Chris Haynes
Perfectly Poisonous Person
I need to make this quick. I actually have to do real work... especially after not being home for two weeks. Unfortunately the last week was to go to a family funeral.
During my time there I encountered my lovely niece. It seems that she is was in a car accident and is still recovering. She didn't break any bones, but she got whiplash and traumatized her back, so she has chronic pain.
That is all well and good until I mentioned how silly homeopathy was. Oooh, did that get her angry. She told that the homeopath was the one who helped her with her allergies to chemicals, and all sorts of other things. Any time I tried to respond I was accused of interrupting! That was even when it seemed like a logical pause (I did manage to ask her why homeopathy is not considered "western", when Germany is considered to be in the "west").
So I just let her talk, talk, talk... she went on for several minutes going over all sorts of nonsense. I had to literally bite my lip to keep from responding (or laughing out loud) when she described that this practitioner diagnosed her acidic stomach by having her hold something in one hand while her other arm was pushed by the "healer" (applied kinesiology).
I finally got to interject, by saying "Okay, a comment on something several sentences back. You say micro dilutions, okay that is possibly okay. Next time ask for specific percentages of the remedy, if it is actually and 1 over 10 to the sixth then you might actually have active ingredients".
I really could not go on any further because it was just too ridiculous.
When my hubby picked me up from the airport I shared the conversation I had with my niece. He noted that is was exactly the same with one of his other relatives (who I've mentioned before, she is bipolar and has lots of issues). He said no one could ever talk to her about it... all they were allowed to do was just listen. She, like my niece, refused to have a dialog...
A response is NOT allowed !!
Actually, this is often how woo forums work. I noticed this recently on a thread in the Science, Math, Med subforum with this:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=63211
I just thought I get this off my chest. Coming to this forum has made me feel better... and I really wish I could go to TAM V. I think this Christmas my niece is getting a copy of The Skeptics Dictionary.
By the way, I would really like to know who this crook is that is bamboozling my niece. She was described as a biochemist with a Down's Syndrome child who found "using homeopathy helped her child". She lives in the Denver, CO area. I tried using Google, but it seems that the relevant search words (colorado down's syndrome biochemist homeopathy) bring up too many hits!
During my time there I encountered my lovely niece. It seems that she is was in a car accident and is still recovering. She didn't break any bones, but she got whiplash and traumatized her back, so she has chronic pain.
That is all well and good until I mentioned how silly homeopathy was. Oooh, did that get her angry. She told that the homeopath was the one who helped her with her allergies to chemicals, and all sorts of other things. Any time I tried to respond I was accused of interrupting! That was even when it seemed like a logical pause (I did manage to ask her why homeopathy is not considered "western", when Germany is considered to be in the "west").
So I just let her talk, talk, talk... she went on for several minutes going over all sorts of nonsense. I had to literally bite my lip to keep from responding (or laughing out loud) when she described that this practitioner diagnosed her acidic stomach by having her hold something in one hand while her other arm was pushed by the "healer" (applied kinesiology).
I finally got to interject, by saying "Okay, a comment on something several sentences back. You say micro dilutions, okay that is possibly okay. Next time ask for specific percentages of the remedy, if it is actually and 1 over 10 to the sixth then you might actually have active ingredients".
I really could not go on any further because it was just too ridiculous.
When my hubby picked me up from the airport I shared the conversation I had with my niece. He noted that is was exactly the same with one of his other relatives (who I've mentioned before, she is bipolar and has lots of issues). He said no one could ever talk to her about it... all they were allowed to do was just listen. She, like my niece, refused to have a dialog...
A response is NOT allowed !!
Actually, this is often how woo forums work. I noticed this recently on a thread in the Science, Math, Med subforum with this:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=63211
I just thought I get this off my chest. Coming to this forum has made me feel better... and I really wish I could go to TAM V. I think this Christmas my niece is getting a copy of The Skeptics Dictionary.
By the way, I would really like to know who this crook is that is bamboozling my niece. She was described as a biochemist with a Down's Syndrome child who found "using homeopathy helped her child". She lives in the Denver, CO area. I tried using Google, but it seems that the relevant search words (colorado down's syndrome biochemist homeopathy) bring up too many hits!