If the voices had nothing sensible to say why would I waste time listening to them. I certainly did not take any directives from them. The Yorkshire ripper did that and he was obviously not too bright.
I was going on what you stated...
"I spent two years trying to work out the voices and at the end of it I decided they were idiots, therefore I was an idiot for listening to them."
So in the sense that you were trying to work out the voices you were hearing but found nothing of intelligent value. I think mybe you are being far too hard on yourself to deduce from that, that you were being an idiot for making the effort.
The sensible voices could be male or female and only spoke briefly, usually to give me advice. They did not identify themselves.
Did you ever ask them to identify themselves?
One of the voices in my head was definitely female.
Are the voices distinguishable in relation to being individual? For example, was the one voice which was female, always the same female voice? (likewise for the male ones).
I already did that on the thread about going to a medium party. I said a female voice told me I would win on the lottery one hour before the draw, on the only occasion I did win.
I am not familiar with the thread - please give the link.
In the example you give here, I would say that this particular individual voice was offering you evidence of her existence and ability to give you truth regarding a future event.
The implications are interesting. Your ability in this is in being able to hear the voices.
When the predicted event eventuated, how did this make you feel in regard to the one female voice in your head? Have you developed any ongoing relationship with the female personality?
This discussion with you interests me greatly. I look at the internet as a kind of place where invisible individuals become 'voices in my head' although the voices are all 'sounding' like my own inner voice in my head...it is in how language is able to be communicated through writing and what is written then can be heard, (and visualized) and perhaps even listened to (acted on) depending on what is being said and how my bias might lean in relation to what is being said. (in relation to bias, I found it to be more the hindrance than the help and worked on ways to reduce it...mainly because it prevented me from hearing, let alone listening.)