World Hunger

Well, I'm not the one who's trying to use nature as an analogy to capitalism in order to make the latter appear to be abiding by the laws of nature, and therefore I'm not confused.
But just for the hell of it I would sure like to know: What is the analogy in nature to hedge fonds, futures and mortgages?

Burying excess nuts for Winter use, massive eating in preparation for hibernation, and territorialism?
 
No, it doesn't sound reasonable to me!

But even people whose only motivation is profit will quite happily do this work for pay.

Thank you for the lesson in social studies, but I'm sorry: You seem to have completely misunderstood the way this society functions:
Profit is not a question of motivation, which is why the 'profiteers' usually profit without doing any kind of "work for pay". The people working for pay are the ones who create the products that their employers profit from. Get the idea?

So you'd argue that the further up you rise in a corporation, the less work you have to do?

Would I??? How do you define "work"?

I'm open to suggestions.

Tell you what: How about you define work however you like, and then, using your own definition, answer my question. Sound reasonable to you?

Well, I referred to your description of work in this post but quoted only the sentence beginning the row of quotations above.
What you actually said about work was this:
As I understand it, people do work because they are motivated to do work. One motivation is "profit", which may also be understood as "survival", or "security", or "personal pleasure". It's not really so much an ideological thing as it is just a thing that animals do: work to survive.

Beyond that, people might do additional work for ideological reasons: feeding the hungry, for example.

But--and here's where I think you and I are disconnecting--feeding the hungry requires work. Somebody has to do it. Somebody has to acquire land, and till it. Somebody has to acquire seeds, and sow them. Somebody has to bring in the harvest, package it, and transport it to the hungry they wish to feed.

This is work. It's costly. It takes time. It takes energy. It takes resources. It prevents the person doing the work from doing something else for that same cost instead.

Now, some people will do this work for ideological reasons. But even people whose only motivation is profit will quite happily do this work for pay. One way to get this work done efficiently is to specialize in some area, so that you can get paid a lot for the work you do--more than enough to feed yourself. Then you can use your surplus capital to pay a food-production profiteer to produce and deliver food to the hungry, on your behalf. In this way, the profit motive, properly understood and ruthlessly exploited, can be used quite successfully to feed the hungry.

Since you don’t seem to want to define work, I guess I’ll have to do it for you, and as in the case of profit, where you are all over the place and ‘defines’ it like this:
One motivation is "profit", which may also be understood as "survival", or "security", or "personal pleasure".
(Why the quotation marks??!), you also have a weird concept of work.

You define work as:
1) “it is just a thing that animals do: work to survive.” Even the Old Testament is ahead of you here: ”Through hard work you will eat [food that comes] from it every day of your life.” You claim that animals actually work!
2) ”Beyond that”, i.e. beyond working to survive, I presume, you talk about working for ”ideological reason”. Nevertheless, you seem to think that it is the same kind of work anyway,“ feeding the hungry requires work”, so it’s hard to tell why you’d want to distinguish between the two.
3) Then you move on to what seems to be your definition of real work:
” Somebody has to do it. Somebody has to acquire land, and till it. Somebody has to acquire seeds, and sow them. Somebody has to bring in the harvest, package it, and transport it to the hungry they wish to feed.
This is work. It's costly. It takes time. It takes energy. It takes resources. It prevents the person doing the work from doing something else for that same cost instead.”

So it’s a tough job, but somebody’s gotta do it, right?
Well, let’s break it down: ”Somebody has to acquire land”, you say, but at least according to my dictionary acquisition of land is very different from work: ”Main entry: acquire (…) 1: to get as one's own: a: to come into possession or control of often by unspecified means”.
But you are right, of course, that in the very real world agricultural corporations “acquire” land, machinery and farm labourers. They “acquire” seeds, have the labourers with their machines sow and harvest them – and don’t forget all the chemicals involved today. And if the companies don’t also own the means of packaging, transportation and marketing, they pay another corporation to do so, or they won’t get their money back – with a profit, which is the sole purpose of this elaborate process.
You are right that it takes time, energy, resources and costs, and it actually does prevent ”the person doing the work from doing something else”, but since the workers aren’t the ones ‘acquiring’ the land, the seed, the tools and the labourers, the people actually ‘acquiring’ all of this, the owners of CEO's of the corporation, usually have plenty of time to spend on the Bahamas while the work is performed by somebody else, who doesn't profit much ...
And if by this, ”It prevents the person doing the work from doing something else for that same cost instead”, you mean to imply that they cannot spend their money acquiring the means of production and yet use it once again, you have understood absolutely nothing of the ongoing crisis of loans, futures and bloated credit.

So, please, Prestige, give us something other than your children’s stories of capitalism. I have seen the same story told by Carl Barks, but at least it was tongue-in-cheek, since he seemed to know a little more about capitalism and wage labour than you do. But then again, he was working for a corporation, so he probably knew a little about the relationship between Work and Wealth.
 
Burying excess nuts for Winter use, massive eating in preparation for hibernation, and territorialism?

:)
At first I thought that you wrote "Buying excess nuts", but, no, I don't think so. I think that territorialism is used as an analogy to war, and socio-biologists are very fond of stealth/camouflage analogies. It's true that burying nuts and preparing for hibernation are often used as analogies to savings accounts, but more immediate parallels spring to mind.
(And I've never seen a fat squirrel!)

Now Google just ruined that for me.
 
Last edited:
Watching Dann's meltdown is amusing.
Call me when the Dictatorship of the Proletariat is established and the world becomes a Worker's Paradise.
 
Last edited:
No, I don't.
That's interesting. Could you explain this a little more?

If an animal expends effort to survive, is it work or not?

If a human expends effort to survive, is it work or not?

If a human expends effort to bring themselves pleasure, is it work or not?

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service in free exchange for a different good or service, is it work or not?

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service without receiving anything in return, is it work or not?

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service because they are compelled to by the state, is it work or not?

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service in free exchange for money which they can then freely exchange for other goods and services, is it work or not?

But you seriously need to take a look at what profit is:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Profit_(economics)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Profit_(accounting)
I probably couldn't persuade you to read Marx' analysis of profit and how to make it ...
... Probably not until I'm sure I understand what you mean by "work". I'd rather not move on to other concepts until I'm clear on this one.
 
Watching Dann's meltdown is amusing.
Call me when the Dictatorship of the Proletariat is established and the world becomes a Worker's Paradise.

Call back when you want to participate and not just toss insults.
 
Call me when you finally understand just how much misery and suffering Marxism has caused in the world.
I consider those advocating it in the same league as those advocating Nazism and other forms of Fascism. The only difference is in the rheteoric.
That is why I get annoyed with dann.
 
Call me when you finally understand just how much misery and suffering Marxism has caused in the world.

Why, just the other day I saw Anarchism mugging a poor old lady.

I consider those advocating it in the same league as those advocating Nazism and other forms of Fascism. The only difference is in the rheteoric.
That is why I get annoyed with dann.

Well, those terms are even harder to define, and the only way we recognize them is for ethnic cleansing.

But still, I like dann even if he is just an old Marxist talking head. Despite what others may say, no one else is a real Commie around here :p .
 
Why, just the other day I saw Anarchism mugging a poor old lady.

[snip]

But still, I like dann even if he is just an old Marxist talking head. Despite what others may say, no one else is a real Commie around here :p .


Well that's different! Off with their heads!
 
Call me when you finally understand just how much misery and suffering Marxism has caused in the world.
I consider those advocating it in the same league as those advocating Nazism and other forms of Fascism. The only difference is in the rheteoric.
That is why I get annoyed with dann.

LOL
you are amusing.
 
I find it incredibly ignorant and insulting how often any talk of socialism, marxism, communism, or anarchy is equated to evil or clitche snide comments you'd see from the actors we call news reporters.

What's even better is that the people who do this usually have no idea what any of these things even are, only that they are evil and to be mocked.

The comments that have come up in response to the criticism of sale of food for profit while ignoring those who can't afford it are rediculous. The point is not to simply provide food for you at someone elses expense. The comment of having someone else work harder and provide you with food so you can quit your job is just extremism for the purpose of preventing real discussion.

You have 10,000 people and all 10,000 have to work 6 hours a day to cultivate or provide adequate amounts of food for all 10,000 people.

New technology comes along and creates improvements.

Now 5,000 of those people work 6 hours a day to provide for all 10,000. Or all 10,000 could still work but only work 3 hours a day.

New technology again.

Now 2,500 people can work 6 hours a day, or 5,000 can work 3 hours a day, or all 10,000 can work 1.5 hours a day.

The thing is if you choose to go with 2,500 people working 6 hours a day that means there are 7,500 other people who now don't work. And under our system if you don't work you don't eat.

This leaves everyone at the mercy of our made up economic system, at the mercy of recessions, unemployment and ultimately at the mercy of business in general for the very necessities of life.

This is the same with shelter, but that is a separate topic.

I have more to say with this but I have a meeting to go to.
 
New technology comes along and creates improvements.
No, it doesn't.

"New technology" isn't some magical santa clause tooth fairy that suddenly appears for no reason and "creates improvements".

It takes work^H^H^H^H--sorry, dann--it takes effort and resources to produce new technology.

While one guy is conceiving of, testing, implementing, and distributing new technology, some other guy has to farm twice as hard in his place (actually, everybody else just farms a little bit harder, but you get the idea). If the new technology is especially resource-intensive, the entire community might have to give up a significant portion of their work product for years to come, just to recover the resources committed to R&D for the new technology.

On a related note, there's not a finite amount of work to be done. People always desire more things, and find more reasons to expend effort and resources to get those things.

I worked for a company that manufactured robots that each did the work of a thousand men--a thousand accountants, actually. But the demand for human accountants--and the demand for more accountant-bots--keeps going up anyway. So does the demand for robot support technicians, too. There's always more work to do.

The simplest solution is that if you want someone to work for you, instead of for himself, you have to pay him something in exchange for his work. And if you can't pay him? Well, there's at least three different solutions here: You could depend on private charity, and work to build a society that valued private charity. You could depend on government aid, and work to build a society that valued taxation of workers to provide for non-workers. You could depend on "from each according to his ability, and to each according to his need", and work to build a society that values this.

Most modern nations try for some combination of the first two, with constant debate about how much of one and how little of the other is ideal, and constant conflict between factions that prefer one over the other.

Some nations have tried to implement the third; but in practice it always seems to end up either as a horrible, corrupt, inhumane, totalitarian version of the second (e.g., the Soviet Union) or of the first (e.g., North Korea).
 
That's interesting. Could you explain this a little more?

Yes, of course. I'm a patient soul and I would love to contribute to your education:

If an animal expends effort to survive, is it work or not?

No, it isn't. Eating a nut or fighting off a predator is not work.

If a human expends effort to survive, is it work or not?

Like swimming to shore instead of drowning? Or running away from or fighting off a mugger? No, it's swimming, running away from or figthing off, it's not work.

If a human expends effort to bring themselves pleasure, is it work or not?

Like what? Masturbating? No, it isn't. It isn't even work when somebody "expends effort to bring" somebody else "pleasure". And if you think that it is, don't tell your wife!!!

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service in free exchange for a different good or service, is it work or not?

Like, 'if I give you one, you give me one'? No, it isn't. (And again: Please don't tell your wife that this is how you feel!)

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service without receiving anything in return, is it work or not?

No, it isn't. (But next time you should really pay a little more attention to her needs, you selfish bastard!)

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service because they are compelled to by the state, is it work or not?

Nope.

If a human expends effort to provide a good or service in free exchange for money which they can then freely exchange for other goods and services, is it work or not?

No, it isn't. (This is starting to get very boring.)

... Probably not until I'm sure I understand what you mean by "work". I'd rather not move on to other concepts until I'm clear on this one.

No, you are right. You seriously need to read up on this. You aren't ready to move on until you master this one. And so far you don't seem to have a clue that your abstraction from what constitutes work only takes place because of the ideas that you want to justify, for instance the idea that animals work and the idea that a lot of people work because it's a necessity of nature and not of capitalism.

You can start here:
Theses on work and wealth
Labour – time that pays money
The "consumer economy" does not serve the consumer, but rather the consumer serves the economy
Progress today: work longer and earn less
The free market fairy tale that profits create jobs
Do CEOs get paid too much?
 
Last edited:
While one guy is conceiving of, testing, implementing, and distributing new technology, some other guy has to farm twice as hard in his place (actually, everybody else just farms a little bit harder, but you get the idea). If the new technology is especially resource-intensive, the entire community might have to give up a significant portion of their work product for years to come, just to recover the resources committed to R&D for the new technology.
(...)
The simplest solution is that if you want someone to work for you, instead of for himself, you have to pay him something in exchange for his work. And if you can't pay him? Well, there's at least three different solutions here: You could depend on private charity, and work to build a society that valued private charity. You could depend on government aid, and work to build a society that valued taxation of workers to provide for non-workers. You could depend on "from each according to his ability, and to each according to his need", and work to build a society that values this.


You need to read a couple of chapters of Das Capital, in particular the ones about primitive accumulation:
26: The Secret of Primitive Accumulation
27: Expropriation of the Agricultural Population of the Land
28: Bloody Legislation against the Expropriated
This primitive accumulation plays in Political Economy about the same part as original sin in theology. Adam bit the apple, and thereupon sin fell on the human race. Its origin is supposed to be explained when it is told as an anecdote of the past. In times long gone-by there were two sorts of people; one, the diligent, intelligent, and, above all, frugal elite; the other, lazy rascals, spending their substance, and more, in riotous living. The legend of theological original sin tells us certainly how man came to be condemned to eat his bread in the sweat of his brow; but the history of economic original sin reveals to us that there are people to whom this is by no means essential. Never mind! Thus it came to pass that the former sort accumulated wealth, and the latter sort had at last nothing to sell except their own skins. And from this original sin dates the poverty of the great majority that, despite all its labour, has up to now nothing to sell but itself, and the wealth of the few that increases constantly although they have long ceased to work. Such insipid childishness is every day preached to us in the defence of property.


The"simplest solution" when "you want someone to work for you, instead of for himself," is not simply to pay him since he might have much better alternatives. The Danish imperialists discovered this when they wanted to turn the Greenland Inuits into factory workers: You see, shelling shrimps is a very tedious job as compared to hunting whales, so whenever the the manufacturers of tinned shrimps thought that they had a good (= profitable) thing going with all the Inuits shelling shrimps and filling tins, somebody would come running into the factory yelling, "Whales in sight!" and the poor capitalists would suddenly have lost most of their workers, leaving the shrimp rotting in the factory (in spite of the notorious cold weather in Greenland). And on a similar note: Builders complained that they couldn't depend on the Inuits slaving away all day: as soon as they got bored, they would disappear from the construction site. In order to keep them from disapperaring they had to turn the boring job into a singing and dancing game: "Then we dance over here, and we pick up a plank, and then we dance over there, and we put it gently down. Then we dance back here, and ..."
And the despairing Danes were so stupid that they actually saw this as proof of the primitive, childish nature of the Inuits, and of their own evolved intelligence and work ethics!!!
They were actually unable to comprehend that as long as you can work for yourself, decide when and where and how long, you cannot be extorted into working for others. Only when you haven't got an alternative does the kind offer from the guy who wants to exploit you for money become attractive. (Who said, prostitution!?)
(And work ethics is just another euphemism for having no other option than to work for money.)

This is also the reason why primitive accumulation did not consist of wealthy gentlemen bribing farmers with career opportunities, as in your fairy tale. It consisted of the expropriation of farmers from their land, who, destitute as they were, were then eager to sell their time for (very little) money. But, of course, it is a very simple solution!
That's progress for you!
 
Last edited:
I forgot about this one, sorry!

I worked for a company that manufactured robots that each did the work of a thousand men--a thousand accountants, actually.

Accountantbots, really? Do you have a photo?

But the demand for human accountants--and the demand for more accountant-bots--keeps going up anyway.

Could this have anything to do with the many scandals being neglected by accounting firms in later years? Enron, Ponzi and other schemes. How many of your bots did Arthur Andersen buy?

So does the demand for robot support technicians, too. There's always more work to do.

Always??!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom