• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Withholding news from prisoner of his execution - cruel or humane?

commandlinegamer

Philosopher
Joined
Oct 3, 2009
Messages
9,758
Location
Mazes of Menace
The Chinese have not yet told Akmal Shaikh he is to be executed and will not do until 24 hours before he is to die.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8431750.stm

I can't see much in this method that is truly humane. If you are to take someone's life would it hurt to let them make final farewells? Maybe it makes the authorities' work easier; keep the guy quiet as long as possible.
 
How long do goodbyes take? And would having more time to think "well, that's me stuffed then" be a blessing?

 
Have just read on BBC that he has now been told of his impending execution, which doesn't look good for any hope of last minute clemency.

In the article above, it says they aren't known for leniency, however, I did read in an another BBC article, that the Chinese have been known to frequently give reprieves at, literally, the last second.
 
According to the Wiki, the Taiwanese did it this way, too:

The death order from the Minister of Justice is received and performed by the High Prosecutors' offices so executions are carried out inside the detention centers of the five cities having a High Court: Taipei, Taichung, Tainan, Kaohsiung and Hualien. Like Japan, Taiwanese death row inmates are kept in detention centers but not prisons, and are kept under harsher conditions than general prisoners. They are imprisoned 2 persons per cell (or sole imprisonment for misbehaving or very violent inmates), handcuffed and fettered all day long (although since late 2006 the Ministry of Justice is experimenting with unfettering death row inmates who behave themselves), only allowed to leave the cell half an hour a day for exercise, but are allowed to read censored newspapers and books as well as practice religious activities with permitted religious personnel.


Executions are carried out by handgun shooting aimed at the heart from the back, or aimed at the brain stem under the ear if the prisoner consents to organ donation. The execution time used to be 5AM, but was changed to 9PM in 1995 to reduce officials' workload. Executions are performed in secret: nobody is informed beforehand, including the condemned. Before the execution a last meal is served and the prisoner is prompted for any last words. The condemned prisoner is then injected with strong anaesthetic to leave him or her completely senseless, and the shooting quickly takes the prisoner's life. After execution the High Prosecutors' Office in charge will announce the execution in detail. Although the Ministry of Justice has studied other methods including hanging and lethal injection since the early 1990s, execution by shooting (performed by local bailiffs or military policemen) is the only execution method used in Taiwan to date (including military executions).
Beautiful:boggled:.

You spoiled the OP header with the post. When I read the title I was thinking "Wouldn't he notice without being told?".
Dear Citizen.

This is to inform you that your self has been executed as of 1200, December 18th, 2009, for crimes against the People's Republic of China. We apologize for the inevitable grief this will caused you.

Sincerely,
the Public Security Bureau
 
Last edited:
Dear Citizen.

This is to inform you that your self has been executed as of 1200, December 18th, 2009, for crimes against the People's Republic of China. We apologize for the inevitable grief this will caused you.

Sincerely,
the Public Security Bureau

P.S. Please return the bullet at the earliest possible opportunity or you will be charged a late fee.
 
Last edited:
The Chinese have not yet told Akmal Shaikh he is to be executed and will not do until 24 hours before he is to die.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8431750.stm

I can't see much in this method that is truly humane.

Well, it is an execution. What do you expect? How can you be nice about killing someone?

If you are to take someone's life would it hurt to let them make final farewells? Maybe it makes the authorities' work easier; keep the guy quiet as long as possible.

I am not sure it makes a difference either way. Some might want to know, others would just suffer from knowing. And the verdict is clear to them, so they could always make their final goodbyes before the announcement, too.
 
Well, it is an execution. What do you expect? How can you be nice about killing someone?
Right, so if you were to be shot, you wouldn't mind not knowing when it would happen?
 
Who cares? If we treat our convicts better than we do our cows and chickens, we need to start eating convicts to even the score.
 
Wouldn't the guy know that he is being sentenced to death when he was convicted? So how is it cruel if they don't tell him when he is actually going to be executed till the last "minute"?
 
P.S. Please return the bullet at the earliest possible opportunity or you will be charged a late fee.
As I recall, and I welcome connections that confirm or deny, but one of those guys with plasticized dead folk shows was getting bodies from the Chinese government and they had telltale 9mm holes at the base of their skulls. This could be a career path for Shaikh.

Not for me, though. I'm divided between an afterlife rotting in a body farm and being stripped clean and my bones rearticulated. Then I could be a skeleton in someone's closet.
 
Wouldn't the guy know that he is being sentenced to death when he was convicted? So how is it cruel if they don't tell him when he is actually going to be executed till the last "minute"?

Actually, no. Not if the entire trial is conducted in Chinese (and why wouldn't it be?) and they don't provide any sort of tranlation services for the accused (this part irks me a bit).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom