub-forum.

I'm not sure if CE will participate in this discussion, but it seems to me that the belief that "Nature is our friend", and that there is no "random nature of reality" is more in line with common forms of fundamentalism than the opposite view. Without further clarification it's impossible to know if she's claiming that proper noun "Nature" has some agency that is concerned with our well-being. She's made it quite clear that she believes that COVID-19 is a hoax, but she seems here to be arguing that it can't be dangerous because "Nature is our friend". Given the vast losses of life, human and otherwise, throughout recorded, archaeological and geological history caused by natural forces, it seems rather a stretch to assert that we should free ourselves from fear or concern for natural disasters, be they geological, astronomical or biological, in the belief that "Nature is our friend".

Anyone else have thoughts on this?

CE, do you care to clarify what you meant by the above?
 
Last edited:
Over in the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum, Childlike Empress made the following post.



This comment was made regarding COVID-19 conspiracy theories, but it seems to be diverting into territory more appropriate to this sub-forum.

I'm not sure if CE will participate in this discussion, but it seems to me that the belief that "Nature is our friend", and that there is no "random nature of reality" is more in line with fundamentalism than the opposite view. Without further clarification it's impossible to know if she's claiming that proper noun "Nature" has some agency that is concerned with our well-being. She's made it quite clear that she believes that COVID-19 is a hoax, but she seems here to be arguing that it can't be dangerous because "Nature is our friend". Given the vast losses of life, human and otherwise, throughout recorded, archaeological and geological history caused by natural forces, it seems rather a stretch to assert that we should free ourselves from fear or concern for natural disasters, be they geological, astronomical or biological, in the belief that "Nature is our friend".

Anyone else have thoughts on this?

CE, do you care to clarify what you meant by the above?

Nature has no agency; does what it does, oblivious of human needs or wants. When we talk about respect for nature, what we're really saying is be careful out there, it'll **** you up. Nature can be beneficial, harmful, or in between; it isn't our friend nor our enemy, and doesn't care a **** about us. An icicle falling from a Chicago skyscraper and impaling you was just a random accident, but explainable through physics, though that doesn't make you less dead. We are also part of the natural world, thus the impulse to anthropomorphize it.

Just one opinion.
 
Nature has no agency; does what it does, oblivious of human needs or wants. When we talk about respect for nature, what we're really saying is be careful out there, it'll **** you up. Nature can be beneficial, harmful, or in between; it isn't our friend nor our enemy, and doesn't care a **** about us. An icicle falling from a Chicago skyscraper and impaling you was just a random accident, but explainable through physics, though that doesn't make you less dead. We are also part of the natural world, thus the impulse to anthropomorphize it.

Just one opinion.

But what about all those signs at Yellowstone that have a picture of a hiker feeding cheesy snacks to grizzly bears with the caption "Nature is your friend"?
 
Over in the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum, Childlike Empress made the following post.



This comment was made regarding COVID-19 conspiracy theories, but it seems to be diverting into territory more appropriate to this sub-forum.

I'm not sure if CE will participate in this discussion, but it seems to me that the belief that "Nature is our friend", and that there is no "random nature of reality" is more in line with common forms of fundamentalism than the opposite view. Without further clarification it's impossible to know if she's claiming that proper noun "Nature" has some agency that is concerned with our well-being. She's made it quite clear that she believes that COVID-19 is a hoax, but she seems here to be arguing that it can't be dangerous because "Nature is our friend". Given the vast losses of life, human and otherwise, throughout recorded, archaeological and geological history caused by natural forces, it seems rather a stretch to assert that we should free ourselves from fear or concern for natural disasters, be they geological, astronomical or biological, in the belief that "Nature is our friend".

Anyone else have thoughts on this?

CE, do you care to clarify what you meant by the above?


I have not "being clear" about COVID-19 being a hoax in the sense that the virus doesn't exist, actually I have been very clear that I'm on the fence about that, just a few days ago. What is clear to me, though, is that "the virus" doesn't in any shape or form justify the totalitarian methods we all had to suffer, which are rooted in different goals than caring for our health.

I'm not sure if I will participate in this thread. Depends on how it develops. My brief comment touched on a lot, I sure think you've openend the reply in the correct subforum. But as stated in your quote of mine, I consider it to likely be a waste of time to discuss these issues here. Never argue with fundamentalists or how that book was titled.
 
But what about all those signs at Yellowstone that have a picture of a hiker feeding cheesy snacks to grizzly bears with the caption "Nature is your friend"?

Just demonstrates the random nature of nature; one year you're feeding griz tasty treats, the next year griz thinks you're the tasty treat.
 
If nature is my friend it's apparently a friend who wants me to have lots of babies, watch half of them die, and be dead by the time I'm 40.

Personally I prefer civilisation.
 
Nature has no agency; does what it does, oblivious of human needs or wants. When we talk about respect for nature, what we're really saying is be careful out there, it'll **** you up. Nature can be beneficial, harmful, or in between; it isn't our friend nor our enemy, and doesn't care a **** about us. An icicle falling from a Chicago skyscraper and impaling you was just a random accident, but explainable through physics, though that doesn't make you less dead. We are also part of the natural world, thus the impulse to anthropomorphize it.
This.

In illustrated dictionaries of the English language, the entry for "indifference" should contain at least one close-up macro shot of nature.

(Indifference is closely related to insouciance, but nature can't be insouciant because "insouciance" is the name of an important human emotion.)

I'm not sure if CE will participate in this discussion, but it seems to me that the belief that "Nature is our friend", and that there is no "random nature of reality" is more in line with common forms of fundamentalism than the opposite view.
Fundamentalism also promotes the belief that Nature is our enemy.
 
n illustrated dictionaries of the English language, the entry for "indifference" should contain at least one close-up macro shot of nature.

Boy are you spot on here; I nominate a close-up of a griz consuming a bleating elk calf alive.
 
The late great iconoclast and editor of Analog Science Fiction once opined in one of his editorials that, "The first thing to recognize is that the Universe does not care". Explains much.
 
I'm not sure indifferent is a suitable word either as it's normally used to describe the mental state of a conscious entity, albeit an unemotional one.

Nature is not a conscious entity, it's a set of laws which are what they are. Good, bad, kind, cruel, indifferent ... none of them are appropriate adjectives for it.
 
I have not "being clear" about COVID-19 being a hoax in the sense that the virus doesn't exist, actually I have been very clear that I'm on the fence about that, just a few days ago. What is clear to me, though, is that "the virus" doesn't in any shape or form justify the totalitarian methods we all had to suffer, which are rooted in different goals than caring for our health.

I'm not sure if I will participate in this thread. Depends on how it develops. My brief comment touched on a lot, I sure think you've openend the reply in the correct subforum. But as stated in your quote of mine, I consider it to likely be a waste of time to discuss these issues here. Never argue with fundamentalists or how that book was titled.

Widely praised study from Johns Hopkins University states that the closing of restaurants and bars had a sizeable affect at reducing virus mortality.

And if the virus is fake, why around 400,000 extra deaths in 2020 and 2021? Or do you believe these numbers are all made up by the New World Order?
 
I have not "being clear" about COVID-19 being a hoax in the sense that the virus doesn't exist, actually I have been very clear that I'm on the fence about that, just a few days ago. What is clear to me, though, is that "the virus" doesn't in any shape or form justify the totalitarian methods we all had to suffer, which are rooted in different goals than caring for our health.

I'm not sure if I will participate in this thread. Depends on how it develops. My brief comment touched on a lot, I sure think you've openend the reply in the correct subforum. But as stated in your quote of mine, I consider it to likely be a waste of time to discuss these issues here. Never argue with fundamentalists or how that book was titled.

Not sure that anyone in this thread was necessarily planning on arguing with you. Depends what you, as the fundamentalist who thinks that nature is guided, actually has to say.
 
Nature has been rather overtly hostile IMO. Grey hair and wrinkles taking a toll on my boyish good looks, for a start. Gravity trying to do me in more often than not. Ocean seems pretty persistent about drowning my ass too. Not even getting into murder hornets and killer bees.
 
"Nature" is nothing more than a human conceit. A fiction used in vain attempt to make the complex simple.
 
"Nature will kill you and make new things out of you." - Welcome to Night Vale.

The pro-disease and "But muh freedums!" arguments don't bare the respect of being addressed for the billionth time just to listen to the same pre-recorded nonsense but the "But it's nature" fallacy is at least worth addressing.

It's nonsense.

There it's now been fully addressed.
 
Got a friend who thinks if things are pure and all natural, they are good for you. I offered a uranium sandwich with mercury dressing and a sprinkle of arsenic. We don't talk much anymore.
 
Got a friend who thinks if things are pure and all natural, they are good for you. I offered a uranium sandwich with mercury dressing and a sprinkle of arsenic. We don't talk much anymore.

But I presume he does have a healthy glow about him?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom