Will Caroline Kennedy Be The Next NY Senator?

Don't expect Eleanor Clift, Diane Rehm, Keith Olbermann, Raychill Maddow, Naomi Wolf, Thomas Mann, etc, vociferous critics of Palin, to echo this sentiment.

I don't expect that, and I mean my comments in no way to be an endorsement of Palin's qualifications. I'd be disappointed to see Palin's most strident critics fall in line behind Caroline Kennedy, though. As much as I disagree with many of Sarah Palin's views, at least she has held elected office before. No one could argue that her current position is based on nepotism. Most importantly, if she had been elected Vice President, it would have been entirely on her merits- she would be VP based on the result of a democratic election, not because of her family connections with powerful politicians.
 
Princess Caroline is even less qualified to be the junior senator from New York than Sarah Palin is to be VPOTUS.

Kennedy may be better educated, better connected and better traveled than Palin, but just because one is poorly qualified for her job doesn't mean the other is necessarily qualified for the one she wants.

I've never understood the Kennedy mystique, and I'm old enough to remember JFK and RFK's run for senate from my state (he hadn't met the then residency requirements so he couldn't even vote for himself). Caroline's calling the governor and asking to be considered for the seat strikes me as a strong sense of entitlement. Why bother running and associating with all the grubby little people when you can just pull strings? Ask what your country -or state- can do for you.

I don't live in New York anymore, so she's not going to be my problem.
 
Kennedy may be better educated, better connected and better traveled than Palin, but just because one is poorly qualified for her job doesn't mean the other is necessarily qualified for the one she wants.


Palin got a rash of **** for performing poorly when responding to questions from her first media encounter. Camelot Caroline pulled a Palin yesterday with her first media encounter, but I have not seen the msm trip over themselves to give her the needle.
 
Senators were not elected until the 17th Amendment, 1913. A bit before my time, but long after the Revolution.

Lest people forget, the original states were literally states, i.e. a group of people with a government that did not answer to any higher government.

They formed the USA to, you know, secure liberties, provide a common defense, and stop trade barriers between states, negotiate as a unit with other governments, and that's pretty much it. But they wanted a direct say in an upper house so pure "the people" stuff wouldn't get out of control.

It took about 150 years for the federal politicians to grow their power, inexorably, until they could push the states around so much they became more or less counties.

Much hilarity ensued.
 
My guess is that this is a done deal. If a member of such a politically powerful family wants to be appointed senator, than this is most likely what will happen.... I’d rather the job went to an experienced politician with a track record.

Oh, I'm sure the New York Times will be just as likely to scream and holler about her lack of experience and track record as they did about, er, Ms. Palin. "All the news that fit to print", "the paper of record", and all that.
 
Palin got a rash of **** for performing poorly when responding to questions from her first media encounter. Camelot Caroline pulled a Palin yesterday with her first media encounter, but I have not seen the msm trip over themselves to give her the needle.

You're comparing someone trying for a Senate seat to someone who was running for V.P. of the U.S. Two different kinds of scrutiny.

On a complete derail: I always chuckle when I hear the term "junior Senator" because of the Latin words those two words derive from.
 
You're comparing someone trying for a Senate seat to someone who was running for V.P. of the U.S. Two different kinds of scrutiny.

Bull! Camelot Caroline is not "trying" for a Senate seat, she expects to be anointed Senator. She is getting a pass from the msm, who seem obvious to the unseemliness of giving a Kennedy this seat even after the Blago scandal broke.

The two different types of msm scrutiny are either aversion to scrutiny (Kennedy), or over-the-top pathological pursuit of the most inane character trait scrutiny (Palin).
 
Bull! Camelot Caroline is not "trying" for a Senate seat, she expects to be anointed Senator. She is getting a pass from the msm, who seem obvious to the unseemliness of giving a Kennedy this seat even after the Blago scandal broke.

The two different types of msm scrutiny are either aversion to scrutiny (Kennedy), or over-the-top pathological pursuit of the most inane character trait scrutiny (Palin).
It's not bull, Cicero.

I live in St. Louis, MO, and I've taken little to no interest whatsoever in Hillary's vacated Senate seat. I took a keen interest in the candidates in U.S. Presidential election in November. I suspect there are tens of millions of people who have similar levels of interest in the two events.

I guess you missed all that stuff about SNL getting the highest ratings it's had in years during the Tina Fey Palin skits? I'll bet a substantial percentage of the population who knew who Sarah Palin was have no idea who Caroline Kennedy is.

Whether you like it or not, it is a different kind of story for the national media.

ETA: Are you even from New York?
 
Last edited:
It's not bull, Cicero.

I live in St. Louis, MO, and I've taken little to no interest whatsoever in Hillary's vacated Senate seat. I took a keen interest in the candidates in U.S. Presidential election in November. I suspect there are tens of millions of people who have similar levels of interest in the two events.

I guess you missed all that stuff about SNL getting the highest ratings it's had in years during the Tina Fey Palin skits? I'll bet a substantial percentage of the population who knew who Sarah Palin was have no idea who Caroline Kennedy is.

Whether you like it or not, it is a different kind of story for the national media.

ETA: Are you even from New York?

Nobody knew who Palin was, outside of Alaskans, until McCain chose her for VP. If you never heard of Caroline Kennedy before she demanded to take over "Snipery" Hillary's Senate seat then you must be in a coma for the last 50 years.

If you actually beleive that the daughter of JFK's first foray into politics is only a local story then you are intellectually dishonest. If Caroline is going through life anonymously, as you suggest, why did Obama jump at the chance for her to offer her support for his campaign at American University?

Whether I like it has nothing to do with the fact that many New Yorkers (particularly up state) object quite strenuously to Camelot Caroline getting the seat. But the msm gives them short shrift.

BTW: I was born in Manhattan.
 
Last edited:
If the New York State democratic party is going to continue to let people with name recognition even to the point of being carpet baggers swoop in and take their Senate seat, then why not just turn it into a reality show while they are at it. Dancing for the Senate seat, or The Surreal Election, or something.

I pity the peons working their way up through state and local offices only to have people like Hillary Clinton or Kennedy lay dibs on office. It goes both ways of course, I had the same criticism of Liddy Dole for her former seat in North Carolina.
 
Nobody knew who Palin was, outside of Alaskans, until McCain chose her for VP. If you never heard of Caroline Kennedy before she demanded to take over "Snipery" Hillary's Senate seat then you must be in a coma for the last 50 years.
I'll take your word for that.

If it's true, then it sounds like yet another good reason to give Palin more scrutiny than Kennedy.



If you actually beleive that the daughter of JFK's first foray into politics is only a local story then you are intellectually dishonest.
If you believe that appointing someone to fill in half a term in the Senate is a situation that deserves as much national media scrutiny as someone running for VP on a ticket with one of the oldest presidential candidates ever to run for office, then you are intellectually dishonest.

You made the comparison, it's up to you to justify it. Why should Caroline Kennedy face the same scrutiny as Sarah Palin did?
 
Last edited:
I guess you missed all that stuff about SNL getting the highest ratings it's had in years during the Tina Fey Palin skits?

SNL's highest rating was the show where Palin appeared in person. But what does this have to do with Her Majesty Caroline being expected to answer questions about her experience and her political views as posed by New York journalists? She believes she can send out a minion to respond to pre submitted questions. How long can she hide behind her handlers before the msm will acuse her of being a dim bulb in the same way they did Palin?

But since you are in St.Louis and have stated you couldn't care less, why do you continue to apologize for Kennedy's reluctance to speak to the press and talk with her potential constituents from upstate New York?
 
SNL's highest rating was the show where Palin appeared in person. But what does this have to do with Her Majesty Caroline being expected to answer questions about her experience and her political views as posed by New York journalists? She believes she can send out a minion to respond to pre submitted questions. How long can she hide behind her handlers before the msm will acuse her of being a dim bulb in the same way they did Palin?
Again, it was you who brought up Palin. I'm merely pointing out that it's an invalid comparison. You're basically asking why the media scrutinized Palin but is, by comparison, going light on Kennedy. I answered. There's a big difference between a VP candidate and someone who may or may not be appointed to take over half a term in the Senate.

But since you are in St.Louis and have stated you couldn't care less, why do you continue to apologize for Kennedy's reluctance to speak to the press and talk with her potential constituents from upstate New York?
Cicero, show me where I once apologize for Kennedy's reluctance to do anything? You're dreaming stuff up now, or perhaps mistaking me for someone else, I don't know. You're sure itchin' for a fight, though.

I am merely pointing out that YOUR comparison between national media scrutiny of Palin and Kennedy is invalid. As I said, they're entirely different situations. For one thing, the Senate seat has a New York constituency. For another, Palin was actually on a ballot, and we got to cast votes for that office.

You're free to rant all you want about whoever gets appointed to take over Hillary's Senate seat. The only thing that would concern me is if a Republican were given that seat somehow (which I suspect is the only case that would make you happy). Otherwise, I don't really care who gets it.
 
Again, it was you who brought up Palin. I'm merely pointing out that it's an invalid comparison. You're basically asking why the media scrutinized Palin but is, by comparison, going light on Kennedy. I answered. There's a big difference between a VP candidate and someone who may or may not be appointed to take over half a term in the Senate.


Cicero, show me where I once apologize for Kennedy's reluctance to do anything? You're dreaming stuff up now, or perhaps mistaking me for someone else, I don't know. You're sure itchin' for a fight, though.

I am merely pointing out that YOUR comparison between national media scrutiny of Palin and Kennedy is invalid. As I said, they're entirely different situations. For one thing, the Senate seat has a New York constituency. For another, Palin was actually on a ballot, and we got to cast votes for that office.

You're free to rant all you want about whoever gets appointed to take over Hillary's Senate seat. The only thing that would concern me is if a Republican were given that seat somehow (which I suspect is the only case that would make you happy). Otherwise, I don't really care who gets it.


It is amazing what you will discover if you actually read through a thread:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4251227#post4251227

And in this thread:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4273115#post4273115

So much for me wanting, or expecting, Patterson to appoint a Republican. You still seem to be oblivious that Her Majesty Caroline has snubbed the major market of MSM, New York City, and still she does not get the drubbing by these same MSM types that Palin received.

We knew about Palin's political positions before the press interviewed her, but we still do not know about Caroline's specific positions on New York politics, even though she has been famous for 50 years.
 
So much for me wanting, or expecting, Patterson to appoint a Republican.
OK, I admit that was hyperbolic. Though my guess is that you won't be happy with whoever gets appointed to replace Hillary--even if it's not Kennedy.

So when are you going to retract your statement about me being an apologist for Caroline Kennedy? Or will you show a quote to support your accusation?


We knew about Palin's political positions before the press interviewed her, but we still do not know about Caroline's specific positions on New York politics, even though she has been famous for 50 years.
I knew virtually nothing about Palin's political positions before those first interviews. She was introduced at the RNC as an anti-pork government reformer who said thanks but no thanks to the bridge to nowhere. I learned that that was a lie before her first interview. I also heard rumors right away that she was a religious nut (creationist, opposed to sex ed, etc.) It took a while to sort out the truth from the noise.

Again, you're making an invalid analogy by comparing the national media scrutiny given to two people in two very different circumstances.

FWIW, I think Kennedy will get more scrutiny before January 20th. Is MSM the only news source that matters to you? I heard a pretty good discussion on Kennedy on NPR the other night.
 
I have a question about when this appointment will be made.

Will Clinton resign her seat some time before Jan 20, or will she wait until after she's confirmed for the new job? I assume she will be confirmed on the afternoon of the 20th.

Obviously, Paterson can announce his pick any time before Clinton resigns, but I wonder what kind of timeline he's up against. Then again, Obama resigned his Senate seat in November, and Blago wasn't too quick to get him replaced. But then he was running an underground auction, and those things take time.
 
If the New York State democratic party is going to continue to let people with name recognition even to the point of being carpet baggers swoop in and take their Senate seat, then why not just turn it into a reality show while they are at it. Dancing for the Senate seat, or The Surreal Election, or something.

I pity the peons working their way up through state and local offices only to have people like Hillary Clinton or Kennedy lay dibs on office. It goes both ways of course, I had the same criticism of Liddy Dole for her former seat in North Carolina.

I always felt it odd that New Yorkers put up with the Democrats using the New York senatorial seats as fast-track enablers to vault people to national prominence.

"Send 'im down to New York to be issued his Senate seat."

:rolleyes:
 
In any case, Caroline ain't one o' those. Hence the reluctance by Democrats to issue her the seat.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom