WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Oystein:Millette is doing his stuff for serious academics, not for "twoofies".

To be fair, some twoofies are serious academics, including Harrit and some ae911 truthers. My annoying ginger cousin is a rather serious academic, and serious about this stuff although I don´t know if he is registered with any group. He is very smart but also crazy.

Originally Posted by jtl
Won´t all whole chips produce those spheres anyway, if they have a gray layer?
Oystein: Difficult to say. That would mean that the gray layer alone, stripped off the red layer, would produce such spheres if slowly heated to 700 °C? I think the iron-rich blobs that Harrit e.al. found are not all from the same source and process.

No, not gray layer alone, the red and gray together. Why would Millette chips not produce spheres given they have a gray layer? Do you think that some chips will while others won´t and that they are all paint? This is something my cousin keeps telling me, the paint/steel chips won´t produce spheres in 700(C) DSC.
 
Gamolon: Have they done tests on other materials, suspected of providing the same results (paint, resin, etc.), to prove that it was NOT any of those?

It has been said Millette will show us that the suspected culprit, paint, will provide the same results. Harrit says his chips are mixed like superthermite and perform like it with sharp energy release, with molten iron spheres after ignition.

This should not be a problem as long as the test is done in air and the samples have a gray layer. The twoofies don´t get it.
 
It has been said Millette will show us that the suspected culprit, paint, will provide the same results. Harrit says his chips are mixed like superthermite and perform like it with sharp energy release, with molten iron spheres after ignition.

This should not be a problem as long as the test is done in air and the samples have a gray layer. The twoofies don´t get it.

From the Bentham paper:
We would like to make detailed comparisons of the red chips with known super-thermite composites, along with comparisons of the products following ignition, but there are many forms of this high-tech thermite, and this comparison must wait for a future study.

Couldn't they determine the "form" this particular "superthermite" that was used based on the analysis of the unreacted material? I am assuming "form" means composition right?

Another question for someone to answer. How does Harrit suppose this "superthermite mixture was applied to the steel, or in what order? Was it mixed with the primer paint? Or was it applied directly on the steel and then the primer paint over it? Was it applied alone in certain areas between the primer paint?
 
"If Dr. Millette is so certain that his testing was infallible, where is the expected professional curiosity when a strong contradiction occurs?

It would appear that all Dr. Millette has to do is pop a few more red chip selects into the oven (now set at 430C plus), and then observe and explain that 'ash'.

You know, like Dr. Harrit and his group of scientists did.

The beauty of complex chemical engineering is that you can create unexpected yet dramatic behaviour.

Take C4 for example. It can catch fire and burn itself out. It will never detonate that way.

But ignite it properly, and you have an incredibly powerful explosive.

So turn up the damn oven and take a look."
"Here, I can agree with you. Millette can do this simple experiment. Only I doubt that he can really explain expected microspheres in the "ash" in detail (which processes exactly took place), but I can be wrong:cool: This is just my opinion.
Just a question (to be sure): do you believe that chips would do exactly the same things when heated in DSC device and in ordinary oven, respectively (considering the same/very similar heating rate)?

(The rest of your post is again weird. There is simply no way how the chips with the composition of paints (kaolinite as pigment, no proper oxidant for polymeric binder) can be miraculously transformed into deadly pyrotechnics. These chips were materials employed for the protection of WTC steel, not for its destruction.)

Regarding your question; "do you believe that chips would do exactly the same things when heated in DSC device and in ordinary oven, respectively (considering the same/very similar heating rate)?"

With the DSC, the scientists reported using a "rising temperature method of ignition", but they also tested with flame-ignition.

Harrit et al said:
"In a later flame-ignition test, the end product was recovered and is shown in the photomicrograph and SEM image inFig. (23). Once again, the formation of iron-rich semi-spherical shapes shows that the residue had been melted, enabling surface tension of the liquid to pull it into spherical shapes. However, the evidence obtained in the DSC analyses is more compelling that a thermitic reaction actually occurs as in that case ignition is observed when the red material is heated to no more than 430 ̊C."

Based on my reading of the paper, I would expect a finding of iron-rich microspheres and/or iron-rich debris.

Harrit et al said:
"…A conventional quantitative analysis routine was used to estimate the elemental contents. In the case of this iron-rich spheroid, the iron content exceeds the oxygen content by approximately a factor of two, so substantial elemental iron must be present. This result was repeated in other iron-rich spheroids in the post-DSC sample as well as in spots in the residue which did not form into spheres. Spheroids were observed with Fe:O ratios up to approximately 4:1. Other iron-rich spheres were found in the post-DSC residue which contained iron along with aluminum and oxygen…"

I hope this answers your question.

MM
 
Gamolon:

Couldn't they determine the "form" this particular "superthermite" that was used based on the analysis of the unreacted material? I am assuming "form" means composition right?

Apparently they already said the chips look like "sol gel superthermite" but that is a very broad term, like "alcohol". I think their actual hypothesis is even more vague "active thermitic material".

Another question for someone to answer. How does Harrit suppose this "superthermite mixture was applied to the steel, or in what order? Was it mixed with the primer paint? Or was it applied directly on the steel and then the primer paint over it? Was it applied alone in certain areas between the primer paint?

He does not say at all, only offers possibilities. I am not sure how much an issue this is, if they would actually prove the chips are explosive or "thermitic" it would be hard to deny that they had to be used for demolition, but that seems so incredible it can hardly be true. Millette should be able to make this all go away with some DSC tests and paint with gray metal layer.
 
Millette should be able to make this all go away with some DSC tests and paint with gray metal layer.

Do you think that if Millette does some DSC tests, truthers are going to lay down and turn off the money making machine :confused:

Just to add: If my understanding is correct ? Al was missing from theses chips, how can DSC testing produce Al ?
 
Last edited:
Do you think that if Millette does some DSC tests, truthers are going to lay down and turn off the money making machine :confused:

I think we should not completely dismiss the impact this kind of study can have. Often belief or curiosity about conspiracy theories is along the lines of, "Hey, did you hear that...[something]?" If word gets around that an independent study found that the "nano-thermite" was actually paint all along, that can make a difference. Perhaps.

I admit, I am influenced here by recently looking back at birther claims. Before Obama released the photocopy of the original form of his birth certificate, many skeptics said that doing so would make no difference. While there are still birthers, releasing the copy made a difference.

I suppose that was a bit more high profile, to put it mildly. But still, the Harritt et al paper was so important to truthers because it was just about the only thing they could point to that was not an out of context quote or a dubious cui bono argument. Tangible evidence of something the military uses to destroy stuff! A clear refutation won't convince the hard core, but it can help put it over the edge for those who have been intrigued by "The Truth" but have become disappointed by the failure. After all, aren't several members here former truthers?

Wait, does this have anything to do with DSC? Maybe not. Umm.
 
Based on my reading of the paper, I would expect a finding of iron-rich microspheres and/or iron-rich debris.

I hope this answers your question.

MM, are you aware of any suggestions among the 9/11 Truth community on how such a thin layer of thermitic material might eat through much greater thicknesses of steel?

What I'm getting at here is that a spark of static electricty or a spark from a kiddies' sparkler might run to a very high temperature indeed, but they won't even damage your hand. Just as tinfoil straight from a hot oven will be handleable in a few seconds whereas the steel or ceramic baking tray will burn you for some minutes after you take it out.

High temperature <> lots of heat.

Just a link would do.
 
"MM, are you aware of any suggestions among the 9/11 Truth community on how such a thin layer of thermitic material might eat through much greater thicknesses of steel?"

The most interesting conjecture that I've heard, and I'm sure you've encountered it as well, is that the nanothermite discovered in the WTC dust by Dr. Harrit et al, was actually designed to ignite around 430C.

As the conjecture goes, the purpose was not to; "eat through much greater thicknesses of steel", but to create a momentary flash temperature high enough to trigger the self-sustaining ignition of a large volume of thermite or thermate which would eat through much greater thicknesses of steel.

MM
 
Spanx: Do you think that if Millette does some DSC tests, truthers are going to lay down and turn off the money making machine

He might at least stop the rumors about bombs. It might stop the hoard of "truthers" from growing more. Maybe the government could do something also to stop the theories. I do agree with truthers up to a point about some issues, like that it is possible that there was some cover-up of incompetence and corruption, and that the investigations may have been fishy. This is the kind of stuff that breeds conspiracy theories. And I agree that fishy investigations may be convenient to keep the wars going. Still no inside job.

GlennB: how such a thin layer of thermitic material might eat through much greater thicknesses of steel?

Why should the layer have been so thin? Maybe it´s just a fragment of a thick piece? Maybe just meant to ignite something bigger? I think this sort of assumption is a dead end.

We show that redgray paint chips do the same as Harrit chips and thats it.
 
He does not say at all, only offers possibilities. I am not sure how much an issue this is, if they would actually prove the chips are explosive or "thermitic" it would be hard to deny that they had to be used for demolition, [...]
Explosive = boom - not heard during the collapse. Denied.
Thermitic = bright flashes - not seen during the collapse. Denied.

No matter whether it was either explosive or thermitic, it was not used to demolish anything.

Just a reality check.

ETA: And if that's not enough, as Beachnut puts it in a different thread:
No steel shows signs thermite was used. No steel shows blast effects.
 
Last edited:
He might at least stop the rumors about bombs. It might stop the hoard of "truthers" from growing more. Maybe the government could do something also to stop the theories. I do agree with truthers up to a point about some issues, like that it is possible that there was some cover-up of incompetence and corruption, and that the investigations may have been fishy. This is the kind of stuff that breeds conspiracy theories. And I agree that fishy investigations may be convenient to keep the wars going. Still no inside

Millette doing DSC tests will not stop anything, truther will say he has the wrong chips, or he was paid off etc. Truthers want to believe in bombs, have a look on YouTube comments that's where they breed.

It's simple no Al no thermite

As far as I am aware Millette's studies are not fully complete ? As far as the thruthers response, what scientific explanation has been given. " he didn't do DSC and has the wrong chips " what about the fact there is no Al. Jones on 911 blogger says he is to busy to talk about it.

Why won't truthers share there chips ?
 
Last edited:
The most interesting conjecture that I've heard, and I'm sure you've encountered it as well, is that the nanothermite discovered in the WTC dust by Dr. Harrit et al, was actually designed to ignite around 430C.

As the conjecture goes, the purpose was not to; "eat through much greater thicknesses of steel", but to create a momentary flash temperature high enough to trigger the self-sustaining ignition of a large volume of thermite or thermate which would eat through much greater thicknesses of steel.

MM

Presumably not, though, as a passive trigger that would happen to ignite when the local temperature reached 430. That would make whether and when the triggers fired a very unpredicatable event. In fact the initial fireballs would set off a good deal of it and a good deal more might never reach that temperature.

So, a trigger set off by what? A radio-controlled device? If so then the thin layer of nano-thermite is worse than redundant, it's a hindrance. It's also a lot of unnecessary work. Just rely on the 'device'.

No, this proposed reason for the presence of the layer still makes no sense.

Any more ideas?
 
jtl:
Thanks for joining us;)

You should read not only this whole thread, but also some older red-gray chips threads to have some closer idea what we know, what is not so sure etc.

Anyway, some remarks regarding your posts from my points of view:

"Maybe Millette chips are not all the same? His paper is not as neat as Harrit paper and this is a weakness. Why give twoofies the ammo? This is why I suggest Millette follow Harrit "to the letter", and maybe he could actually narrow down the pool of chips that match Harrit."

Indeed, it is very natural/plausible presumption that Millette's chips are not all the same (as well as Harrit's chips). After analyzing results here, it seems that most of Millette's chips are Laclede paint, some others are perhaps Tnemec paint. There are perhaps also some other paint chips (e.g.with Ti stuffs), but we are not sure. Ti can be contaminant. Harrit's paper perhaps look neater than Millette's one, since Harrit et al presorted results/chips with the aim to come to some specific conlusion ("thermite"). This is not basically a wrong approach (choosing only some results), it's quite normal in science. Anyway, fortunately for us, Harrit's results as for chips (a) to (d) indicate one specific paint (Laclede). On the other hand, Millette's results are not so unambigous in some respects (namely, various methods of purificication of chips prior XEDS measurements lead to different results and only XEDS spectra taken on freshly cut surfaces seem to be reliable).

"The ignition tests are missing, and I think Millette could have followed other tests more closely, such as showing that chips remain brittle after MEK and as I already told Sunstealer I think there is too much XEDS clutter to rule out differences."

Millette indeed tested some chips in contact with MEK (and also with other solvents); they behaved like "MEK chip" in Bentham paper. i.e. they were only swollen/softened in MEK. I'm a polymer chemist with a long experience, so I can tell you for sure: not only Tnemec paint, but also Laclede paint and any other paint with crosslinked polymer binder are supposed to behave exactly like this: they can only swell in any solvent (they can not be dissolved). After the solvent evaporation, they can be brittle.
And yes, there is some "clutter" in Millette's XEDS results and Sunstealer chose only spectra corresponding to Laclede (exactly like Harrit;)). This "clutter" is apparently connected with the manner of chips preparation/purification prior measurements and you would know more after reading this whole thread. Without doing this, you are necessarily confused.

"It seems to assume that there was no structure to Harrit paper and that chips a to d somehow did not represent chips tested via MEK and ignition. And isn´t the main spectra for chips "a to d" supposed to be clean surface(no ti) vs contaminated MEK and ignition chips?"

You are basically right and all this stuff has been debated here ad nauseam. Juts one detail: we do not know anything about "ignition chips" prior ignition, Harrit forgot to tell us what was their composition/how they looked. Anyway, "ignition tests" in Bentham papers belong to the badly chosen tests with zero scientific value (similarly to eletrical conductivity tets). Tests were done using oxyacetylene torch with extremely hot flame (ca 3000 degrees C and more), which should easily ignite/melt anything.

"Why would Millette chips not produce spheres given they have a gray layer? Do you think that some chips will while others won´t and that they are all paint? This is something my cousin keeps telling me, the paint/steel chips won´t produce spheres in 700(C) DSC"

We simply do not know. There is zero scientific literature available dealing with the behavior of paints on rust heated to 700 degrees (except Bentham paper;). This is not interesting topic, so nobody has cared so far. Personally, I think that some rust scales attached to some paints would be transformed into microspheres, some others would not be. But this is just my guess. And the meaning of your cousin is simply irrelevant.

"Harrit says his chips are mixed like superthermite and perform like it with sharp energy release, with molten iron spheres after ignition."

Whereas the second part is basically correct, the first part is a pure, utter nonsense! You seem to try to stay neutral here, so please, do not repeat/do not believe apparent lies of Harrit et al. There was no sharp energy release shown anywhere in Bentham paper! The release of heat took several minutes (according to DSC device)! Please, try to come back to the plain facts/reality, otherwise no rational debate is possible.

"Apparently they already said the chips look like "sol gel superthermite" but that is a very broad term, like "alcohol". I think their actual hypothesis is even more vague "active thermitic material".

They said that, but this is again lie/nonsense/wishfull thinking, since chips don't look like any "sol gel superthermite" at all. In any sol-gel thermite preparation, only low molar mass stuffs are created, no polymer is formed. And, in all red-gray chips closely analyzed, some polymeric binder strongly prevailed (which is incompatible with any pyrotechnics without proper oxidant for this polymer, if the polymer is not fluorinated, which is not the case here).

"I do agree with truthers up to a point about some issues, like that it is possible that there was some cover-up of incompetence and corruption, and that the investigations may have been fishy. This is the kind of stuff that breeds conspiracy theories. And I agree that fishy investigations may be convenient to keep the wars going. Still no inside job."

I agree:o

"Why should the layer have been so thin? Maybe it´s just a fragment of a thick piece?"

This possibility (chips can be fragments of thick piece) had been torn apart into tiny pieces long ago here. There is simply no even closely reasonable truthers explanation, why active thermite layers should be diluted by inactive iron oxide (rust) layers, which can "serve" only as heat sinks and can only stop/preclude any thermitic reaction. (For me, there are also some other strong contra-arguments available, e.g.: alleged "thick piece" consisting of many multilayers in a fashion "red-gray-red-gray-red-gray-etc. layer) cannot be "delaminated" only to bilayers "red-gray", which we see in Bentham paper as well as in Millette's report. In such a case, also some other objects with more than two layers should be always and frequently found in WTC dust. At least I think so.)

I hope that this will help to understand our findings/opinions here (well, at least my findings/opinion):cool:
 
Last edited:
The most interesting conjecture that I've heard, and I'm sure you've encountered it as well, is that the nanothermite discovered in the WTC dust by Dr. Harrit et al, was actually designed to ignite around 430C.

As the conjecture goes, the purpose was not to; "eat through much greater thicknesses of steel", but to create a momentary flash temperature high enough to trigger the self-sustaining ignition of a large volume of thermite or thermate which would eat through much greater thicknesses of steel.

MM



I dare you to provide a link! Don't worry, I know you won't!
 
"…Indeed, it is very natural/plausible presumption that Millette's chips are not all the same (as well as Harrit's chips). After analyzing results here, it seems that most of Millette's chips are Laclede paint, some others are perhaps Tnemec paint. There are perhaps also some other paint chips (e.g.with Ti stuffs), but we are not sure. Ti can be contaminant. Harrit's paper perhaps look neater than Millette's one, since Harrit et al presorted results/chips with the aim to come to some specific conlusion ("thermite"). This is not basically a wrong approach (choosing only some results), it's quite normal in science. Anyway, fortunately for us, Harrit's results as for chips (a) to (d) indicate one specific paint (Laclede). On the other hand, Millette's results are not so unambigous in some respects (namely, various methods of purificication of chips prior XEDS measurements lead to different results and only XEDS spectra taken on freshly cut surfaces seem to be reliable).

Unquestionably, since the structural steel in the WTC was coated with primer paint, a lot of primer paint chips would exist in the WTC dust.

But the chips that Dr. Harrit et al found to be thermitic, do not behave the same way as chips from steel primer paint.

You have decided that all the red chips are either Tnemec or LaClede primer paint, despite contrary evidence provided by both Dr. Harrit (tested original WTC-sourced steel primer paint, Tnemec, and a study on epoxy paint, both of which produced basically ash in the DSC, and no iron-rich microspheres), and Dr. Millette (could not find evidence of LaClede).

MM
 
You have decided that all the red chips are either Tnemec or LaClede primer paint, despite contrary evidence provided by both Dr. Harrit (tested original WTC-sourced steel primer paint, Tnemec, and a study on epoxy paint, both of which produced basically ash in the DSC, and no iron-rich microspheres), and Dr. Millette (could not find evidence of LaClede).

MM

Are you claiming that the chips that produced the "micro-spheres" did not include the gray layer? Do you have evidence of this?

Can you tell us what chips did produce the "micro-spheres"?
 
Last edited:
Ivan Kminek: You should read not only this whole thread, but also some older red-gray chips threads to have some closer idea what we know, what is not so sure etc.

My cousin introduced me to all these debates years ago, and I have checked on them once in a while so I am familiar with most theories. Given my cousin´s education and research into this I have a pretty high standard.
I am educated also but in other fields, but I do know what good research is about, and real data.

Indeed, it is very natural/plausible presumption that Millette's chips are not all the same (as well as Harrit's chips). After analyzing results here, it seems that most of Millette's chips are Laclede paint, some others are perhaps Tnemec paint. There are perhaps also some other paint chips (e.g.with Ti stuffs), but we are not sure.

But this will not do. This implies there are at least 3 unidentified kinds of redgray chips that are lumped together into one, and leaves open the claim that some chips are evidently not paint (when ignited). This is not the way to close the case.

they behaved like "MEK chip" in Bentham paper. i.e. they were only swollen/softened in MEK.

I can´t remember, does Millette say that chips remain hard? Then was that all the different kinds of chips?

Juts one detail: we do not know anything about "ignition chips" prior ignition, Harrit forgot to tell us what was their composition/how they looked. Anyway, "ignition tests" in Bentham papers belong to the badly chosen tests with zero scientific value (similarly to eletrical conductivity tets). Tests were done using oxyacetylene torch with extremely hot flame (ca 3000 degrees C and more), which should easily ignite/melt anything.

I commented on this before, and again I don´t think this is a strong argument because it just assumes that the ignited chips are not the ones described in the paper. This would be fraud. There was also DSC with only 700 degrees.

There is zero scientific literature available dealing with the behavior of paints on rust heated to 700 degrees (except Bentham paper. This is not interesting topic, so nobody has cared so far.

I don´t agree, the main point of Harrit paper seems to be that the chips ignite and make very high temperatures while paint does not. We don´t need literature to falsify those claims, some tests will do the trick. Someone could have shut up those truthers long ago with these tests.

There was no sharp energy release shown anywhere in Bentham paper! The release of heat took several minutes (according to DSC device)! Please, try to come back to the plain facts/reality, otherwise no rational debate is possible.

The paper compares the DSC release to known superthermite paper and it seems like a fact that they are similar. Harrit does not compare it to paint so I can´t be sure that there is anything special about it. Millette also fails to do this
 
Ivan Kminek: They said that, but this is again lie/nonsense/wishfull thinking, since chips don't look like any "sol gel superthermite" at all. In any sol-gel thermite preparation, only low molar mass stuffs are created, no polymer is formed.

It seems the chips are similar on the surface, with same basic ingredients and looks, but paints do have some similarities also. The solgel process may have started as a way to make paints. The best way to confirm there is nothing special about the chips would be to show that there is nothing special about the ignition results.

This possibility (chips can be fragments of thick piece) had been torn apart into tiny pieces long ago here.

It is just my opinion that these sort of arguments are weak. If there had been larger pieces then it does not seem impossible that explosive force could leave behind tiny fragments of the material and whatever it was attached to. Arguing about this kind of stuff gets us nowhere because it looks like avoiding Harrit. Much better to just falsify his hypothesis.
 
@jtl

Perhaps you could explain some thing to me. What is written below is from the bentham paper. I am assuming it relates to MM,s post above.

Why would it be necessary to use this thermite to ignite high explosives after exploding an aircraft in the building ? It also states that NIST admits it did not look for high explosives residue. If NIST was hiding something, why not just say they looked for explosive residue and could not find any ?




[The red material does burn quickly as shown in the DSC, and we have observed a bright flash on ignition, but determi- nation of the burn rate of the red material may help to classify this as a slow or fast explosive. It may be that this material is used not as a cutter-charge itself, but rather as a means to ig- nite high explosives, as in super-thermite matches [30]. Hav- ing observed unignited thermitic material in the WTC residue, we suggest that other energetic materials suitable for cutter charges or explosives should also be looked for in the WTC dust. NIST has admitted that they have not yet looked for such residues [11].]
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom