William Rodriguez revisited.

Who said this? MaGZ? A coherent post? Are you coming around to seeing the light? I thought missiles hit the towers?

I have to remark that this is not an uncommon phenomenon -- a conspiracy theorist displaying sound critical thinking skills, so long as it's not in reference to his or her pet conspiracy theory. And particularly if it competes with his or her theory.

As evidence, consider the almost lucid debunking of Steven Jones and his thermite theory, composed by former colleagues Morgan Reynolds and Judy Wood, who themselves have advanced perhaps the most provably insane Sept. 11th theory of all time.

On the other hand, many who believe one conspiracy will believe in another, on totally unrelated topics, as I discussed here. Perhaps the issue is one of stubbornness...

In any case, we should always encourage critical thinking, regardless of other beliefs or misconceptions that any individual might have.

To William Rodriguez, welcome; I am sorry that there are some people in the world who cannot conduct themselves maturely, and have demonstrated that by sending you atrocious e-mails. While I too feel your recollection about, in particular, the timing of what you experienced may be in error -- particularly because it cannot be reconciled with siesmic data published by the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, which shows conclusively that there was no explosion prior to impact -- I don't hold this against you, nor is there any disrespect implied. Thanks for coming here to face some of your critics.
 
Done, as far as I'm concerned anyway.
I am interested in what is right and fair, I do not use the term "truth" as it has become a euphamism (bad spelling) for any theory however insane.
I still believe there is something fishy about the events of 911


So do I. I don't believe in controlled demolitions or fly over at
the pentagon, but there were indeed fishy things - at least after
9/11 - but in my opinion also before it happened. So change your
mind and let's find out about the factual things concerning the events. :)
 
Once again getting back to the original topic.

Has the man, who came out of the basement elevator been identified? What is his view on things?

I might remember all wrong, but I have a hunch I have seen a short videoclip of him, and he was African American male. Correct me if I'm just plain wrong here.

ETA: Felipe David. Somehow I had completely missed that. Forget the earlier post :) Has he given statements of his experiences?
 
Last edited:
And/ or what changed his mind from this 2002 account:

William Rodriguez said:
And at that terrible day when I took people out of the office, one of them totally burned because he was standing in front of the freight elevator and the ball of fire came down the duct of the elevator itself, I put him on the ambulance.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0209/11/se.48.html

It is hard to reconcile with this 2005 statement:

""He was burned terribly," said Rodriguez. "The skin was hanging off his hands and arms. His injuries couldn’t have come from the airplane above, but only from a massive explosion below. I don’t care what the government says, what scientists say. I saw a man burned terribly from a fire that was caused from an explosion below.

I know there were explosives placed below the trade center. I helped a man to safety who is living proof, living proof the government story is a lie and a cover-up.
”

http://www.arcticbeacon.com/24-Jun-2005.html
ETA: Felipe David. Somehow I had completely missed that. Forget the earlier post :) Has he given statements of his experiences?

This account is also from Greg Szymanski's Arctic Beacon. He's not a reputable journalist, but I haven't heard William Rodriguez complain about inaccuracies in any of the many quotes of his on Szymanski's site.

David's Story

Standing in front of a freight elevator on sub level 1 near the office where Rodriguez and 14 others were huddled together when the explosion erupted below, David said in the taped interview:

"That day I was in the basement in sub-level 1 sometime after 8:30am. Everything happened so fast, everything moved so fast. The building started shaking after I heard the explosion below, dust was flying everywhere and all of a sudden it got real hot.

"I threw myself onto the floor, covered my face because I felt like I was burned. I sat there for a couple of seconds on the floor and felt like I was going to die, saying to myself 'God, please give me strength.'"

Although severely burned on his face, arms and hands with skin hanging from his body like pieces of cloth, David picked himself up, running for help to the office were Rodriguez and others were gathered.

"When I went in, I told them it was an explosion," said David, who was then helped out of the WTC by Rodriguez and eventually taken by ambulance to New York Hospital. "When people looked at me with my skin hanging, they started crying but I heard others say 'OK, good, good, you made it alive." http://www.arcticbeacon.com/articles/13-Jul-2005.html
This account gives a sense of the time between the first sound and the fireball:

In the 2002 taped statement, Sanchez recalls, at the same time Rodriguez and the others heard the explosion, being in a small sub-level 4 workshop with another man who he only knew by the name of Chino when, out of nowhere, the blast sounded as the two men were cutting a piece of metal.

“It sounded like a bomb and the lights went on and off,” said Sanchez in the tape recording. “We started to walk to the exit and a huge ball of fire went through the freight elevator. The hot air from the ball of fire dropped Chino to the floor and my hair got burned,” said Sanchez in the tape recording. “The room then got full of smoke and I remember saying out loud ‘I believe it was a bomb that blew up inside the building.’ http://www.arcticbeacon.citymaker.co...8131/29079.htm
On the lowest level, the 6th sub-basement:

Deep below the tower, Mike Pecoraro was suddenly interrupted in his grinding task by a shake on his shoulder from his co-worker. "Did you see that?" he was asked. Mike told him that he had seen nothing. "You didn't see the lights flicker?," his co-worker asked again. "No," Mike responded, but he knew immediately that if the lights had flickered, it could spell trouble. A power surge or interruption could play havoc with the building's equipment. If all the pumps trip out or pulse meters trip, it could make for a very long day bringing the entire center's equipment back on-line.

Mike told his co-worker to call upstairs to their Assistant Chief Engineer and find out if everything was all right. His co-worker made the call and reported back to Mike that he was told that the Assistant Chief did not know what happened but that the whole building seemed to shake and there was a loud explosion. They had been told to stay where they were and "sit tight" until the Assistant Chief got back to them. By this time, however, the room they were working in began to fill with a white smoke. "We smelled kerosene," Mike recalled, "I was thinking maybe a car fire was upstairs", referring to the parking garage located below grade in the tower but above the deep space where they were working.

The two decided to ascend the stairs to the C level, to a small machine shop where Vito Deleo and David Williams were supposed to be working. When the two arrived at the C level, they found the machine shop gone.

"There was nothing there but rubble, "Mike said. "We're talking about a 50 ton hydraulic press – gone!" [Note: "50-tons" refers to the hydraulic capacity of the press, not to its weight. An average 50-ton press weighs about 500-650 lbs.] The two began yelling for their co-workers, but there was no answer. They saw a perfect line of smoke streaming through the air. "You could stand here," he said, "and two inches over you couldn't breathe. We couldn't see through the smoke so we started screaming." But there was still no answer.

The two made their way to the parking garage, but found that it, too, was gone. "There were no walls, there was rubble on the floor, and you can't see anything" he said. http://www.chiefengineer.org/article.cfm?seqnum1=1029
 
Thanks Mark.

I found this about Felipe David:

When the first plane crashed, David was taking inventory of the vending machines in the center's basement. "I asked God to give me strength. And I was able to get up and run six blocks to find an exit," he says.

Despite his injuries, David is grateful for his life. "Things have always happened, and they will continue to happen," he says. "I have to learn to continue to survive because there was a reason God saved my life. Although it will never be the same."

Lutheran Disaster Response-New York initially provided rent money, says David's pastor, Heidi Neumark. "[His family] had no income because he was the only one working," she says. "After his wife found a job, he had to go alone to therapy, which created other problems. He got jostled on the subway and his burns opened up. So LDRNY gave him cab money."

http://www.thelutheran.org/article/article.cfm?article_id=4447


What does he mean by six blocks?
 
Last edited:
That's a strange quote. I don't think there's any doubt about William Rodriguez helping him out to the ambulance, and six blocks to an exit just doesn't make sense.
 
That's a strange quote. I don't think there's any doubt about William Rodriguez helping him out, and six blocks to an exit doesn't make sense.

I thought the same thing. Strange.
 
More investigation:

The man was Felipe David, whose job, Rodriguez later discovered, was to replenish the vending machines. He had been standing in front of a lift about 400 yards from the office when a fireball had burst out of the lift shaft.

http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/loca...nterview_the_untold_story_of_september_11.php

Felipe could be describing the huge distance with an expression 6 blocks.

But if Felipe was 400 yards from William, it must have taken him minutes to get to where Rodriguez was. After all, he was first thrown to the ground, the ran 400 yards before meeting anyone.

Here William states the following:

"We thought the generator blew up. Walls cracked, the ceiling fell on us, and the sprinkler system went off. Horror," the former North Tower janitor said Sunday.


A man with skin melting from his face, arms and hands came running into the office shortly after, yelling "explosion, explosion!"
A plane rammed into the building moments later, recalled Rodriguez, a native of Puerto Rico and United States citizen.

http://www.pjstar.com/stories/042307/TRI_BD10AM9S.060.php

So first there was an explosion, then Felipe David came and then the plane hit the building, according to Mr. Rodriguez.

But since Felipe David was 400 yards away, was there a 1-2 minute difference between the explosion and the plane?


ETA: In here William says, the explosion was 7 seconds before the plane:

At 8:46 a.m. on Sept. 11, 2001, Rodriguez, who was two levels below ground, said he felt a large explosion that “pushed him upward into the air” seven seconds before the plane hit the building.

That's physically impossible, if Felipe David was 400 yards away during the explosion.
 
Last edited:
That's an error. He was in the center of the same building as Rodriguez, on the same floor.

Ok, thanks for the correction. That huge distance sounded odd. I posted this as I work, so now when I stop to think about it, 400 yards would have been impossible. Just a lesson to me once again, think twice before you post at work. Here you can't concentrate on this too much. For obvious reasons :)
 
Last edited:
This is starting to sound like troofer talk. Picking through the testimonies of people caught in traumatic situations, on the lookout for anomalies, is hardly fair.

We all know testimony can be unreliable, especially when it's second or third hand. Can't we just leave it at that until these folks want to answer questions directly?
 
This is starting to sound like troofer talk. Picking through the testimonies of people caught in traumatic situations, on the lookout for anomalies, is hardly fair.

We all know testimony can be unreliable, especially when it's second or third hand. Can't we just leave it at that until these folks want to answer questions directly?


Well I didn't look for anomalies. That distance just was so strange it caught my eye. Because it would have meant minutes instead of seconds. We can forget that one.

We have had many questions in this thread. We can wait if Mr. Rodriguez want's to address them.
 
If Mr Rodriguez does intend to post here at a later date, I am less concerned about his explosion accounts than I am regarding his power-down claims and his claims regarding the 34th floor of the North Tower that are presented in 9/11 Mysteries.
 
If Mr Rodriguez does intend to post here at a later date, I am less concerned about his explosion accounts than I am regarding his power-down claims and his claims regarding the 34th floor of the North Tower that are presented in 9/11 Mysteries.

Many open questions indeed. Let's hope Mr. Rodriguez continues here. He could set many things straight with a couple of posts, if he wishes.
 
For god's sake, leave him alone. Why on earth would he want to post in this atmosphere?

I couldn't care less what he says on his talks. He's been through hell. Stick to harrassing those who have no excuse.
 
Sorry, if this feels like harrassment. Maybe I've said enough then. Apologies to all concerned. I'll get back to topic, if there is something new.
 
Sorry ref, I didn't mean to single you out. I've just read the whole thread and found it very upsetting.

I've practically given up reading or posting in threads where new CT posters are explaining their POV. The deluge of posters all trying deliver the decisive killer question, is just confrontational and ugly, no matter how respectful an individual tries to be.
 
Sorry ref, I didn't mean to single you out. I've just read the whole thread and found it very upsetting.

I've practically given up reading or posting in threads where new CT posters are explaining their POV. The deluge of posters all trying deliver the decisive killer question, is just confrontational and ugly, no matter how respectful an individual tries to be.

No problem, Shrinker.

This has been a strange thread. Some posts have maybe crossed the line and the thread has diverted badly off-topic a couple of times. Maybe things could calm down a bit.
 
I'm not sure if this has been taken into consideration yet, but I recall in the NIST report an account that said that at least one service elevator, the 50, plummeted(with screaming passengers still in it) all the way to the basement from somewhere above the 40th floor. It seems reasonable that this may have proceeded the fireball. This elevator crashing to the bottom may have been what people perceived to be the explosion from below that was then followed by the fireball descending from above. I don't know if the overpressure from the falling elevator dislodged or opened access doors along its decent, but if it did the fireball would then have found an easier way out on certain floors accounting for the somewhat hit and miss nature of the fuel fed fireball.
 
Given the sub-forum relevant topic of discussion in this thread I feel it worthwhile to repost the following:
I am completely exasperated with the constant equivocating of explosions, explosives and loud noises as exhibited some of the people that post here. What follows is a rant with the intent to provide edification on the matter.

Executive Summary
The use of "explosive" and "explosion" interchangeably in discussion is erroneous; and the use of "explosions" as evidence of "explosives" is fundamentally flawed.

Loud Noises (aka bangs, booms, cracks, explosions (heard but not seen) etc)
Q. What are loud noises?
A. Within the context of this post I will be defining loud noises as "Sound or a sound that is loud, unpleasant, unexpected, or undesired." http://www.thefreedictionary.com/noise (def. #1)

Explosions
Q. What are explosions?
A. Wikipedia defines ExplosionsWP as "a sudden increase in volume and release of energy in a violent manner, usually with the generation of high temperatures and the release of gases. An explosion causes pressure waves in the local medium in which it occurs. Explosions are categorized as deflagrations if these waves are subsonic and detonations if they are supersonic (shock waves)."

Q. What are causes of explosions?
A. The Wikipedia article on ExplosionsWP lists a number of causes of explosions:
  • Chemical explosions
  • Nuclear explosions
  • Steam boiler explosions
  • Electrical explosions
  • Volcanic explosions
  • Astronomical event explosions and
  • Exploding animals
Explosives
Q. What are explosives?
A. Wikipedia defines ExplosivesWP as "a material that either is chemically or otherwise energetically unstable or produces a sudden expansion of the material usually accompanied by the production of heat and large changes in pressure (and typically also a flash and/or loud noise) upon initiation; this is called the explosion."

The Logic
Argument 1
P1: If an explosive is detonated then there will be an explosion;
P2: An explosive is detonated;
C: Therefore, there was an explosion.

This is a logically sound argument. P1 is true by definition of what an explosive does and is included in the definition of things that can cause explosions.
This is known as affirming the antecedent and is expressed as:
P1: If A then B;
P2: A;
C: Therefore, B.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
Argument 2
P1: If there is an explosion, then you will hear a loud noise;
P2: There was an explosion;
C: Therefore, it was heard as a loud noise.

This is a logically sound argument. P1 is true as, by definition, explosions create shock-waves. The shock-waves are heard and meet the criteria of being a loud noise.
This is known as affirming the antecedent and is expressed as:
P1: If A then B;
P2: A;
C: Therefore, B.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
Argument 3
P1: If there is an explosion then you will hear a loud noise;
P2: There was a loud noise;
C: Therefore, there was an explosion.

This is not a logically sound argument as there are, by definition of what a loud noise is, causes of loud noises that are not explosions (ex. steel bar snapping, book slamming on the floor, etc).
This is known as affirming the consequent and is a logical fallacy. It is expressed as:
P1: If A then B;
P2: B;
C: Therefore, A.

The generalized expression of why it is fallacious is:
P1: If A then B;
P2: If C then B;
P3: B;
C: Therefore, A.

Expressed as such, it is clear why it is not a sound logical argument.

It can be made in to a sound logical argument with the addition of another premise (which must be shown to be true), such that:
P1: If A then B;
P2: Only A can cause B;
P3: B;
C: Therefore, A.

Therefore, we would have to be able to say:
P1: If there is an explosion then you will hear a loud noise;
P2: Only explosions can cause loud noises;
P3: There was a loud noise;
C: Therefore, there was an explosion.

This is clearly an untenable argument.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
Argument 4
P1: If an explosive is detonated then there will be an explosion;
P2: There was an explosion;
C: Therefore, there was an explosive was detonated.

This is not a logically sound argument as there are, by definition of what a loud noise is, causes of loud noises that are not explosions (ex. steel bar snapping, book slamming on the floor, etc).
This is known as affirming the consequent and is a logical fallacy. It is expressed as:
P1: If A then B;
P2: B;
C: Therefore, A.

The generalized expression of why it is fallacious is:
P1: If A then B;
P2: If C then B;
P3: B;
C: Therefore, A.

Expressed as such, it is clear why it is not a sound logical argument.

It can be made in to a sound logical argument with the addition of another premise (which must be shown to be true), such that:
P1: If A then B;
P2: Only A can cause B;
P3: B;
C: Therefore, A.

This requirement means that for proponent of CD in the WTC to claim that witness reports of explosions are evidence of the use of explosives the following must be true:
P1: If an explosive is detonated then there will be an explosion;
P2: Only explosives can cause explosions;
P3: There was an explosion;
C: Therefore, there was an explosive was detonated.

This clearly runs counter to the definition of what an explosion is, and is shown to not be true by the examples cited for causes of explosions that do not fall in to the category of explosives. Therefore, this is also an untenable argument.

What does this mean for discussion?
It means that...
  • ... if a witness reported hearing a loud noise and called it an explosion we can not conclude it was caused by an explosion
  • ... if a witness reported seeing an explosion we can not conclude it was caused by an explosive
  • ... the term "explosion" and "explosive" can not be used interchangeably
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom