Woo Way: Response is NOT allowed!

You're assuming that your niece would read it with the same dispassion you would. Which I doubt.

Although I'm only guessing, I would assume that she would view it as a historical text that inspired an age of modern medicine. Sure, we can point out the stupid insinuations, but to somebody who embraces this nonsense, they would read it with a generous amount of Orwellian 'double-think'.

I see your point, HC, but not sure it will result in ways you would imagine. Homeopathy is accepted in spite of its contrast with logic and science.

Athon

I see your point. Though I am hoping that this woman who took great delight in pointing out the lack of intelligence in other people, might actually use some of the smarts she claims to have. Also, I think the historical part is important. She kept saying what was bad about "Western" medicine, to which I kept reminding her that Germany is not in the East! She clearly had no idea what the history of homeopathy was other than what the "healer" was telling her.

If you were trying to dissuade someone from getting involved in a church, would you send them a Bible?

Unfortunately no, for the same reason that makes $cientologists think Dianetics is the greatest book ever ...

I suspect you are all correct... Next year it will be Voodoo Science.

My only hope is that I have planted a seed of doubt which would counter the placebo effect.
 
Working in the county courthouse dealing with victims of crime, specifically domestic violence victims.
Ask her why she doesn't just adjust their chi so that abuse no longer happens?

Or rearrange the furniture a la feng shui to calm their partners?
 
A couple weeks ago, my brother (Michael) was induced by his friend (Suzy) to go to a seminar by her friend (Emily), a recent graduate in "naturopathy" who was recruiting victims ... er, clients. During her talk, an attendee asked if she should stop her daughter from using an asthma treatment. Emily looked really pained, like she wanted to say yes; but she said "I could get in trouble saying that, I can only suggest that you explore alternatives."

Emily Kane, ND (a former, senior editor of their official journal), has a huge list of treatment options http://www.healthy.net/scr/Article.asp?Id=783 Note that one option is a bath in dilute hydrogen peroxide to oxygenate the blood. Apparently, Kane never learned that the technical term for people trying to absorb oxygen through the skin is "drowning." Also, peroxide is not oxygen.

Anyway, I asked another friend if she heard about Michael's experience, and she said that Suzy reported he was really annoyed all night. There are three dozen naturopaths, here, in Massachusetts. We are blessed with two in our little town.
 
Ask her why she doesn't just adjust their chi so that abuse no longer happens?

Or rearrange the furniture a la feng shui to calm their partners?

:D

I could ask her if the defending lawyers have used applied kinesiology to find out what the offenders are allergic to... the allergies are obviously causing them to hit their wives and kids.
 
:D

I could ask her if the defending lawyers have used applied kinesiology to find out what the offenders are allergic to... the allergies are obviously causing them to hit their wives and kids.
I know you say it in jest, as I did, but truthfully I would look for an opening to ask something very similar, and then pursue it.

If she responds as if the idea is silly, you have your opening based on inconsistency.

If she responds as if the idea has merit, you have grounds for righteous ire.
 
A couple weeks ago, my brother (Michael) was induced by his friend (Suzy) to go to a seminar by her friend (Emily), a recent graduate in "naturopathy" who was recruiting victims ... er, clients. During her talk, an attendee asked if she should stop her daughter from using an asthma treatment. Emily looked really pained, like she wanted to say yes; but she said "I could get in trouble saying that, I can only suggest that you explore alternatives."

My first responce to that is something like "how much do you like having your kid being able to breath?"
 
I know you say it in jest, as I did, but truthfully I would look for an opening to ask something very similar, and then pursue it.

If she responds as if the idea is silly, you have your opening based on inconsistency.

If she responds as if the idea has merit, you have grounds for righteous ire.

Hmmmm... It is just that she is in another state, and I sincerely doubt I will be speaking to her in person for a long time.

Especially since coming back from the funeral I was insufferable for about 48 hours. Since this often happens after visiting my family (like my dad and other siblings) my hubby thinks I should avoid them in the future. :boxedin:
 
The book! What about the Organon?

That is why I bumped this thread!

Wouldn't a halfway intelligent person reading this drivel (which is at http://www.homeopathyhome.com/reference/organon/organon.html ) not think that two century concepts have nothing to do with modern medicine?

I would agree with the others that it's a bad idea to try to combat someone's belief in homeopathy by giving them the organon.
However, if you're interested in understanding the organon, MRCHans has made an annotated version pointing out all the inconsistencies and internal conflicts.

I think it was him anyway. He probably still has it linked in his sig.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom