jtl:
Thanks for joining us
You should read not only this whole thread, but also some older red-gray chips threads to have some closer idea what we know, what is not so sure etc.
Anyway, some remarks regarding your posts from my points of view:
"Maybe Millette chips are not all the same? His paper is not as neat as Harrit paper and this is a weakness. Why give twoofies the ammo? This is why I suggest Millette follow Harrit "to the letter", and maybe he could actually narrow down the pool of chips that match Harrit."
Indeed, it is very natural/plausible presumption that Millette's chips are not all the same (as well as Harrit's chips). After analyzing results here, it seems that most of Millette's chips are Laclede paint, some others are perhaps Tnemec paint. There are perhaps also some other paint chips (e.g.with Ti stuffs), but we are not sure. Ti can be contaminant. Harrit's paper perhaps look neater than Millette's one, since Harrit et al presorted results/chips with the aim to come to some specific conlusion ("thermite"). This is not basically a wrong approach (choosing only some results), it's quite normal in science. Anyway, fortunately for us, Harrit's results as for chips (a) to (d) indicate one specific paint (Laclede). On the other hand, Millette's results are not so unambigous in some respects (namely, various methods of purificication of chips prior XEDS measurements lead to different results and only XEDS spectra taken on freshly cut surfaces seem to be reliable).
"The ignition tests are missing, and I think Millette could have followed other tests more closely, such as showing that chips remain brittle after MEK and as I already told Sunstealer I think there is too much XEDS clutter to rule out differences."
Millette indeed tested some chips in contact with MEK (and also with other solvents); they behaved like "MEK chip" in Bentham paper. i.e. they were only swollen/softened in MEK. I'm a polymer chemist with a long experience, so I can tell you for sure: not only Tnemec paint, but also Laclede paint and any other paint with crosslinked polymer binder are supposed to behave exactly like this: they can only swell in any solvent
(they can not be dissolved). After the solvent evaporation, they can be brittle.
And yes, there is some "clutter" in Millette's XEDS results and Sunstealer chose only spectra corresponding to Laclede (exactly like Harrit

). This "clutter" is apparently connected with the manner of chips preparation/purification prior measurements and you would know more after reading this whole thread. Without doing this, you are necessarily confused.
"It seems to assume that there was no structure to Harrit paper and that chips a to d somehow did not represent chips tested via MEK and ignition. And isn´t the main spectra for chips "a to d" supposed to be clean surface(no ti) vs contaminated MEK and ignition chips?"
You are basically right and all this stuff has been debated here
ad nauseam. Juts one detail: we do not know anything about "ignition chips" prior ignition, Harrit forgot to tell us what was their composition/how they looked. Anyway, "ignition tests" in Bentham papers belong to the badly chosen tests with zero scientific value (similarly to eletrical conductivity tets). Tests were done using oxyacetylene torch with extremely hot flame (ca 3000 degrees C and more), which should easily ignite/melt anything.
"Why would Millette chips not produce spheres given they have a gray layer? Do you think that some chips will while others won´t and that they are all paint? This is something my cousin keeps telling me, the paint/steel chips won´t produce spheres in 700(C) DSC"
We simply do not know. There is zero scientific literature available dealing with the behavior of paints on rust heated to 700 degrees
(except Bentham paper
. This is not interesting topic, so nobody has cared so far. Personally, I think that some rust scales attached to some paints would be transformed into microspheres, some others would not be. But this is just my guess. And the meaning of your cousin is simply irrelevant.
"Harrit says his chips are mixed like superthermite and perform like it with sharp energy release, with molten iron spheres after ignition."
Whereas the second part is basically correct, the first part is a pure, utter nonsense! You seem to try to stay neutral here, so please, do not repeat/do not believe apparent lies of Harrit et al.
There was no sharp energy release shown anywhere in Bentham paper! The release of heat took several minutes (according to DSC device)! Please, try to come back to the plain facts/reality, otherwise no rational debate is possible.
"Apparently they already said the chips look like "sol gel superthermite" but that is a very broad term, like "alcohol". I think their actual hypothesis is even more vague "active thermitic material".
They said that, but this is again lie/nonsense/wishfull thinking, since chips don't look like any "sol gel superthermite" at all. In any sol-gel thermite preparation, only low molar mass stuffs are created, no polymer is formed. And, in all red-gray chips closely analyzed, some polymeric binder strongly prevailed
(which is incompatible with any pyrotechnics without proper oxidant for this polymer, if the polymer is not fluorinated, which is not the case here).
"I do agree with truthers up to a point about some issues, like that it is possible that there was some cover-up of incompetence and corruption, and that the investigations may have been fishy. This is the kind of stuff that breeds conspiracy theories. And I agree that fishy investigations may be convenient to keep the wars going. Still no inside job."
I agree
"Why should the layer have been so thin? Maybe it´s just a fragment of a thick piece?"
This possibility (chips can be fragments of thick piece) had been torn apart into tiny pieces long ago here. There is simply no even closely reasonable truthers explanation, why active thermite layers should be diluted by inactive iron oxide (rust) layers, which can "serve" only as heat sinks and can only stop/preclude any thermitic reaction.
(For me, there are also some other strong contra-arguments available, e.g.: alleged "thick piece" consisting of many multilayers in a fashion "red-gray-red-gray-red-gray-etc. layer) cannot be "delaminated" only to bilayers "red-gray", which we see in Bentham paper as well as in Millette's report. In such a case, also some other objects with more than two layers should be always and frequently found in WTC dust. At least I think so.)
I hope that this will help to understand our findings/opinions here (well, at least my findings/opinion)
