WTC conspiracy theory giving me problems

you should not worry about 9-11 CT to the point that it gives you a problem. that's sooooo 2006.
 
I'm starting to understand the powerful negative vibes eminating fom the JREF. jamesraio, the issue of thermite, the so-called publication about its use at the WTC, and Bentham publications has been gone over ad nauseum on this forum.

Bentham journals are not journals in any sense that you are describing them. They do not review papers. They simply publish what is sent to them after the contributors pay a fee. This has been written about extensively here and elsewhere.

NIST and FEMA are not the only groups to have researched the WTC collapse. There is a vast published literature on this and it has been posted here several times. For example, a group from Ching Hwa University in China published a series of papers on the WTC collapse.

Finally, there's just the common sense point that this talk about thermite makes no sense at all. As I stated here http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=157289
This is simply amazing. The amount of research on nano-thermite is so much more than I ever imagined. It's going on everywhere. It almost seems that the entire US scientific community is mobolized around the idea of advancements in nanothermite. No wonder the technology was so developed in 2001 that it could be used to demolish the largest building in the world.

How are these scientists connected to the actual demolishion of the WTC? Which ones produced the thermite that was used? Name some names. It's amazing how quite the thermite community is staying on this considering they must have deep understanding of what happened that day. Any ideas on why that could be?

I'm so glad you posted this document again. I feel so much convinced knowing that nano-thermite research is so much more developed than I ever imagined.
 
you should not worry about 9-11 CT to the point that it gives you a problem. that's sooooo 2006.

Actually, this is the cutting edge of Truther Talk. If you're dealing with the dwebbs outside of this range, they've just discovered thermite and AE911.
 
you're learning :) After a while you get sick of these guys.

I don't want to discourage the guy from asking questions, but he sure does look like someone pretending to ask about what he thinks is a hard question. He knows there's no real answer to the problem of thermite and we've just been ignoring it. And just to prove it, he's asked us once again to explain about the amazing high-quality world of Bentham publications.

But hay, I'm just a reviewer for history journals. What do I know?

jamesraio, just keep asking your questions. But please try to keep in mind that you are just kind of coming across like a Truther pretending to ask questions. If you really want this explained once again, I'll do it. But the information really is already on the forum.
 
Really, even that's beisde the fact. What's more compelling is the fact that even if it WAS thermite, it would be WAY to thin to do any adverse structural damage to the steel and would burn off with out doing much more then scorching the steel (if that). The Thermite theory was never logical.

This is a point that shouldn't be ignored. We can argue the minutiae of the research Jones, Harrit, and others have done, but that's losing sight of the forest to concentrate on the branches on a tree. The reality is that any thermite or explosives (or thermite detonating explosives; seriously, that's one of the propositions Steven Jones has forwarded) is flatly, utterly contradicted by the state of the debris itself. I keep telling conspiracy peddlers that, if you want me to take your explosives or thermite proposals seriously, go to NCSTAR 1-3C - a subreport detailing the state of recovered steel columns from under the collapse initiation zone - and point out which of those steel columns were the ones explosively separated or cut with thermite. Given their locations in the towers, if there were any columns at all that would be targeted for severance, these would have to be among them. So far, not a single conspiracy peddler has even tried to address that.

The fact of the matter is that the columns only show signs of stress from being buckled, bent, and otherwise distorted in all sorts of directions due to the tower losing structural integrity and being forced apart by the descending upper floors. The state of the debris very clearly shows that during the collapse the floors were forcibly separated from the columns - the state of the connection points between the floor trusses and columns prove this - and the columns, thus losing lateral support, lost any ability to stay standing, much less resist downward force. The debris tells us how the towers came apart, and they all show that they did not come apart due to explosives. If that was the case, we'd see the effects on the recovered steel. We do not.

That right there is the real rebuttal to any explosives or thermite/nanothermite proposal. We dive into the Bentham paper as an intellectual exercise, but no one needs to do that to refute the overall concept it tries to support.
 
I don't want to discourage the guy from asking questions, but he sure does look like someone pretending to ask about what he thinks is a hard question. He knows there's no real answer to the problem of thermite and we've just been ignoring it. And just to prove it, he's asked us once again to explain about the amazing high-quality world of Bentham publications..

He's still nothing compared with the guy whos currently trolling one of my videos . Look at the ridiculous lengths he is going to defend Griffins claim. I didnt take long to figure out these people are idiots once I tried getting them to self correct and take responsibilty for their false claims.
 
Last edited:
That "article" was peer reviewed by scientists outside of the twoofer circle and the so-called nano thermite was found to be nothing but paint chips. Furthermore, the samples they used for testing had no chain of custody and we're turned in years after 9/11.

But one of the funniest parts about the Controlled Demo CT is that there are some seriously fundamental flaws in their logic.

First off, thermite would have been painfully obvious to anyone who watched the videos, in which you can clearly see the core clumns still standing for a few seconds after initial collapse...SUPRIZE!!! No glowing orange crap on the cores or on any other parts of the collapsed debris, other than a couple of isolated areas, which thermal imaging suggested was a result of the melted aluminum from the plane.

Secondly, the man power and expense of setting up such an operation would have been astronomical, which would quickly dismiss the likelyhood of these people having anything to gain from such an operation.

Third...You have a plethora of verifiable quotes from firefighters that confirm the inevitable collapse of all three buildings, due to fire alone...

Welcome to the forums!!! I'm a recovering Truther myself and glad to have joined the NWO.

Greetings Former Truther, I'm glad to have stumbled upon you and to let you know that I am also a Former Truther!

Maybe I should start another thread on this subject but I'm just curious, what made you change your mind about the 9/11 Truth Movement? For me, it was many things. Although I think what saved me the most was the fact that I never completely bought into the conspiracy as a whole, I did feel that there were issues that weren't answered and... oh yes, I was also tuning into Alex Jones' podcast on a daily basis.

It wasn't until I viewed the Alex Jones/Mark Roberts confrontation from Ground Zero video on Google that I realized that Jones is nothing more than a pudgy liar and his minions are nothing but Jones Drones. Now, I didn't buy into Mark Roberts' debunking at first either. To be honest, that particular video got me angry at Roberts. So I started doing my own research and after reading several articles on the destruction of the WTC, the Pentagon crash and especially the crash in Shanksville I realized this "Truth" movement has been absolutely WRONG all along. As much as Alex Jones will get on his show and say that people are waking up to their "truth" it's nothing but a lie. The people who make up the Truth movement now are nothing but the hardcore wackos who will probably never learn about facts, evidence, or empirical data.
 
In a conversation via email with real scientist Frank Greening, Steven Jones admitted that the thermite they found was likely used for fuses to ignite conventional explosives.

http://the911forum.freeforums.org/active-thermitic-material-in-wtc-dust-t150-30.html

Go to Dr.G. post #479

SO you see, their new hybrid (and bizarre) theory involves both...lol

TAM:)

Yeah, no kidding. That's utterly schizophrenic. What Jones fails to see is that in combining the "benefits" of both theories, he also opens himself to being falsified from both directions. We all know that thermite couldn't have been used due to the lack of effects on the steel; we also know that explosives weren't used for the same reason plus the lack of effect on neighboring buildings as well as human beings in the vicinity. Yet, combining the theses doesn't solve either problem. Funny, that.

Jones is intelligent enough to realize this, but his audience is gullible enough to not even think of it. That's another reason I'm cynical about Jones: He's surfing on the adulation of naifs, and has to realize it. Yet it doesn't seem to bother him. If that's not the behavior of a budding cult figure, I don't know what is.
 
"In a conversation via email with real scientist Frank Greening, Steven Jones admitted that the thermite they found was likely used for fuses to ignite conventional explosives."

will someone please pay the 9-11 Sheepers to come up with one, single, unified CT?
 
I have no more questions, I say near the beginning of this thread they have been answered. It appears people are projecting onto me what they suspect me to be, not what I actually am. I of course know that any Bentham journal is not a high up there journal, though there are quite a few peer reviewed online journals with fast publication times that get legit articles (usually exploited by "scholars" to pad their resumes). I worked for one a few years ago.

As for me, an article I wrote in the field of philosophical history is finally being published after 3 years. I'm sure if I was a big name, perhaps it would have taken quicker.


Proof of my anti-truth credentials, search "alex jones howard stern" on youtube. The video ("Alex Jones get pranked by Baba Booey") with the call in from the guy that sounds like he's 15 years old is me.
 
As for me, an article I wrote in the field of philosophical history is finally being published after 3 years. I'm sure if I was a big name, perhaps it would have taken quicker..

Do they have peer review in philosophy?

If so... :D
 
Yikes! Has this dude been trolling you since July??:jaw-dropp

lol, no. Only very recently I think, or maybe I only noticed one of his comments recently I cant remember.

He showed very quickly he never even watched my video and says Griffin based his claim off seeing the actual flight manifests... but at the same time says I should show him the actual flight manifests.... It boggles my mind how they are to make sense of all the contradictions they create!
 
Last edited:
It appears people are projecting onto me what they suspect me to be, not what I actually am.


The problem is, no one can truly know what you are and can only judge what you say here. Internet claims are worth the paper they are printed on, and it really did sound like you had not done the most basic research before starting this thread. I am not saying you didn't do any research, but that is the impression I gained from the original post.

I realize that the search tools on this forum are not the best, but they can at least give you some information that can be used as the basis for reasonable questions. Although you have hopefully learned a bit from the way this thread went (;)), there are some things that may be helpful for you or any other newbies.

1) Use the "Tags" feature to see what other threads have been started on the same or similar topics. Most of the time, you will find too much information rather than too little.

2) After reading at least some of the information available, ask a specific question about the topic. Rather than simply asking, "What do you think about this?", pick one aspect of the topic that you find either most compelling ("Is the amount of energy released consistent with what was observed?") or that you find most confusing ("What is the chemical signature of thermite?").

3) Focus on the topic, not the personal stuff. I couldn't care less if you are a CTist, a "government shill", or the queen of England. Even if the majority of the answers are less than helpful, there will probably be at least one or two that move the discussion forward. Stick to responding to those. (And for those being less than helpful, it really is less than helpful. Just sayin'.)

4) If someone does provide an answer that helps you, let them know. A little thanks goes a long way. :)
 
In a conversation via email with real scientist Frank Greening, Steven Jones admitted that the thermite they found was likely used for fuses to ignite conventional explosives.

http://the911forum.freeforums.org/active-thermitic-material-in-wtc-dust-t150-30.html

Go to Dr.G. post #479

SO you see, their new hybrid (and bizarre) theory involves both...lol

TAM:)

Let me see if I got this correct... in other words, it's sort of like saying if I were to ignite a thermite reaction and use it to light a firecracker?

Nice! Maybe next time I want to cook a pizza in a short amount of time, screw the microwave... I'll just ignite some thermite!!
 
lol, no. Only very recently I think, or maybe I only noticed one of his comments recently I cant remember.

He showed very quickly he never even watched my video and says Griffin based his claim off seeing the actual flight manifests... but at the same time says I should show him the actual flight manifests.... It boggles my mind how they are to make sense of all the contradictions they create!

Scary what type of education these kids are getting these days! Yikes!
 
Scary what type of education these kids are getting these days! Yikes!

The best bit was when he lied about what he said in his previous post, no less!

He says... "[Griffin's] making his claim based on the manifest."

Very next post...."No, i never said Griffin based anything off anything"


:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I have no more questions, I say near the beginning of this thread they have been answered. It appears people are projecting onto me what they suspect me to be, not what I actually am.

I believe you.

After 9/11, I followed some of the early scientific debate about the collapse of the WTC towers, paid attention to the political controversies during the formation of the 9/11 commission, and read its report, but I had no idea of what the truth movement had become until Rob Balsamo invaded a guitar newsgroup I frequented. I was just amazed by the prevalence of 9/11 nonsense in my Google searches, and by how hard I had to dig to find any information that would hold up under scrutiny.

Will
 
The best bit was when he lied about what he said in his previous post, no less!

He says... "He's making his claim based on the manifest."

Very next post...."No, i never said Griffin based anything off anything"


:rolleyes:

You gotta throw him for a loop...

...say something like "Hey... smurfs and clowns are in your closet right now... and if you stand on the bed it will float!"

or... "David Ray Griffin is a smurf... yeah... and if he farts, he'll blame it on you!"

or something to the effect of... "Don't eat the turkey once it turns into a bicycle... please, may I ask you whisky sip?"

Then ask him if he knows why you pulled him over!! LMAO
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom