William Rodriguez revisited.

Honest witnesses can still be wrong. Your above statement is a false choice fallacy.

I choose to believe he can't actually remember.

Yeah well then you are claiming that Willie has chosen to become an activist in support of 9/11 truth based solely on a faulty memory.

Seems like a heck of a commitment based on a hazy recollection. No?
 
Says the guy who claims hundreds of witnesses at the Pentagon were mistaken because they disagree with his theory :rolleyes:

Pathetic.

Not even close to the same thing.

Most witnesses at the Pentagon were were deliberately fooled with a perfectly timed sleight of hand illusion pulled off with military precision.

You know......kind of like what ILLUSIONISTS like James Randi pull off for entire audiences.
 
Uh huh. It's always someone "mistaken" or simply another coincidence when it contradicts the official story.

But it makes more sense that when other eyewitnesses, the physical evidence, and experts who look at the data contradict the CT to call them Brainwashed, planted, or shills?:confused:
 
Not even close to the same thing.

Most witnesses at the Pentagon were were deliberately fooled with a perfectly timed sleight of hand illusion pulled off with military precision.

You know......kind of like what ILLUSIONISTS like James Randi pull off for entire audiences.

It's clear no one is getting through to you Lyte. People have explained in several threads how your "illusion" theory is impossible, irrational and down-right stupid. There's no point derailing this thread by trying to install some sanity into you. Instead, I'll just link to this thread so the fence-sitters can see the several debunkings of your theory:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=79314

I'll allow the fence sitters, lurkers and on-lookers read your post in this thread and make up their own judgments regarding your sanity and research. I do apologize for laughing when I read it though.
 
Not even close to the same thing.

Most witnesses at the Pentagon were were deliberately fooled with a perfectly timed sleight of hand illusion pulled off with military precision.

You know......kind of like what ILLUSIONISTS like James Randi pull off for entire audiences.

Don't you mean...

"a perfectly timed slight of hand illusion pulled off with military precision kind of like what ILLUSIONISTS like James Randi pull off for entire audiences, except in the midst of this perfectly planned illusion months or years in the making, being carried out by the best the USG/NWO/illuminatti has to offer, the new guy knocked down the wrong light poles enabling Merc and I to figure it all out with the help of 4 witnesses who saw the plane on the north side of the Citgo, (in which they are absolutley right) but still saw the plane hit the Pentagon (in which the new guy, to cover for his mistake in knocking down the wrong poles, yelled Hey you four!!!! and they all looked his way for a second missing the flyover"?
 
Sorry the truth hurts so much that you feel compelled to lash out so strongly LashL but I am free to post when and where I please.

Bottom line this is the SINGLE point that needs to be discussed if you are going to accept William Rodriguez as an honest witness or a fraud.

If his account is true it is proof that 9/11 was an inside job.

Which came first? The explosion below him or above him?

Surely nobody here would argue that he couldn't tell the difference.

So the only question is whether or not YOU choose to believe Willie when he says the one below him came first.

It is obvious that you have no concept of "the truth", Lyte, so your post started out with BS, and not surprisingly, it ended the same way.

1) The truth does not hurt me at all.

2) I did not "lash out" at all, let alone "strongly".

3) I did not suggest that you are not free to post where you like.

4) Like I said, Willie is here. If he is willing to answer legitimate questions about his various accounts and his various interpretations of events, that is terrific. So far, he has declined to do so.

5) You seem to be trying to substitute yourself in answering for him, but I don't recall seeing him inviting you to do so, and I don't recall seeing him accepting you as a substitute, nor do I think that you are qualified to respond on his behalf.

6) Your post is rife with nonsensical false dilemmas, strawmen, and non sequiturs. And you wonder why people do not take you seriously?

7) No, it is not a matter of choosing between Willie being an "honest witness" or "a fraud".

8) No, it is not true that "if his account is true it is proof that 9/11 was an inside job".

9) No, it is not true that nobody would argue that he couldn't tell the difference about whether "the explosion" was below him or above him. His stories have been inconsistent and there is good reason to believe that he would not know the difference, in any event.

10) No, it is not a matter of "choosing" to believe him when he says that there was an explosion from below first, especially since that has not always been his story.

It's a good thing you aren't a baseball player, LyteTrip, as you are batting 0.00 so far.
 
I'm not surprised you guys would prefer to make this thread about me and ignore the question over whether or not you believe Willie's assertion that the explosion BELOW him came first therefore proving 9/11 was an inside job.
 
5) You seem to be trying to substitute yourself in answering for him, but I don't recall seeing him inviting you to do so, and I don't recall seeing him accepting you as a substitute, nor do I think that you are qualified to respond on his behalf.

I am not speaking for Willie.

I am simply relaying what I know about his account from what he has said.

He heard the explosion below him first.
 
I seem to remember someone (possibly our own rocket scientist) saying that vibrations propagate faster through steel than they do through air. In that case, what Mr. Rodriguez describes is exactly what would be expected: the vibration of the plane strike propagating through the steel of the tower reached him first (the "explosion" he felt), THEN the sound of the explosion arriving.
 
I'm not surprised you guys would prefer to make this thread about me and ignore the question over whether or not you believe Willie's assertion that the explosion BELOW him came first therefore proving 9/11 was an inside job.

Au contraire. You made it about you when you interjected the *cough* "witnesses" from your nonsensical little video into your post. Nobody (not even your fellow troofers) actually buys into anything from your little video for a second, so it was just silly for you to interject it. If you are actually interested in the subject matter of this thread, please make an attempt to keep your little video out of it.

I am not speaking for Willie.

I am simply relaying what I know about his account from what he has said.

He heard the explosion below him first.

Then stop purporting to speak for him and let him speak for himself. He is here. His initial claims were not that he heard an explosion from below first. He subsequently made claims to the contrary, and he has given various different accounts of events since, which appear to get "better" over time. This thread is about his various versions of events, and he is here to address the inconsistencies if he chooses.

You are still batting 0.00
 
Last edited:
Lyte,

How about asking your own questions of Mr Rodriguez?

Being a supporter, he would probably answer them. Try to ask questions which would disprove our questions that suggest Mr Rodriguez is mistaken in his recollections or that he has drawn incorrect conclusions regarding events that happened to him.

Reason for edit: correct spelling of Mr Rodriguez
 
Last edited:
I really wish Mr. Rodriguez would speak out against the way Lyte and others manipulate him for their own personal agenda. What is being said here on his behalf practically right in front of him is far more insulting than anything that has been said by anyone in the skeptic community in regards to Mr. Rodriguez's claims.
 
I seem to remember someone (possibly our own rocket scientist) saying that vibrations propagate faster through steel than they do through air. In that case, what Mr. Rodriguez describes is exactly what would be expected: the vibration of the plane strike propagating through the steel of the tower reached him first (the "explosion" he felt), THEN the sound of the explosion arriving.

I remember that too- and it's the most plausible explanation I can recall...

Unfortunately I've been looking for it and am unable to find it.
 
Welcome M. Rodriguez. Let me echo Crazy Chainsaw's post and salute the amazing selflessness and courage you have shown on that terrible day of infamy.

I also apreciate the fact that you decided not to go to Iran to speak about your theories on 9/11.

I agree with Hyperviolet, I wish the posters here let not this become a personal issue, let's just stick to M. Rodriguez' accounts and claims. I will try to do the same.

Agreed.

Mr. Rodriguez, please understand that our questioning your interpretation of the noises you heard is not the same thing as questioning your honesty or integrity, which I doubt anyone here is doing.

These are not personal attacks - they are merely questions to you personally. I hope you can see the difference. I hope you can address such questions, as they will not go away until you do so.

I seem to remember someone (possibly our own rocket scientist) saying that vibrations propagate faster through steel than they do through air. In that case, what Mr. Rodriguez describes is exactly what would be expected: the vibration of the plane strike propagating through the steel of the tower reached him first (the "explosion" he felt), THEN the sound of the explosion arriving.

Exactly.

Mr. Rodriguez, is it possible that you heard/felt the force of the plane hitting before you heard the sound of it reach you?
 
I'm not surprised you guys would prefer to make this thread about me and ignore the question over whether or not you believe Willie's assertion that the explosion BELOW him came first therefore proving 9/11 was an inside job.

And I'm not surprised that you latch on to one persons interpretation of what he witnessed/experienced on that day to blow apart the official account.

Except that it is just an interpretation.

We know a plane crashed into the tower.

We know that jet fuel was released and ignited.

Our witness (mr rodriquez) has stated that he smelled kerosene while he was in the basement.

A victim of 9/11 suffered burns.

Now, as Gravy points out, not all witnesses in the wtc towers claimed to have heard the plane strike, just the movement caused by that impact.

But, you also have to consider that the floors where most witnesses would have been located were also subdivided into offices. And these offices would have been formed with fire containment in mind, so the wall, doors etc would have had some substance (as in mass) to them, even though they may have been quite thin. This substance could have had a sound insulating quality as well as fire protecting, and this, together with the seperation of the floors themselves would have insulated alot of people from hearing the actual explosive impact of the plane.

But lift shafts would be a good conduit for sound, and an open plan basement area (I'll have to check my copy of the leaked wtc plans to confirm that claim) would have none of the sound insulation properties of a sub-divided office space.

So, to my mind, it is entirely possible that mr rodriguez did hear the plane impact as well as the explosion of fuel coming down the lift shaft.

It is also possible that he heard the sound of the immediate structural damage caused by the impact, which may also have sounded like explosions as large steel members were displaced and connections failed.

How such an experience then gets translated into 'explosives' in the basement is a leap of faith born of a predisposition to believe the conspiracy fantasy.

Mr Rodriguez cannot tell us for certain that what he heard was explosives, but to him and the 'truthers' explosives becomes a possibility because they all believe he heard the noise before the plane impacted the building.

But we need evidence that this is indeed the case before we can speculate as to what caused the sound of the explosions.

If the evidence presented by mr rodriguez or any other person is that he could not have heard the plane impact, fuel explosion, lifts crashings down or structural failure, then I find that to be extremely weak and certainly not enough to hang a conspiracy on.
 
When you have Giuliani, getting 3 million dollars for a book on 9/11, then 3 millions for speaking in Mexico, 50 to 125k for speaking engagements, close to 220k for managing the firemen fund and finally close to half a million from Giuliani partners, you get to wonder who is making money on the events. My tour was put together by shoestring donations to pay for the airfare. I stayed on individual houses around UK. There were not charge at the events, except on a handful that they ask for a minimunof 3 to 5 punds to cover the cost of the rental of the venue, everything else...free. I raised from the whole tour a total of $7,560. as you may know by now, while in UK I received a call from here and had to end the tour 5 presentations short. My wife lost the baby we were eagerly waiting for. An emergency ticket..$600 dollars. Hospital bill, $6125 and medical expenses $2200. As you can see it was not a profitable venture at all. When I travel to speak in other countries in conferences, this organizations will pay for hotel and tickets and a food allowance. rarely will I get a honorarium. Finally, I made money as a janitor at the WTC than as a speaker.

There are many things I do not agree with and have been openly attacking people like Judy woods, Morgan Reynolds, CGI, Holograms , Bollyn, hufhsmidft, etc etc. That is one of the reasons I joined this forum.

Lashl, obviously think it is not a loss for me to open a dialogue so on that note, I will wait until Randi put an event together were I can meet personally with all of you and answer your questions face to face. God bless you all.

Welcome on board, Mr. Rodriguez.

I have very much respect for your courageous rescue efforts on 9/11. You helped to save numerous lives. And I want you to know, that I did not start this thread out of any disrespect.

Like you see, we have many open questions regarding some statements. It's only, that some of us would like you to clarify, what you experienced, since some of your statements can be interpreted into a conspiracy. And many conspiracy theorists use your statements as a proof of an inside job.

I am not making this a money issue. That was never my intention. It's only, that when you have been seen in Loose Change, speaking with Barrett, in UK events organized by local truther groups, there easily comes and impression, that you sympathize with the conspiracy theorists.

I am also very sorry for the loss of your child..

I really hope you continue to post here. If you want to clarify some of the issues raised here, that would be great. I think we all want the same thing, the truth. Take care Mr. Rodriguez and feel free to join our discussion whenever you may.
 
Yeah well then you are claiming that Willie has chosen to become an activist in support of 9/11 truth based solely on a faulty memory.

Seems like a heck of a commitment based on a hazy recollection. No?



Not really. People believe their memories.

-Gumboot
 
Sorry the truth hurts so much that you feel compelled to lash out so strongly LashL but I am free to post when and where I please.

Bottom line this is the SINGLE point that needs to be discussed if you are going to accept William Rodriguez as an honest witness or a fraud.

If his account is true it is proof that 9/11 was an inside job.

Which came first? The explosion below him or above him?

Surely nobody here would argue that he couldn't tell the difference.

So the only question is whether or not YOU choose to believe Willie when he says the one below him came first.

It was all the same event. It is a matter of the speed of sound from the plane crash and explosion above vs. the jet fuel exploding in the freight elevator. He experienced the jet fuel explosion form the elevator and then heard the sound of the explosion from the plane crash above. This explains why he thought he heard two different explosions.
 
When you have Giuliani, getting 3 million dollars for a book on 9/11, then 3 millions for speaking in Mexico, 50 to 125k for speaking engagements, close to 220k for managing the firemen fund and finally close to half a million from Giuliani partners, you get to wonder who is making money on the events.

There are many things I do not agree with and have been openly attacking people like Judy woods, Morgan Reynolds, CGI, Holograms , Bollyn, hufhsmidft, etc etc. That is one of the reasons I joined this forum.

"I know there are many people going crazy right now because of the amount of media interest in my presentations....oh envy is bad for the soul!

WR "

It is good you can see the lies from Judy Wood, Morgan Reynolds, and others.

But why do you support the any lies of the 9/11 truth movement?
 
@William: William, could forward the mentioned Email to me?

- Oliver :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom