WTC conspiracy theory giving me problems

jamesraio

New Blood
Joined
Nov 12, 2009
Messages
9
I have over the years made a hobby of debunking 9-11 conspiracy theories and I'm having major problems with this one:

The NIST and FEMA thus far have been the only respectable groups to research the cause of the Twin Towers' collapse and they concluded with the obvious answer: big ass planes flew into the buildings.

The 911 nut jobs aren't scientists and cannot debunk this. However, recently a supposedly peer reviewed journal (Bentham) printed an article by quite a few actual university level scientists concluding that rare and active explosive residue of a relatively new variety (nano-thermite) has been found in the WTC dust. If these guys were right, it would mean that the terrorists or the "evil government" had planted explosives in the towers.

Now, I'd obviously be uncomfortable believing this so I researched the journal's editorial board and the names check out. They're all run-of-the-mill scientists who work at the university level, none are eminent or anything. I tried using common sense and this has even failed me. If nano-thermite only commercially became available in the year 2000, it's traces cannot be explained by having been there innocuously for some huge period of time. Plus, it's quantity in the dust wasn't barely a trace, but .01% of the total mass...pretty high when taking into account how big those towers were.

Any ideas on debunking this?

p.s. this site doesn't let me link. here's the article's name: "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe" in the "The Open Chemical Physics Journal"
 
It's been talked about to death here already. Search the forum using Bentham, or peer review as search fields.
 
I have over the years made a hobby of debunking 9-11 conspiracy theories and I'm having major problems with this one:

The NIST and FEMA thus far have been the only respectable groups to research the cause of the Twin Towers' collapse and they concluded with the obvious answer: big ass planes flew into the buildings.

The 911 nut jobs aren't scientists and cannot debunk this. However, recently a supposedly peer reviewed journal (Bentham) printed an article by quite a few actual university level scientists concluding that rare and active explosive residue of a relatively new variety (nano-thermite) has been found in the WTC dust. If these guys were right, it would mean that the terrorists or the "evil government" had planted explosives in the towers.

Now, I'd obviously be uncomfortable believing this so I researched the journal's editorial board and the names check out. They're all run-of-the-mill scientists who work at the university level, none are eminent or anything. I tried using common sense and this has even failed me. If nano-thermite only commercially became available in the year 2000, it's traces cannot be explained by having been there innocuously for some huge period of time. Plus, it's quantity in the dust wasn't barely a trace, but .01% of the total mass...pretty high when taking into account how big those towers were.

Any ideas on debunking this?

p.s. this site doesn't let me link. here's the article's name: "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe" in the "The Open Chemical Physics Journal"
From what I have seen, the experiments were flawed. I'm not a scientist or anything, but I think it was done in open air. If it was thermite, it wouldn't need any source to ignite or react.

I think they are paint chips.

Also, some people here might call you a truther based on this post. I get called a truther for asking these types of questions all the time.
 
Like most every other 9/11 piece of nonsense, this one has been beaten to death.

Search this forum for Bentham.

You will find lot's'o'links

Quick version

It's a vanity publication
Not peer reviewed (at least in the way you would expect)

Edit - redundant, others beat me to it.
 
The editor quit when she realised the paper had been published without her knowledge - ergo no peer review was done.
 
Bentham might've had someone who was a Truther trying to spread that around, kind of like when Steven Jones was spreading his "peer-review" around without BYU's knowledge & was either fired or he retired.
 
From what I have seen, the experiments were flawed. I'm not a scientist or anything, but I think it was done in open air. If it was thermite, it wouldn't need any source to ignite or react.
Really, even that's beisde the fact. What's more compelling is the fact that even if it WAS thermite, it would be WAY to thin to do any adverse structural damage to the steel and would burn off with out doing much more then scorching the steel (if that). The Thermite theory was never logical.
 
Really, even that's beisde the fact. What's more compelling is the fact that even if it WAS thermite, it would be WAY to thin to do any adverse structural damage to the steel and would burn off with out doing much more then scorching the steel (if that). The Thermite theory was never logical.

Well, no thermite should be found AT ALL. And none was found. Finding ANY thermite, no matter the amount in a particular sample (because that would be just 1 sample of TONS of dust), would destroy the official story (unless thermite was used at the towers in some way during construction or something).
 
1. I'm not a truther, so please be polite.

2. The journal has quite a large editorial board.

J.M. Anglada (Spain)
A.T. Balaban (USA)
A.S. Barnard (Australia)
V. Barone (Italy)
M.N. Berberan-Santos (Portugal)
M. Bergström (Sweden)
A. Bianco (Italy)
U. Boesl (Germany)
T. Bürgi (Switzerland)
D. Cahen (Israel)
D. Canet (France)
L.A.D. Carlos (Portugal)
T.W.D. Chan (Hong Kong)
M. Chergui (Switzerland)
P.T. Chou (Taiwan)
P. Conte (Italy)
A. Corma (Spain)
M. Cotlet (USA)
G. Delgado-Barrio (Spain)
J. Delhommelle (USA)
L.R. Domingo (Spain)
O. Dopfer (Germany)
C. Dybowski (USA)
J. Enderlein (Germany)
F. Endres (Germany)
A. Frontera (Spain)
H. Fukumura (Japan)
K.H. Gericke (Germany)
F.A. Gianturco (Italy)
J. Grotemeyer (Germany)
P. Hanggi (Germany)
M. Hochlaf (France)
P. Jensen (Germany)
A.L. Kawczynski (Poland)
D.E. Khoshtariya (Georgia)
B.K. Kim (Korea)
H.K. Kim (Korea)
P.B. Kingsley (USA)
P. Knauth (France)
O. Kuehn (Germany)
R. Lavery (France)
L.M. Lawson Daku (Switzerland)
J. Leszczynski (USA)
H. Liang (China)
J. Limtrakul (Thailand)
M. Liu (USA)
X.Q. Lu (China)
Y. Luo (Sweden)
O.L. Malta (Brazil)
R.L. Mancera (Australia)
V. Mandelshtam (USA)
D. Mandler (Israel)
G. Maofa (China)
M. Mas-Torrent (Spain)
M. Meuwly (Switzerland)
E.A. Muller (UK)
A. Niño (Spain)
N.Y. Ohrn (USA)
T. Oka (USA)
D.W. Pang (China)
A.P. Pathak (India)
R.J.M. Pellenq (France)
J. Pérez-Prieto (Spain)
P. Piecuch (USA)
N. Pinna (Portugal)
J.M. Pitarke (Spain)
T. Plakhotnik (Australia)
W.S. Price (Australia)
A. Quandt (Germany)
L.G. Rio (Spain)
J.R. Sabin (USA)
E. Sackmann (Germany)
P. Samorì (Italy)
A. Samoson (Estonia)
M. Schmitt (Germany)
F.S. Sheu (Singapore)
T.E. Simos (Greece)
C. Simpson (New Zealand)
Z. Slanina (Japan)
M. Speranza (Italy)
L.K. Tamm (USA)
P. Terech (France)
M. Toyoda (Japan)
J. Traeger (Australia)
D.D. Traficante (USA)
V. van Speybroeck (Belgium)
A.J.C. Varandas (Portugal)
W. Veeman (Germany)
J. Vigo-Aguiar (Spain)
J. Waluk (Poland)
P. Wang (China)
T. Wohland (Singapore)
M. Yañez (Spain)
B. Zhang (China)
S. Zhou (China)

Unlike a lot of people here, back in my school days I served as an editor for two different jounals. The chief editor does not necessarily read every article, assistant editors often send out papers to be read to advisors and jr. editors. The fact the chief editor didn't claim that the article lacked any review whatsoever leads me to believe the paper was obviously reviewed by other legitimate editors, as would be standard practice.

3. I'll need to read past threads on this issue, but I'm interested chefly in the science (i.e. the integrity of the tests) or legitimate questions regarding the article's scholarship (i.e. BYU professor Steven E Jones has a peer reviewed article on this stuff in the Marxist Political Science Journal, which has nothing to do with real science.) It appears to me that this article's journal went through a real peer review, unless I am misunderstanding some how.
 
Well, no thermite should be found AT ALL. And none was found. Finding ANY thermite, no matter the amount in a particular sample (because that would be just 1 sample of TONS of dust), would destroy the official story (unless thermite was used at the towers in some way during construction or something).

Regular thermite (are chemicals that resemble its properties) are often used in welding, so finding run of the mill thermite isn't that big of a deal.

Finding nano-thermite, which only became available in the year 2000, would be a big deal.

So, the question is, did they or did they not find nano-thermite. Nano thermite is not readily available so the samples can be contaminated or used in run of the mill applications. If the tests are legit, then there is more to the 911 story than what is apparent.
 
So, the question is, did they or did they not find nano-thermite. Nano thermite is not readily available so the samples can be contaminated or used in run of the mill applications. If the tests are legit, then there is more to the 911 story than what is apparent.

The tests they run show the following:
- the range of energies their material can produce range from 1/4th to 2x as much energy as a thermitic reaction can in theory
- their material has a different ignition temperature than materials they cite in literature for comparison

These two reasons are more than enough to say for certain the studies' conclusions are flawed, and their tests cannot be deemed legit. There are other major problems with the tests and the integrity of the samples, inconsistencies with their sources, etc, but really, those two are all you need.

Now go back to wherever you came from, and tell them this fake debunker tactics isn't very likely to work. It's not like we hide any twoofer paper here, we point out where they got it wrong, and ridicule them from there on. There isn't really much more to say.

McHrozni
 
Well, no thermite should be found AT ALL. And none was found. Finding ANY thermite, no matter the amount in a particular sample (because that would be just 1 sample of TONS of dust), would destroy the official story (unless thermite was used at the towers in some way during construction or something).

Really? Suppose someone in the WTC made some thermite and grabbed the wrong bag on his way to work. The towers collapse, and this thermite is found in the rubble. Does this thermite destroy the official story or not?

McHrozni
 
Really? Suppose someone in the WTC made some thermite and grabbed the wrong bag on his way to work. The towers collapse, and this thermite is found in the rubble. Does this thermite destroy the official story or not?

McHrozni
Hmm, odd situation, but I guess you are right... That could happen.
 
The tests they run show the following:
- the range of energies their material can produce range from 1/4th to 2x as much energy as a thermitic reaction can in theory
- their material has a different ignition temperature than materials they cite in literature for comparison

These two reasons are more than enough to say for certain the studies' conclusions are flawed, and their tests cannot be deemed legit. There are other major problems with the tests and the integrity of the samples, inconsistencies with their sources, etc, but really, those two are all you need.

Now go back to wherever you came from, and tell them this fake debunker tactics isn't very likely to work. It's not like we hide any twoofer paper here, we point out where they got it wrong, and ridicule them from there on. There isn't really much more to say.

McHrozni
I'm not a fan of your tone, but your response makes sense and pretty much settles it for me.
 
1. I'm not a truther, so please be polite.

2. The journal has quite a large editorial board.

Unlike a lot of people here, back in my school days I served as an editor for two different jounals.

Then it's really quite surprising that Bentham Science Publishing hasn't yet asked you to serve as an editor for one of their journals. I discard their emails when I clean out my inbox, but here's one of their E-book solicitations that arrived just two days ago: http://www.ccs.neu.edu/home/will/Temp/bentham.txt

The chief editor does not necessarily read every article, assistant editors often send out papers to be read to advisors and jr. editors. The fact the chief editor didn't claim that the article lacked any review whatsoever leads me to believe the paper was obviously reviewed by other legitimate editors, as would be standard practice.
I doubt whether a chief editor's resignation on principle is standard practice, even at Bentham.

3. I'll need to read past threads on this issue, but I'm interested chefly in the science (i.e. the integrity of the tests) or legitimate questions regarding the article's scholarship...

Read the article. You will find that it mostly consists of (1) calorimetric data that covers a wide range and, for one sample, exceeds the theoretical maximum for the aluminum-iron (III) oxide thermite the authors are promoting, (2) qualitative spectra with no comparisons to spectra of known thermites or paint chips, and (3) electron microscopy (pictures). The substantive sections of the article don't point to anything in particular; they can't really say what it is. Then, in their discussion section, they engage in rather wild speculation about nano-thermite.

Here's my summary: They'd like to think it's thermite, but it doesn't look like any thermite they or anyone they know has ever seen, so it must be double top secret nano-thermite.

Will
 
Last edited:
Hmm, odd situation, but I guess you are right... That could happen.

Yup. It's way more likely than a government conspiracy too.

Another option: some rust comes off, and finds way to some small pieces of aluminum, either from the plane, or from the towers. It got mixed during the collapse, and you got thermite. Whee.

McHrozni
 
Then it's really quite surprising that Bentham Science Publishing hasn't yet asked you to serve as an editor for one of their journals. I discard their emails when I clean out my inbox, but here's one of their E-book solicitations that arrived just two days ago:


I doubt whether a chief editor's resignation on principle is standard practice, even at Bentham.



Read the article. You will find that it mostly consists of (1) calorimetric data that covers a wide range and, for one sample, exceeds the theoretical maximum for the aluminum-iron (III) oxide thermite the authors are promoting, (2) qualitative spectra with no comparisons to spectra of known thermites or paint chips, and (3) electron microscopy (pictures). The substantive sections of the article don't point to anything in particular; they can't really say what it is. Then, in their discussion section, they engage in rather wild speculation about nano-thermite.

Here's my summary: They'd like to think it's thermite, but it doesn't look like any thermite they or anyone they know has ever seen, so it must be double top secret nano-thermite.

Will

You know the conspiracy theory, the editor had ties to military interests...so, if this is true then her resignation could be political which in scholarship isn't odd at all.

However, the science appears to be flawed (i.e. global warming "research"), so bad science is hardly surprising to me. This appears to be the case.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom